The Other Conquest
|This article needs additional citations for verification. (September 2016) (Learn how and when to remove this template message)|
|The Other Conquest
(La Otra Conquista)
|Directed by||Salvador Carrasco|
|Produced by||Plácido Domingo|
The Other Conquest (Spanish: La Otra Conquista) is a 2000 Mexican feature film (re-released theatrically in 2008) written and directed by Salvador Carrasco and produced by Alvaro Domingo. Plácido Domingo, the world-renowned tenor, was the executive producer.
The film is a drama about the aftermath of the 1520s Spanish Conquest of Mexico told from the perspective of the indigenous Aztec people. It explores the social, religious, and psychological changes brought about by a historical process of colonization that both defined the American continent.
It is regarded by top critics (e.g., Kevin Thomas , Richard Nilsen , Larry Ratliff , among others) as one of the best cinematic explorations on the effects of colonization and also "one of the more astonishing feature film debuts in recent memory" .
It is May 1520 in the vast Aztec Empire, one year after the Spanish Conqueror Hernán Cortés arrived in Mexico. The Other Conquest opens with the infamous massacre of the Aztecs at the Great Temple of Tenochtitlan (what is now called Mexico City). The sacred grounds are covered with the countless bodies of priests and nobility slaughtered by the Spanish armies under Cortés' command. The lone Aztec survivor of the massacre is a young Indian scribe named Topiltzin [toˈpiɬt͡sin] (Damián Delgado). Topiltzin, who is the illegitimate son of the Aztec Emperor Moctezuma, survives the onslaught by burying himself under a stack of bodies. As if awakening from a dream, the young man rises from among the dead to find his mother murdered, the Spanish in power, and the dawn of a new era in his native land - a New World with alien leaders, language, customs... and God. Representing the New Order is the Spanish Friar Diego (José Carlos Rodríguez). His mission is to convert the "savage" natives into "civilized" Christians; to replace their human sacrifices and feathered deities with public Christenings and fealty to the Blessed Virgin Mary. With Topiltzin, Friar Diego faces his most difficult spiritual and personal challenge, for when Topiltzin is captured by Spanish troops and presented to Cortés (Iñaki Aierra), the Spanish Conqueror places Topiltzin's conversion under Friar Diego's care. Old world confronts the New as Topiltzin struggles to preserve his own beliefs, whilst Friar Diego attempts to impose his own. Moreover, throughout the film, a fundamental question arises: Who is really converting whom?
On November 8, 1519 the Spanish Conqueror Hernando Cortés and his small army rode into the Aztec capital of the vast Aztec Empire, where they were welcomed by the Emperor Moctezuma. Within two years, the Aztec civilization was in a state of collapse, the survivors having lost their families, homes, language, temples... and gods
The Other Conquest opens in May 1520 when Topiltzin (Damián Delgado), a skillful Aztec scribe who is one of Moctezuma's illegitimate sons, survives the Massacre of the Great Temple by hiding under a corpse. After the Spaniards leave the sacred site, he finds his people dead, including his mother.
By 1526, Topiltzin is still striving to preserve the cult of Tonantzin, based upon the Aztec Mother Goddess. When a squadron commanded by Captain Cristóbal (Honorato Magaloni) and Friar Diego (José Carlos Rodríguez) discover the clandestine human sacrifice of a beautiful Aztec princess, two incompatible ways of life come face to face... and violence erupts. Topiltzin manages to escape by making Friar Diego believe he is drawn to the statue of the Virgin Mary that accompanies the Spaniards wherever they go. He is eventually captured and presented to Hernando Cortés (Iñaki Aierra), who has just returned from an ill-fated campaign to Las Hibueras (today's Honduras). In an attempt to create a hybrid empire, Cortés has taken Emperor Moctezuma's daughter and heiress, the notorious Tecuichpo (Elpidia Carrillo), as his new mistress and interpreter. She reveals that Topiltzin is her half-brother, and a skeptical Cortés spares the young man's life, but in turn decides to convert him to the new Spanish ways with the aid of Tecuichpo (from now on, Doña Isabel) and Friar Diego. After being subject to a brutal ritual of conversion, Topiltzin (now called Tomás) is confined in the Franciscan Monastery of Our Lady of Light.
Five years later (1531), under the tutelage of Friar Diego, Tomás is struggling to reconcile two worlds which could hardly be more different but which also share some basic truths. However, Friar Diego realizes that Tomás and Doña Isabel are forging Cortés's correspondence with Charles V, King of Spain. Things become even worse when Friar Diego discovers them making love inside the monastery, in a desperate attempt to perpetuate their race. Friar Diego takes it upon himself to save Tomás's soul, and asks Cortés to keep Doña Isabel from returning to the monastery. A pregnant Doña Isabel is secluded in a dungeon.
The overwhelming absence of his half-sister erodes what is left of Tomás's world. He falls into a state of desolation and illness. A well-meaning Indian nun (Zaide Silvia Gutiérrez) applies medieval remedies to him, but these only help turn his feverish attacks into hallucinations that merge Christian and Aztec imagery. Tomás has a vision whereby the Virgin Mary is revealed as the Aztec Mother Goddess.
The arrival of the statue of the Virgin Mary in the monastery, a token of gratitude from Cortés to Friar Diego, now causes Tomás to become genuinely drawn to the statue as a substitute for all he has lost, and he sets on a personal crusade to conquer her. If he absorbs her powers, if he fuses with her, redemption will follow.
Is the Indian's conversion real? Or is Tomás trying to retain his own beliefs under the guise of the new creed? Will he be able to survive with his sanity intact? These questions start revolving in Friar Diego's head, and although he puts many obstacles to keep Tomás from entering the sacristy and consummating his obsession with the statue, he finally allows Providence to decide whether Tomás's mission is legitimate or not. So who is in fact converting whom? Maybe the greatest mystery in the history of beliefs is how certain unorthodox encounters make us continue believing...
- Damián Delgado as Topiltzin / Tomás
- José Carlos Rodríguez as Fray Diego de La Coruña
- Elpidia Carrillo as Tecuichpo / Doña Isabel
- Iñaki Aierra as Hernando Cortés
- Honorato Magaloni as Capitán Cristóbal Quijano
- Guillermo Ríos as Alanpoyatzin - brother
- Diana Bracho as Doña Juana
- Carlos Torres Torrija as Soldier Héctor (credited as Carlos Torrestorija)
The Other Conquest broke box-office records upon its 1999 release in Mexico by Twentieth Century Fox, "enjoying the biggest opening weekend of any Mexican film in history on its home turf" (The New York Times).
In the summer of 2007, the film was re-released in select cities across the United States and it made its long-awaited debut on DVD  in October 2007. Bonus materials include director-writer Salvador Carrasco's commentary and 15 deleted scenes.
Along with top critics Kevin Thomas, Richard Nilsen, Larry Ratliff, Top LA Weekly critic Ron Stinger called the film "An arresting, balletic performance by Damian Delgado powers this vividly imagined, elegantly paced mystery play beyond period exoticism to a bona fide illumination of social, and sacred, history."
Kevin Thomas official statement of the film was that "In his bravura feature debut, [Salvador] Carrasco has created nothing less than a dazzling vision of the birth of a uniquely Mexican religion born of the searing fusion of Catholic and Aztec deities."
Richard Nilsen also with his official statement said the film was "[Director] Carrasco uses shadows and mirrors to create effects he has no actual budget for. The lack of money shows on-screen but is cleverly hidden by the director's genius for making us care about his story so much that we forgive all else."
Release and Academic screenings
The Other Conquest was shown in 2003-04 as part of the exhibition "AZTECS: A Civilization Carved in Blood and Stone" at the Royal Academy of Arts in London, the Martin-Gropius-Bau Museum in Berlin, and the Solomon R. Guggenheim Museum in New York, where writer/director Salvador Carrasco and producer Alvaro Domingo did Q&As to full-house capacity. In addition, Salvador Carrasco has been invited to screen the film and do Q&As in over 30 universities and colleges in the United States, including NYU (his alma mater), Columbia University, USC, UCLA, Pomona College, Tulane University, University of Wisconsin–Madison, Georgetown University, Purdue University, Northwestern University, Santa Monica College, etc.
On June 23, 2010 The Other Conquest was shown to a packed auditorium at the Getty Villa in Pacific Palisades, California as part of the exhibition "The Aztec Pantheon and the Art of Empire," with director Salvador Carrasco present for a Q&A.
On January 27, 2012 a new 35mm print of The Other Conquest was shown at The Los Angeles County Museum of Art's Bing Auditorium as the closing event of the exhibition "Contested Visions In The Spanish Colonial World," with writer/director Salvador Carrasco present for a Q&A following the screening.
Conception and production
The idea for The Other Conquest came to director Salvador Carrasco, a native of Mexico City, during his final years as a film student at New York University's Tisch School of the Arts, specifically on August 13, 1991, the 470th anniversary of the fall of Tenochtitlan, the Aztec capital. "Living in New York at the time, I found myself more sensitive to such dates. Trying to imagine what it might have been like back then, it occurred to me that in the face of military defeat and the ensuing losses, an Aztec Indian could resist the Spanish Conquest by carrying out his own form of spiritual conquest --i.e., through ‘conquering’ or absorbing the powers of a statue of the Virgin Mary, in whose name his oppressors were ruling, he’d be able to redeem himself and his people. Needless to say, it is no coincidence that the patron saint of Mexico is the Virgin of Guadalupe, a Virgin Mary with indigenous features. This singular image became the launching point for a short screenplay I began to write, which later evolved into The Other Conquest." - Salvador Carrasco.
It was at NYU where Carrasco met his friend and future producer, Alvaro Domingo, son of legendary tenor Plácido Domingo. After an intense period of research, Carrasco developed a script centering on a young Aztec scribe and his forced conversion to Catholicism at the hands of Spanish invaders. Domingo was immediately taken in with the story after Carrasco presented it to him at a restaurant in Mexico City, and it was his idea to take the short film idea and expand it into a full-length feature film. Domingo says, "I just fell in love with the story right then and there. We resolved to create our own company, Carrasco & Domingo Films, using it as a platform to take the plunge together."
Getting funding for the project proved to be a tough road; the film was first rejected by three different administrations of the Mexican Institute of Cinema (IMCINE). Carrasco was even berated by some for wanting to cast a pure indigenous actor in the lead role. After the initial rejections, Carrasco and Domingo sought independent financing, including from Plácido Domingo himself, who served as Executive Producer of The Other Conquest. Of the film Plácido Domingo has commented, "What makes this film so unique is its message of cultural tolerance --something so much needed in today's world." Seed money also came from Mexican philanthropist Manuel Arango, who had also sponsored Carrasco's film studies in New York. More funding came from private investors and Mexican public institutions.
Casting began with an eye towards the authentic and Carrasco searched the world over for his ideal cast. "I wanted actors not only to appear as if they belonged in 16th century Mexico, but also to embody the prevailing values of the time," remembers Carrasco.
It was not long before the perfect actor to embody the film's lead character, Topiltzin, was found. Damián Delgado, a native of Oaxaca, had made a career as a professional theatrical dancer.
Filming lasted about seven years, due to funding and even domestic political and economic issues Mexico faced during the 1990s. "Those were three hard years of carting around a VHS videotape with 35 minutes worth of an unfinished film. Three hard years of a great uncertainty, wondering whether we’d be able to complete this film, though deep in my heart, I always knew we would."- Alvaro Domingo.
Salvador Carrasco has also commented on the feeling of being a young, opera-prima director attempting to accomplish a major work: "We needed to dispel certain notions that a film like this couldn’t be made; that first-timers like ourselves couldn’t accomplish something as ambitious as this. We needed to prove that we could…to others, and to ourselves."
Shooting took place in many diverse, original locations including the pyramid of Tenayuca (in the heart of Mexico City), the archaeological site of Xochicalco and the Hacienda de Santa Mónica. Carrasco's wife, Andrea Sanderson, a Juilliard-trained violinist, joined the production team and especially helped with the film's impressive production design. "Andrea and I must have visited every possible archaeological site within a 300-kilometer radius of Mexico City," remembers Carrasco. "We were looking for an intimate, timeless setting with distinctive architecture, far away from the metropolis, where clandestine rituals could have taken place without the Spaniards knowing." Colonial plazas and even underground caves were also discovered and used to great effect in the film, giving it a rare, convincing air of complete authenticity.
For the film's lush, evocative music score, Salvador Carrasco approached classical composer Samuel Zyman and Jorge Reyes, renowned for his work in original indigenous music. Plácido Domingo contributed by performing an aria, "Mater Aterna," with music by Zyman and lyrics by Carrasco, that plays during the end credits.
- Los Angeles Times 2007 feature story on The Other Conquest re-release
- Los Angeles Times article on high-audience turnout for The Other Conquest
- Los Angeles Times 2000 feature story on The Other Conquest release
- Los Angeles Times feature story on Director Salvador Carrasco
- Los Angeles Times article: "Chasm Separates 2 Movie Views of Mexican History"
- Los Angeles Times article on soundtrack of The Other Conquest
- "Alibi" (New Mexico) (USA) 3 May 2007, Vol. 16, Iss. 18, pg. cover, by: Devin D. O'Leary, "The Other Conquest Conquers America: An interview with writer/director Salvador Carrasco"
- "The Hollywood Reporter" (USA) 11 April 2007, by: Gregg Kilday, "Indie 'Conquest" re-enters U.S."
- "Indie" (USA) 12 April 2007, by: Monika Bartyzel, "Mexican Indie Flick 'The Other Conquest' Gets Second Chance"
- "Variety" (USA) 11 April 2007, by: Dave McNary, "'Conquest' wins re-release"
- Miriam Haddu. Contemporary Mexican Cinema, 1989-1999: History, Space and Identity. The Edwin Mellen Press, 2007, Pg. 276, (BK), 0773454330
- Tom Hayden. The Zapatista Reader. Nation Books, 9 November 2001, Pgs. 166-177, (BK), 1560253355
- Jack Rothman. Hollywood in Wide Angle: How Directors View Filmmaking. The Scarecrow Press, Inc., 2004, Pgs. 113-165, (BK), ISBN 0-8108-5015-X
- Deborah Shaw. Contemporary Latin American Cinema: Breaking into the Global Market. Rowman & Littlefield Publishers, Inc., February 2007, Pg. 216, (BK), 0742539156
- John Willis. Screen World: Film Annual. Applause Cinema Books, Vol. 52, 2001, Pgs. 296-297, (BK), 1557834784
- Jason Wood. The Faber Book of Mexican Cinema. Faber and Faber, 7 September 2006, Pgs. 49-56, (BK), ISBN 0-571-21732-X
- Jorge Ayala Blanco. La Fugacidad del Cine Mexicano. Océano de México, 11 September 2001, Pgs. 331-334, (BK), 9706512349
- Salvador Carrasco. "The Invisible Sight". In: The Zapatista Reader, Nation Books, 9 November 2001, Pgs. 166-177, (BK), ISBN 978-1-56025-335-8 --Scroll down to bottom of page--
- Santiago Juan-Navarro. "Between El Dorado and Armageddon: Utopia and Apocalypse in the Films of the Encounter" Delaware Review of Latin American Studies; Vol. 6, No. 2; January 15, 2006
- Guadalupe Loaeza. "Todos Somos Topiltzin". In: Periódico Reforma, Palabra, 14 April 1999, (NP)
- Eduardo Subirats. La Otra Conquista. In: Revista El Angel, Periódico Reforma, 25 October 1998, Pgs. 3-6, (MG)
- Salvador Velazco. La guerra de imágenes en 'La Otra Conquista,' de Salvador Carrasco. In: Cuadernos Americanos Nueva Epoca, UNAM, Vol. 87, May 2001, Pgs. 128-132, (BK)
Print media reviews
- Don Bain. The Other Conquest Examines the Consequences of Empire. In: La Voz Nueva (Denver, Colorado, USA), 17 October 2007, Pgs. 8-11, (NP)
- Elsa Bragato. La Otra Conquista. In: Revista Así, 17 December 1998, Pg. 1, (MG)
- Eduardo Ruiz. La Otra Conquista: el triunfo de la tesis sobre el drama personal. In: Excelsior, 5 November 1998, Pg. 33, (NP)