The Riddle (Five for Fighting song)

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
  (Redirected from The Riddle (You and I))
Jump to navigation Jump to search
"The Riddle"
The Riddle (You and I).jpg
Single by Five for Fighting
from the album Two Lights
ReleasedMay 15, 2006
FormatCD single
GenrePop rock
Songwriter(s)John Ondrasik
Producer(s)Curt Schneider
Five for Fighting singles chronology
"If God Made You"
"The Riddle"

"The Riddle" is the title of a song by American singer Five for Fighting. It was released in May 2006 as the lead single from his third album Two Lights. The song peaked at number 40 on the Billboard Hot 100 chart during an 18-week chart stay. On the Adult Contemporary chart, the song reached number four.

Background and content[edit]

John Ondrasik has stated that it was the hardest to write of any of his songs, taking 18 months to write. By the end, he had over 100 drafts before he came up with the final version. Although it began as a song on the meaning of life, it later evolved into a song about the love between a father and his son, inspired by his relationship with his own five-year-old.

Critical reception[edit]

Chuck Taylor, of Billboard magazine gave the song a mixed review, calling it "refreshingly more uptempo and optimistic than previous 'Superman' and '100 Years,' albeit still probing for the meaning of life." He goes on to say that "the sap factor is pretty high here, limiting the song's appeal to moms and wistful philosophers, and there's little remaining doubt that Five for Fighting is pretty much a one-trick pony."[1]

Music video[edit]

In July 2006, a music video was released to accompany the single, directed by Vem (also credited for directing the videos for O.A.R.'s "Love and Memories" and The Click Five's "Just the Girl").

The video features Five for Fighting's frontman John Ondrasik allowing his imagination to run wild, when he finds a crayon in the sand while waiting for a tow truck to collect his overheated '65 Mustang. Hastily he scribbles a piano to perform the ballad, and then draws and colors out all sorts of various distractions, including buzzards, rainclouds and jet fighters.


Chart (2006–2007) Peak
Canada (Canadian Hot 100)[2] 88
US Billboard Hot 100[3] 40
US Adult Contemporary (Billboard)[4] 4
US Adult Top 40 (Billboard)[5] 8