The Right Thing to Do
|"The Right Thing to Do"|
Cover in the Netherlands
|Single by Carly Simon|
|from the album No Secrets|
|B-side||"We Have No Secrets"|
|Recorded||Autumn 1972, Trident Studios|
|Carly Simon singles chronology|
"The Right Thing to Do" is a song written and performed by Carly Simon that first appeared on her 1972 album No Secrets. It was released as the second single to the album, following "You're So Vain" and reached #17 on the Billboard Hot 100 and #4 on Billboard's Adult Contemporary chart. It also reached #20 on the Canada Top Singles chart and #9 on the Canadian Adult Contemporary chart. It reached #17 in the UK.
Lyrics and music
"The Right Thing to Do" is a love song directed to Simon's then husband James Taylor. Simon has stated that "it was actually one of my absolutely undisputed songs about James, written three months into our relationship." Author Sheila Weller notes that the song is both romantic and realistic about the relationship. She shows the romanticism by disregarding her lover's problems but realistic in recognizing "her fading value in the sex-and-love marketplace." To Weller, the latter is displayed in the lines:
- And it used to be for a while
- The river flowed right to my door
- Making me just a little too free
- But now the river doesn't seem to stop here anymore
Simon acknowledged that Taylor helped "with a lot of the changes" after she had written the original lyrics and music. Taylor claimed that told Simon that he liked everything except the original third verse, and Simon replaced that verse, and Taylor said that he likes that one. Simon got the line "loving you is the right thing to do" from the movie The Last Picture Show. Allmusic critic Joe Viglione and Billboard Magazine both praised the song's production by producer Richard Perry. Viglione also comments on Simon's "heartfelt" vocal performance. Simon accompanies herself on piano, and other instrumentation includes bass guitar, drums, congas, horns and strings. Vicki Brown and Liza Strike also provide backing vocals. Billboard considered the "light horn backing" to be particularly effective in making the song catchy.
Weller described the melody as "fetching." Carly Simon biographer Stephen Davis remarks on the songs "sweet and lulling acoustics." Viglione calls it a "great pop record" and "two minutes and fifty-seven seconds of sublime Adult Contemporary radio music." Viglione also suggests that Simon reused the formula of "The Right Thing to Do" a year later for her bigger hit "Haven't Got Time for the Pain."
|Canada (RPM Charts)||20|
|Canada (RPM Charts) Adult Contemporary||9|
|US Billboard Pop Singles (Hot 100)||17|
|US Billboard Adult Contemporary||4|
|UK Singles Chart||17|
"The Right Thing to Do" has been included on several Carly Simon compilation albums, including The Best of Carly Simon in 1975, Clouds in My Coffee in 1995, The Very Best of Carly Simon: Nobody Does It Better in 1999, Anthology in 2002, Reflections: Carly Simon's Greatest Hits and Carly Simon Collector's Edition in 2009. It was also included on Simon's live album Greatest Hits Live.
"We Have No Secrets"
The B-side of "The Right Thing to Do" single was "We Have No Secrets," also a song from the No Secrets album. According to Weller, "'We Have No Secrets,' was both personally—echoing Carly's boundary-less but betrayal-laced childhood family life—and culturally resonant." According to Simon biographers Charles and Ann Morse, it portrays Simon's efforts to remain honest with herself and others throughout her life. The lyrics reflect on the tension between desire to know more about one's lover's past and the fact that sometimes that knowledge is painful. The lyrics acknowledge that there are some things one may not want to know. Weller regards the line "You always answer my questions/But they don't always answer my prayers" as "[nailing] the tension between" the supposed desirability of open, non-monogamous marriages and the reality that people want to be their lover's sole partner. Rolling Stone Magazine critic Stephen Holden regarded "We Have No Secrets" as exemplifying the theme of No Secrets, which he saw as the "difficulty of being happy," by "painfully" expressing "the realization that emotion and rationalization are often irreconcilable."
Fox News Sunday used "We Have No Secrets" as bumper music over a clip of United States Secret Service agents when they arrived for the Ken Starr grand jury hearing. "We Have No Secrets" has been included on multiple Carly Simon compilation albums, including The Best of Carly Simon, Clouds in My Coffee, The Very Best of Carly Simon: Nobody Does It Better, Anthology, the import version of Reflections: Carly Simon's Greatest Hits and Carly Simon Collector's Edition.
- "No Secrets awards". Allmusic. Retrieved 2014-05-12.
- "RPM 100 Singles". Library and Archives Canada. May 26, 1973. Retrieved 2014-07-04.
- "Adult Contemporary Playlist". Library and Archives Canada. May 26, 1973.
- "Carly Simon". The Official Charts Company. Retrieved 2014-07-04.
- Viglione, J. "The Right Thing to Do". Allmusic. Retrieved 2014-05-12.
- Weller, S. (2008). Girls Like Us: Carole King, Joni Mitchell, Carly Simon--And the Journey of a Generation. Simon & Schuster. pp. 364–365, 373, 472. ISBN 9780743491471.
- Davis, S. (2012). More Room in a Broken Heart: The True Adventures of Carly Simon. Penguin. ISBN 9781101554258.
- Werbin, S. (January 4, 1973). "The Rolling Stone Interview: Carly Simon & James Taylor". Rolling Stone Magazine. pp. 32–42.
- Tiegel, E., ed. (March 17, 1973). "Pop Picks". Billboard Magazine. p. 60. Retrieved 2014-05-12.
- Griffith, J.T. "You Are the Sunshine of My Life". Allmusic. Retrieved 2014-05-12.
- Theakston, R. "Will & Grace: Let the Music Out!". Allmusic. Retrieved 2014-05-12.
- Morse, C. & Morse, A. (1974). Carly Simon. Creative Education. p. 31. ISBN 0871913933.
- Farber, B.A. (2006). Self-disclosure in Psychotherapy. Guilford Press. p. 14. ISBN 9781593853235.
- Harris, J.F. (1993). Philosophy at 33 1/3 Rpm: Themes of Classic Rock Music. Open Court Publishing. p. 38. ISBN 9780812692419.
- Holden, S. (January 4, 1973). "No Secrets". Rolling Stone Magazine. Retrieved 2014-07-04.
- Cuprisin, T. (July 23, 1998). "Fox's Snow is toe-to-toe with Sunday talkers". Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel. p. 8B. Retrieved 2014-07-04.
- "We Have No Secrets". Allmusic. Retrieved 2014-07-04.
- Erlewine, S.T.. "Reflections: Carly Simon's Greatest Hits [Bonus Track]". Allmusic. Retrieved 2014-07-04.