The Road to Dune
First edition cover
|Author||Frank Herbert, Brian Herbert and Kevin J. Anderson; edited by Patrick LoBrutto|
|Cover artist||Stephen Youll|
|Genre||Science fiction novel|
|Published||2005 (Tor Books)|
|Media type||Print (Hardback)|
This companion work to the Dune novels includes an alternate novel based on Frank Herbert's original notes for Dune, letters between Frank Herbert and his editor, the original article by Frank Herbert that inspired the creation of Dune — "They Stopped The Moving Sands" — as well as unused chapters from Dune and Dune Messiah and the short stories in the Dune universe written by Brian Herbert and Kevin J. Anderson.
Spice Planet is an alternate Dune story written by Brian Herbert and Kevin J. Anderson based upon the original story outline that Frank Herbert made for Dune. It features House Linkam (a version of House Atreides) temporarily taking control of Duneworld from their rivals, House Hoskanner (the forerunner of the Harkonnens), in order to settle a dispute between them. The Hoskanners had received a monopoly concession on the recently discovered Duneworld, but as melange had grown in popularity in the Empire, other Houses had begun to dislike the Hoskanner's wealth and pushed House Linkam to challenge House Hoskanner. The Emperor, secretly allied with the Hoskanners, orders Linkam to take over Duneworld for two years with the promise that if they produce more melange, then they will receive the concession — else it will go permanently to the Hoskanners. Much like in Dune, the Hoskanners sabotage and thwart to the best of their abilities, although the Linkams enlist the help of the Imperial Planetologist to devise a way to neutralize the sandworms and vastly increase the efficiency of operations.
The story has some obvious links to the original Dune novel, such as many of the same characters but there are some key themes that are under-developed in this version:
When we arranged all the chapters and read through the remarkable outline, we found that Spice Planet was a unique and worthy story in its own right, not just a precursor to Dune. Although the harsh desert is very similar to the one familiar to millions of fans, the tale itself is thematically different, focusing on decadence and drug addiction instead of ecology, finite resources, freedom, and religious fanaticism.
The work is a view into "what-might-have-been" had Frank Herbert bowed to the pressure of his editors and written a novel at a length of most paperbacks during the mid-1960s — approximately 20,000 words.
Letters of Dune
This collection of letters details the trials and tribulations that Frank Herbert went through in order to have Dune published in Analog magazine and later by Chilton Books. The letters detail how he was encouraged to cut the length of the novel and to ease up on his descriptions of Paul Atreides's prescient powers.
"They Stopped The Moving Sands"
"They Stopped The Moving Sands" is an uncompleted article about how sand dunes were held in place by specially designed grasses. The article was never published, but was the impetus for Frank Herbert writing Dune.
Missing chapters from Dune and Dune Messiah
Also included in The Road to Dune are deleted chapters and alternate scenes from the first two novels in the Dune chronicles, Dune and Dune Messiah. These include alternate and extended scenes between Paul and Reverend Mother Mohiam, between Paul and Dr. Yueh, between Paul and Thufir Hawat, between Paul and his father Duke Leto Atreides, the passage to Arrakis on the Spacing Guild heighliner, the escape from Arrakeen and between Paul and a Muad'Dib mouse. The Dune Messiah scenes include a new chapter between Alia Atreides and Duncan Idaho, a new introduction and a discarded ending that features the death of the conspirators Edric, the Reverend Mother Mohiam and possibly Princess Irulan at the hands of a Fremen mob incensed by Paul Atreides' death.
The Dune short stories A Whisper on Caladan Seas, Hunting Harkonnens, Whipping Mek and The Faces of a Martyr by Brian Herbert and Kevin J. Anderson are included in this collection. The story Dune: Sea Child, originally published in Elemental, a 2006 benefit anthology for children who survived the 2004 Indian Ocean tsunami, is also included in the paperback edition of Road to Dune.
- "Using Frank's outline, we have written the novel Spice Planet according to the original design, providing a window into the Dune that might have been." pg 27, Introduction to Spice Planet, BH/KJA; The Road to Dune
- pg 26 of the Introduction to Spice Planet, The Road to Dune
- "Ironically, if Frank had written Spice Planet according to his original plan — a science-fiction adventure novel about the same lengthy as most paperback books published at the time — he might have had a much easier task finding an editor and a publishing house." pg 27, Introduction to Spice Planet, The Road to Dune