The Undisputed Truth

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search

The Undisputed Truth was a 1970s Motown recording act, assembled by record producer Norman Whitfield as a means for being able to experiment with his psychedelic soul production techniques. Joe "Pep" Harris served as main lead singer, with Billie Rae Calvin and Brenda Joyce Evans on additional leads and background vocals.


Billie Calvin and Brenda Evans had been part of a group called The Delicates in the 1960s. They were introduced to Motown by singer Bobby Taylor, and, when The Delicates broke up in 1970, the two began providing background vocals for artists around Motown.[1] They sung backing on the hits "Ain't No Mountain High Enough" for Diana Ross and "Still Water (Love)" for The Four Tops. Joe Harris had been part of a Detroit soul group called The Fabulous Peps. Formed in 1962, the group were renowned for their energetic stage performances, and they cut a handful of singles for various different labels before their dissolution in 1968. Harris also became a member of The Ohio Untouchables (later The Ohio Players). In 1970, Motown producer Norman Whitfield - partly as a response to criticism from Temptations fans that he was using their group as his personal plaything - put together Joe Harris, Billie Calvin and Brenda Evans to create his own recording act, The Undisputed Truth.

The group's music and unusual costuming (large Afros and white makeup) typified the then-popular trend of "psychedelic soul" which their producer Norman Whitfield had inaugurated. A number of their singles became minor hits, and many of them were also songs for Whitfield's main act, The Temptations, among them 1971's "You Make Your Own Heaven and Hell Right Here on Earth" and "Papa Was A Rollin' Stone". Their single Top 40 hit in the United States was the ominous "Smiling Faces Sometimes," originally recorded by The Temptations, which hit #3 on the US Pop Charts in mid-1971.

Although they could never recreate the success of "Smiling Faces" they continued to make chart appearances throughout the early 1970s. They found some success with songs like "What It Is" (1972) and "Law of the Land" (1973) becoming modest hits on the US R&B Charts. In 1973, nevertheless, dissatisfied with the lack of major success, Brenda Evans left. She was briefly replaced by singer Diane Evans, but both she and Billie Calvin then left. Norman Whitfield subsequently took the opportunity to expand the group, and Joe Harris was joined by Virginia "V" McDonald, Tyrone "Big Ty" Douglas, Tyrone "Lil Ty" Barkley and Calvin "Dhaak" Stephenson. The latter four were all members of The Magic Tones, a Detroit soul group with similarities to George Clinton's pre-Funkadelic Parliament. Virginia McDonald (otherwise known as "Vee") is also the niece of Miracles member Warren "Pete" Moore.[2]

This new group scored several minor hits of their own, like "Help Yourself" and "I'm A Fool For You" (both 1974). "Help Yourself" became their second ever Top 20 R&B hit, peaking at #19, and reached #63 on the Hot 100, the highest position attained by any Undisputed Truth record for Motown besides their hit "Smiling Faces Sometimes".[3] In 1975, the group's costuming and style changed, becoming even more unusual and Funkadelic-influenced. Their final albums for Motown, Cosmic Truth and Higher Than High (both 1975), yielded minor R&B chartings. Their 1975 song "Higher Than High" was featured most prominently in a TV advertisement for the 2015 film The Man From UNCLE.[4]

The Undisputed Truth, along with Rose Royce and Willie Hutch, followed Whitfield during his exodus from Motown to set up Whitfield Records in 1975. Both Virginia McDonald and Tyrone Douglas then left. The group went through many personnel changes thereafter, although original member Joe Harris remained with the group throughout. Taka Boom, Chaka Khan's sister, took over as female lead singer for 1976's Method To The Madness and Marcy Thomas replaced her for 1979's Smokin. Melvin Stewart and Lloyd Williams replaced Calvin Stevenson and Tyrone Barkley for the group's last album as well.[5] Former member Billie Calvin later wrote songs for Whitfield's other group, Rose Royce, including the hit single "Wishing On A Star".

The group had relatively little success at their new label, and faded into obscurity after two more albums. They did make their only ever entry into the UK Singles Chart in January 1977 (#43) with the disco single "You + Me = Love" from the album Method to the Madness.[6] The song reached #48 on the American Billboard Hot 100, their second highest position ever on the chart. The Undisputed Truth nevertheless disbanded in the early 1980s following the collapse of Whitfield Records. Several former members became part of another Norman Whitfield-assembled group, Dream Machine, who had one album released, Dream Machine, and two singles, "Don't Walk Away" and "Shakedown", all in 1981.[7] Vee McDonald recorded a solo album entitled Heavy Traffic Starring V (written and produced by Brian and Eddie Holland), which was released by Atlantic Records in 1986,[8] with one single, "Jealousy", released that same year.[9] Tyrone Barkley recorded a cover of The Del Royals' 1969 song "Man Of Value" in 1979; it is his only ever solo record and has since become an acclaimed Northern Soul favourite.

In 1990, Joe Harris and Brenda Evans revived the group with singer Belita Woods, and recorded for Ian Levine's Motown revival label Motorcity Records. They recorded a new version of their 1973 song "Law of the Land", which was released as a 12" single (the group's last ever single) in 1991.[10] Members Billie Calvin and Vee McDonald also made separate solo recordings for the same label, and all three feature on the A Tribute To Norman Whitfield album, a Motorcity compilation CD released in September 1996.[11] Notably, McDonald recorded a song entitled "You're My Loveline" (co-written by former Motown lyricists Janie Bradford and Marilyn McLeod), which Ian Levine has described as one of his "favourite ever Motorcity songs".[12] Both she and Joe Harris continue to perform; Harris has most recently worked with the UK-based Stone Foundation band,[13] and, along with Undisputed Truth member Calvin Stephenson, was inducted into the R&B Hall of Fame in 2015.[14]

Founding member Billie Calvin died on June 23, 2007, at the age of 58, in Mureitta, California, USA, of heart disease.[15]



Year Album Peak chart positions Label and Catalog Number
1971 The Undisputed Truth 43 7
Gordy (Motown)
G 955L
1972 Face to Face with the Truth 114 16
G 959L
1973 Law of the Land 191 52
G 963L
1974 Down to Earth 35
G6 968S1
1975 Cosmic Truth 186 42
G6 970S1
Higher Than High 173 52
G6 972S1
1976 Method to the Madness 66 19
WH 2967
1979 Smokin'
WHK 3202
"—" denotes releases that did not chart


Year Title and Catalog Number US US
UK Album Label
1971 "Save My Love for a Rainy Day" (G 7106)
b/w "Since I've Lost You"
The Undisputed Truth
Gordy (Motown)
"Smiling Faces Sometimes" (G 7108)
b/w "You Got the Love I Need"
"You Make Your Own Heaven and Hell Right Here on Earth" (G 7112F)
b/w "Ball of Confusion (That's What the World is Today)"
Face to Face With the Truth
1972 "What It Is" (G 7114F)
b/w "California Soul"
"Superstar (Remember How You Got Where You Are)" (UK-only) (TMG 818)
b/w "Ain't No Sun Since You've Been Gone"
"Papa Was a Rollin' Stone" (G 7117F)
b/w "Friendship Train"
Law of the Land
1973 "Girl, You're Alright" (G 7122F)
b/w "With a Little Help from My Friends"
"Law of the Land" (G 7130F)
b/w "Just My Imagination (Running Away with Me)"
"Mama I Got a Brand New Thing (Don't Say No)" (G 7124F)
b/w "Gonna Keep on Tryin' 'Til I Win Your Love"
1974 "Help Yourself" (G 7134F)
b/w "What's Going on"
Down to Earth
"I'm a Fool for You" (G 7139F)
b/w "The Girl's Alright with Me"
"Lil' Red Ridin' Hood" (G 7140F)
b/w "Big John is My Name"
Cosmic Truth
1975 "UFO's" (G 7143F)
b/w "Got to Get My Hands on Some Lovin'"
"Higher Than High" (G 7145F)
b/w "Spaced Out"
Higher Than High
1976 "You + Me = Love" (WHI 8231)
b/w "You + Me = Love (Instrumental)"
Method to the Madness
"Let's Go Down to the Disco" (WHI 8295)
b/w "Loose"
1977 "Sunshine" (WHI 8362)
b/w "Hole in the Wall"
1979 "Show Time (Part I)" (WHI 8781)
b/w "Show Time (Part II)"
"I Can't Get Enough of Your Love" (WHI 8873)
b/w "Misunderstood"
The albums noted are where the A-Sides come from
"—" denotes a single that was not released in that territory or did not chart


  1. ^  Missing or empty |title= (help)
  2. ^ Video Description on YouTube
  3. ^  Missing or empty |title= (help)
  4. ^
  5. ^  Missing or empty |title= (help)
  6. ^ Roberts, David (2006). British Hit Singles & Albums (19th ed.). London: Guinness World Records Limited. p. 576. ISBN 1-904994-10-5. 
  7. ^  Missing or empty |title= (help)
  8. ^
  9. ^  Missing or empty |title= (help)
  10. ^  Missing or empty |title= (help)
  11. ^
  12. ^ Comments by Ian Levine on YouTube
  13. ^  Missing or empty |title= (help)
  14. ^  Missing or empty |title= (help)
  15. ^

External links[edit]