The Witness (2000 film)
|Directed by||Jenny Stein|
|Produced by||James LaVeck|
|Edited by||Jenny Stein|
The film depicts the transformation of a New York City construction contractor--who was brought up to treat animals with suspicion or indifference--into an animal lover and animal rights activist.
Jason Longo was the cinematographer, and Jane Greenberg did the sound.
The Witness has been translated into Spanish, Russian, Polish, and other languages.
The film begins with scenes showing the day-to-day life of a construction contractor by the name of Eddie Lama. Footage shows Lama discussing a construction job with one of his employees, and Lama also talks about how various different racial and ethnic groups who work at his firm are able to get along together. There is a scene of Lama petting two dogs, and other footage showing that Lama keeps multiple cats in his office.
Lama recalls how his family did not have any animals; his mother was instinctively frightened by them. He also remembers how kids would sometimes chase cats in alleyways or harm animals when he was growing up in Brooklyn.
After an attractive female friend asks Lama to take care of a kitten, his perspective on animals begins to change. He grows to love the kitten, and he agrees when his friend asks whether he would or would not like to take care of another cat.
Lama then talks about petting a cat and feeling its lower legs; he then associates it with a drumstick. When his brother invites him over for a chicken dinner, he does not eat it, and his interest in the welfare of animals continues to grow.
Footage shows how Lama has rigged the vehicles in his business with posters depicting an animal that has been stripped of its fur to make a fur coat.
The next segment of the movie has Lama discussing the treatment of pigs as they are brought to slaughter while the camera shows a television playing undercover footage of a factory farm. Lama discusses the treatment that pigs get on the way to slaughter.
The final segment of the movie has Lama discussing the fur business. Lama talks about how the animal must be either trapped in the wild or raised in captivity. Undercover footage is shown of animals who have been trapped in the wild, but the trap did not kill instantly. As a result, the animal must suffer for hours or days until the trapper kills it.
Footage is then shown of animals kept in captivity on a fur farm, and Lama discusses the conditions they are kept in and the method in which they are slaughtered.
The undercover video comes from Farm Sanctuary, Humane Society of the United States, People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals, International Fund for Animal Welfare, World Society for the Protection of Animals (Now known as World Animal Protection), and others.
The final scenes of the movie show how Lama has outfitted a truck with an audio/visual system that can show the undercover footage of animals that have been trapped and animals raised in captivity.
A camera records the reactions of New York City shoppers when they see the undercover footage as Sarah McLachlan's song Angel is heard in the background (McLachlan donated Angel for use in the film; she has used the song for many years in her capacity as a spokesperson for the ASPCA).
Pulitzer Prize–winning journalist Howard Rosenberg praised the film writing in that, "The importance of The Witness lies in its subject matter combined with its unconventional voice that denounces cruelty."  Rosenberg contrasted The Witness with such television shows as Steve Irwin's Crocodile Hunter: Captured on Camera, and When Animals Attack! calling Irwin a buffoon, and stating such shows exploit animals.
Reviewer Marianne Eimer, writing for Library Journal, stated that the film "should be considered a tool to promote kindness toward animals," noting however, that it was "not for the faint of heart."
Reviewer Syd Baumel writing for The Aquarian also praised the film writing "though this is a film about heartbreaking tragedy, The Witness is infused with warmth and humour. Interspersed with his surprisingly erudite (. . . for a goodfella) tutorials on animal rights issues, Lama tells a frequently comical story of his awakening."
The film has won various awards:
- 2007 — STEPS International Rights Film Festival — Free Thinker Award
- 2007 — Open Your Eyes! International Film Festival — Best Documentary Award
- 2005 — Artivist Film Festival — Best Short Film Award
- 2001 — New Jersey International Film Festival — Best Documentary Award
- 2000 — Brooklyn Film Festival — Best Documentary Feature (Jury)
- 2000 — Brooklyn Film Festival — Best Documentary Feature (Audience)
- 2000 — Crested Butte Reel Fest — Best of Festival Award
- 2000 — Crested Butte Reel Fest — Best Documentary Award
- 2000 — Canyonlands Film Festival — Best Documentary Award
The film was also nominated in 2000 for the Pare Lorentz Award.
Individuals and entities that endorsed The Witness:
- Actor William Baldwin
- Primatologist Dr. Jane Goodall
- Writer Susan McElroy (author of Animals as Teachers and Healers: True Stories and Reflections, All My Relations: Living with Animals As Teachers and Healers, and other books)
- Actor Alicia Silverstone
- Individuals affiliated with the California Teachers Association, United Federation of Teachers, and the Stanford Center for Biomedical Ethics.
Later work by Tribe of Heart
In 2009, LaVeck and Stein released Peaceable Kingdom: The Journey Home which tells the story of the awakening consciousness of farmers with respect to animals (an early version was released in 2004, but is no longer offered by Tribe of Heart). The duo has also created a website called HumaneMyth.org which advocates the view that it is not possible to humanely use animals for food.
- "James LaVeck - Biography". IMDB. Retrieved 2013-02-10.
- "Jenny Stein (II) - Biography". IMDB. Retrieved 2013-02-10.
- "Tribe of Heart: The Art of Peaceful Transformation | Award-winning Documentaries | The Witness | Peaceable Kingdom: The Journey Home". Tribe of Heart. Retrieved 2013-02-10.
- Jenny Stein (Editor and Director), James LaVeck (Producer) (2000). The Witness (Motion picture). Tribe of Heart. ISBN 1-882979-12-5. OCLC 45068096. Position: 43 min. 12 sec.
- Stephanie Strom (25 December 2008). "Ad Featuring Singer Proves Bonanza for the A.S.P.C." The New York Times. Retrieved 2013-02-10.
- Howard Rosenberg (2000-12-08). "'Witness' to the Slaughter". Los Angeles Times.
- Eimer, Marianne (2001-05-01). "VIDEO Reviews: The Witness". Library Journal. 126 (8): 142.
- "Animals 'R Us: The Witness". The Aquarian. 2001. Retrieved 2013-02-10.
- "Satya: A Magazine of Vegetarianism, Environmentalism, Animal Advocacy and Social Justice". Retrieved 2013-02-10.
- "Reviews received by The Witness". The Witness: Official Site. Tribe of Heart. Retrieved 2013-02-10.
- "Amazon.com: The Witness: A Tribe of Heart Documentary: Jenny Stein, James LaVeck: Movies & TV". Retrieved 2013-02-10.
- "Film Festival Awards received by The Witness, A Tribe of Heart Documentary". The Witness: Official Site. Tribe of Heart. Retrieved 2013-02-10.
- "The Witness (2000) - Awards". IMDB. Retrieved 2013-02-10.
- "Endorsements received by The Witness". The Witness: Official Site. Tribe of Heart. Retrieved 2013-02-10.
- Susan Chernak McElroy. "Animals as Teachers & Healers". Retrieved 2013-02-10.
- "The Witness Award-winning Documentary | Tribe of Heart: The Art of Peaceful Transformation". The Witness: Official Site. Tribe of Heart. Retrieved 2013-02-10.
- Stein, Jenny; LaVeck, James. "Humane Myth: Encouraging Truth, Transparency and Integrity in Animal Advocacy". Retrieved 2013-02-10.