This Divided State
|This Divided State|
|Directed by||Steven Greenstreet|
|Produced by||Phil Gordon|
|Edited by||Steven Greenstreet|
This Divided State is a documentary film by first-time filmmaker Steven Greenstreet that details the conflict that erupted at Utah Valley State College, now called Utah Valley University, when controversial figure Michael Moore was scheduled to come speak on campus shortly before the 2004 presidential election.
In September 2004, UVSC student council leaders, Jim Bassi and Joseph Vogel, invited liberal filmmaker Michael Moore to come speak on campus. The predominantly conservative community of Orem surrounding the school erupted in an uproar. A pandemonium of protests, petitions, and demonstrations escalated into hate mail, threatening phone calls, threatened lawsuits, and countless incendiary editorials.
Attempting to offset the controversy, UVSC invited conservative commentator Sean Hannity, scheduling his appearance a few days prior to Moore’s visit. Hannity waived his normal $100,000 speakers fee, but still demanded that UVSC cover his travel costs, which totaled $49,850, a figure which "generally surprised" UVSC officials when they received the bill. Also featured in the film is prominent voice of the opposition, Kay Anderson, a local real estate mogul who offered UVSC $25,000 to cancel Moore’s appearance, and, when that failed, tried to sue the school for misuse of funds.
Steven Greenstreet embarked on the concept along with his friends, Bryan Young and Elias and Michelle Pate, describing the ensuing commotion as “a huge crush of political debate and an overwhelming sense of activity and electricity.”
The filmmakers captured at least 70 hours of material in the course of three months. Greenstreet eventually maxed out three credit cards, emptied his bank account, and dropped out of Brigham Young University, devoting himself exclusively to this project. In one instance, when the filmmakers could no longer afford the cost of home internet access, they resorted to piggybacking on an unsuspecting neighbor's wireless signal, only accessible at the foot of a family member’s bed.
Often spending twenty hours a day editing, Greenstreet carefully trimmed the footage down to eighty-eight minutes. Juxtaposing candidly emotional interviews against unruly public spectacles, he consistently strove for neutrality, advancing the story without narration and allowing equal time to all opposing opinions. The filmmakers could not forget the vital importance of finishing the film soon, while the events involved were still relevant and fresh in the public’s minds.
Upon learning UVSC professor and self-proclaimed liberal Phil Gordon had become involved in the project, Kay Anderson filed a claim against Greenstreet, attempting to revoke his previously signed consent to be included in the film. With the aiding representation of attorney Patrick Shea, Anderson’s attempts to remove himself from the film proved unsuccessful. Greenstreet defended using Anderson in the film, “without the personal interview that I did with him, he doesn’t get a chance to explain his motivation.”
On February 5, 2005, the eighty-eight-minute final product premiered at UVSC's Ragan Theater, receiving a standing ovation from the 700 people overflowing the Theater's 400-seat capacity. On the heels of the sold-out premiere, the filmmakers commenced a publicity blitz to any magazine, newspaper, or film studio that would take their call. Without previous experience, the filmmakers had to quickly learn how to produce their own press kits and market their movie with a team of only four people and minimal resources. Their first big break occurred when Campus Progress, a division of the Center for American Progress, sponsored a tour of the film as part of its "Reel Progress" series. The film went on to screen at twenty-three college campuses, including Yale, Cornell, Vanderbilt, and the University of Southern California.
With Greenstreet on the road for months at a time, his colleagues continued to promote their film in any way possible, arranging a self-distributed theatrical release. Not having money to transfer the film to 35mm screening prints, they simply projected the film digitally from a DVD-R disc. The film went on to play theatrically in more than twenty major U.S. cities, before being released in North America on DVD on September 27, 2005, by The Disinformation Company.
This Divided State has an approval rating of 83% on Rotten Tomatoes from 24 reviews counted. The New York Times called it "filmmaking gold" and "extremely moving." Variety found the film “as boisterous as it is sobering,” while Deseret News claimed it is “surprisingly cohesive and coherent and it does its best to tell all sides of the story.” Orlando Sentinel further posits, “This Divided State shows the power of the newer, cheaper video documentary in all its glory.”
- The New York Times
- Deseret News
- The Village Voice
- Christian Science Monitor
- eFilm Critic
- The A.V. Club
- TV Guide
- Orlando Sentinel
- Pate, Michelle. "This Divided State (2005)". The International Movie Database. Retrieved 11 November 2011.
- Catsoulis, Jeanette (19 August 2005). "Trouble in Mormon Country When a Liberal Pays a Visit". The New York Times. Retrieved 19 November 2011.
- Leiby, Richard (27 March 2005). "Documenting the Cost of Free Speech". The Washington Post. Retrieved 7 November 2011.
- "Hannity's bill totals $49,850". Brigham Young University. Retrieved 14 October 2004.
- Eddington, Mark (17 March 2005). "Film on Moore visit to go on tour". The Salt Lake Tribune. Retrieved 15 November 2011.
- Hancock, Laura (6 February 2005). "Film dissects pros, cons of Moore visit". Deseret News. Retrieved 14 November 2011.
- "Any which way you can: : Local film 'This Divided State' finishes rocky road to DVD distribution". Daily Herald. Retrieved 4 November 2011.
- "Movie made of controversial Moore campus visit". CTV News. Retrieved 4 November 2011.
- "Moore documentary". Daily Herald. 4 February 2005. Retrieved 4 November 2011.
- Montesano, Anthony P. (8 March 2006). "Interview With: Steven Greenstreet, Director/Producer". Movies on My Mind. Retrieved 4 November 2011.
- Eddington, Mark (February 3, 2005). "Documentary on Moore's UVSC visit has the usual critic". The Salt Lake Tribune. Retrieved 13 November 2011.
- Decker, Marin (28 January 2005). "Film footage is disputed". Deseret News. Retrieved 4 November 2011.
- Eddington, Mark (February 4, 2005). "Film on Moore fiasco a big hit with 400-plus UVSC audience". The Salt Lake Tribune. Retrieved 16 November 2011.
- Hawkins, Emily (17 February 2005). "Reel Progress: This Divided State". Campus Progress. Retrieved 4 November 2011.
- Peterson, Chris (9 May 2005). "Filmmaker enjoys success of Moore documentary". Daily Herald. Retrieved 4 November 2011.
- "This Divided State (2005)". Rotten Tomatoes. Retrieved 2010-09-10.
- Harvey, Dennis (23 August 2005). "This Divided State". Variety. Retrieved 4 November 2011.
- Vice, Jeff (22 July 2005). "'Divided' surprisingly coherent". Deseret News. Retrieved 4 November 2011.
- Moore, Roger (8 September 2005). "This Divided State". Orlando Sentinel. Retrieved 4 November 2011.