Toffs and Toughs
Toffs and Toughs is a 1937 photograph of five boys: two dressed in the Harrow School uniform including waistcoat, top hat, boutonnière, and cane; and three nearby wearing the plain clothes of pre-war working class youths. The picture was taken by Jimmy Sime on 9 July 1937 outside the Grace Gates at Lord's Cricket Ground during the Eton v Harrow cricket match. It has been reproduced frequently as an illustration of the British class system, although the name "Toffs and Toughs" may be no older than 2004.
The day of the picture
The names of the five boys were published in a 1998 article by Geoffrey Levy in the Daily Mail. The Harrovians were Peter Wagner and Thomas "Tim" Dyson, who had arranged to be at Grace Gates at 2 pm, where Wagner's father would pick them up and drive them to Russ Hill, the Wagners’ country home in Surrey, for the weekend. The other three boys were George Salmon, Jack Catlin, and George Young, 13-year-old pupils at the local Church of England primary school. They had visited the dentist that morning and decided to skip school in order to earn money at Lord's by carrying luggage and returning hired cushions for the deposit. The photographer, Jimmy Sime, worked for the Central Press Agency; Sime took several shots of the five boys outside Grace Gates. Ian Jack speculates that Sime solicited the cooperation of the three "toughs", but not that of the two "toffs".
Use of the photograph
The picture first appeared next day, 10 July 1937, on the front page of the News Chronicle, a left-wing newspaper, under the heading "Every picture tells a story". A different photograph from the same reel was printed in a photo-essay in Life on 2 August 1937; Life erroneously described Wagner and Dyson as "Young Etonians", and described the other three as "village boys". Ian Jack speculates that Life used an inferior shot because the original had been sold by the Central Press Agency exclusively to the News Chronicle.
The News Chronicle photograph reappeared in 1941 in Picture Post, illustrating an article by A. D. Lindsay arguing for reform of Britain's education system. Bert Hardy, who joined the Picture Post in 1941, has often been misidentified as the photographer who took the picture. It has been reused often in subsequent decades; Levy called it "the defining image of class division". In 1979 it was a plate in François Bédarida's Social history of England, captioned "The Two Nations". It was the illustration on the covers of books about the British class system published in the 1990s, and in newspaper articles in the 2000s. Paul Barker of the Institute for Community Studies described the picture in 2000 as an "easy caricature" symbolising an obsolete social divide.
In 2004, the title "Toffs and Toughs" was used in the Getty Images online catalogue, and for a jigsaw puzzle of the photograph. Ian Jack has criticized this title, since Salmon, Catlin and Young were not especially poor or disreputable, merely part of the respectable working-class majority of the time.
The boys in later life
Tim Dyson died of diphtheria 13 months after the photograph was taken, in August 1938. This was shortly after traveling to join his parents in Trimulgherry, India, where his father, George St John Armitage Dyson, was was serving as an army officer. George Dyson died in 1942 while imprisoned in a Japanese prisoner of war camp in Korea.
Peter Wagner studied natural sciences at Peterhouse, Cambridge. In 1943, he was commissioned as a Lieutenant in the Royal Corps of Signals. However, he suffered from pericarditis and never saw active service during World War 2. After being discharged from the army in 1945, he entered the family stockbroking firm, married, and had three daughters; he became mentally unstable in the 1970s and died in Hellingly Hospital in 1984.
During World War 2, George Salmon served as an anti-aircraft gunner on board HMS Duckworth. After the war, he worked for Rightons Limited, a metal supplier. He was married when interviewed by the Daily Mail in 1998 and was still living in Marylebone when he died in 2000. George Young was also married when interviewed for the Daily Mail. Young had a flat in The Barbican. Jack Catlin's family moved to Rickmansworth soon after 1937; he was widowed, remarried and living in Weymouth in 2010.
- Jack, Ian (Spring 2010). "Five boys: the story of a picture". Intelligent Life. Retrieved 1 October 2010.
- Levy, Geoffrey (30 October 1998). "Revealed:The real story of the toffs and three urchins". Daily Mail. Retrieved 6 October 2010.
- Barker, Paul (19 June 2000). "Who's afraid of the class system?". New Statesman.
- "The Camera Overseas: Eton beats Harrow by seven wickets at Lord's". Life. 2 August 1937. p. 54. Retrieved 1 October 2010.
- Bédarida, François (1979). A social history of England, 1851-1975. Cambridge University P ress. p. 315. ISBN 978-0-416-85920-1. Retrieved 6 October 2010.
- Jack, Ian (Summer 2010). "Five boys: a postscript". Intelligent Life. Retrieved 1 October 2010.