Treaty on Open Skies
|Treaty on Open Skies|
States that signed and ratified the treaty
States that have signed, but not ratified
States that have withdrawn from the Treaty
|Signed||24 March 1992 (also start of provisional application)|
|Effective||1 January 2002|
|Depositary||Governments of Canada and Hungary|
|Languages||English, French, German, Italian, Russian and Spanish|
The Treaty on Open Skies establishes a program of unarmed aerial surveillance flights over the entire territory of its participants. The treaty is designed to enhance mutual understanding and confidence by giving all participants, regardless of size, a direct role in gathering information about military forces and activities of concern to them. It entered into force on January 1, 2002, and currently has 34 party states. The idea of allowing countries to openly surveil each other is thought to prevent misunderstandings (e.g., to assure a potential opponent that one's country is not about to go to war) and limit the escalation of tensions. It also provides mutual accountability for countries to follow through on treaty promises. Open Skies is one of the most wide-ranging international efforts to date promoting openness and transparency of military forces and activities.
The concept of "mutual aerial observation" was initially proposed to Soviet Premier Nikolai Bulganin at the Geneva Conference of 1955 by U.S. President Dwight D. Eisenhower; however, the Soviets promptly rejected the concept and it lay dormant for several years. The treaty was eventually signed as an initiative of U.S. president (and former Central Intelligence Agency Director) George H. W. Bush in 1989. Negotiated by the then-members of NATO and the Warsaw Pact, the agreement was signed in Helsinki, Finland, on March 24, 1992. The United States officially withdrew on 22 November 2020. Russia also announced intentions to exit the treaty on January 15, 2021 citing the US withdrawal and the inability of the member nations to assure that no further details would be shared with US now.
The 34 state parties to the Open Skies Treaty are Belarus, Belgium, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Bulgaria, Canada, Croatia, Czech Republic, Denmark (including Greenland), Estonia, Finland, France, Georgia, Germany, Greece, Hungary, Iceland, Italy, Latvia, Lithuania, Luxembourg, the Netherlands, Norway, Poland, Portugal, Romania, Russia, Slovakia, Slovenia, Spain, Sweden, Turkey, Ukraine and the United Kingdom. Kyrgyzstan signed the treaty but has not yet ratified it. Canada and Hungary are the Depositories of the treaty in recognition of their special contributions to the Open Skies process. Depository countries maintain treaty documents and provide administrative support.
The Open Skies treaty is one of unlimited duration, and is open to accession by other states. Republics of the former Soviet Union (U.S.S.R.) that have not already become state parties to the treaty may join it at any time. Applications from other interested countries are subject to a consensus decision by the Open Skies Consultative Commission (OSCC). Eight countries have joined into the treaty since it entered into force in 2002: Bosnia and Herzegovina, Croatia, Estonia, Finland, Latvia, Lithuania, Slovenia, and Sweden. Notably[why?] missing are Austria, Cyprus, Ireland, Switzerland, Serbia, Montenegro, Albania, North Macedonia, Moldova, Armenia and Uzbekistan. The Republic of Cyprus submitted its application to accede the Treaty in 2002; since then, however, Turkey has blocked its accession.
Open Skies Consultative Commission
The Open Skies Consultative Commission is the implementing body for the Treaty on Open Skies. It comprises representatives from each state party to the treaty and meets monthly at the Vienna headquarters of the Organization for Security and Co-Operation in Europe.
The Open Skies regulations covers the territory over which the parties exercise sovereignty, including mainland, islands, and internal and territorial waters. The treaty specifies that the entire territory of a member state is open to observation. Observation flights may only be restricted for reasons of flight safety and not for reasons of national security.
Observation aircraft may be provided by either the observing party or by the observed party (the "taxi option"), at the latter's choice. All Open Skies aircraft and sensors must pass specific certification and pre-flight inspection procedures to ensure that they are compliant with treaty standards.
Canada uses a C-130 Hercules aircraft equipped with a "SAMSON" sensor pod to conduct flights over other treaty nations. The pod is a converted CC-130 fuel tank modified to carry the permitted sensors, along with associated on-board mission systems. A consortium of nations consisting of Belgium, Netherlands, Luxembourg, Canada, France, Greece, Italy, Portugal and Spain own and operate this system. The costs of maintaining the SAMSON Pod are shared, based on each nation's flight quota and actual use.
Bulgaria, Romania, Russia and Ukraine use the Antonov An-30 for their flights. The Czech Republic also used to use the An-30 for this purpose but apparently retired all of theirs from service in 2003.
Russia also uses a Tu-154M-ON monitoring aircraft. Germany formerly used this type as well until the aircraft was lost in a 1997 accident. Russia is phasing out both An-30 and Tu-154M-ON and replacing them with two Tu-214ON with the registrations RA-64519 and RA-64525. This aircraft's new sensor suite, though, is being challenged by the US.
Open Skies aircraft may have video, optical panoramic and framing cameras for daylight photography, infrared line scanners for a day/night capability, and synthetic aperture radar for a day/night all weather capability. Photographic image quality will permit recognition of major military equipment (e.g., permit a member state to distinguish between a tank and a truck), thus allowing significant transparency of military forces and activities. Sensor categories may be added and capabilities improved by agreement among member states. All sensors used in Open Skies must be commercially available to all signatories. Imagery resolution is limited to 30 centimetres.
Each state party is obligated to receive observation flights per its passive quota allocation. Each state party may conduct as many observation flights – its active quota – as its passive quota. During the first three years after entry into force, each state was obligated to accept no more than seventy-five percent of its passive quota. Since the overall annual passive quota for the United States is 42, this means that it was obligated to accept no more than 31 observation flights a year during this three-year period. Only two flights were requested over the United States during 2005, by the Russian Federation and Republic of Belarus Group of states parties (which functions as a single entity for quota allocation purposes). The United States is entitled to 8 of the 31 annual flights available over Russia/Belarus. Additionally, the United States is entitled to one flight over Ukraine, which is shared with Canada.
Data sharing and availability
Imagery collected from Open Skies missions is available to any state party upon request for the cost of reproduction. As a result, the data available to each state party is much greater than that which it can collect itself under the treaty quota system.
At a Geneva Conference meeting with Soviet Premier Nikolai Bulganin in 1955, U.S. President Eisenhower proposed that the United States and Soviet Union conduct surveillance overflights of each other's territory to reassure each country that the other was not preparing to attack. The fears and suspicions of the Cold War led Soviet General Secretary Nikita Khrushchev to reject Eisenhower's proposal.
During a five-day summit conference held in Geneva at the end of July 1955, the Soviet Union and United States held serious talks about disarmament and the United States put forward proposals for mutual reconnaissance flights over each other's air space, known as the Open Skies proposal. The United States had a large number of RB-47 and RB-36 reconnaissance aircraft at its disposal for such activities. However, the Soviets turned down this proposal. This Geneva Conference was nonetheless accepted as a turning point in the Cold War. The tensions in Europe were felt to be a stalemate. Both the Soviet Union and United States were willing to talk about their differences, rather than escalate them into a state of war.
Thirty-four years later, the Open Skies concept was reintroduced by U.S. President George H. W. Bush as a means to build confidence and security between all North Atlantic Treaty Organisation (NATO) and Warsaw Pact countries. In February 1990, an international Open Skies conference involving all NATO and Warsaw Pact countries opened in Ottawa, Canada. Subsequent rounds of negotiations were held in Budapest, Hungary; Vienna, Austria; and Helsinki, Finland.
On March 24, 1992, the Open Skies Treaty was signed in Helsinki by U.S. Secretary of State James Baker and foreign ministers from 23 other countries. The treaty entered into force on January 2, 2002, after Russia and Belarus completed ratification procedures.
In November 1992, President Bush assigned responsibility for overall training, management, leadership, coordination and support for U.S. Open Skies observation missions to the On-Site Inspection Agency (OSIA), now a part of the Defense Threat Reduction Agency (DTRA). Until entry into force in January 2002, DTRA support for the treaty involved participating in training and joint trial flights (JTFs). The U.S. has conducted over 70 JTFs since 1993. By March 2003, DTRA had successfully certified 16 camera configurations on the OC-135B aircraft. They also had contributed to the certification of the Bulgarian An-30, Hungarian An-26, SAMSON POD Group (see above) C-130H, Romanian An-30, Russian An-30, and Ukrainian An-30. The United States successfully flew its first Open Skies mission over Russia in December 2002.
With entry into force of the treaty, formal observation flights began in August 2002. During the first treaty year, state parties conducted 67 observation flights. In 2004, state parties conducted 74 missions, and planned 110 missions for 2005. On March 8 and 9, 2007, Russia conducted overflights of Canada under the Treaty. The OSCC continues to address modalities for conducting observation missions and other implementation issues.
Since 2002, a total of 40 missions have taken place over the U.K. There were 24 quota missions conducted by: Russia – 20; Ukraine – three; and Sweden – one. There were 16 training flights conducted by: Benelux (joint with Estonia); Estonia (joint with Benelux); Georgia – three (one joint with Sweden); Sweden – three (one joint with Georgia); US – three; Latvia; Lithuania; Romania; Slovenia; and Yugoslavia. Also since 2002 the U.K. has undertaken a total of 51 open skies missions – 38 were quota missions to the following countries: Ukraine (five); Georgia (seven) and Russia (26); 13 missions were training missions to the following nations: Bulgaria; Yugoslavia; Estonia; Slovenia (three); Sweden (three); US; Latvia, Lithuania and the Benelux. The flights cost approximately £50,000 per operational mission, and approximately £25,000 for training missions with an approximate annual cost of £175,000.
A Russian Defence Ministry spokesman stated on 4 February 2016 that Turkey had refused a Russian Open Skies mission, planned to take place on 1–5 February 2016, to fly over areas adjacent to Syria, as well as over NATO airbases. According to Russia, Turkey gave no explanation regarding the limitations, and claimed them to indicate illegal military activity in Syrian territory. The OSCC has not commented on the alleged violation of the Treaty by Turkey.
Challenges to the treaty
Both Russia and the United States have alleged that the other is violating the provisions of the treaty. U.S. Secretary of State Mike Pompeo cited for example Russia's access refusal in the Russian-controlled areas of Georgia. On 20 September 2019, the U.S. and Canada were denied access to a military exercise in central Russia.
In October 2019, according to documents from the House of Representatives, the United States' President was considering withdrawing from the Open Skies Treaty. NATO allies and partners, in particular Ukraine, were against the move, fearing it would license Russia to reduce further or ban overflights, thus reducing their knowledge of Russian military movements.
In April 2020, it was reported that Secretary of State Mike Pompeo and Secretary of Defense Mark Esper had agreed to proceed with U.S. withdrawal from the Treaty on Open Skies. On May 21, 2020, President Trump announced that the United States would be withdrawing from the treaty due to alleged Russian violations.
On 22 May 2020, the United States submitted notice of withdrawal from the Treaty on Open Skies. Senate Democrats questioned the legality, wisdom, and appropriateness of the planned withdrawal so close to the 2020 United States presidential election. The US said it would share some of its intelligence and reconnaissance information with European allies to make up for any loss of critical information from the end of the Treaty.
On 22 November 2020, United States official sources—including US Department of State websites, Secretary of State Mike Pompeo and the National Security Council's official Twitter account—announced that the six-month period was over and the US was no longer a party to the Treaty.
In January 2021, Russia announced that it will follow the United States of America in withdrawing from the Treaty on Open Skies. The Foreign Ministry said that Russia does not intend to stay in the treaty.
- "Open Skies Treaty". U.S. Department of State. Retrieved May 21, 2020.
- One or more of the preceding sentences incorporates text from a United States Government publication in the public domain: Open Skies Treaty Fact Sheet published by the United States Department of State Bureau of Arms Control on March 23, 2012, last accessed on April 11, 2012.
- "United States formally withdraws from Open Skies treaty - US & Canada". Al Jazeera. 2020-11-22. Retrieved 2020-11-22.
- "Russia follows US in withdrawal from Open Skies Treaty". AP NEWS. 2021-01-15. Retrieved 2021-01-19.
- "Treaty on Open Skies". Open Skies Consultative Commission. Retrieved 10 August 2013.
- Alejandro Micco, Tomás Serebrisky (2006). "Competition regimes and air transport costs: The effects of open skies agreements". Journal of International Economics. 70.
- Wiegold, T. (5 January 2017). "Flugbereitschaft erhält zusätzlichen Airbus" [Open Skies Adds Airbus Aircraft]. Augen geradeaus (in German).
- "Washington Debates Role of Satellites in Open Skies Treaty". Air Force Magazine. 2019-12-09. Retrieved 2019-12-10.
- "Foreign Affairs". American Experience. WGBH Educational Foundation. Retrieved 28 July 2013.
The two sides would not meet face-to-face until the Geneva summit of 1955. At the summit, Eisenhower asserted, "I came to Geneva because I believe mankind longs for freedom from war and the rumors of war. I came here because my lasting faith in the decent instincts and good sense of the people who populate this world of ours." In this spirit of good will, Eisenhower presented the Soviets with his Open Skies proposal. In it he proposed that each side provide full descriptions of all their military facilities and allow for aerial inspections to insure the information was correct. The Soviets rejected the proposal. Eisenhower was disappointed, but not surprised. In truth, the Open Skies proposal would have benefited the U.S. much more so than the Soviets – the Russians already knew the location of most American strategic defense facilities, it was the Americans who stood to gain new information.
- One or more of the preceding sentences incorporates text from a United States Government publication in the public domain: On-Site Inspection Operations: Treaty on Open Skies page at the United States Defense Threat Reduction Agency, last accessed on July 19, 2009.
- "Russian military to inspect Canada from above". Archived from the original on March 10, 2007. Retrieved March 8, 2007.
- "Military Intelligence".
- Briefing of the Russian Defence Ministry spokesman concerning activities of Rus aircraft in the Syrian Arab Republic : Ministry of Defence of the Russian Federation
- "News and press releases".
- Liewer, Steve (27 March 2016). "Russia's 'ahead of us' on technology used in Open Skies observation flights, StratCom warns". Omaha World-Herald. Omaha, Nebraska, United States. Retrieved 18 April 2017.
- Sharkov, Damien (8 June 2015). "New Russian Surveillance Jets Able to 'See Underground'". Newsweek Europe. Retrieved 18 April 2017.
- "Russia wants to fly surveillance planes over US with advanced cameras, congressional staffer says". Fox News. New York. Associated Press. 22 February 2016. Retrieved 18 April 2017.
- "U.S., Russia Trade Charges Over Open Skies Treaty Compliance". AINOnline. 27 September 2017. Retrieved 14 August 2018.
- Michael R. Gordon; James Marson (May 21, 2020). "U.S. Moving to Leave 'Open Skies' Treaty Designed to Reduce Conflict With Russia". The Wall Street Journal. Retrieved 22 May 2020.
Secretary of State Mike Pompeo said years of what he called violations by Russia had undermined the treaty. Russia “weaponized the Treaty by making it into a tool of intimidation and threat,” he said. He cited Moscow’s refusal of access to breakaway regions that it controls in the former Soviet republic of Georgia
- Michael R. Gordon; Vivian Salama (27 October 2019). "Trump Moves Closer to Ending Another Post-Cold War Treaty". The Wall Street Journal. Retrieved 22 May 2020.
Russia prevented the U.S. and Canada from carrying out a flight near a military exercise in central Russia on Sept. 20
- "Unfriendly Skies: Trump Wants to Scrap Valuable Intelligence Treaty". The Bulwark. 2019-10-15. Retrieved 2019-10-17.
- "Letter to Robert O'Brien" (PDF).
- King, Iain (2019-10-27). "Storm Clouds Gather over Open Skies Treaty". CSIS. Retrieved 2019-11-25.
- "Trump administration determined to exit treaty reducing risk of war". The Guardian. 2020-04-05. Retrieved 2019-04-10.
- Riechman, Deb (May 21, 2020). "US says it's pulling out of Open Skies surveillance treaty". Associated Press. Archived from the original on May 21, 2020. Retrieved May 21, 2020.
- "On the Treaty on Open Skies". United States Department of State. Retrieved 2020-11-22.
- "Open Skies Treaty: US to withdraw from arms control deal". BBC News. 2020-05-21. Retrieved 2020-11-22.
- "Leading Senate Democrats Question Legality of Trump Administration's Withdrawal from Open Skies Treaty". www.foreign.senate.gov (Press release). United States Senate Committee on Foreign Relations. June 22, 2020. Retrieved 2020-11-24.
The Senators questioned the legitimacy of the Administration’s May 22 letter declaring the President’s intent to withdraw from the treaty, saying it was a violation of the provision in the law mandating the Administration give 120 days of advanced notification to Congress prior to beginning the withdrawal process from the Open Skies Treaty.
- Mastrangelo, Dominick (22 November 2020). "Trump administration pulls out of Open Skies Treaty with Russia". TheHill. Retrieved November 22, 2020.
- Browne, Ryan. "US formally withdraws from Open Skies Treaty that bolstered European security". CNN. Retrieved 2020-11-23.
- "Treaty on Open Skies". United States Department of State. Retrieved 2020-11-22.
- Pompeo, Mike [@secpompeo] (Nov 22, 2020). "Today, pursuant to earlier notice provided, the United States withdrawal from the Treaty on Open Skies is now effective. America is more secure because of it, as Russia remains in non-compliance with its obligations" (Tweet). Retrieved 2020-11-24 – via Twitter.
- National Security Council [@whnsc] (Nov 22, 2020). "(1/2) "Today marks six months since the United States submitted our notice of withdrawal from the Treaty on Open Skies. We are now no longer a party to this treaty that Russia flagrantly violated for years" (Tweet). Retrieved 2020-11-24 – via Twitter.
- National Security Council [@whnsc] (Nov 22, 2020). "(2/2) @POTUS has never ceased to put America first by withdrawing us from outdated treaties and agreements that have benefited our adversaries at the expense of our national security." –NSA Robert C. O'Brien" (Tweet). Retrieved 2020-11-24 – via Twitter.
- Khurshudyan, Isabelle. "Russia plans withdrawal from Open Skies treaty allowing surveillance flights after U.S. pullout". Washington Post. ISSN 0190-8286. Retrieved 2021-01-19.
- "Russia is coming out of Open Skies". RT на русском (in Russian). Retrieved 2021-01-15.
|Wikimedia Commons has media related to Open Skies aircraft.|
- Norway and Denmark conducting observation flights over Belarus and Russia at Wikinews
- Photogallery of flights under the Open Skies Treaty – on the Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe website
- YouTube historical video on Open Skies Treaty
- Text of the treaty
- Open Skies Treaty Factsheet, cns. miis.edu
- Treaty Information (including recent updates) from the Open Skies Media Processing Facility at Wright-Patterson Air Force Base
- "U.S. Starts Air Inspections Over Russian, Belarus Military Objects" MosNews.com June 15, 2005
- Open Skies for Peace in the Age of Nuclear Weapons Video and documents about President Eisenhower's open skies proposal.
- Open Skies to Build Trust Article in the Cincinnati Post on 1/10/2006
- Eisenhower's Open Skies to Reach 500th Flight
- Relevance of the Open Skies Treaty Program in the Twenty-First Century by Tony D. Holmes, Major, USAF