Turtle Creek Industrial Railroad
Turtle Creek Industrial Railroad locomotive #550 in Export, PA
|Locale||Westmoreland County, Pennsylvania|
|Dates of operation||1982–2009|
|Predecessor||Turtle Creek Branch of the Pennsylvania Railroad|
|Successor||Westmoreland Heritage Trail|
|Track gauge||4 ft 8 1⁄2 in (1,435 mm) standard gauge|
|Length||10.7 miles (17.2 km)|
Turtle Creek Industrial Railroad
The Turtle Creek Industrial Railroad (reporting mark TCKR) was a short line freight railroad that operated in western Pennsylvania between the boroughs of Export and Trafford, where it connected to the Pittsburgh Line. The TCKR was a wholly owned subsidiary of the Dura-Bond Corporation, a steel products company headquartered in Export. The company purchased the railroad from Conrail (the successor to the Pennsylvania Railroad) in 1982. For the next 27 years, three to five trains per week made the round trip along just over ten miles of track, delivering materials such as steel pipe to the shortline's parent company in Export and lumber to lumber yards in neighboring Murrysville. In the shortline's heyday, trains of about four cars in length were typical, and were hauled by one of the railroad's two 1940s era switch engines, operated by a two man crew. The railroad was in service until 2009, when flash flooding of Turtle Creek severely damaged the TCKR's tracks which ran adjacent to the stream. After cessation of service, most of the right-of-way was sold to Westmoreland County to become part of the Westmoreland Heritage Trail.
- 1 Founding and acquisition by Pennsylvania RR: 1886-1982
- 2 Sale from Conrail to Dura-Bond: 1982
- 3 Short line operations: 1982-2009
- 4 The flood, end of service and conversion to rail-trail: 2009-2019
- 5 Rolling Stock: Locomotives and Caboose
- 6 Operational Statistics
- 7 References
- 8 External links
Founding and acquisition by Pennsylvania RR: 1886-1982
The Turtle Creek Industrial Railroad traces its origins back to 1886, when George Westinghouse chartered what was then called the Turtle Creek Valley Railroad with the hopes of exploiting the natural gas fields in Murrysville. At its westernmost point, the line began in East Pittsburgh where it dovetailed into Andrew Carnegie's Union Railroad, then ran eastward along the right bank of Turtle Creek to a junction near SZ tower in Trafford, where it intersected the main line of the Pennsylvania Railroad before proceeding farther up the Turtle Creek Valley to Murrysville. Service on the line began to Murrysville in 1891, and was extended to Export the following year. A branch along Lyons Run was built in 1892/1893, which ran 3.86 miles from Saunders Station to Pleasant Valley. In 1917 the primary line was extended eastward from Export to the mines in Slickville.
The Pennsylvania Railroad Company began operating the line in 1891 and purchased it outright in 1903. It assigned names to these new branches of its expanding rail network. The portion which ran downstream from Trafford on the right bank of the Turtle Creek waterway would be dubbed the East Pittsburgh Branch, and was leased back to the Westinghouse Company, which operated its Interworks Railway on the tracks until a flood control project on Turtle Creek broke apart the tracks in 1962. The Lyons Run Branch was used to transport coal from the mines in Pleasant Valley; it was retired in 1950 and the Pennsylvania Turnpike was extended over part of its path the following year. The section which ran up the main stem of Turtle Creek from Trafford through Export was called the Turtle Creek Branch; of the three branches it would have the longest history as an active rail line, which would culminate with its service as the Turtle Creek Industrial Railroad.
At its peak the Turtle Creek Branch extended from Westinghouse's facilities in Trafford all the way through Saltsburg, and its primary cargo was not gas but coal. Passenger service to and from Pittsburgh and points west was also popular, first served by steam engine trains and later by a single car diesel vehicle known as the "Doodlebug". Vehicles made stops in North Trafford, Blackburn, Saunders, Murrysville, Newlonsburg and Export. At its peak, an average of 1000 passengers each weekend would ride this rail line down to Pittsburgh; passenger service eventually declined, ultimately ending in 1936. Coal shipments declined as well as mines closed, and businesses located along Old and New William Penn Highway became the railroad's only customers.
In 1968 the owner of the Turtle Creek Branch, the Pennsylvania Railroad Company, merged to form Penn Central, which declared bankruptcy only two years later. A new company, Conrail, was formed to take over the freight lines of the short-lived Penn Central; it renamed its "Branches" as "Industrial Tracks", giving the Turtle Creek railroad its penultimate name: The Turtle Creek Industrial Track. In 1980, Congress passed the Staggers Rail Act which deregulated the rail industry, permitting carriers to sell-off unprofitable lines. Subsequently Conrail announced that it was looking to was looking to abandon several lines, and its Turtle Creek Industrial Track was among them.
Sale from Conrail to Dura-Bond: 1982
In November 1981 Conrail announced intention to abandon its unprofitable Turtle Creek Valley Line. At the time several businesses relied on it for shipments, including Dura-Bond, an Export based protective coating company owned by the Norris family. Wayne Norris then sized up the company's situation: "Losing this line would be inconvenient for the other companies, but it would be devastating for us". He noted that Dura-Bond needed to move large steel products too big and heavy to ship by truck, a number of truck strikes had occurred in the area, and his company needed a reliable, competitive transportation alternative. They were faced with a choice: move their company to a new location served by rail, subsidize Conrail's existing operations, or purchase the railroad. After discussing their options, Dura-Bond decided to purchase the railroad outright, taking on other businesses along the line as paying customers. They renamed the railroad the "Turtle Creek Industrial Railroad", and would own and operate it themselves as a privately owned subsidiary company.
To defray some of the start up costs, Dura-Bond received a $313,240 grant from the commonwealth of Pennsylvania. Governor Dick Thornburgh, who traveled to Export for the newly acquired railroad's opening ceremony, justified the grant, remarking that the rail service would preserve more than 700 industrial jobs in Westmoreland County. The Westmoreland County Industrial Development Authority also backed the project with low interest revenue bonds. The purchase price of the line would be $125,000, but this relatively low number reflected something all of the parties in the deal knew: the track was in very poor condition. Dura-Bond secured a bank loan to help pay the additional costs that it knew would soon come.
The newly purchased short-line railroad began operations in June 6, 1982 and experienced 12 derailments in its first month. Since the trains were limited to a maximum of 10 miles per hour, these were not necessarily as dramatic as the word "derailment" can imply, but were still disruptive enough for Dura-Bond to quickly hire a contractor to perform two months worth of track repair on an expedited basis. In addition to its general state of disrepair that came from decades of neglect, the track was also too steeply banked around its bends, causing the TCKR's relatively slow, heavy trains to exert too much pressure on the inner rail as they went through turns. Track rehabilitation costs would total $418,000 in the first year, when the railroad lost money, and $225,000 in the second year, when it hoped to break even. These were anticipated costs, as Dura-Bond had committed to operating the rail line for at least two years and could not sell it for at least five as conditions of the acquisition.
Short line operations: 1982-2009
A Norris family engineer summarized the company's key to its plan for turning the railroad to profitability, "Conrail needed a seven man crew to run the line. We do it with two men and a dog." In addition to the engineer's pit-bull, the TCKR employed 4 persons, nominally two engineers and two brakemen. They would do everything including driving the trains, keeping the railroad's 1940s era locomotives running, and maintaining the track. They also had the skills and equipment to re-rail minor derailments, as well as replace damaged rail ties using only hand tools if need be.
As many as three round trips per day were possible on the line, and Dura-Bond believed that trains of up to 10 cars could be safely transported. Trains running 3-5 times per week, averaging 4 cars per train would come to be described as typical. A routine daily shipment began with Conrail dropping off a train in Trafford. Next Conrail would pick up a train of empty cars to be returned that had been previously left there by the TCKR. Later that day a TCKR locomotive would pick up the loaded train that had been left by Conrail and take it to Murrysville and/or Export for distribution to customers. Cargo could include steel products, lumber, aluminum and rubber, and single train could contain cars destined for multiple different locations. Sidings positioned along the single track in Trafford, Murrysville and Export made it possible for a TCKR locomotive to run around a train parked at any of those places, allowing it to detach cars from the train and push them to their individual recipients. Once deliveries had been made, the process would be reversed, as the short line's locomotive would gather and return empty cars to be towed back to Trafford where they would be picked up again by Conrail. The TCKR's staff promised to work to keep the freight cars moving, stating that the cars "cost you money" when just sitting on a siding. This won praise from the customers; two that were interviewed after the first year Dura-Bond owned the railroad commented that service had improved dramatically. One noted that shipments which could be delayed over a week on the transfer track when Conrail owned and operated the line were arriving the same day under the new local ownership and management.
Despite the positive reviews and the efforts to expand the railroad's customer base, the number of shippers reported on the line was at its highest when it first began operations, and would decline slowly over the next three decades. A preliminary report indicated that the newly acquired short-line had 10 customers, which, together with Dura-Bond, would total 11 patrons of the railroad. These were Beckwith Machinery, Building Components, Delmont Builders, 84 Lumber, Export Tire, Gateway Packaging, J&M Machinery, Long Mill Rubber, National Aluminum and Weyerhaeuser. A total of 9 shippers were reported for the TCKR later in 1982 and 1983. This had dropped again to 7 by 1984, 5 in 1991, and 4 in 1996. In 2009 this number had dwindled to just 2: Dura-Bond itself and the lumber company Weyerhaeuser, which had long been the railroad's biggest customer.
Reports do not state with certainty when the railroad was turning a profit and when it was operating at a loss, but they do give some clues. When it first started operations in 1982, the company estimated it would be hauling 500-1000 cars per year at first, and would eventually have to haul "about 1500 cars a year" to turn a profit, charging $250 per car. In 1991 about 500 cars/year was the reported haul; circa 1996 it was again nearly 500; in 1999 it was about 700 cars per year. Between those years Wayne Norris commented that his railroad was making enough money to pay for its basic maintenance, but not enough to replace a locomotive. In 2009 an engineering survey indicated that only 150 cars per year were traveling over the railroad's bridges. Norris attributed part of the drop off in business to the closure of Pittsburgh based steel mills.
The railroad was kept running despite its apparent lack of profits. This was partly out of the need to ship materials to the railroad's parent company, but something less tangible may have also factored in. When his company first purchased the railroad, Wayne Norris admitted nostalgia played "a small role" in his decision to buy and operate it. His words shed further light on this: "I was born and raised here in Export. I remember steam engines rolling through here. The trains were a part of our lives..I'm proud to be running a piece of Turtle Creek Valley history...Coal gave this borough its name..I'd read somewhere that a community suffers psychologically when it loses its rail service, and I believe there's some truth in it."
The flood, end of service and conversion to rail-trail: 2009-2019
On the night of June 16–17, 2009 a powerful storm struck western Pennsylvania causing flash flooding along many streams and creeks, including Turtle Creek. Flooding in the borough of Export was particularly bad; its mayor commented that he had not seen water so high since the 1960s. In addition to damaging Dura-Bond's main facility, the water washed out five feet of the embankment that the Turtle Creek Industrial Railroad rested on. Dura-Bond reported approximately $1 million in uninsured losses in addition to $1/4 million in losses to its railroad. Governor Ed Rendell requested federal aid to deal with the impact or the storms, however this request was denied as the damages were not determined to be of such severity and magnitude to exceed the ability of state and local agencies to deal with them. The flooding caused an extended outage of rail service, during which the only remaining customer on the line made arrangements to have rail cars sent to their facility via truck.
The rails become a trail
The Regional Trail Corporation had long expressed interest in creating a rail-trail along the path of the TCKR, though initially the railroad's owners did not share this interest. Sensing that the flood may have changed this, in 2011 the RTC and Westmoreland County put together an extensive plan to convert the railroad to a greenway. In 2013 the TCKR officially filed for a discontinuation of service, having previously acknowledged that service actually ended in 2009. Soon thereafter, an agreement was finalized to sell most of the railroad to Westmoreland County for the appraised value of $863,000. Dura-Bond president Wayne Norris acknowledged that continuing to operate the railroad would result in "a lot of flood related costs", noting a general trend of water flowing into the Turtle Creek valley more rapidly than in the past and attributing the increased runoff to increased suburban development in the watershed. As of September 2017, the tracks have been removed from most of the railbed, and several miles of the western section have been made into an extension of the Westmoreland Heritage Trail, with the remaining eastern section scheduled for trail completion by 2019.
A few sections of TCKR track are expected to remain in place after this rail trail section is completed. About 1.5 miles of the railroad track was not part of the original sale to Westmoreland county. A portion of this is at the end of the line in Export, where Dura-Bond maintains its facilities. The other major segment is 0.9 miles of track at the beginning of the line in Trafford; this portion of track was not owned by Dura-Bond but was retained by Conrail, which handed it down to one of its successors, Norfolk Southern. The county has expressed interest in acquiring a portion of this track from NS. The Westmoreland Heritatge Trail group intends to leave in place some of the track which it has already acquired: a 40 foot siding in Murrysville remains, where the local historical society intends to place a railroad artifact.
Rolling Stock: Locomotives and Caboose
Before acquisition of the railroad, Dura-Bond already owned a small 300 horsepower 44-ton Whitcomb Co. switcher which it used to handle cars in the railyard at its facility; it would later acquire a comparable General Electric 50-ton switcher to take over these duties. But to operate the length of the railroad, the company would need some more powerful locomotives to haul up to 10 fully loaded cars up the steepest section of the track, reported to be a 2 percent gradient section in Murrysville. So in May 1982 the new railroad company purchased from the Johnstown and Stony Creek Railroad a 600 h.p. 100-ton switcher, model EMD SW1 built in August 1949, which became TCKR engine #462. Included as part of the $44,000 price of this locomotive was a cupola caboose, which the seller insisted had to be taken along with the engine as part of a two-for-one deal. In 1985 the railroad purchased from the Union Railroad what it would dub TCKR engine #550, a 110-ton 1200 h.p. model. A documentary video indicates TCKR 550 was manufactured in 1947, while a 1996 railway guide and railfans state that it was built in October of 1949. These same two sources identify Engine 550 as a model EMD NW2, but it is listed as a model EMD SW7 in a 2006 official filing with the Surface Transportation Board.) These two switch engines, both originally manufactured for the Union Railroad, would remain with the TCKR throughout the rest of its operations. Engine 462 was described as the primary workhorse of the railroad, with engine 550 also seeing occasional duty.
The caboose bundled in the deal that acquired TCKR 462 was reportedly built in either 1927, 1937 or 1939, and given the name TCKR 9 by its new owner. The company originally announced intentions to use this car to serve as a lookout at the end of its trains. But the 1980s would be a time when freight operators in the US were phasing out this traditional role of the caboose, and a documentary video of the Turtle Creek Industrial Railroad produced just after this decade showed many of its freight trains in operation, but none with a caboose in tow. By 1999, TCKR 9 was spending most of its days parked near Old William Penn Highway in Export, serving as "a symbol of days gone by". Dura-Bond did continue to maintain the caboose in rail-worthy condition for the special occasions on which it would see use, such as transporting Santa Claus during Export's Christmas celebrations.
When it was decided that the line would be discontinued, new homes would be found for some of the equipment that once worked the tracks. In August 2014, engine 462 was moved to Dura-Bond's Duquesne facility, with the other engine remaining behind at its Export plant. The company's caboose was thoroughly restored by Dura-Bond and donated to the Export Historical Society; it now sits on what remains of the TCKR track in downtown Export.
- Total Train Miles
- Employee Hours Worked
Data logged with the Federal Railroad Administration showed that service on the Turtle Creek Industrial Railroad was steady from 1987 through 2008. (Data prior to 1987 are incomplete.) Given that the track distance between Trafford and Export is 10 miles in each direction, the total train miles reported per year are consistent with the "three to five trains per week" cited in the 1991 documentary. The drop-off in miles logged as a result of the June 2009 flood is apparent. Regular train service halted in June 2009, and after a three month pause, a final 64 train miles were recorded in October. Employee work hours continued to be logged each month through July 2010.
- Boucher, John Newton; Jordan, John Woolf (1906). History of Westmoreland county, Pennsylvania, Volume 1. New York: The Lewis publishing company. p. 284.
- No. 9756 Track Chart, PRR Central Region, Pittsburgh Division Branches (PDF). Pittsburgh, PA: Pennsylvania RR Co. Dec 31, 1951.
- Laman, Jeffrey; Guyer, Robert C. (Feb 1, 2010). Conditional Assessment of Short-line Railroad Bridges in Pennsylvania. Pennsylvania Department of Transportation.
- "How did the B.Y. Park get its name?". Trafford History. Trafford Historical Society. Retrieved 17 July 2018.
- "1895 – Real estate plat-book of the eastern vicinity of Pittsburgh". G.M. Hopkins Company Maps. Retrieved 17 August 2018.
- Trafford Borough 75th Anniversary Souvenir Book. Trafford, PA: Diamond Jubilee Committee. 1979.
- Bluman, Allan R.; Bluman, Allan G.; Emry, Stu; Norris, Jim; Rubright, Charley; Karas, Luke (1991). "The Turtle Creek Industrial Railroad : A Short Line Operation". (Video, 50min). Box Office Productions.
- Varine, Patrick (July 23, 2015). "Turtle Creek short-line rail marks 125th anniversary". Pittsburgh Tribune-Review.
- No. IX Track Chart, PRR Pittsburgh Region, District-A Branches (PDF). Pittsburgh, PA: Pennsylvania RR Co. Dec 31, 1958.
- Acquisition of the Turtle Creek Railroad Corridor for the Westmoreland Heritage Trail (PDF). Regional Trail Corporation. August 2013. p. 6.
- "Turtle Creek Industrial Railroad". Retrieved August 21, 2009.
- Burgess, George H.; Kennedey, Miles C. (1949). Centennial history of the Pennsylvania Railroad Company, 1846-1946. Philadelphia: The Pennsylvania Railroad Company. p. 511.
- Conrail Maintenance Program and Track Chart, Centrail Region Pittsburgh Division (PDF). January 1, 1981.
- Richmond, Charles (July 15, 2004). Pennsylvania Historical Resource Survey (PDF). Harrisburg, PA: Pennsylvania Historical and Museum Commission, Bureau of Historic Preservation.
- Bach, Howard A. (December 10, 1983). "Faced With Rail Service Cutoff, Family Acquires, Runs Short Line". Altoona Mirror (Page 24).
- Bowman, Lee (June 10, 1982). "Tiny Railroad Gets On Track". Pittsburgh Press.
- Kurutz, Daveen Rae (Dec 26, 2012). "Flood-control project wraps up". TribLive.
- "New Westmoreland Rail Service Unveiled". Pittsburgh Post-Gazette (PG East, Page 2). June 10, 1982.
- Gibb, Tom (August 7, 1982). "Keeping State Business Online: Revival Of Abandoned Rail Picks Up Momentum". Altoona Mirror. p. 15, 19.
- Hoffman, Ernie (April 7, 1999). "End of the line for Turtle Creek caboose". Pittsburgh Post-Gazette (Page 136).
- Smith, Helene (1986). EXPORT: A Patch of Tapestry out of Coal Country America. Greensburg, PA: McDonald/Swärd Publishing Company. p. 210-211. ISBN 0945437005.
- McKay, Jim (June 16, 1996). "Short lines are in it for the long haul - Off the beaten track". Pittsburgh Post-Gazette (Pages C1-C4).
- "Fears of job, service cuts grow as Conrail sale nears". Pittsburgh Post-Gazette (Pages 1, 10–11). September 5, 1984.
- "$hort Line $uccess - Railroads pick up the slack left by bigger companies". Altoona Mirror (Page C8). July 14, 1996.
- Lewis, Edward A. (1996). American Shortline Railway Guide. Kalmbach Publishing. p. 315. ISBN 0-89024-290-9.
- Varine, Patrick (August 10, 2016). "Refurbished caboose to debut at Export Ethnic Food & Music Festival". Pittsburgh Tribune-Review.
- Gazarik, Richard (June 20, 2009). "Westmoreland officials assess damage while residents salvage what they can". Greensburg Tribune-Review.
- "Governor Rendell Signs Disaster Emergency Proclamation; Requests Federal Aid for Allegheny, Westmoreland Counties". PR Newswire (USA). June 29, 2009.
- Federal Emergency Management Agency (September 3, 2009). "Pennsylvania Severe Storm – Denial of Appeal" (PDF).
- Rico, Martha (October 30, 2014). EMPLOYER STATUS DETERMINATION Turtle Creek Industrial Railroad, Inc. (TCIR) (PDF).
- Scott, Rebekah (September 24, 2003). "Trail Group Won't Let Train Derail Plan For Link in Allegheny Passage". Pittsburgh Post-Gazette.
- Mackin Engineering (February 2011). Turtle Creek Greenway Plan.
- Wilson, Richard (September 3, 2013). Turtle Creek Industrial Railroad, Inc. - Discontinuance of Service Exemption- In Westmoreland County, PA; STB Docket No. AB-825 (PDF).
- "DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION Surface Transportation Board [Docket No. FD 35678] Turtle Creek Industrial Railroad, Inc.— Acquisition and Operation Exemption—Consolidated Rail Corporation" (PDF). Federal Register. 77 (208): 65446. October 26, 2012.
- Means, Tim (Feb 13, 2014). "Westmoreland County set to buy Turtle Creek railroad". Pittsburgh Post-Gazette.
- Blazina, Ed (Feb 12, 2016). "Funding arrives for Westmoreland Heritage Trail between Trafford and Murrysville". Pittsburgh Post-Gazette.
- McGee, Tom (April 27, 2016). "Westmoreland Heritage Trail supporters hope for cooperation from Norfolk Southern". Pittsburgh Tribune-Review.
- "Turtle Creek Industrial RR.Incorporated Photographic Roster". rrpicturearchives.net. Retrieved 5 August 2017.
- Alvord, Robert (October 4, 2006). Memorandum of Security Agreement (PDF).
- Carmichael, Allison (December 9, 1999). "Holiday Lanterns to Light up the Streets". Pittsburgh Post-Gazette (Page E-4).
- "(title unknown)". Delmont Salem News (Volume 46, Number 55). August 27, 2014.
- "1.02 - Operational Data Tables". Federal Railroad Administration Office of Safety Analysis. Retrieved 26 February 2019.
note: only 11 months of data were reported in 1997
|Wikimedia Commons has media related to Turtle Creek Industrial Railroad.|
- Turtle Creek Industrial Railroad archived on Aug 21, 2009 from Dura-Bond.com/railroad.html