Ufton Nervet rail crash

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search
Ufton Nervet rail crash
Date 6 November 2004
Time 18:12
Location Ufton Nervet, Berkshire
Country United Kingdom
Rail line Reading to Taunton Line
Operator First Great Western
Cause Obstruction on line
Statistics
Trains 1
Passengers 180–200
Deaths 7 (including the driver of the car involved)
Injuries 71
List of UK rail accidents by year

The Ufton Nervet rail crash was a collision between a train and car near Ufton Nervet, Berkshire, England in 2004. Seven people, including the drivers of the train and the car, were killed.

Collision[edit]

View westwards across the level crossing

On 6 November 2004 at 18:12 GMT, the First Great Western 17:35 service from London Paddington to Plymouth, an InterCity 125 (HST) led by a Class 43 power car (43019) collided with a stationary car at an automatic level crossing close to the rural West Berkshire village of Ufton Nervet. The inquest concluded that the crash was caused by Brian Drysdale, a chef at the nearby Wokefield Park Hotel, committing suicide by parking his car on the crossing.

More than 20 ambulances from 5 counties and 14 fire engines attended the crash. Injured passengers were first helped at the Winning Hand pub. Survivors reported using safety hammers to break the train windows after the collision to escape. The incident occurred during the hour of darkness, and so light sticks and mobile phones were used by passengers to provide some light. 61 injured people were taken to the Royal Berkshire Hospital in Reading and others to the North Hampshire Hospital in Basingstoke. Other passengers were treated at the scene and the Winning Hand pub for minor injuries.[1]

The rear of the 220 m (720 ft) long InterCity 125 train came to rest about 100 m (110 yd) beyond the crossing with all eight coaches derailed. Seven people were killed in the crash: the car's driver, the driver of the train, and five of its passengers.[2] About 200 people were on board at the time of the incident (official estimates are around 180–200). About half of these were injured, 12 of them seriously. Eleven people were cut free from the wreckage. The high structural integrity of the Mark 3 coaches prevented a much higher death toll, plus the fact that the more lightly loaded first-class coaches were at the leading end of the train.

The crash, investigation and necessary repairs blocked the main railway route between London and the West Country until the morning of 16 November 2004, subsequently operating under temporary speed restrictions to allow the bedding in of ballast. In the meantime InterCity trains operated via Swindon and Westbury and local services were replaced by rail and bus shuttles.

Background[edit]

A First Great Western Class 165 train from Paddington to Newbury passing through the level crossing. The half-barrier, with red and white stripes, is lowered over the left-hand carriageway.

In the United Kingdom, automatic half-barrier level crossings (AHB) are used on roads where traffic is unlikely to queue across the crossing and where rail line-speed is not more than 100 mph (160 km/h).[3] There are no means of checking that the crossing is not obstructed before the passage of a train. The half barriers close the road to traffic approaching the crossing but allow any vehicle still crossing to escape.[4] However, this does not physically prevent road users from zigzagging around the barriers and crossing the line, usually in an attempt to save time.

Site[edit]

The crash was at a level crossing on the narrow lane linking the village of Ufton Nervet to the Bath Road (A4), about 300 m (330 yd) from their junction. The crossing is between Theale and Aldermaston stations. The train was not scheduled to stop at either station.

Position: grid reference SU616687

Investigation[edit]

An investigation was carried out by Thames Valley Police and British Transport Police. A preliminary report by the Health and Safety Executive indicated that the car stopped on the level crossing before any warnings and failed to react to the barrier alarm sequence. A minor deflection of the stationary car to one side by the train derailed the forward bogie, which continued to travel at about 25° to the rails until reaching the points at the start of a loop. At this point the power car derailed completely, causing the remainder of the train to derail.

In the absence of information from the investigation, local and news media speculation centred on the theory that Bryan Drysdale, the car's driver, might have parked on the level crossing in order to attempt suicide, because there was no evidence of any attempt to move or exit the car.

The Rail Safety and Standards Board published a preliminary report on 1 February 2005[5] which stated:

  • The automatic half-barrier equipment and its associated ancillary equipment is in good condition and properly maintained.
  • The train driver shut off power and coasted for around four seconds, which was normal for this point in the journey. He then applied the emergency brakes at or about the time of impact with the car.
  • All lighting was lost in all the coaches during the accident. As a result, passengers and crew found orientation difficult, though the provision of glow sticks alleviated this to some extent. Some passengers who attempted to break windows in order to escape from the vehicle were hampered by breakage of the window hammers, and by the difficulty of reaching the upper windows of a vehicle leaning heavily to one side.
  • No evidence has been presented that the maintenance condition of the train contributed in any way to the derailment or exacerbated its consequences.
  • No evidence has been presented to the inquiry that would indicate there were any deficiencies in the fitness for duty on the part of the staff of either Network Rail or First Great Western.

The RSSB report made recommendations including improving emergency communications at the level crossing and moving a set of points whose position was a factor in the train's derailment. Network Rail implemented all the safety recommendations.[6][7]

Plaque in the Area of Reflection next to the level crossing: One event — many realities

On 1 June 2005 it was announced that an inquest into the crash would be held at the Guildhall in Windsor, Berkshire.[8] The inquest was expected to last 12 days, starting on 17 October 2005. It had been delayed due to a dispute over whether the families of the victims should be granted legal aid.[9] The inquest finally began in October 2007. A policeman who had witnessed the crash, PC Brazier, testified at the inquest. He told the jury that he believed the crash was caused by a suicide attempt.[10] The Forensic Accident Investigator, David Price, told the inquest that he had been able to determine that the car had been parked on the level crossing with its engine switched off, the handbrake fully applied, the vehicle's lights switched off, the steering on a partial left hand lock (which was not consistent with driving across the crossing), and that its fuel tank still contained at least 8 litres (about 2 gallons) of petrol.

On 1 November 2007 the inquest returned the verdict that the crash was caused by Brian Drysdale's (completed) attempt at suicide.[11] A support network, the Ufton Nervet Train Crash Network,[12] was set up for survivors and relatives of the victims.

Royal Humane Society awards[edit]

In 2005 the Royal Humane Society awarded its Bronze Medal to two passengers who were on the train: salesman Brian Kemsley and Royal Marines company sergeant major Tom McPhee.[13] The two men found nine-year-old Louella Main and her mother Anjanette Rossi, both of whom had been thrown out of the train by the force of the crash. Rossi was dead but Kemsley testified to the 2007 inquest:[14]

We came across a young person on the tracks and me and Tommy could see blood coming from the little girl's head and she had a little pulse. We were trying our hardest to keep her going.

Despite the men's efforts Main died of her injuries. Kemsley then found a clergyman who had been a passenger on the train, and got him to walk back to the bodies to say a prayer.[15] McPhee also found injured passenger Sharmin Bacchus trapped in the wreckage, and kept her conscious until she was freed.[16]

List of the dead[edit]

Name plate of First Great Western power car 43139 Driver Stan Martin, named 25 June 2005
  • Stanley Martin, 54, of Torquay, Devon (the train driver)
  • Anjanette Rossi, 38, of Speen, Berkshire (the mother of Louella Main)
  • Louella Main, 9, of Speen, Berkshire (the daughter of Anjanette Rossi)
  • Charlie Matthews, 72, of Warminster, Wiltshire
  • Barry Stevens, 55, of Wells, Somerset
  • Emily Webster, 14, of Doccombe, Devon
  • Brian Drysdale, 48, of Reading, Berkshire (the car driver)

Commemoration of the dead[edit]

Beside the level crossing a small gravelled "Area of Reflection" has been created with two wooden benches facing an engraved steel memorial plaque remembering all people affected by the collision. Also, on what would have been his 55th birthday, First Great Western named power car 43139 after the driver of the train.

Subsequent incidents[edit]

View northwest across the crossing, away from Ufton Nervet village

2009 suicide[edit]

In 2009 a man from Reading committed suicide at the crossing by jumping in front of a train.[17]

2010 death[edit]

In 2010 a man from Fareham, Hampshire was struck and killed by a train on the crossing. British Transport Police concluded that the death was not suspicious.[18]

2011 near miss[edit]

There was a near miss at the same level crossing on 4 September 2011. The Rail Accident Investigation Branch investigated the cause, which was found to be an error by a signaller working in a central location who failed to contact the train driver and the attendant at the crossing. This failure was likely due to work overload of the signaller.[19]

2012 death[edit]

At 13:10 on 22 May 2012 the 12:18 InterCity 125 express from Paddington to Taunton hit a motor scooter on the crossing, killing the rider, David Montague.[20] The train driver was slightly injured[21] and the line was closed until 19:30 that day.[20] British Transport Police reports that the crossing was working correctly when the collision happened.[21] Following an inquest an open verdict was recorded, with Berkshire's assistant deputy coroner stating that there was insufficient evidence to be certain that Montague had intended suicide.[22]

View southeast across the crossing, towards Ufton Nervet village


2014 death[edit]

At 18:50 hrs on 16 October 2014 a man from Calcot, Berkshire was struck and killed by a train on the crossing.[7][23] British Transport Police concluded that the circumstances were not suspicious.[24]

Survivors of the 2004 crash, local councillors, campaigners and the National Union of Rail, Maritime and Transport Workers[25] all responded by renewing calls for either full barriers or a replacement bridge at the crossing. Network Rail admitted it had "significantly underestimated" the cost of the bridge and was seeking more funding,[26] but stated that nevertheless it had been "assessing the best way of placing a large structure on a complicated and constricted site, near a busy road and a river". The company declared that "The investment into the modernisation of the Great Western Main Line has given us access to the substantial funding needed and we hope to be able to proceed very shortly".[27]

Safety proposals[edit]

In July 2012 an Internet petition was started by Liberal Democrat members of West Berkshire Council[28] and a Hungerford resident to lobby for full barriers and closed circuit television to be installed at the level crossing. The petition closed with 148 votes of support.

On 6 July 2012, Network Rail announced that it was considering either converting the crossing to full barriers or a bridge, and that the latter would have the advantage that Network Rail could safely increase train speeds on that part of the line.[28] Network Rail said it would decide whether to implement either of these options in "about three or four months".[28]

On Friday 2 November 2012, Network Rail issued a news release stating that it would like to replace the level crossing with a road bridge, but funding would need to be secured.[29] Geoff Mayes, the Liberal Democrat councillor who started the petition for full barriers and CCTV, objected to the decision to build a bridge due to lack of funding, design and building timescales, and its position on the River Kennet's flood plain. He also suggested that a bridge would endanger road traffic and pedestrians.[17]

In March 2014 Network Rail said it "remained on course" to replace the level crossing "by mid-2014 or 2015".[30] In April the company made exploratory boreholes and other tests to help it to evaluate the site, and in October 2014 it submitted bridge designs to West Berkshire Council.[26]

In August 2015, West Berkshire Council approved plans for a road bridge to replace the level crossing, with Network Rail announcing that work to construct the bridge would begin in 2016. [31]

See also[edit]

References[edit]

Instructions to drivers of large or slow road vehicles at the level crossing
  1. ^ http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk/3989277.stm
  2. ^ "Six die as train ploughs into car". BBC News. 7 November 2004. Retrieved 3 June 2010. 
  3. ^ "Railway Safety Principles and Guidance, part 2, section E, Guidance on level crossings" (PDF). HSE Books. 2005. Retrieved 13 October 2010. 
  4. ^ Leach, Maurice (1991). Railway Control Systems. London: A & C Black. ISBN 0-7136-3420-0. 
  5. ^ "Formal Inquiry: Preliminary Report: Ufton Level Crossing Passenger Train Collision with a Road Vehicle and Subsequent Derailment, 06 November 2004" (PDF). London, United Kingdom: Rail Safety and Standards Board. 25 January 2005. Retrieved 3 June 2010. [dead link]
  6. ^ "New safety call over level crossings". Western Morning News (South West Media Group). 4 November 2014. Retrieved 5 November 2014. 
  7. ^ a b "Ufton Nervet 2004 rail crash: Bridge being built at crossing". BBC News. 5 November 2014. Retrieved 5 November 2014. 
  8. ^ "Inquest into Ufton Nervet crash". BBC News. 1 June 2005. Retrieved 3 June 2010. 
  9. ^ "Memorial for rail crash victims". BBC News. 5 November 2005. Retrieved 3 June 2010. 
  10. ^ "Rail crash was 'suicide attempt'". BBC News. 17 October 2007. Retrieved 3 June 2010. 
  11. ^ "Rail crash was caused by suicide". BBC News. 1 November 2007. Retrieved 3 June 2010. 
  12. ^ Ufton Nervet Train Crash Network[dead link]
  13. ^ "Royal Humane Society Bronze Medals, taken from the Annual Report for 2005". Life Saving Awards Research Society. Retrieved 7 November 2014. 
  14. ^ Williams, Rachel (9 October 2007). "Plea for safer windows at rail deaths hearing". The Guardian (Guardian Media Group). Retrieved 7 November 2014. 
  15. ^ Clifton, Paul (November 2007). "The Survivors' Stories" (pdf). Rail Professional. Retrieved 7 November 2014. 
  16. ^ "Tributes paid to Exeter victims of Ufton Nervet train crash horror which killed seven people". Express & Echo (Local World). 6 November 2014. Retrieved 7 November 2014. 
  17. ^ a b Williams, James (3 December 2012). "Anger over rail firm’s bridge decision at Ufton Nervet". Newbury Weekly News (Blacket Turner Co). Retrieved 16 October 2014. 
  18. ^ "Fareham crossing death man is named by police". The News (Johnston Press). 1 February 2010. Retrieved 17 October 2014. 
  19. ^ "Rail Accident Report: Near miss incident at Ufton Automatic Half Barrier Crossing, Berkshire 4 September 2011" (PDF). Rail Accident Investigation Branch, Department for Transport. December 2012. 121220_R282012_Ufton. Retrieved 24 August 2014. 
  20. ^ a b "Ufton Nervet train crash victim named". Reading Chronicle (Berkshire Media Group). 23 May 2012. Retrieved 6 July 2012. 
  21. ^ a b "Moped rider killed in Ufton Nervet level crossing crash". BBC News. 22 May 2012. Retrieved 6 July 2012. 
  22. ^ "Open verdict at Ufton Nervet crossing inquest". Reading Chronicle. 19 September 2012. Retrieved 6 August 2015. 
  23. ^ Cooper, Dan (28 October 2014). "Man hit by train at Ufton Nervet is named". Newbury Weekly News (Blacket Turner Co). Retrieved 5 November 2014. 
  24. ^ "Man dies after being struck by a train at Ufton Nervet level crossing". Reading Chronicle (Berkshire Media Group). 16 October 2014. Retrieved 16 October 2014. 
  25. ^ "RMT renews call for level crossing action ten years after fatal crash at Ufton Nervet". National Union of Rail, Maritime and Transport Workers. 5 November 2014. Retrieved 5 November 2014. 
  26. ^ a b Cooper, Dan (24 October 2014). "Fresh calls for bridge at Ufton Nervet after latest fatality". Newbury Weekly News (Blacket Turner Co). Retrieved 5 November 2014. 
  27. ^ Walker, William (5 November 2014). "Bridge at Ufton Nervet level crossing will be built “very shortly”". Newbury Weekly News (Blacket Turner Co). Retrieved 5 November 2014. 
  28. ^ a b c "Rail crash level crossing at Ufton Nervet: Bridge considered". BBC News. Retrieved 6 July 2012. 
  29. ^ "Network Rail aims to replace Ufton Nervet level crossing with a road bridge". Network Rail Limited. 2 November 2012. Retrieved 24 August 2014. 
  30. ^ "Ufton Nervet deaths: Network Rail apology 'late', says MP". BBC News. 7 March 2014. Retrieved 5 November 2014. 
  31. ^ "Ufton Nervet level crossing: Rail bridge approved". BBC. 6 August 2015. Retrieved 6 August 2015. 

External links[edit]

Coordinates: 51°24′50″N 1°06′56″W / 51.41398°N 1.11563°W / 51.41398; -1.11563