University of Cambridge Chancellor election, 2011
The University of Cambridge Chancellor election, 2011 refers to a rare instance of a contested election for this position of Chancellor that occurred in October 2011, resulting in the choice of Lord Sainsbury of Turville to succeed the retiring incumbent Prince Philip, Duke of Edinburgh. The Duke had retired on 30 June 2011, shortly after his 90th birthday, having been Chancellor since December 1976. Three other candidates were nominated to oppose the candidate proposed by the university's Nomination Board; the post was won by Baron Sainsbury with 52% of the vote, with a simple majority required to avoid a runoff. Contesting the post were actor Brian Blessed, who finished second with 25% of the votes cast, barrister Michael Mansfield, QC with 17%, and local grocery-owner Abdul Arain with 6%. The election was the first time the Chancellorship had been contested since 1950, and the first actively fought contest since 1847. Although the election was conducted by the single transferable vote system, no transfers of votes were needed as Sainsbury secured a majority of first preference votes.
Prince Philip, Duke of Edinburgh retired on June 30, 2011, creating the opening which led to the October 2011 election. The Duke, husband of Queen Elizabeth II, had served as Chancellor since December 1976, and announced departure of the post as he reached his 90th birthday, after more than 30 years in the post. Prince Philip was quoted by The New York Times as saying "he wanted a life with 'less frantic rushing about' to ceremonial occasions and 'less trying to think of something to say.'"
Precedent and electorate
|This section requires expansion with: sourcing of history of contested chancellorships, and further details of earlier contested races. (March 2015)|
The electorate consisted of the Senate: all members of the University holding a higher degree from Cambridge. In effect, this meant that every Cambridge graduate holding a degree other than a bachelor's degree (save the BD) had a vote. Cambridge offers an upgrade of a BA to an MA six years and one term after undergraduates matriculate, so usually around three and a half years after they first graduate. Additionally, MA degrees are given to some members of staff, to make them a senior member of the university. In addition, all members of the Regent House were also entitled to vote as they are automatically members of the Senate, even if they have no previous Cambridge degree; this included most post-doctoral research staff with three years' service and also fellows of the colleges who do not hold a Cambridge degree.
Although not required to wear full academic dress to vote, voters were required to wear the appropriate gown and the university provided gowns, without charge, to voters who did not have them. By contrast, the University of Oxford dispensed entirely with such dress requirements for its Chancellor election in 2003.
According to the regulations, one of the candidates is nominated by the university's Nomination Board, and anyone else (whether a member of the University or not) can stand as a candidate if nominated by at least fifty senior members of the University holding higher degrees. Beyond the fifty or more nominators, there are no other requirements for candidates.
Four candidates were nominated:
- Abdul Arain, local grocery-owner
- Brian Blessed, actor and mountaineer
- Michael Mansfield, barrister
- David Sainsbury, Baron Sainsbury of Turville, businessman, politician and philanthropist
In December 2010, aware that Prince Philip intended to retire at the end of that academic year, the university convened a Nomination Board, composed of the University Council, plus sixteen members appointed by the University Senate. On 20 May 2011, the Nomination Board put forward Lord Sainsbury as their candidate. As per statutory procedure, if nobody had challenged him, he would then have been deemed elected unopposed on 1 July 2011, without the need for a ballot. No election has been opposed since 1950, where one candidate withdrew before the poll; the last election actively contested at a poll was in 1847.
In the event of a contested election, a ballot must take place over two days, between 21 and 28 days of full term after the close of nominations. Since the date of the close of nominations - 17 June 2011 - fell on the last full day of Easter Term, this meant that an election could not be held until a month after the end of the summer vacation, in October 2011.
The election came as a surprise to some, as it had generally been assumed that Lord Sainsbury's candidature would be unopposed, and an initial press announcement from the university seemed to confirm that preparations were underway to install Sainsbury unopposed.
On 27 May, local grocery-owner Abdul Arain announced that he was standing against Sainsbury, in opposition to an application to build a Sainsbury's Local in Cambridge's Mill Road district, which he claimed would harm the character of the area. He argued that, "once again, the university is called upon to be the vanguard of local communities", later adding, "Cambridge should be an institution that nurtures the community as well as world-renowned educational values", and that, "I'm standing for the whole Cambridge community." Speaking to The Grocer, Arain commented, "I’m not against Lord Sainsbury personally but the university should defend the local community. Cambridge is becoming a clone town." He also compared his "outsider" status to that of Barack Obama. Despite Arain's early declaration to stand, it took him a while to accumulate the 50 nominations necessary, stating on 3 June that he had 40 signatures, and expected to have another 10 by the close of nominations. On 6 June, he confirmed that he now had 50 nominators.
On 31 May, it was announced that over the preceding Bank Holiday weekend, a Facebook campaign by Cambridge graduates to draft veteran Shakespearean actor Brian Blessed as a candidate had resulted in the necessary 50 signatures being generated. Blessed was then approached, and released a statement on 2 June that he was "absolutely staggered" by the nomination, but that he was "delighted to accept", stating in his acceptance letter, "For me, Cambridge has always been the centre of the earth, there is a brightness and light there that rivals that on Mount Everest. The University buildings are architecturally beautiful, the whole setting is wonderful and enchants the soul. I am thrilled to be asked and wish you every success with the campaign." Blessed later added, "To me, being the next Chancellor of Cambridge University would be a miracle, because I’m the son of a coal miner", and he pledged to be an active Chancellor, remarking, "I’d like to inspire them to do expeditions all over the world. I would love to join them in expeditions, and promote adventure, adventure, adventure: I think the key to the new millennium is adventure. And it is that that I want to urge; and the university has so many projects, so many enterprises, so many departments, it makes my hair stand on end at the prospect of working with them." A poll in The Tab amongst their student readers (few of whom can vote) found Blessed to be the overwhelming favourite amongst students, polling 63.2%, compared to 13.5% for none of the candidates, 10% for Abdul Arain, and 5.7% for Lord Sainsbury, with 7.7% voting "I don't care."
On 2 June, Cambridge Classics Professor and Times columnist Mary Beard noted that despite "no connection" over Sainsbury's £82 million in donations to Cambridge University, she would "probably" vote for him, branding Arain a "publicity seeker", and describing Blessed's popularity with younger voters and students as "puzzling."
On 6 June, The Independent commented that the election had been expected to be a, "David and Goliath battle between Lord Sainsbury and local shopkeeper Abdul Arain. But this unlikely face-off could be disrupted by the unexpected participation" of Blessed.
On 14 June, it was reported that radical socialist barrister Michael Mansfield had been nominated by several Cambridge academics, with the lawyer describing his candidature as, "a fine opportunity to defend the principles of Higher Education and critical thinking in particular, which have been steadily eroded by successive governments wedded to market forces." In their supporting letter, his nominators contrasted his stance on several issues with that of Lord Sainsbury, writing that, "even if Mr Mansfield does not win this election, the campaign in his support will be able to articulate very clearly the fundamental opposition between what these two men stand for.". One of Mansfield's nominators elaborated to the Law Gazette on why the barrister was standing: "Is it too rude to call (Lord Sainsbury) a plutocrat? He has inherited wealth, and represents some of the capitalist focus that threatens the ideas on which a university is founded. We’d like to see someone who is prepared to question the establishment."
Nominations closed on 17 June, when a university spokesman confirmed that all four candidates had secured the level of support needed to get on to the ballot paper. Lord Sainsbury made his first public statement on the election since being nominated, stating, "I have great admiration and affection for the university, built up over all the years since I was an undergraduate at King's, studying history and then psychology. I also have a life-long interest in education. I have no personal agenda, and if elected, my sole aim would be to help the university in any way that I can."
On 24 July, Brian Blessed launched his official campaign website.
On 22 August, Blessed drew press attention as he released his first campaign video, in which Blessed described his humble origins and argued that the next Chancellor "must sweat blood to help people who are underprivileged", and offered to help in widening access to Cambridge, "with humour, and drive and soul and appreciation."
On 14 September, the Cambridge Union Society announced that they had secured the agreement of all four candidates for each to give their own separate hustings in the week before the election, with four Q&A sessions scheduled for between 10 and 12 October. None of the candidates would be attending hustings opposite their rival candidates.
On 23 September, it was announced in the local press that Blessed intended to spend the afternoon of one of the election days holding court in a Cambridge pub, thanking his supporters as they return from voting. Blessed subsequently received endorsements from Cambridge alumni Stephen Fry and Sir Derek Jacobi.
On 3 October, Lord Sainsbury gave an election interview with the Cambridge Evening News, in which he said "I’m not quite certain why any of the other three" candidates were standing against him, and he described his links to Cambridge as an undergraduate at King's between 1959 and 1963, his strong record in promoting British universities as a government minister, and his support for the introduction of student fees in the 1990s.
On 6 October, Abdul Arain revealed that he had the backing of the Cambridge's Mill Road Society, of which he is a former Chairman. He also unveiled several posters of himself, some YouTube videos in which he set out his case for standing, based on "representing a world-class university which has deep roots in its local community." Subsequently, Cambridge Student paper The Tab commented, "This leaves radical lawyer Michael Mansfield the quietest contender so far", with Mansfield having made no public statement on the election since his letter accepting nomination four months earlier.
On 7 October, IT analysts speculated "a failure by Cambridge University administrators to understand online campaign techniques may result in the defeat of their preferred candidate for the next university chancellor - Lord Sainsbury of Turville", and predicted a possible victory for Blessed. Cambridge alumnus Anthony Zacharzewski, a democracy analyst and founder of the Democratic Society, argued that the University's failure to engage with online campaigning and to adequately publicise the candidates' web presences, "plays into the hands of the Blessed vote", since his supporters had the best-organised online presence. The same analysts also predicted "gridlock in the city centre" on the election days. Neither prediction was borne out by events.
The election and aftermath
|This section requires expansion with: details regarding post-election analysis, and commentary from all candidates and supporters. (March 2015)|
It was confirmed by the university authorities on 18 June that the two polling days would be held on Friday 14 October and Saturday 15 October 2011, with voting taking place in the Senate House between 10am and 8pm on each day.
The results were announced just after mid-day on Sunday 16 October.
|Lord Sainsbury of Turville, K||2,893||52.1|
|Mr Brian Blessed||1,389||25.0|
|Michael Mansfield QC||964||17.3|
|Mr Abdul Arain||312||5.6|
Analysis of the election noted low turnout, with 2.5% of those eligible casting votes.
On hearing of his success, Lord Sainsbury said:
I am delighted and honoured to have been elected as the next Chancellor of Cambridge University, and would like to thank all those who have supported me, and the other candidates who have made this such a friendly election. I am particularly pleased that the election did not turn into a battle between the arts and humanities and science, or between political parties, and I look forward to championing the University in its entirety at home and abroad in the years ahead.
- Official information on election arrangements
- Abdul Arain for Chancellor Facebook page
- Brian Blessed for Chancellor - official campaign website
- Election statement from Michael Mansfield QC
- David Sainsbury official site
- List of Chancellors of the University of Cambridge
- Election for the Chancellorship of the University of Cambridge, 1950
- Election for the Chancellorship of the University of Cambridge, 1847
- Election for the Chancellorship of the University of Cambridge, 1811
- Election for the Chancellorship of the University of Cambridge, 1748
- Election for the Chancellorship of the University of Cambridge, 1626
- Election for the Chancellorship of the University of Oxford, 2003
- Election for the Chancellorship of the University of Oxford, 1987
- Election for the Chancellorship of the University of Oxford, 1925
- Category:University and college elections
- John F. Burns, 2011, "Cambridge Vote Ends With Supermarket Mogul on Top and Grocer in Last," The New York Times (online), October 16, 2011, see , accessed 14 March 2015.
- "University Statute A (1)". Admin.cam.ac.uk. 2010-05-19. Retrieved 2011-11-12.
- "The University". Admin.cam.ac.uk. Retrieved 2011-11-12.
- "Cambridge University Chancellor nomination bandwagon gathers speed". Tcs.cam.ac.uk. 2011-06-02. Retrieved 2011-06-10.
- "The Chancellor and Government of the University" (PDF). Statutes of the University of Cambridge.
- "MEMBERSHIP UNDER STATUTE A, III, 7(E)" (PDF). Ordinances of the University of Cambridge.
- "Chapter I : The Chancellor And The Government Of The University - Nomination And Election Of The Chancellor". Admin.cam.ac.uk. Retrieved 2011-10-13.
- "Chancellor of the University of Cambridge election". University of Cambridge. 28 July 2011.
- "Chancellorship of the University". Admin.cam.ac.uk. 2011-05-20. Retrieved 2011-06-10.
- "Trader hopes to battle Lord Sainsbury for chancellor". Cambridge News. Retrieved 2011-06-10.
- Kirsty Gray (2011-05-29). "Mill Road shopkeeper to take on Lord Sainsbury for Chancellorship". Varsity.co.uk. Retrieved 2011-06-10.
- Baker, Simon (21 May 2011). "Need a chancellor? Best knock on Sainsbury’s door". Times Higher Education Supplement. Retrieved 31 August 2011.
- "Trader hopes to battle Lord Sainsbury for chancellor". Cambridge Evening News.
- "Brian Blessed bids to be Cambridge chancellor". Bbc.co.uk. 2011-06-03. Retrieved 2011-06-10.
- "Cambridge indie owner battles Lord Sainsbury for university honour". Thegrocer.co.uk. Retrieved 2011-06-10.
- "Blessed to be Chancellor". Cambridge News. 2011-05-31. Retrieved 2011-06-10.
- "Grocery store owner passes 50 backers to run Cambridge University chancellor race - News". Cambridge First. Retrieved 2011-06-19.
- Jess Holland (2011-05-31). "Actor Brian Blessed becomes third potential contender for Chancellorship". Varsity.co.uk. Retrieved 2011-06-10.
- Jess Holland (2011-06-04). "Blessed accepts nomination for Chancellorship". Varsity.co.uk. Retrieved 2011-06-10.
- 03 Jun 2011 (2011-06-03). "Brian Blessed to run for Cambridge University chancellor". London: Telegraph. Retrieved 2011-06-10.
- "Brian is blessed with 50 backers". Cambridge News. Retrieved 2011-06-10.
- "Brian Blessed: 'Cambridge University Chancellor's job would be a miracle'". Cambridge News. Retrieved 2011-06-20.
- "Update: Booming Blessed To Bloom As Chancellor? « The Tab – www.cambridgetab.co.uk". Cambridgetab.co.uk. 2011-06-02. Retrieved 2011-06-19.
- Beard, Mary (2011-06-02). "A Don's Life by Mary Beard - Times Online - WBLG: Cambridge University Chancellor: the race, the runners and riders". Timesonline.typepad.com. Retrieved 2011-06-10.
- "Diary: Blessed in with a shout". London: The Independent. 2011-06-06. Retrieved 2011-06-10.
- "Michael Mansfield QC to enter fight to be Chancellor". Varsity.
- "Top barrister joins race to be Cambridge University Chancellor". Cambridge Evening News.
- "Supermarket Sweep". Law Gazette.
- Davies, Caroline (17 June 2011). "Cambridge university chancellor race gets tasty as grocer joins in". The Guardian (London).
- BBC Breakfast News, 5 July 2011, broadcast c.9:10am BST
- "'Brian Blessed for Chancellor' bid gets website". Cambridge Evening News.
- "Brian Blessed explains Cambridge University Chancellor bid". Cambridge Evening News.
- "Full house of candidates for union debates". Cambridge Evening News.
- "David Sainsbury". campaign website.
- "Brian Blessed in city pub for University vote". Cambridge Evening News.
- "Sir Derek Jacobi backs Brian Blessed bid for Cambridge University Chancellor". Cambridge Evening News.
- "'University is part of me - that's my edge'". Cambridge Evening News.
- "Mission to unite town and gown". Cambridge Evening News.
- "Jacobi and Fry Join the Blessed bandwagon". The Tab.
- "Cambridge dons learn a lesson in virtual democracy". UKauthorITy - the leading independent published of UK public sector technology news.
- "Office of Chancellor: Appointment of Voting Days". Admin.cam.ac.uk. 2011-05-26. Retrieved 2011-06-19.
- Samantha Sharman, 2011, "Sainsbury wins Chancellor election," Varsity (online), October 16, 2011, see , accessed 14 March 2015.
- Maev Kennedy, 2011, "Lord Sainsbury beats grocer to become Cambridge University chancellor," The Guardian (online), October 16, 2011, see , accessed 14 March 2015.