User:Nehrams2020/GA reviews

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search

I have started reviewing good articles in February 2007 (a year after joining Wikipedia), and here are the statistics for the articles I have passed and failed. I may assess the articles quite harsh, as so far, I haven't passed any articles without putting them on hold first. I'm not trying to get the article to fail, but want the article to improve in quality and earn its good article status. If you see an article below that I failed, consider working on it to bring it up to GA status (unless it already reached it after my failing it). If you ever have the time, review an article or two at Wikipedia:Good article nominations.

Template:WikiProjectGATasks Wikipedia:Good article candidates/Report

Passed (102)[edit]

Failed (24)[edit]

Quick-failed (50)[edit]

I will quick-fail an article if it is a list (not covered under the GA criteria), lacks inline citations, is not broad enough, or there are tags on the articles including "citation needed" templates.

GA Sweeps[edit]

All of the articles that I have reviewed for GA Sweeps can be found here.

GAC backlog elimination May 23-June 13, 2007 (Completed)[edit]

If you reviewed five or more articles between May 23 and June 13, 2007 please include your name in a list here, stating which reviews you performed. I will award the Good Article Medal of Merit to those listed here. If you have any questions about the process let me know on my talk page. (Note: The number of required reviewed articles may be raised, based on the number of people who help to contribute)

Done, no more names please. I'll be sending out the medals later today after I review the reviews. Good job to everyone that helped! --Nehrams2020 08:17, 14 June 2007 (UTC)