User:Wer900/Consensus study

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search

On this page, I shall document the results of a study on consensus which is currently in progress. Each discussion shall have three parameters of (actual decision, "appropriate" decision, and systematic decision). The value for the last parameter shall be determined as per my essay WP:Consensus defined, and shall be determined after the other factors in order to ensure minimum bias and conflict of interest. Each parameter may have a value of "consensus affirmative", "consensus negative", or "no consensus". Following the collection of data, statistics will be derived as to how much improvement the proposed policy has created.

Data tables[edit]

Here all data collected from each page shall be visible, sorted by category of discussion. Please look at the discussion page itself for relevant background on it.

Articles for deletion[edit]

In this section, "consensus affirmative" shall be a discussion resulting in the deletion or merger of the page, "consensus negative" shall be defined as a discussion electing to keep the content on its own separate page, and "no consensus" where consensus is not the determinant of the ultimate action due to lack thereof, regardless what the future actions may be.


For every month of AfDs in a year, from March on back, 30 AfDs shall be selected, for a total of 360 for every year.

AfD Discussions in 2012
Discussion Date of discussion Actual consensus Ideal consensus Systematic consensus
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Log/2012 March 11#Focus Fusion Society 11 March 2012 consensus affirmative consensus affirmative cell
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Log/2012 March 11#Allen Senne 11 March 2012 consensus affirmative consensus affirmative cell
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Log/2012 March 11#Richardice of Sweden 11 March 2012 consensus affirmative consensus affirmative cell
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Log/2012 March 11#Kaspiysk bid for the 2018 Summer Youth Olympics 11 March 2012 consensus affirmative consensus affirmative cell
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Log/2012 March 11#Abuja bid for the 2018 Summer Youth Olympics 11 March 2012 consensus affirmative consensus affirmative cell
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Log/2012 March 11#Charles Butler (umpire) 11 March 2012 consensus affirmative (redirect) consensus affirmative (redirect) cell
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Log/2012 March 11#Rob Baird 11 March 2012 no consensus no consensus cell
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Log/2012 March 11#ISO/IEEE 11073 Personal Health Data (PHD) Standards 11 March 2012 consensus negative consensus negative cell
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Log/2012 March 11#Alana Valentine 11 March 2012 consensus affirmative consensus affirmative cell
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Log/2012 March 11#Forward Operating Base Echo 11 March 2012 consensus negative consensus negative cell
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Log/ cell cell cell cell
cell cell cell cell cell
cell cell cell cell cell
cell cell cell cell cell
cell cell cell cell cell
cell cell cell cell cell
cell cell cell cell cell
cell cell cell cell cell
cell cell cell cell cell
cell cell cell cell cell
cell cell cell cell cell
cell cell cell cell cell
cell cell cell cell cell


Statistical measures[edit]