ValuJet Flight 592
A ValuJet McDonnell Douglas DC-9-32, similar to the one involved
|Date||May 11, 1996|
|Summary||In-flight fire caused by improperly stored oxygen generators|
|Site||Everglades, Miami-Dade County, Florida, United States
|Aircraft type||McDonnell Douglas DC-9-32|
|Flight origin||Miami International Airport
|Destination||William B. Hartsfield Atlanta Int'l Airport, Atlanta, Georgia|
ValuJet Flight 592 was a regularly scheduled flight from Miami International Airport to Hartsfield-Jackson Atlanta International Airport. On May 11, 1996, the McDonnell-Douglas DC-9 operating the route crashed into the Everglades shortly after taking off from Miami as a result of a fire in the cargo compartment caused by improperly stored cargo, killing all 110 people on board.
In 1996, an American Trans Air McDonnell-Douglas DC-10 being serviced at Chicago's O'Hare International Airport was destroyed by a fire caused by a chemical oxygen generator. In 1988, American Airlines Flight 132 (a McDonnell-Douglas MD-80, the successor airplane to the DC-9) had a similar accident. A fire began in the cargo hold, caused by hazardous materials (primarily hydrogen peroxide), but the crew landed the aircraft safely. After this incident, the National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) recommended to the FAA that all class D cargo holds have smoke detectors and/or fire suppression systems.
Aircraft and crew
The aircraft that crashed, a DC-9,  was 27 years old and had been previously owned by Delta Air Lines. Its first flight was April 18, 1969. Delivered to Delta on May 27, 1969, the airframe flew for Delta until the end of 1992, when it was retired and sold back to McDonnell Douglas. McDonnell Douglas then sold the plane to ValuJet in early 1993.
In the cockpit were two experienced pilots: Captain Candalyn Kubeck (35) and First Officer Richard Hazen (52). The captain had accumulated more than 8,900 hours throughout her career and the first officer had more than 11,800 total flight hours.
On the afternoon of May 11, 1996, Flight 592 pushed back from gate G2 in Miami after a delay of 1 hour and 4 minutes due to mechanical problems. There were 105 passengers, mainly from Florida and Georgia, on board, as well as a crew of two pilots and three flight attendants, bringing the total number of people on board to 110. At 2:04 pm, 10 minutes before the disaster, the DC-9 took off from runway 9L (now runway 8R) and began a normal climb.
At 2:10 pm, the passengers started to smell smoke. At the same time, the pilots heard a loud bang in their headphones and noticed the plane was losing electrical power. The spike in electrical power and the bang were eventually determined to be the result of a tire in the cargo hold exploding. Seconds later, flight attendant Jennifer Stearns entered the cockpit and informed the flight crew of a fire in the passenger cabin. Passengers' shouts of "fire, fire, fire" were recorded on the cockpit voice recorder when the cockpit door was opened. Though the ValuJet flight attendant manual stated that the cockpit door should not be opened when smoke or other harmful gases might be present in the cabin, the intercom was disabled and there was no other way to inform the pilots of what was happening. The CDR indicated a progressive failure of the DC-9's electrical and flight control systems due to the spreading fire.
Kubeck and Hazen immediately asked air traffic control for a return to Miami due to the increasing smoke in the cockpit and cabin, and were given instructions for a return to the airport. One minute later, Hazen requested the nearest available airport. Kubeck began to turn the plane left in preparation for the return to Miami. At that time, flight attendant Jennifer Stearns entered the cockpit asking why the pilots didn't lower the oxygen masks for the passengers. The pilots had refused; they knew that oxygen would only make the fire worse.
Flight 592 disappeared from radar at 2:13:42 pm. Eyewitnesses nearby watched as the plane banked sharply to the left, rolled onto its side and nosedived into the Francis S. Taylor Wildlife Management Area in the Everglades, a few miles west of Miami, at a speed in excess of 507 miles per hour (816 km/h). Kubeck lost control of the plane less than 10 seconds before impact. Examination of debris suggested that the fire burned through the floorboards in the cockpit, resulting in structural failure and damage to cables underneath the instrument panels; however, it was just as likely that the crew had also become incapacitated by smoke and fumes. As power had been lost to the cockpit voice recorder about 55 seconds before impact, it was impossible to pinpoint either scenario with certainty.
Kubeck, Hazen, the three flight attendants, and all 105 passengers aboard were killed instantly. Recovery of the aircraft and victims was made extremely difficult by the location of the crash. The nearest road of any kind was more than a quarter mile (400 m) away from the crash scene, and the location of the crash itself was a deep-water swamp with a floor made out of solid limestone. The DC-9 was destroyed on impact, with no large pieces of the fuselage remaining. Sawgrass, alligators, and risk of bacterial infection from cuts plagued searchers involved in the recovery effort.
A group of fishermen witnessed the crash and reported that "The plane was flying in a steep right bank, after which it turned so that the nose was facing downward in a nearly vertical angle. It plummeted into the swamp followed by an explosion, shock wave, and a massive geyser of water." They reported seeing no external damage to the DC-9 or any sign of fire or smoke other than the engine exhaust. A group of sightseers in a small private plane also witnessed the crash and provided a nearly identical account, stating that Flight 592 seemed to "disappear" after impacting the swamp and they could see nothing but scattered small debris and part of an engine near the crash site.
|Residences of passengers:||Passengers||Crew||Total|
Notable passengers killed on the flight included:
- San Diego Chargers running back Rodney Culver and his wife
- Songwriter and musician Walter Hyatt
- Del-Marie Walker, primary suspect in the murder of Catherine Holmes in College Park, Georgia
- Former Miami Hurricanes football offensive lineman Robert Woodus
The oldest person aboard the jet was 84-year-old Conway Hamilton of Miami, and the youngest was 4-year-old Daniel Darbor of Atlanta.
The majority of the passengers were from Georgia and Florida; there were also passengers from Virginia, North Carolina, Maryland, Indiana, and Tennessee on the flight. There was also a woman bound for Massachusetts and two passengers from Texas on Flight 592. Recovery of the passengers and crew took several weeks and little in the way of intact human remains were found due to the sheer violent force of impact, immersion in swamp water, and scavenging wildlife. Approximately 68 of the 110 persons aboard the plane were identified, in some cases from examining jawbones and at least one individual from a single tooth. A piece of torn flesh was proven to belong to First Officer Hazen, but Captain Kubeck's remains were never found. Due to the above-mentioned factors, it was no longer possible to perform toxicology tests on the passengers' and crew's remains to determine how much exposure they would have had to fumes and smoke from the in-flight fire.
The NTSB investigation eventually determined that the fire that downed Flight 592 began in a cargo compartment below the passenger cabin. The cargo compartment was a Class D design, in which fire suppression is accomplished by sealing off the hold from outside air. Any fire in such an airtight compartment would quickly exhaust all available oxygen and then burn itself out. As the fire suppression is accomplished without any intervention by the crew, such holds are not equipped with smoke detectors. However, the NTSB determined that just before takeoff, expired chemical oxygen generators were placed in the cargo compartment in five boxes marked COMAT (Company-Owned MATerial) by ValuJet's maintenance contractor, SabreTech, in contravention of FAA regulations forbidding the transport of hazardous materials in aircraft cargo holds. Failure to cover the firing pins for the generators with the prescribed plastic caps made an accidental activation much more likely. The investigation revealed that rather than covering the firing pins, the SabreTech workers simply duct-taped the cords around the cans, or cut them, and used tape to stick the ends down. It is also possible that the cylindrical, tennis-ball-can-sized generators were loaded on board in the mistaken belief that they were just empty canisters, thus being certified as safe to transport in an aircraft cargo compartment. SabreTech employees indicated on the cargo manifest that the "oxy canisters" were "empty" instead of being expired oxygen generators. ValuJet employees interpreted this to mean that they were empty oxygen canisters, when in fact they were neither simple oxygen canisters, nor empty. A worker then loosely packed the oxygen canisters in several cardboard boxes with a layer of bubble wrap.
Chemical oxygen generators, when activated, produce oxygen for passengers if the plane suffers an explosive decompression. As a byproduct of the exothermic chemical reaction, they also produce a great quantity of heat. These two factors together were sufficient not only to start an accidental fire, but also to produce enough oxygen to keep the fire burning. The fire risk was made much worse by the presence of combustible aircraft wheels in the hold. Two main tires and wheels and a nose tire and wheel were also included in the COMAT. NTSB investigators theorized that when the plane experienced a slight jolt while taxiing on the runway, an oxygen generator activated, producing oxygen and heat. Over time, as the DC-9 was taxiing to its takeoff position the surface of the activated generator got hotter and hotter. Soon, the heat ignited the cardboard box and bubble wrap, allowing the fire to start.
Laboratory testing showed that canisters of the same type could heat nearby materials up to 500 °F (260 °C), enough to ignite a smoldering fire. The oxygen from the generators fed the resulting fire in the cargo hold without any need for outside air, defeating the airtight fire suppression design. A pop and jolt heard on the cockpit voice recording and correlated with a brief and dramatic spike in the altimeter reading in the flight data recording were attributed to the sudden cabin pressure change caused by a semi-inflated aircraft wheel in the cargo hold getting so hot that it exploded. Investigators also determined that in this process, the fire began to destroy control cables that ran to the back of the DC-9, which explained why the pilots began losing control 3 and 1/2 minutes before the plane crashed.
Smoke detectors in the cargo holds can alert the flight crew of a fire long before the problem becomes apparent in the cabin, and a fire suppression system buys valuable time to land the plane safely. In February 1998, the FAA issued revised standards requiring all Class D cargo holds to be converted by early 2001 to Class C or E; these types of holds have additional fire detection and suppression equipment.
The NTSB report placed responsibility for the accident on three parties:
- SabreTech, for improperly packaging and storing hazardous materials,
- ValuJet, for not supervising SabreTech, and
- the FAA, for not mandating smoke detection and fire suppression systems in cargo holds.
In 1997, a federal grand jury indicted SabreTech for mishandling hazardous materials, failing to train its employees in proper handling of hazardous materials, conspiracy, and making false statements. SabreTech's maintenance supervisor, Daniel Gonzalez, and two mechanics who worked on the plane, Eugene Florence and Mauro Valenzuela, were charged with conspiracy and making false statements. Two years later, having been found guilty on the mishandling hazardous materials and improper training charges, SabreTech was fined $2 million and ordered to pay $9 million in restitution. Gonzalez and Florence were acquitted on all charges, while Valenzuela failed to appear and was indicted in absentia for contempt of court. Valenzuela is still a fugitive; he was specifically highlighted in the EPA's announcement of a website to search for "environmental fugitives."
In 2001, the United States 11th Circuit Court of Appeals reversed the SabreTech guilty verdict in part. In so doing, the panel concluded that federal law at the time of the crash could not support a conviction for mishandling hazardous materials and that the government did not prove that SabreTech intended to cause harm. The panel did, however, uphold the conviction for improper training, and on remand, the District Court sentenced SabreTech to a $500,000 fine, three years' probation, and no restitution.
Just before the federal trial, a Florida grand jury indicted SabreTech on 110 counts of manslaughter and 110 counts of third-degree murder: one for each person who died in the crash. SabreTech settled the state charges by agreeing to plead no contest to a state charge of mishandling hazardous waste and to donate $500,000 to an aviation safety group and a Miami-Dade County charity.
SabreTech was the first American aviation company to be criminally prosecuted for its role in an American airline crash. The company, a subsidiary of St. Louis-based Sabreliner Corporation, went out of business in 1999, but Saberliner Corporation is still operating.
ValuJet was grounded by the FAA on June 16, 1996. It was allowed to resume flying again on September 30, but never recovered from the crash. In 1997, the company merged with AirTran Airways. Although ValuJet was the nominal survivor, the ValuJet name was so tarnished by this time that it was scrapped in favor of the AirTran name. In 2006, AirTran did not make any major announcements on the crash's 10th anniversary out of respect for the victims' families.
Many families of the Flight 592 victims were outraged that ValuJet was not prosecuted, given the airline's poor safety record. ValuJet's accident rate was not only one of the highest in the low-fare sector, but 14 times higher than those of the mainline airlines. In the aftermath of the crash, an internal FAA memo surfaced questioning whether ValuJet should have been allowed to stay in the air. The victims' families also point to statements made by ValuJet officials immediately after the crash that appeared to indicate the company knew the generators were on the plane, and in fact had ordered them returned to Atlanta rather than properly disposed of in Miami.
|This section needs additional citations for verification. (May 2013)|
On the third anniversary of the accident, in 1999, a memorial was dedicated to the victims in the Everglades. The memorial, consisting of 110 concrete pillars, is located just north of Tamiami Trail at about 11.9 miles west of Krome Avenue in Miami-Dade County and points to the location of the crash site eight miles to the north.
Students from the American Institute of Architecture Students designed the memorial and local contractors, masons and labor unions built it for free.
In a June 4, 2013 Miami Herald article, a local resident stated that while slogging through the sawgrass several months earlier he found a partially melted gold pendant in the same area, which is thought possibly to be from either the ValuJet crash or the crash of Eastern Air Lines Flight 401, which had occurred about 2 miles (3.2 km) from the ValuJet crash site.
In popular culture
|This section needs additional citations for verification. (November 2012)|
COPS happened to be taping with the Miami-Dade Police Department when the accident occurred. As a result, season 9, episode 12, aired featuring some of the first 911 calls and the initial investigations into the accident. Three National Geographic shows, Why Planes Crash ("Fire In The Sky"), Seconds From Disaster ("Florida Air Swamp Crash"), and Mayday ("Fire in the Hold"), covered the crash. It was also featured in the last episode of the four-part Travel Channel series Probable Cause: Air Crash Investigations (Acceptable Risk).
- List of accidents and incidents on commercial airliners
- Nigeria Airways Flight 2120 - crash resulting from an inflight fire triggered by a faulty tire
- Eastern Air Lines Flight 401 - another airliner crash in the Florida Everglades, the crash site of which is only 6 kilometers from that of Flight 592
- Swissair Flight 111 - 1998 crash resulting from an inflight fire caused by faulty wiring
- Northwest Orient Airlines Flight 705 - another airliner that crashed in the Everglades in February 1963
- Asiana Airlines Flight 991
- "NTSB Report AAR97-06"
- Candiotti, Susan (15 November 1996). "ValuJet 592 Crash to Be Blamed on Oxygen Canisters". CNN. Cable News Network. Retrieved 6 May 2014.
- Incident description for AA 132 at the Aviation Safety Network
- Lawrence, Neal (Autumn 1998). "Danger in the Skies". Midwest Today. Retrieved June 2013.
- "Complete list of passengers and crew." CNN. Retrieved on December 23, 2008.
- "Murderer died in Valujet crash". Reuters, February 27, 1997, St. Petersburg Times, page 5A, Column 1. . Retrieved December 10, 2008.
- "Atlanta News, Sports, Atlanta Weather, Business News | ajc.com". Nl.newsbank.com. 1 March 1997. Retrieved 2010-02-10.
- "Police Believe Killer Died in ValuJet Crash". Los Angeles Times, March 2, 1997, Los Angeles Times, LA Times On-line Collections. . Retrieved March 20, 2013.
- Mayday, "Fire in the Hold", season 12 episode 2
- "Revised Standards for Cargo or Baggage Compartments in Transport Category Airplanes". Federal Register. 17 February 1998. Retrieved 2008-10-23.
- "Mechanic in SabreTech Case Indicted for Contempt of Court". USDOT. October 13, 1999. Archived from the original on September 17, 2008. Retrieved June 2013.
- "12/10/2008: Wanted: Environmental Fugitives/ Federal government launches first-ever environmental crimes fugitive web site". Environmental Protection Agency. Retrieved 2010-02-10.
- Huettel, Steve (May 11, 2006). "10 years after tragedy, AirTran flies on". St. Petersburg Times. Archived from the original on October 12, 2012. Retrieved June 2013.
- "US Attorneys' Office Ignores Critical Evidence in the Valujet Crash: Valujet admitted oxygen generators were to be returned". flight592.com. July 12, 1999. Archived from the original on November 31, 2007. Check date values in:
- Herrera, Chabeli (2013-06-04). "Gold pendant found at site of Everglades plane crashes". Miami Herald. Retrieved 2013-10-01.
- Langewiesche, William (March 1, 1998). "The Lessons of Valujet 592". The Atlantic. Retrieved June 2013. - Langewiesche presents a case that the ValuJet crash is an example of a "system accident," including the overly formal labeling and safety information on the oxygen 'canisters' (which actually were oxygen generators).
- Larson, Eric (May 20, 1996). "Death in the Everglades". TIME. Retrieved June 2013. (Subscription required for access to full article.)
- Flight 592 special report (CNN)
- NTSB brief report
- NTSB full report (PDF)
- Valenzuela's post on US EPA's Fugitive Site
- Audio transcript of the Air Traffic Control conversations
- "Valujet: The Crash of Flight 592 - The Accident". CNN. 1997. Archived from the original on August 16, 2000. Retrieved June 2013.
- Tester, Hank. "ValuJet Crash Remembered 15 Years Later" (Archive). NBC Miami. Wednesday May 11, 2011.
- "Valujet 592's Last Flight". The New York Times. November 19, 1996. Retrieved June 2013. - Transcript of the Valujet 592 flight recorder.
- Memorial location on Google Maps
- ValuJet Flight 592 Memorial
- Bragg, Rick (December 7, 1999). "Contractor Found Guilty in Trial on ValuJet Crash". The New York Times. Retrieved June 2013.
- Reed, Dan; Jones, Charisse (September 28, 2010). "Low-fare king Southwest to buy AirTran for $1.4 billion". USA Today. Retrieved June 2013.
- Photo of the plane after being retired by Delta and bought by Valujet
- Photo of the plane while in service with Valujet
- "Passenger list and gallery". flight592.com. Archived from the original on June 14, 2007.