Vladimir Alexandrov

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search
This article is about the physicist. For the bobsledder, see Vladimir Aleksandrov.

Vladimir Valentinovich Alexandrov (Russian: Владимир Валентинович Александров; born 1938; disappeared 1985) was a Soviet/Russian physicist who created a mathematical model for the nuclear winter theory. He disappeared while at a conference[which?] on "nuclear-free zones"[clarification needed] in Cordoba, Spain on March 31 and his ultimate fate remains unknown, with much speculation continuing.[1] One of his last papers was Man and Biosphere published in 1985, it is said to have charted the moving trend in the science of nuclear winter.[2] It was co-authored with Nikita Moiseyev and A.M Tarko.[3]

The last moments of his life are shrouded in contradiction. When questioned by journalists in 1986, his acquaintances in Madrid give differing accounts on how much he resisted when being driven towards the Soviet embassy.[4]

In 2016 Andrew Revkin argues that “He’s almost assuredly dead. ...This wasn’t just, you know, thumb-sucking climate science. It was in the middle of a war—a long Cold War—and there were bodies.”[1]

Research[edit]

According to a FBI white paper Alexandrov was a mathematician specializing in computer sciences. In 1976 he was directed to shift his research from gas dynamics and plasma mechanics to climatology. He was sent to USA under a research exchange agreement, and studied at the NCAR in 1978, 1980 and 1982, which gave him access to the Cray-1 supercomputer. In 1983 he was directed by Evgeny Velikhov to work on nuclear winter scenarios heading an ad hoc group of 20 scientists.[5]

A pioneer in global climate modelling, he presented a mathematical solution to baroclinicity in 1982.[6] The following year, with G.I. Stenchikov, he used the model to calculate the consequences of nuclear war[7] and the prospects of nuclear winter. However, Richard P. Turco and Starley L. Thompson, two major figures in the development of the nuclear winter scenario, described Alexandrov and Stenchikov's model as "a very weak piece of work" and "a primitive rendition of an obsolete US model."[8] Later they were to rescind these "harsh" criticisms and instead applauded Alexandrov's pioneering work, saying that the Soviet model shared the weaknesses of all the others.[9]

Disappearance[edit]

How Alexandrov disappeared and what happened to him afterward remains unknown,[8][10][11][12][13] but several theories have been put forward. According to an article in the newsmagazine Time in October 1985, the leading thoughts on the matter were that "The mystery of his disappearance had been compounded by the suspicions of some Western scientists that the nuclear winter scenario was promoted by Moscow to give antinuclear groups in the U.S. and Europe some fresh ammunition against America's arms buildup"...and that others "speculate that Alexandrov was planning to renounce the nuclear winter concept and may have been kidnapped by the KGB. According to another theory, the physicist defected to the West."[14]

A. Levakov suggests that his supercomputer work on nuclear winter was as embarrassing to the Soviet Union as it was to the USA.[15] According to the Mitrokhin Archive, during a conference in 1987 the head of the KGB's First Chief Directorate Vladimir Kryuchkov accused the CIA's Deputy Director Robert Gates of kidnapping Alexandrov and holding him against his will.[citation needed] Andrew Revkin assumes that he was a spy; it was never clear whether for the USSR, USA, or both.[16]

US colleagues regard his work on Nuclear winter computer models to be on the extreme exaggerated fringe, a position which toed the soviet party-line at the time. A position however, that in private, he reportedly acknowledged was nonsense.[17]

US colleagues also point to his unorthodox denial by the US visa agency to permit him access to dual-use supercomputers, a denial which transpired after his name-dropping jokes about how he could freely access the much coveted Cray X-MP at the US nuclear weapons lab LLNL, and a denial which is likely a key factor in how he could have possibly fallen so far from favor in the Soviet establishment. Someone from Moscow would attempt to "phone"/internet access this powerful US computer a few months before his disappearance.[18]

Upon learning of the missing persons case that was not reported on in Madrid at the time, nuclear winter colleagues, in particular the US team that included Alan Robock, took a pact not to raise the alarm as they thought it conceivable that he defected to the West. Robock would later regret taking this pledge as a lost opportunity to find him before the trail went cold.[19]

References[edit]

  1. ^ a b Scientific thaw during the cold war. Pulitzer center. May 2, 2016 Kit R. Roane
  2. ^ Climate as a problem of physics. A S Monin and Yu A Shishkov 2000 Uspekhi Fizicheskikh Nauk and Russian Academy of Sciences Physics-Uspekhi, Volume 43, Number 4
  3. ^ 1985 Moiseev N.N., Aleksandrov V.V., and Tarko A.M. Man and Biosphere. System Analysis Experience and Model Experiments. Moscow, Nauka, 272 pp. (in Russian).
  4. ^ Science Digest, July 1986. Why is this top Soviet scientist missing.A Cold War Climate Mystery Endures: the Vanishing of Vladimir Alexandrov
  5. ^ Interagency Intelligence Assessment (1984): The Soviet Approach to Nuclear Winter, page 10-11
  6. ^ Alexandrov, V. V. 1982. A general atmospheric circulation model with baroclinic arrangement. Rep. Acad. Sci. USSR 265(5):1094-1097.
  7. ^ Alexandrov, V. V. and G. I. Stenchikov (1983): "On the modeling of the climatic consequences of the nuclear war" The Proceeding of Appl. Mathematics, 21 p., The Computing Center of the AS USSR, Moscow.
  8. ^ a b Laurence Badash, A Nuclear Winter's Tale, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, 2009
  9. ^ An assessment of global atmospheric effects of a major nuclear war pg 59
  10. ^ Vera Rich, “Nuclear winter expert vanishes without trace,” Nature, Vol. 316, 4 July 1985, 3
  11. ^ Vera Rich, “Aleksandrov still not found,” Nature, Vol. 316, 8 August 1985, 479
  12. ^ Tim Beardsley, “Soviet missing person,” Nature, Vol. 317, 19 September 1985, 191
  13. ^ I. Andronov, "Where is Vladimir Aleksandrov?", Literaturnaya Gazeta, n.30, 23 July 1986
  14. ^ [A 1985 Time magazine account of Alexandrov's disappearance. Also found in "Another Return From the Cold. By Jacob V. Lamar Jr. Sunday, June 24, 2001"]
  15. ^ A. Levakov, "Supercomputer Technology and Projects in the U.S.", Jet Info online, No.12 (115)/2002 (In Russian)
  16. ^ http://www.edge.org/documents/schneider10/schneider10.html
  17. ^ Science Digest, July 1986. Why is this top Soviet scientist missing.A Cold War Climate Mystery Endures: the Vanishing of Vladimir Alexandrov
  18. ^ Science Digest, July 1986. Why is this top Soviet scientist missing.A Cold War Climate Mystery Endures: the Vanishing of Vladimir Alexandrov
  19. ^ Science Digest, July 1986. Why is this top Soviet scientist missing.A Cold War Climate Mystery Endures: the Vanishing of Vladimir Alexandrov