Voice therapy (transgender)
|Part of a series on|
|Health care and medicine|
|Society and culture|
|Theory and concepts|
Voice therapy or voice training refers to any non-surgical technique used to improve or modify the human voice. Because voice is a gender cue, trans people may frequently undertake voice therapy as a part of gender transition in order to make their voices sound more like what is typical of their gender, and therefore increase their readability as that gender in society.
Voice feminization is the desired goal of changing a perceived male sounding voice to a perceived female sounding voice. The term voice feminization is used to describe the desired outcome of surgical techniques, speech therapy, self-help programs and any other techniques to acquire a female-sounding voice. The methods used for voice feminization vary from professional techniques used for vocal training, speech therapy by trained speech pathologists and several pitch-altering surgeries. Having voice and speech characteristics be in agreement with one's gender identity is important to transgender individuals, whether their goal be feminization or masculinization.
Voice masculinization is the opposite of voice feminization, being the change of a voice from feminine to masculine. Voice masculinization is not generally required for transgender men as the masculinising effects of testosterone on the larynx are usually sufficient to produce a masculine voice. However, Alexandros N. Constansis has stated that "apart from being unfair to transmen, [this assumption] is also overtly simplistic" and cites Davies and Goldberg in saying that "testosterone doesn’t always drop pitch low enough for FTMs to be perceived as male". Many transgender men also choose not to take testosterone, and use voice masculinization as an alternative way to deepen their voices.
- 1 Voice feminization
- 2 Voice masculinization
- 3 Vocal surgeries
- 4 Therapeutic techniques
- 5 Controversy
- 6 See also
- 7 Resources
- 8 References
Voice feminization refers to the voice change from male to female. It is considered an essential part of care for transgender women. Transgender women trying to feminize their voice represent the largest group seeking speech therapy services, therefore, most studies regarding transgender voice have focused on voice feminization, as opposed to voice masculinization.
Therapy has been shown to be effective in voice feminization, and the modification of certain voice characteristics, such as fundamental frequency and voice resonance, can help in that effect. Fundamental frequency, also called pitch, was initially thought to be the characteristic most effective in voice feminization. Raising the fundamental frequency can help towards voice feminization. However, each person might have different perspectives regarding speech and voice, and therefore the salient characteristics, and their relative impact towards femininity, can vary from person to person, and many clients are not satisfied with only a change in fundamental frequency. The efficacy of treatment should therefore be evaluated, not only by acoustic characteristics, but also using the transgender person’s perception of the voice and its femininity.
What is considered a feminine or a masculine voice varies depending on age, region, and cultural norms. The changes with the greatest effects towards feminization, based on current evidence are fundamental frequency and voice resonance. Other characteristics that have been explored include intonation patterns, loudness, speech rate, speech-sound articulation and duration.
Voice modifications for transgender males typically involve the lowering of the speaking fundamental frequency. Voice therapy is generally not required for transgender men as the effects of testosterone on the larynx result in a deeper pitch. However, testosterone therapy does not always deepen the voice to the person's desired level, and others choose to not undergo hormone replacement therapy (female-to-male) at all. Voice masculinization therapy can help to further lower the pitch of transgender males and address voice problems associated with hormone therapy. Another option for female-to-male clients who wish to further lower their speaking pitch is to undergo vocal surgery (see Surgical Techniques for more details).
A speech-language pathologist (SLP) may be involved in aiding the female-to-male client achieve their desired voice goals, while usually prioritizing the overall health of the voice. Therapy techniques may involve finding the client's most comfortable pitch range, using breath support and relaxation exercises, introducing voice strengthening warm-ups, stabilizing posture and increasing chest resonance.
While hormone replacement therapy and gender reassignment surgery can cause a more feminine outward appearance for trans women, they do little to alter the pitch of the voice or to make the voice sound more feminine. The existing vocal structure can be surgically altered to raise vocal pitch by shortening the vocal folds, decreasing the whole mass of the folds, or by increasing the tension of the folds. Trans women can undergo surgery to raise their vocal pitch as measured by fundamental frequency (F0), to increase their pitch range and to remove access to lower frequency ranges in their voice. The current pitch-raising vocal surgeries include:
- Cricothyroid approximation (CTA) (The most common procedure)
- This surgery tenses and elongates the vocal folds in order to increase vocal pitch. This is done by bringing the cricoid cartilage closer to the thyroid cartilage with sutures or metal plates. The cricoid cartilage is shifted backward and upward and the thyroid cartilage is moved forward and downward. This mimics cricothyroid muscle contraction that tenses and elongates the vocal folds which causes the pitch to increase.
- Anterior Glottal Web Formation or Anterior Commissure Advancement
- Laser assisted voice adjustment (LAVA)
- In this procedure, microlaryngoscopy (a surgical procedure that looks at the vocal folds in great detail) is done in conjunction with a carbon dioxide (CO2) laser that vaporizes small portions of the vocal folds. When the vocal fold tissue is in the process of healing and scarring, the vocal folds decrease in mass and increase in stiffness. This results in a rise in vocal pitch.
- Laser Reduction Glottoplasty (LRG)
Usually, trans women consider vocal surgery when they feel dissatisfied with voice therapy results, or when they want a more authentic sounding female voice. However, it is important to note that vocal surgery alone may not produce a voice that sounds completely feminine, and voice therapy may still be needed. Although there has been evidence to show that all these surgeries can be effective in increasing vocal pitch as measured by F0, results have been mixed. However, many patients do report being satisfied with the results. Negative effects from these surgeries have been noted, including reduced voice quality, reduced vocal loudness, negative effects on swallowing and/or breathing, sore throat, infections and scarring. A positive effect of surgery can be protecting the voice from damage due to the strain of constantly elevating pitch while speaking. Because of the risks, vocal surgery is often considered a last resort after vocal therapy has been pursued.
As for trans men, it is generally presumed that hormone therapy does successfully masculinize the voice and lower vocal pitch. However, this may not be the case for all trans men. Although it is far less common, surgery to lower vocal pitch does exist, and may be considered if traditional hormone therapy did not adequately lower it. Medialization laryngoplasty (or masculinization laryngoplasty) is a procedure where the vocal fold contours are medially augmented with the injection of silastic implants. This mimics the changes that the vocal folds go through during male puberty, which causes a lower sounding voice.
Therapy may take place in an individual or group setting. The most common focus in transgender voice therapy is pitch raising or lowering; however, other gender markers may be more important for the client to work on. Clients and clinicians should discuss goals of therapy to ensure that they are working together toward the voice that most fits the person's gender identity.
In a review of speech literature, Davies and Goldberg (2006) were unable to find any clear protocols for treating the female to male (transgender man) voice. Based on the protocols they found for treating the male to female (transgender woman) voice, they proposed the following therapeutic techniques for both voice feminization and masculinization:
- Imitation of non-transgender people observed in daily life.
- Progressively complex practice while maintaining good voice quality.
- Vocal flexibility exercises to maintain vocal range and voice quality.
- Motor training.
- Identifying and altering voice qualities when coughing, laughing, and clearing the throat.
- Experimentation with a broad range of voice styles.
While there is some evidence for the effectiveness of voice therapy for transgender people, it is still weak. In a 2012 review by Oates (as referenced in Davies, Papp, and Antoni, 2015) of the literature on transgender voice therapy, 83% of studies were found to be at the lowest level of the evidence hierarchy for evidence-based practice, and the remaining 17% were also at low levels. However, research does show that transgender clients who have had voice therapy have high satisfaction with the results, and there is a strong consensus among speech language pathologists (SLPs) as to what are strong markers of speaker gender in voice.
The most common concern for male-to-female transgender individuals is their pitch and speaking fundamental frequency (SFF) (the average frequency produced in a connected speech sample) because they typically perceive a feminine voice as using a higher pitch. Although pitch is the not the most essential element of voice change for these individuals, it is necessary to raise the SFF to a gender appropriate pitch to help with vocal feminization. A speech-language pathologist will work with the individual to raise their pitch and provide therapeutic exercises.
The first step in therapy is determining the habitual speaking fundamental frequency of the individual using an acoustic analyzing program. This is accomplished through several tasks including sustained phonation of the vowels /i/, /a/ and /u/, reading a standardized passage and producing a spontaneous speech sample. Then the therapist and the individual determine what the target pitch should be, based on the gender acceptable range for ciswomen (i.e. a socially acceptable pitch based on the average female vocal pitch range). When therapy begins, they establish a starting frequency to work on, that is slightly above the client's SFF. The point is to choose a starting pitch that can be produced without strain or excessive vocal effort. As therapy progresses, the target SFF will gradually increase until the goal has been reached. Progression moves from using the target pitch in a sustained vowel to using it in a 2-5 minute conversation.
Semi-occluded vocal tract (SOVT) techniques may be used to facilitate voice production in the higher pitch range. SOVT techniques include phonating into straws, lip or tongue trilling, and producing multiple speech sounds such as nasals /m/, /n/, voiced fricatives (i.e. /z/, /v/), and high vowels such as /u/ and /i/. There are two exercises that are often used: producing a pitch glide that goes from the middle of the pitch range to the upper pitch range; and a messa di voce exercise, where the voice goes from soft to loud to soft again. SOVT techniques have the individual prolong their voice at a higher pitch, which may help make voice production at a higher, non-habitual pitch easier and more efficient.
Pitch can also be altered through voice resonance modification. The length of the vocal tract affects the resonance of the vocal tract, which in turns affects the pitch. Cismen tend to have vocal tracts that are 10-20% larger than those of ciswomen, and therefore cismen have a lower vocal tract resonance, and a lower pitch, than ciswomen. Modifying the length of a vocal tract results in a change in resonance and in pitch, as can be shown by saying the sound “sss” and protruding and retracting the lips. Transgender women can use techniques, such as retracting the lips, to shorten the vocal tract and sound more feminine.
A lack of training on how to use their new voice may cause female-to-male clients have increased muscle tension. Therefore, a speech-language pathologist can give clients vocal exercises to help find their optimal speaking pitch and maintain overall vocal health. Adler, Hirsch, & Mordaunt (2012), describe the following therapy techniques for transgender male clients:
- Optimal Pitch: Rather than straining to achieve a lower speaking pitch, the client should seek to maintain a comfortable pitch range. This range is generally approximately between 100 and 105 Hz.
- Diaphragmatic Breathing Patterns: In order to maintain their new speaking pitch, the female-to-male client needs to establish an appropriate breathing pattern to support their speech output. Establishing a stable speaking posture is also important to optimize pitch and breath support.
- Warm-up Exercises: The client can do these at home help to strengthen the voice, maintain optimal pitch and prevent vocal fatigue. Resting the voice after long periods of use is also important.
- Relaxation Techniques: The speech-language pathologist may teach their client tension-releasing techniques for the jaw, tongue, shoulders, neck and overall laryngeal area.
- Chest Resonance: Head resonance is more commonly used by females, and therefore female-to-male clients must establish a pattern of chest resonance to match their lower speaking pitch. Exercises can help establish this chest resonance and help the client lower their larynx.
Non-verbal communication may have more of an effect on a transgender person's readability than verbal factors such as pitch or resonance. Regardless of what is most effective, congruency between a person's visual and auditory gender presentation contributes greatly to their perceived authenticity. Non-verbal communication includes posture, gesture, movement, and facial expressions. In a discussion of the differences between masculine and feminine non-verbal behaviour, Hirsch and Boonin (2012) describe feminine communication as generally more fluid and continuous. Examples of feminine non-verbal communication behaviours include more smiling, expressive and open facial expression, more side-to-side head movement, and more expressive finger movements than men. Deborah Tannen's book, You Just Don't Understand (1990) is referred to by the authors as a seminal work on the difference in male and female non-verbal communication.
Within the speech therapy context, non-verbal communication may be targeted through encouragement of focused observation, offering feedback on the client's self-defined non-verbal goals, offering information about the differences between male and female non-verbal communication, and/or referring to peer support or expert services.
While some specific psychosocial issues faced by transgender people are often addressed through psychotherapy, there are psychosocial factors that can influence transgender voice therapy. For example, some clients feel that hormone therapy for transitioning changes concentration and emotional stability, which could affect receptiveness to speech therapy. Davies and Goldberg (2006) also note that an altered voice may feel inauthentic, and it may take time for the client to feel as if their new voice is an expression of their true self.
Trans erasure describes systematic, individual, or organizational discrimination against transgender people. Informational erasure and institutional erasure were identified in a 2009 Canadian study of health care for transgender people as being the most prominent barriers to care. Informational erasure involves a lack of knowledge, or a perceived lack of knowledge, about transgender health care. This may manifest itself in health care providers being more reluctant to treat transgender clients because of an unwillingness to find information about their specific population. Institutional erasure describes policies that do not accommodate transgender identities or bodies. For example, forms, texts, or prescriptions may refer to a person by an unpreferred name or pronoun. Issues of erasure may hinder a transgender person's ability to find speech therapy services, or may affect the person's comfort with speech therapy.
In addition to paying attention to problems of erasure, Adler and Christianson (2012) suggest that a clinician should be sensitive to the following areas when working with a transgender client:
- Gender attribution and discrimination
- Possible feelings of shame and guilt
- Consequences of the coming out process
- Spouse, partner, or family attitudes
- Employment issues
- Incidence of HIV/AIDS
- Racial and cultural differences
The authors note that this is not an exhaustive list of possible psychosocial factors, and that every client is different. Psychosocial factors such as these may affect a transgender client's progress and prognosis in speech therapy.
Transition in childhood and adolescence
Few studies have considered the potential repercussions of age on therapy. Currently, there is no consensus regarding speech therapy for adolescents. During adolescence, there is an increase of both vocal tract size and vocal fold length, especially for males, which affects the voice and pitch. Because of these physical changes and hormonal changes, it is difficult to focus on pitch. Previous studies have shown that therapy shaped from adult therapy can be effective.
Transition in aging populations
Few studies have looked into the transition in the elderly. A survey has shown that many elderly members of the LGBT community do not disclose their LGBT status to their clinicians, including members that receive speech therapy; they choose not to disclose this information because they are afraid it would negatively affect their access to services.
There are two major areas of controversy for professionals working on transgender voice. The first is regarding vocal surgery, and the second is regarding bigender voice therapy.
Professional opinion is mixed regarding the use of vocal surgery. There is currently a lack of outcome data, particularly longitudinal data, for pitch-elevating surgery, and outcomes have not been well-monitored over time. Because of this, some SLPs do not think that phonosurgery is a viable treatment option. Others believe it is, and still others believe it should be considered only as a "last resort" after the desired pitch change has not been seen in therapy. Critics cite variability in outcome, lack of outcome data, and reported negative effects like compromised voice quality, decreased vocal loudness, adverse impact on swallowing/breathing, sore throat, wound infection, and scarring as reasons to avoid vocal surgery. Proponents argue that surgery may protect a person's voice from damage caused by repetitive strain to elevate pitch in therapy. Ultimately, the decision to undergo surgery is up to the patient, with input from a knowledgeable physician and SLP.
There is also some controversy regarding the use of a bigender voice. A person may want to have both a masculine and a feminine voice in their vocal repertoire, possibly to fit with their own bigender identity, or to read as a different gender in different contexts. Many clinicians will not train bigender voice, arguing that it decreases the opportunity for practice, and it may be difficult or even damaging to the vocal folds for the person to switch from one voice to another. However, Davies, Papp and Antoni (2015) reference the ability of actors to use different accents and dialects, and people to learn different languages as a sign that training a bigender voice may be a viable treatment goal.
- List of transgender-related topics
- Transgender health care
- Chest register
- Human voice
- Intonation (linguistics)
- Speech therapy
- Speech pathology
- Vocal fry
- Vocal folds
- Laver, John (1984). Principles of Phonetics. Cambridge University Press. ISBN 978-0-521-45031-7.
- Benninger, Michael (1994). Vocal Arts Medicine: The Care and Prevention of Professional Voice Disorders. Thieme Medical Publishers, Inc. ISBN 978-0-86577-439-1.
- MSc, Shelagh Davies; RSLP-C; Goldberg, Joshua M. (2006-09-01). "Clinical Aspects of Transgender Speech Feminization and Masculinization". International Journal of Transgenderism. 9 (3-4): 167–196. doi:10.1300/J485v09n03_08. ISSN 1553-2739.
- Abitbol, J.; B. Abitbol; P. Abitbol (September 1999). "Sex hormones and the female voice". J. Voice. Mosby. 13 (3): 424–446. doi:10.1016/S0892-1997(99)80048-4. PMID 10498059.
- Constansis, A. (2008). "The Changing Female-To-Male (FTM) Voice". Radical Musicology. 3. Retrieved 2009-09-21.
- Shelagh, Davies; Goldberg, Joshua M. (2006-09-01). "Clinical Aspects of Transgender Speech Feminization and Masculinization". International Journal of Transgenderism. 9 (3-4): 167–196. doi:10.1300/J485v09n03_08. ISSN 1553-2739.
- Davies, Shelagh; Papp, Viktória G.; Antoni, Christella (2015-07-03). "Voice and Communication Change for Gender Nonconforming Individuals: Giving Voice to the Person Inside". International Journal of Transgenderism. 16 (3): 117–159. doi:10.1080/15532739.2015.1075931. ISSN 1553-2739.
- McNeill, Emma J. M.; Wilson, Janet A.; Clark, Susan; Deakin, Jayne (2008-11-01). "Perception of voice in the transgender client". Journal of Voice: Official Journal of the Voice Foundation. 22 (6): 727–733. doi:10.1016/j.jvoice.2006.12.010. ISSN 1873-4588. PMID 17400427.
- Abitbol; Abitbol; Abitbol (1999). "Sex Hormones and the Female Voice". Journal of Voice. 13 (3): 424–446.
- Adler, Richard; Hirsch, Sandy; Mordaunt, Michelle (2012). Voice and communication therapy for the transgender/transsexual client: a comprehensive clinical guide. San Diego, CA: Plural Publishing Inc.
- Van Damme, Silke; Cosyns, Marjan; Deman, Sofie; Eede, Zoë Van den; Borsel, John Van. "The Effectiveness of Pitch-raising Surgery in Male-to-Female Transsexuals: A Systematic Review". Journal of Voice. doi:10.1016/j.jvoice.2016.04.002.
- Van Borsel, John; Eynde, Elke Van; Cuypere, Griet De; Bonte, Katrien. "Feminine after cricothyroid approximation?". Journal of Voice. 22 (3): 379–384. doi:10.1016/j.jvoice.2006.11.001.
- Anderson, Jennifer A. "Pitch Elevation in Trangendered Patients: Anterior Glottic Web Formation Assisted by Temporary Injection Augmentation". Journal of Voice. 28 (6): 816–821. doi:10.1016/j.jvoice.2014.05.002.
- Orloff, L. A.; Mann, A. P.; Damrose, J. F.; Goldman, S. N. "Laser-assisted voice adjustment (LAVA) in transsexuals". The Laryngoscope. 116: 655–660. doi:10.1097/01.mlg.0000205198.65797.59.
- Koçak, Ismail; Akpınar, Meltem Esen; Çakır, Zeynep Alkan; Doğan, Müzeyyen; Bengisu, Serkan; Çelikoyar, Mehmet Mazhar. "Laser Reduction Glottoplasty for Managing Androphonia After Failed Cricothyroid Approximation Surgery". Journal of Voice. 24 (6): 758–764. doi:10.1016/j.jvoice.2009.06.004.
- Mastronikolis, Nicholas S.; Remacle, Marc; Biagini, Michela; Kiagiadaki, Debora; Lawson, George. "Wendler Glottoplasty: An Effective Pitch Raising Surgery in transgender women". Journal of Voice. 27 (4): 516–522. doi:10.1016/j.jvoice.2013.04.004.
- Adler, R. K., & van Borsel, J. (2006). Female-to-male considerations. In R. K. Adler, S. Hirsch, & M. Mordaunt (Eds.), Voice and communication therapy for the transgender/transsexual client: A comprehensive clinical guide (pp. 139–168). San Diego, CA: Plural.
- Spiegel, Jeffrey H. "Phonosurgery for Pitch Alteration: Feminization and Masculinization of the Voice". Otolaryngologic Clinics of North America. 39 (1): 77–86. doi:10.1016/j.otc.2005.10.011.
- Hoffman, Matthew R.; Devine, Erin E.; Remacle, Marc; Ford, Charles N.; Wadium, Elizabeth; Jiang, Jack J. (2013-11-16). "Combined type IIIB with bilateral type I thyroplasty for pitch lowering with maintenance of vocal fold tension". European Archives of Oto-Rhino-Laryngology. 271 (6): 1621–1629. doi:10.1007/s00405-013-2798-0. ISSN 0937-4477. PMC . PMID 24241252.
- Davies, S.; Papp, V. G.; Antoni, C. (2015). "Voice and Communication Change for Gender Nonconforming Individuals: Giving Voice to the Person Inside". International Journal of Transgenderism. 16 (3). doi:10.1080/15532739.2015.1075931.
- Adler, Richard; Hirsch, Sandy; Mordaunt, Michelle (2012). Voice and Communication Therapy for the Transgender/Transsexual Client: A Comprehensive Clinical Guide. San Diego, CA: Plural Publishing Inc. ISBN 1597564702.
- Carew, Lisa; Dacakis, Georgia; Oates, Jennifer (2007-09-01). "The effectiveness of oral resonance therapy on the perception of femininity of voice in male-to-female transsexuals". Journal of Voice: Official Journal of the Voice Foundation. 21 (5): 591–603. doi:10.1016/j.jvoice.2006.05.005. ISSN 0892-1997. PMID 16822646.
- Adler, Richard K.; Hirsch, Sandy; Mordaunt, Michelle (2012). Voice and Communication Therapy for The Transgender/Transsexual Client : A Comprehensive Clinical Guide (2 ed.). San Diego: Plural Publishing. ISBN 9781597566315 – via ProQuest ebrary.
- Bauer, Greta R.; Hammond, Rebecca; Travers, Robb; Kaay, Matthias; Hohenadel, Karin M.; Boyce, Michelle. ""I Don't Think This Is Theoretical; This Is Our Lives": How Erasure Impacts Health Care for Transgender People". Journal of the Association of Nurses in AIDS Care. 20 (5): 348–361. doi:10.1016/j.jana.2009.07.004.
- de Vries, Annelou L. C.; Cohen-Kettenis, Peggy T. (2012-01-01). "Clinical management of gender dysphoria in children and adolescents: the Dutch approach". Journal of Homosexuality. 59 (3): 301–320. doi:10.1080/00918369.2012.653300. ISSN 1540-3602. PMID 22455322.
- Hancock, Adrienne; Helenius, Lauren (2016-10-01). "Adolescent male-to-female transgender voice and communication therapy". Journal of Communication Disorders. 45 (5): 313–324. doi:10.1016/j.jcomdis.2012.06.008. ISSN 1873-7994. PMID 22796114.
- Kelly, Rebecca J.; Robinson, Gregory C. (2011-05-01). "Disclosure of Membership in the Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, and Transgender Community by Individuals With Communication Impairments: A Preliminary Web-Based Survey". American Journal of Speech-Language Pathology. 20 (2). doi:10.1044/1058-0360(2011/10-0060). ISSN 1058-0360.