Sara Watkins described the making of the music video in 2000:
...the day before yesterday (Monday) we made our SECOND VIDEO! This is amazing! Not only have we gotten to do one this year, but now TWO! This one is for song "When You Come Back Down" off of our self titled CD. We were fortunate enough to be able to work with the awesome Brent Hedgecock again as the director and producer. There were some of the same people in the crew as well. We had so much fun! I don't want to spoil too much of it, but we shot most of it on a Mountain top over looking Malibu in California. We're all really excited about it.