Wikipedia:Ambassadors/Research/Article quality/Priority 4

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search

Here are the explanations of each metric category! You will want to refer to this page as you are rating articles!

When reviewing an article, please keep the following in mind:

  • The wiki markup should look like this:
==University, Course==
=== Article Name ===
==== [link to article Pre] ====
;Reviewer 1
Reviewer: {{User|user_id}}
Scores:
* Comprehensiveness: #
* Sourcing: #
* Neutrality: #
* Readability: #
* Formatting: #
* Illustrations: #
Total: '''#'''
Comment: (optional)

==== [link to article Post] ====
;Reviewer 1
Reviewer: {{User|user_id}}
Scores:
* Comprehensiveness: #
* Sourcing: #
* Neutrality: #
* Readability: #
* Formatting: #
* Illustrations: #
Total: '''#'''
Comment: (optional)
  • Only fill out: the user id section (user_id) and all score sections (#).
  • Do not leave comments in the score sections

Contents

UC Berkeley, Cyberlaw[edit]

Toys "R" Us, Inc. v. Step Two, S.A.[edit]

New Article[edit]

Reviewer 1

Reviewer: Mike Christie (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 7
  • Sourcing: 4
  • Neutrality: 3
  • Readability: 2
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 0

Total: 17
Mike Christie (talk - contribs - library) 17:38, 17 June 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 2

Reviewer: Pjoef (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 4
  • Sourcing: 2
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 2
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 1

Total: 12
pjoef (talkcontribs) 17:47, 17 June 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 3

Reviewer:

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness:
  • Sourcing:
  • Neutrality:
  • Readability:
  • Formatting:
  • Illustrations:

Total:

The Mortgage Specialists, Inc. v. Implode-Explode Heavy Industries, Inc.[edit]

New Article[edit]

Reviewer 1

Reviewer: Mike Christie (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 7
  • Sourcing: 6
  • Neutrality: 3
  • Readability: 1
  • Formatting: 2
  • Illustrations: 0

Total: 19

Reviewer: Pjoef (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 4
  • Sourcing: 2
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 2
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 1

Total: 12
pjoef (talkcontribs) 17:47, 17 June 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 3

Reviewer:

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness:
  • Sourcing:
  • Neutrality:
  • Readability:
  • Formatting:
  • Illustrations:

Total:

U of Arizona, Language Development[edit]

Vocal-Auditory Channel[edit]

New Article[edit]

Reviewer 1

Reviewer: The Interior (Talk) 21:55, 16 June 2012 (UTC)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness:1
  • Sourcing:2
  • Neutrality:2
  • Readability:1
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations:0

Total: 7

Reviewer 2

Reviewer: Pjoef (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 1
  • Sourcing: 6
  • Neutrality: 3
  • Readability: 0
  • Formatting: 0
  • Illustrations: 0

Total: 10
pjoef (talkcontribs) 17:33, 17 June 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 3

Reviewer:

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness:
  • Sourcing:
  • Neutrality:
  • Readability:
  • Formatting:
  • Illustrations:

Total:

Mount Allison, Environment and Society CRN 66[edit]

Deep Green Resistance[edit]

Pre[edit]

Reviewer 1

Reviewer:

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness:
  • Sourcing:
  • Neutrality:
  • Readability:
  • Formatting:
  • Illustrations:

Total:

Reviewer 2

Reviewer: Pjoef (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 4
  • Sourcing: 2
  • Neutrality: 1
  • Readability: 2
  • Formatting: 2
  • Illustrations: 0

Total: 11
pjoef (talkcontribs) 17:19, 17 June 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 3

Reviewer:

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness:
  • Sourcing:
  • Neutrality:
  • Readability:
  • Formatting:
  • Illustrations:

Total:

Mount Allison, Archaeology and Pop Culture CRN 65[edit]

The Awakening (1980 film)[edit]

Post[edit]

Reviewer 1

Reviewer: The Interior (Talk) 22:27, 16 June 2012 (UTC)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness:6
  • Sourcing:4
  • Neutrality:2
  • Readability:2
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations:1

Total:16

Reviewer 2

Reviewer: Pjoef (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 6
  • Sourcing: 2
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 2
  • Formatting: 2
  • Illustrations: 1

Total: 15
pjoef (talkcontribs) 17:14, 17 June 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 3

Reviewer:

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness:
  • Sourcing:
  • Neutrality:
  • Readability:
  • Formatting:
  • Illustrations:

Total:

U South Carolina, Corporate Training and Development[edit]

Constructivism (learning theory)[edit]

Pre[edit]

Reviewer 1

Reviewer: The Interior (Talk) 23:27, 16 June 2012 (UTC)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness:8
  • Sourcing:5
  • Neutrality:2
  • Readability:2
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations:0

Total: 18

Reviewer 2

Reviewer: Pjoef (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 7
  • Sourcing: 3
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 2
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 0

Total: 15
pjoef (talkcontribs) 16:37, 17 June 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 3

Reviewer:

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness:
  • Sourcing:
  • Neutrality:
  • Readability:
  • Formatting:
  • Illustrations:

Total:

Post[edit]

Reviewer 1

Reviewer:

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness:8
  • Sourcing:5
  • Neutrality:2
  • Readability:2
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations:0

Total:18

Comment: Only a minor addition here. Sourced, readable. The Interior (Talk) 23:31, 16 June 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 2

Reviewer:

Scores: Pjoef (talk · contribs)

  • Comprehensiveness: 7
  • Sourcing: 3
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 2
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 0

Total: 15
pjoef (talkcontribs) 16:37, 17 June 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 3

Reviewer:

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness:
  • Sourcing:
  • Neutrality:
  • Readability:
  • Formatting:
  • Illustrations:

Total:

U South Carolina, Corporate Training and Development[edit]

Broken windows theory[edit]

Pre[edit]

Reviewer 1

Reviewer: --Piotr Konieczny aka Prokonsul Piotrus| reply here 12:09, 15 June 2012 (UTC)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 4
  • Sourcing: 2
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 2
  • Formatting: 2
  • Illustrations: 1

Total: 13

Reviewer 2

Reviewer: Pjoef (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 4
  • Sourcing: 3
  • Neutrality: 1
  • Readability: 2
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 1

Total: 12
pjoef (talkcontribs) 16:27, 17 June 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 3

Reviewer:

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness:
  • Sourcing:
  • Neutrality:
  • Readability:
  • Formatting:
  • Illustrations:

Total:

Post[edit]

Reviewer 1

Reviewer: --Piotr Konieczny aka Prokonsul Piotrus| reply here 12:10, 15 June 2012 (UTC)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 4
  • Sourcing: 2
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 2
  • Formatting: 2
  • Illustrations: 1

Total: 13

Comment: the new article has been expanded, but as the unreferenced content is still present, the article class has not improved. The students added some content, but the expansion was not significant to warrant any change in quality. This is not to say their efforts was useless, but it was not overly significant.--Piotr Konieczny aka Prokonsul Piotrus| reply here 12:12, 15 June 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 2

Reviewer: Pjoef (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 5
  • Sourcing: 3
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 2
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 1

Total: 14
pjoef (talkcontribs) 16:27, 17 June 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 3

Reviewer:

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness:
  • Sourcing:
  • Neutrality:
  • Readability:
  • Formatting:
  • Illustrations:

Total:

UBC, North American Environmental History CRN 38[edit]

Columbia River Treaty[edit]

Pre[edit]

Reviewer 1

Reviewer: Fifelfoo (talk)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 4
  • Sourcing: 2
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 1
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 2

Total: 12

Reviewer 2

Reviewer: Pjoef (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 4
  • Sourcing: 2
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 2
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 2

Total: 13
pjoef (talkcontribs) 12:31, 16 June 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 3

Reviewer:

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness:
  • Sourcing:
  • Neutrality:
  • Readability:
  • Formatting:
  • Illustrations:

Total:

Post[edit]

Reviewer 1

Reviewer: Fifelfoo (talk)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 7
  • Sourcing: 3
  • Neutrality: 1
  • Readability: 2
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 2

Total: 16

Reviewer 2

Reviewer: Pjoef (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 7
  • Sourcing: 4
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 2
  • Formatting: 2
  • Illustrations: 2

Total: 19
pjoef (talkcontribs) 12:31, 16 June 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 3

Reviewer:

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness:
  • Sourcing:
  • Neutrality:
  • Readability:
  • Formatting:
  • Illustrations:

Total:

U Alberta Augustana, Language Acquisition CRN 46[edit]

Vocabulary development[edit]

Pre[edit]

Reviewer 1

Reviewer: Graeme Bartlett (talk)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness:3
  • Sourcing:1
  • Neutrality:2
  • Readability:2
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations:0.5

Total:9.5

Reviewer 2

Reviewer: Pjoef (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 3
  • Sourcing: 2
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 1
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 1

Total: 10
pjoef (talkcontribs) 11:43, 16 June 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 3

Reviewer:

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness:
  • Sourcing:
  • Neutrality:
  • Readability:
  • Formatting:
  • Illustrations:

Total:

Post[edit]

Reviewer 1

Reviewer: Graeme Bartlett (talk)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness:8
  • Sourcing:6
  • Neutrality:3
  • Readability:2
  • Formatting: 2
  • Illustrations:1

Total:22

Reviewer 2

Reviewer: Pjoef (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 7
  • Sourcing: 4
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 2
  • Formatting: 2
  • Illustrations: 1

Total: 18
pjoef (talkcontribs) 11:43, 16 June 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 3

Reviewer:

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness:
  • Sourcing:
  • Neutrality:
  • Readability:
  • Formatting:
  • Illustrations:

Total:

Joint attention[edit]

Pre[edit]

Reviewer 1

Reviewer: Graeme Bartlett (talk)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness:1
  • Sourcing:4
  • Neutrality:3
  • Readability:2
  • Formatting: 2
  • Illustrations:0

Total:12

Reviewer 2

Reviewer: Pjoef (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 2
  • Sourcing: 3
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 1
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 0

Total: 9
pjoef (talkcontribs) 11:43, 16 June 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 3

Reviewer:

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness:
  • Sourcing:
  • Neutrality:
  • Readability:
  • Formatting:
  • Illustrations:

Total:

Post[edit]

Reviewer 1

Reviewer: Graeme Bartlett (talk)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 7
  • Sourcing:6
  • Neutrality:3
  • Readability:2
  • Formatting: 1.5
  • Illustrations:1.5

Total:21

Reviewer 2

Reviewer: Pjoef (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 6
  • Sourcing: 3
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 2
  • Formatting: 2
  • Illustrations: 2

Total: 17
pjoef (talkcontribs) 11:43, 16 June 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 3

Reviewer:

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness:
  • Sourcing:
  • Neutrality:
  • Readability:
  • Formatting:
  • Illustrations:

Total:

Ohio U, Writing & Rhetoric[edit]

Athens Lunatic Asylum[edit]

Pre[edit]

Reviewer 1

Reviewer: JayJasper (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 4
  • Sourcing: 2
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 1
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 2

Total: 12
--JayJasper (talk) 17:51, 15 June 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 2

Reviewer: Pjoef (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 5
  • Sourcing: 2
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 1
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 1

Total: 12
pjoef (talkcontribs) 11:34, 16 June 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 3

Reviewer:

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness:
  • Sourcing:
  • Neutrality:
  • Readability:
  • Formatting:
  • Illustrations:

Total:

Post[edit]

Reviewer 1

Reviewer: JayJasper (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 6
  • Sourcing: 2
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 1
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 2

Total: 14
--JayJasper (talk) 17:58, 15 June 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 2

Reviewer: Pjoef (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 6
  • Sourcing: 3
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 1
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 1

Total: 14
pjoef (talkcontribs) 11:34, 16 June 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 3

Reviewer:

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness:
  • Sourcing:
  • Neutrality:
  • Readability:
  • Formatting:
  • Illustrations:

Total:

Ball State, Industrial Psychology[edit]

Wonderlic Test[edit]

Pre[edit]

Reviewer 1

Reviewer: Pjoef (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 5
  • Sourcing: 2
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 2
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 0

Total: 12
pjoef (talkcontribs) 07:00, 14 May 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 2

Reviewer:JayJasper (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 4
  • Sourcing: 2
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 2
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 0

Total:11
--JayJasper (talk) 21:51, 14 May 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 3

Reviewer:

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness:
  • Sourcing:
  • Neutrality:
  • Readability:
  • Formatting:
  • Illustrations:

Total:

Post[edit]

Reviewer 1

Reviewer: Pjoef (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 6
  • Sourcing: 3
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 2
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 0

Total: 14
pjoef (talkcontribs) 07:29, 14 May 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 2

Reviewer:JayJasper (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 7
  • Sourcing: 4
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 2
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 0

Total:16
--JayJasper (talk) 21:58, 14 May 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 3

Reviewer:

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness:
  • Sourcing:
  • Neutrality:
  • Readability:
  • Formatting:
  • Illustrations:

Total:

Personnel selection[edit]

Pre[edit]

Reviewer 1

Reviewer: Pjoef (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 3
  • Sourcing: 1
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 1
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 0

Total: 8
pjoef (talkcontribs) 18:10, 14 May 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 2

Reviewer:JayJasper (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 4
  • Sourcing: 1
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 1
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 0

Total:9
--JayJasper (talk) 18:10, 15 May 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 3

Reviewer:

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness:
  • Sourcing:
  • Neutrality:
  • Readability:
  • Formatting:
  • Illustrations:

Total:

Post[edit]

Reviewer 1

Reviewer: Pjoef (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 5
  • Sourcing: 2
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 2
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 0

Total: 12
pjoef (talkcontribs) 18:12, 14 May 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 2

Reviewer:JayJasper (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 6
  • Sourcing: 2
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 2
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 0

Total: 13
--JayJasper (talk) 18:14, 15 May 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 3

Reviewer:

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness:
  • Sourcing:
  • Neutrality:
  • Readability:
  • Formatting:
  • Illustrations:

Total:

Ball State, Intro to Digital Literacies CRN 75[edit]

Year-round school[edit]

Post[edit]

Reviewer 1

Reviewer: Pjoef (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 6
  • Sourcing: 2
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 2
  • Formatting: 2
  • Illustrations: 0

Total: 14
pjoef (talkcontribs) 14:07, 14 May 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 2

Reviewer:JayJasper (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness:6
  • Sourcing: 3
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 2
  • Formatting: 2
  • Illustrations: 0

Total: 15
--JayJasper (talk) 21:33, 14 May 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 3

Reviewer:

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness:
  • Sourcing:
  • Neutrality:
  • Readability:
  • Formatting:
  • Illustrations:

Total:

Ball State, Teaching with Technology CRN 76[edit]

Donald Murray (writer)[edit]

Post[edit]

Reviewer 1

Reviewer: Pjoef (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 5
  • Sourcing: 4
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 2
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 0

Total: 14
pjoef (talkcontribs) 15:31, 14 May 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 2

Reviewer: JayJasper (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 6
  • Sourcing: 3
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 2
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 0

Total: 14
--JayJasper (talk) 18:24, 15 May 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 3

Reviewer: Mike Christie (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 5
  • Sourcing: 4
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 2
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 0

Total: 14
--Mike Christie (talk - contribs - library) 19:58, 22 October 2012 (UTC)

Writer's block[edit]

Post[edit]

Reviewer 1

Reviewer: Pjoef (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 5
  • Sourcing: 3
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 2
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 0

Total: 13
pjoef (talkcontribs) 15:31, 14 May 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 2

Reviewer: JayJasper (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 5
  • Sourcing: 2
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 2
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 0

Total: 12
--JayJasper (talk) 18:32, 15 May 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 3

Reviewer: Mike Christie (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 3
  • Sourcing: 4
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 2
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 0

Total: 12
--Mike Christie (talk - contribs - library) 20:01, 22 October 2012 (UTC)

Davidson, Psychology Senior Capstone[edit]

Self-serving bias[edit]

Pre[edit]

Reviewer 1

Reviewer: Pjoef (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 4
  • Sourcing: 2
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 1
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 1

Total: 11
pjoef (talkcontribs) 12:09, 15 May 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 2

Reviewer: JayJasper (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 5
  • Sourcing: 2
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 1
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 1

Total: 12
--JayJasper (talk) 18:42, 22 May 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 3

Reviewer:

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness:
  • Sourcing:
  • Neutrality:
  • Readability:
  • Formatting:
  • Illustrations:

Total:

Post[edit]

Reviewer 1

Reviewer: Pjoef (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 6
  • Sourcing: 4
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 2
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 0

Total: 15
pjoef (talkcontribs) 12:09, 15 May 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 2

Reviewer: JayJasper (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 8
  • Sourcing: 5
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 2
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 0

Total: 18
--JayJasper (talk) 18:52, 22 May 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 3

Reviewer:

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness:
  • Sourcing:
  • Neutrality:
  • Readability:
  • Formatting:
  • Illustrations:

Total :

Carleton University, Contemporary Research in Psychology[edit]

Addiction[edit]

Pre[edit]

Reviewer 1

Reviewer: Pjoef (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 3
  • Sourcing: 3
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 1
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 0

Total: 10
pjoef (talkcontribs) 10:44, 15 May 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 2

Reviewer: JayJasper (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 2
  • Sourcing: 3
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 1
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 0

Total: 9
--JayJasper (talk) 19:29, 16 May 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 3

Reviewer:

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness:
  • Sourcing:
  • Neutrality:
  • Readability:
  • Formatting:
  • Illustrations:

Total:

Post[edit]

Reviewer 1

Reviewer: Pjoef (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 6
  • Sourcing: 5
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 1
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 0

Total: 15
pjoef (talkcontribs) 10:44, 15 May 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 2

Reviewer: JayJasper (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 6
  • Sourcing: 5
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 2
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 0

Total: 16
--JayJasper (talk) 19:41, 16 May 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 3

Reviewer:

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness:
  • Sourcing:
  • Neutrality:
  • Readability:
  • Formatting:
  • Illustrations:

Total:

Nature connectedness[edit]

New Article[edit]

Reviewer 1

Reviewer:

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 6
  • Sourcing: 4
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 2
  • Formatting: 2
  • Illustrations: 1

Total: 17
pjoef (talkcontribs) 10:44, 15 May 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 2

Reviewer: JayJasper (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 8
  • Sourcing: 5
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 2
  • Formatting: 2
  • Illustrations: 1

Total: 20

Reviewer 3

Reviewer:

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness:
  • Sourcing:
  • Neutrality:
  • Readability:
  • Formatting:
  • Illustrations:

Total:

Carnegie Mellon, Social Web CRN 13[edit]

Reciprocity (social psychology)[edit]

Pre[edit]

Reviewer 1

Reviewer: Pjoef (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 4
  • Sourcing: 2
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 1
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 0

Total: 10
pjoef (talkcontribs) 11:09, 15 May 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 2

Reviewer: JayJasper (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 3
  • Sourcing: 2
  • Neutrality: 1
  • Readability: 1
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 0

Total: 8
--JayJasper (talk) 03:39, 17 May 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 3

Reviewer:

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness:
  • Sourcing:
  • Neutrality:
  • Readability:
  • Formatting:
  • Illustrations:

Total:

Post[edit]

Reviewer 1

Reviewer: Pjoef (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 5
  • Sourcing: 2
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 2
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 0

Total: 12
pjoef (talkcontribs) 11:09, 15 May 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 2

Reviewer: JayJasper (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 6
  • Sourcing: 2
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 2
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 0

Total: 13
--JayJasper (talk) 03:46, 17 May 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 3

Reviewer:

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness:
  • Sourcing:
  • Neutrality:
  • Readability:
  • Formatting:
  • Illustrations:

Total:

Collaborative filtering[edit]

Pre[edit]

Reviewer 1

Reviewer: Pjoef (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 5
  • Sourcing: 2
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 2
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 0

Total: 12
pjoef (talkcontribs) 11:09, 15 May 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 2

Reviewer: JayJasper (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 6
  • Sourcing: 2
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 2
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 0

Total: 13
--JayJasper (talk) 15:39, 17 May 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 3

Reviewer:

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness:
  • Sourcing:
  • Neutrality:
  • Readability:
  • Formatting:
  • Illustrations:

Total:

Post[edit]

Reviewer 1

Reviewer: Pjoef (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 6
  • Sourcing: 2
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 2
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 0

Total: 13
pjoef (talkcontribs) 11:09, 15 May 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 2

Reviewer: JayJasper (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 8
  • Sourcing: 2
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 2
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 0

Total: 15
--JayJasper (talk) 15:46, 17 May 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 3

Reviewer:

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness:
  • Sourcing:
  • Neutrality:
  • Readability:
  • Formatting:
  • Illustrations:

Total:

Overjustification effect[edit]

Pre[edit]

Reviewer 1

Reviewer: Pjoef (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 5
  • Sourcing: 3
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 2
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 0

Total: 13
pjoef (talkcontribs) 11:09, 15 May 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 2

Reviewer: JayJasper (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 6
  • Sourcing: 3
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 2
  • Formatting: 2
  • Illustrations: 0

Total: 15
--JayJasper (talk) 15:57, 17 May 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 3

Reviewer:

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness:
  • Sourcing:
  • Neutrality:
  • Readability:
  • Formatting:
  • Illustrations:

Total:

Post[edit]

Reviewer 1

Reviewer: Pjoef (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 5
  • Sourcing: 4
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 2
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 0

Total: 14
pjoef (talkcontribs) 11:09, 15 May 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 2

Reviewer: JayJasper (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 8
  • Sourcing: 4
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 2
  • Formatting: 2
  • Illustrations: 1

Total: 19
--JayJasper (talk) 16:06, 17 May 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 3

Reviewer:

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness:
  • Sourcing:
  • Neutrality:
  • Readability:
  • Formatting:
  • Illustrations:

Total:

Clemson, Rhetoric and Composition CRN 70[edit]

Bill Finch (politician)[edit]

Pre[edit]

Reviewer 1

Reviewer: Mike Christie (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 1
  • Sourcing: 2
  • Neutrality: 3
  • Readability: 2
  • Formatting: 2
  • Illustrations: 0

Total: 10
-- Mike Christie (talk - contribs - library) 19:43, 13 May 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 2

Reviewer: Pjoef (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 1
  • Sourcing: 4
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 1
  • Formatting: 0
  • Illustrations: 0

Total: 8
pjoef (talkcontribs) 11:40, 15 May 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 3

Reviewer:

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness:
  • Sourcing:
  • Neutrality:
  • Readability:
  • Formatting:
  • Illustrations:

Total:

Post[edit]

Reviewer 1

Reviewer: Pjoef (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 5
  • Sourcing: 2
  • Neutrality: 1
  • Readability: 1
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 0

Total: 10
pjoef (talkcontribs) 11:40, 15 May 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 2

Reviewer: Mike Christie (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 6
  • Sourcing: 3
  • Neutrality: 1
  • Readability: 2
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 0

Total: 13
Mike Christie (talk - contribs - library) 10:33, 25 May 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 3

Reviewer:

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness:
  • Sourcing:
  • Neutrality:
  • Readability:
  • Formatting:
  • Illustrations:

Total:

Infamous Stringdusters[edit]

Pre[edit]

Reviewer 1

Reviewer: Pjoef (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 3
  • Sourcing: 2
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 1
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 1

Total: 10
pjoef (talkcontribs) 11:40, 15 May 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 2

Reviewer: JayJasper (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 4
  • Sourcing: 2
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 1
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 1

Total: 11
--JayJasper (talk) 18:18, 18 May 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 3

Reviewer: Mike Christie (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 3
  • Sourcing: 1
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 2
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 1

Total: 10
--Mike Christie (talk - contribs - library) 20:14, 22 October 2012 (UTC)

Clemson Tigers women's tennis[edit]

New Article[edit]

Reviewer 1

Reviewer: Pjoef (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 5
  • Sourcing: 3
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 1
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 1

Total: 13
pjoef (talkcontribs) 11:40, 15 May 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 2

Reviewer: JayJasper (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 7
  • Sourcing: 3
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 1
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 2

Total: 16

Reviewer 3

Reviewer:

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness:
  • Sourcing:
  • Neutrality:
  • Readability:
  • Formatting:
  • Illustrations:

Total:

Georgetown, Art and Ethics[edit]

Google Art Project[edit]

Post[edit]

Reviewer 1

Reviewer: Pjoef (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 6
  • Sourcing: 4
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 2
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 2

Total: 17
pjoef (talkcontribs) 14:21, 15 May 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 2

Reviewer: JayJasper (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 7
  • Sourcing: 5
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 2
  • Formatting: 2
  • Illustrations: 2

Total: 20
--JayJasper (talk) 23:12, 20 May 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 3

Reviewer: {{user|Mike Christie

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 8
  • Sourcing: 5
  • Neutrality: 3
  • Readability: 2
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 2

Total: 21
--Mike Christie (talk - contribs - library) 20:21, 22 October 2012 (UTC)

The West As America Art Exhibition[edit]

New Article[edit]

Reviewer 1

Reviewer: Pjoef (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 7
  • Sourcing: 4
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 2
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 2

Total: 18
pjoef (talkcontribs) 14:21, 15 May 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 2

Reviewer: JayJasper (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 8
  • Sourcing: 4
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 2
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 2

Total: 19
--JayJasper (talk) 18:59, 22 May 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 3

Reviewer: Mike Christie (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 7
  • Sourcing: 5
  • Neutrality: 3
  • Readability: 2
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 2

Total: 20
--Mike Christie (talk - contribs - library) 20:24, 22 October 2012 (UTC)

Georgetown, Communication Technology and Organizations[edit]

Groundswell (book)[edit]

Post[edit]

Reviewer 1

Reviewer: Pjoef (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 5
  • Sourcing: 2
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 1
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 0

Total: 11
pjoef (talkcontribs) 18:34, 15 May 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 2

Reviewer: JayJasper (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 5
  • Sourcing: 3
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 1
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 0

Total: 12
--JayJasper (talk) 23:27, 20 May 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 3

Reviewer: Mike Christie (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 4
  • Sourcing: 4
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 1
  • Formatting: 0
  • Illustrations: 1

Total: 11
--Mike Christie (talk - contribs - library) 20:29, 22 October 2012 (UTC)

Telecommuting[edit]

Pre[edit]

Reviewer 1

Reviewer: Pjoef (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 4
  • Sourcing: 2
  • Neutrality: 1
  • Readability: 1
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 0

Total: 9
pjoef (talkcontribs) 18:34, 15 May 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 2

Reviewer: JayJasper (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 6
  • Sourcing: 3
  • Neutrality: 1
  • Readability: 1
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 0

Total: 12
--JayJasper (talk) 16:26, 25 May 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 3

Reviewer: Mike Christie (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 6
  • Sourcing: 4
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 2
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 0

Total: 15
--Mike Christie (talk - contribs - library) 20:34, 22 October 2012 (UTC)

Post[edit]

Reviewer 1

Reviewer: Pjoef (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 6
  • Sourcing: 4
  • Neutrality: 1
  • Readability: 2
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 1

Total: 15
pjoef (talkcontribs) 18:34, 15 May 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 2

Reviewer: JayJasper (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 8
  • Sourcing: 5
  • Neutrality: 1
  • Readability: 2
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 1

Total: 18
--JayJasper (talk) 16:32, 25 May 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 3

Reviewer: Mike Christie (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 7
  • Sourcing: 4
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 2
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 0

Total: 16
--Mike Christie (talk - contribs - library) 20:34, 22 October 2012 (UTC)

Georgetown, Film Theory[edit]

Cinema Novo[edit]

Pre[edit]

Reviewer 1

Reviewer: Pjoef (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 2
  • Sourcing: 2
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 2
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 0

Total: 9
pjoef (talkcontribs) 10:35, 16 May 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 2

Reviewer: JayJasper (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 2
  • Sourcing: 1
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 2
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 0

Total: 8
--JayJasper (talk) 16:38, 25 May 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 3

Reviewer:

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness:
  • Sourcing:
  • Neutrality:
  • Readability:
  • Formatting:
  • Illustrations:

Total:

Post[edit]

Reviewer 1

Reviewer: Pjoef (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 7
  • Sourcing: 3
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 2
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 0

Total: 15
pjoef (talkcontribs) 10:35, 16 May 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 2

Reviewer: JayJasper (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 8
  • Sourcing: 4
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 2
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 0

Total: 17

Reviewer 3

Reviewer:

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness:
  • Sourcing:
  • Neutrality:
  • Readability:
  • Formatting:
  • Illustrations:

Total:

Georgetown, Media in Arab World[edit]

Abdel-Bari Zamzami[edit]

New Article[edit]

Reviewer 1

Reviewer: Mike Christie (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 4
  • Sourcing: 3
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 1
  • Formatting: 0
  • Illustrations: 0

Total: 10
--Mike Christie (talk - contribs - library)

Reviewer 2

Reviewer: Pjoef (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 5
  • Sourcing: 4
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 2
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 0

Total: 14
pjoef (talkcontribs) 12:25, 16 May 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 3

Reviewer:

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness:
  • Sourcing:
  • Neutrality:
  • Readability:
  • Formatting:
  • Illustrations:

Total:

Hunter, CUNY, Human Rights of Indigenous Peoples[edit]

Aweer people[edit]

Pre[edit]

Reviewer 1

Reviewer: Mike Christie (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 1
  • Sourcing: 1
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 2
  • Formatting: 2
  • Illustrations: 0

Total: 8'
--Mike Christie (talk - contribs - library)

Reviewer 2

Reviewer: Pjoef (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 1
  • Sourcing: 2
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 2
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 0

Total: 8
pjoef (talkcontribs) 16:51, 16 May 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 3

Reviewer:

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness:
  • Sourcing:
  • Neutrality:
  • Readability:
  • Formatting:
  • Illustrations:

Total:

Jackson Community College, American National Government[edit]

Primary election[edit]

Post[edit]

Reviewer 1

Reviewer: Pjoef (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 4
  • Sourcing: 3
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 2
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 0

Total: 12
pjoef (talkcontribs) 13:44, 17 May 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 2

Reviewer: Mike Christie (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 4
  • Sourcing: 4
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 2
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 0

Total: 13
Mike Christie (talk - contribs - library) 10:30, 27 May 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 3

Reviewer:

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness:
  • Sourcing:
  • Neutrality:
  • Readability:
  • Formatting:
  • Illustrations:

Total:

LSU, Intro to Dramatic Lit[edit]

The Sign in Sidney Brustein's Window[edit]

New Article[edit]

Reviewer 1

Reviewer: Mike Christie (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 7
  • Sourcing: 4
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 2
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 0

Total: 16
Mike Christie (talk - contribs - library) 14:03, 20 May 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 2

Reviewer: Pjoef (talk · contribs)

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness: 6
  • Sourcing: 4
  • Neutrality: 2
  • Readability: 2
  • Formatting: 1
  • Illustrations: 0

Total: 15
pjoef (talkcontribs) 07:52, 21 May 2012 (UTC)

Reviewer 3

Reviewer:

Scores:

  • Comprehensiveness:
  • Sourcing:
  • Neutrality:
  • Readability:
  • Formatting:
  • Illustrations:

Total: