Jump to content

Wikipedia:Edit filter/Requested

Add topic
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Latest comment: 6 days ago by Daniel Quinlan in topic Submitted AfC drafts
Requested edit filters

This page can be used to request edit filters, or changes to existing filters. Edit filters are primarily used to address common patterns of harmful editing.

Private filters should not be discussed in detail. If you wish to discuss creating an LTA filter, or changing an existing one, please instead email details to wikipedia-en-editfilters@lists.wikimedia.org.

Otherwise, please add a new section at the bottom using the following format:

== Brief description of filter ==
* '''Task''': What is the filter supposed to do? To what pages and editors does it apply?
* '''Reason''': Why is the filter needed?
* '''Diffs''': Diffs of sample edits/cases. If the diffs are revdelled, consider emailing their contents to the mailing list.
~~~~

Please note the following:

  • Edit filters are used primarily to prevent abuse. Contributors are not expected to have read all 200+ policies, guidelines and style pages before editing. Trivial formatting mistakes and edits that at first glance look fine but go against some obscure style guideline or arbitration ruling are not suitable candidates for an edit filter.
  • Filters are applied to all edits on all pages. Problematic changes that apply to a single page are likely not suitable for an edit filter. Page protection may be more appropriate in such cases.
  • Non-essential tasks or those that require access to complex criteria, especially information that the filter does not have access to, may be more appropriate for a bot task or external software.
  • To prevent the creation of pages with certain names, the title blacklist is usually a better way to handle the problem - see MediaWiki talk:Titleblacklist for details.
  • To prevent the addition of problematic external links, please make your request at the spam blacklist.
  • To prevent the registration of accounts with certain names, please make your request at the global title blacklist.
  • To prevent the registration of accounts with certain email addresses, please make your request at the email blacklist.



Overwriting of birth range templates

[edit]
  • Task: Warn or disallow when an edit replaces a {{birth based on age as of date}} template with a date or year, without simultaneously adding a URL or reference tag
  • Reason: This "based on age" template is a strong indicator that Wikipedia editors have already tried and failed to find an exact, reliably-sourced birth date for a person, and have only been able to confirm a two-year date range. Readers sometimes step in to replace these with a particular year or date, offering no source, often just asking IMDb or Google. An unsourced DOB is obviously against WP:BLPDOB, and a "based on age" template suggests that any added date (even if correct) has not been widely published by reliable sources.
  • Diffs: eg. , . Belbury (talk) 09:12, 17 March 2026 (UTC)Reply

New users commenting out blocks of text

[edit]

iLands

[edit]
  • Task: Edit filter, for summaries and/or edits to User and Talk namespace (and, if possible, usernames) that contain the string "iLands". Probably warn is best
  • Reason: iLands is an AI agent network: . Sometimes its agents make edits here, which obviously is not allowed.
  • Diffs: Special:Diff/1380812942, Special:Diff/1380730633, Special:Diff/1377662222

Gnomingstuff (talk) 14:51, 18 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

I'm not sure we need a filter for this specific site's agents, but I'll take a look at whether we could create a more generalized filter. Is Category:Confirmed Wikipedia AI agents up to date? Daniel Quinlan (talk) 15:20, 18 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
 Done. See filter 1418. Daniel Quinlan (talk) 07:12, 28 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

warn on submission of unchanged draft after being declined

[edit]
  • Task: show a warning to submitter if they are submitting a draft that was declined (or draftified) that hasnt been edited (other than by bots or the addition of maintenance tags)
  • Reason: if a draft was declined or draftified, its (probably) not ready to be an article, so it shouldnt be submitted without being edited
  • Diffs: Special:Diff/1380943161 Special:Diff/1377483498 (there are other examples but theyre pretty much all gonna look like these)

/etc/owuh $ (💬 | she/they) 04:41, 19 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

AI chatbot communication in HTML comments

[edit]
  • Task: Flag when an edit contains an HTML comment along the lines of "Verify ____ before publication". This will require regex tweaking, catching "before submitting/submission/publication/publishing" before an end --> comment will get some, "Verify " before comment start <!-- should get some. These conservative patterns seem to have very few to zero fales positives, but there are probably other patterns and variants in spacing/punctuation I can go through my samples and find. Claude in particular is idiosyncratic with these but I haven't seen enough Claude examples to have a reproducible search.
  • Reason: Strong verging on unambiguous and G15-able indicator of AI output, and seems to be getting more prevalent; however, it is easy to miss since it is not visible in article text, which is resulting in stuff getting through AfC and DYK, etc., that should have been speedied.
  • Diffs: Special:Diff/1380217032 (was on DYK briefly until it got pulled for being confirmed AI output, which could have been nipped in the bud right away if there was a filter), Special:Diff/1372484563, Special:Diff/1377048009. As above these are G15-able so undoubtedly many examples have been found (But not all)

Gnomingstuff (talk) 05:51, 25 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

Thanks. The comments are definitely not being missed in working on this. I'm working on a filter for this type of communication in addition to AI disclosures (see this), but it's a complex filter and there are a lot of variations on the theme. Daniel Quinlan (talk) 07:09, 25 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

Small change to filter 1418

[edit]

The following string generated by AfC's AI disclosure thing "In preparing this draft, I disclose that AI assistance was used as follows..." trips this filter, and I assume is for most edits that trip this filter. These are not disclosures of one being an AI agent Maybe make an exclusion for these types of automatically-generated AfC comments, if that is the only part of the edit that trips the filter? Beta Beta Beta - talk 06:56, 29 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

 Not done. The filter's description was changed earlier to "Possible self-disclosure of AI agent or AI use". I'm still actively working on this edit filter. I may end up excluding some disclosures for things that are allowed, but it looks like a number of disclosures are less than accurate so leaving these hits in the log might be best. Daniel Quinlan (talk) 07:03, 29 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

Submitted AfC drafts

[edit]

Beta Beta Beta - talk 20:57, 4 November 2026 (UTC)Reply

As opposed to Special:NewPagesFeed's AfC tab? Tenshi! (Talk page) 21:03, 4 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
Was not aware of that existing. Thank you. Beta Beta Beta - talk 22:43, 4 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
 Not done. As per Tenshi Hinanawi. Daniel Quinlan (talk) 00:39, 5 November 2026 (UTC)Reply

Stacey Lines Railway

[edit]
  • Task: Prevent the addition of the AI-generated "Stacey Lines Railway" on Wikipedia's 2-10-4 page.
  • Reason: An unknown user is providing their fictional railway and its engines and passing it as fact, alongside repeatedly using an AI-generated picture of a locomotive related to the page.
  • Diffs:

~2026-58710-70 (talk) 00:36, 5 November 2026 (UTC) [] and []Reply

 Not done. @~2026-58710-70: An issue specific to a single article is better solved with page protection or blocking. Please make a request at WP:RFPPI or WP:ANI (just one, not both), following the instructions at the top of the noticeboard. Daniel Quinlan (talk) 00:38, 5 November 2026 (UTC)Reply