Wikipedia:Featured list removal candidates/log/June 2007

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Frölunda HC seasons[edit]

Still a featured list.

The criterion applied to seasons lists so far has been 1(a)1: "The list brings together a group of existing articles related by well-defined entry criteria []bold emphasis mine." This fails the criterion utterly: it does not link together articles on either Country, league, division or team seasons. Circeus 03:25, 8 June 2007 (UTC)

What about the alternative 1(a)3: "The list contains a finite, complete and well-defined set of items that naturally fit together to form a significant topic of study, and where the set's members are not notable enough to have individual articles." -- Colin°Talk 06:49, 8 June 2007 (UTC)
Considering that Manchester F.C. season failed to get promoted for apparently the same reason, and had country season articles as well as quite a few division ones, I don't think we can argue that ground.Circeus 10:46, 8 June 2007 (UTC)
Well I'm not a big soccer fan but as far as I know Manchester FC is the worlds most famous club. This is a swedish ice hockey team, one of the most famous, but stil, I do not belive that creating articles for every season in the past is that important. --Krm500 23:14, 8 June 2007 (UTC)

Er, that was Manchester City F.C. seasons, not Manchester United. Not nearly such a famous club. Anyway, I've looked at that list's candidacy and believe that User:Timpcrk87 failed to notice that criterion 1a has moved on (changed at the start of this year) despite linking to the discussion that caused the change. Don't get too hung up on "this list failed/succeeded for this/that reason". If this list meets 1(a)3 rather than 1(a)1, then it passes the criterion. Colin°Talk 19:12, 10 June 2007 (UTC)

Sorry, forgot that there's two clubs from Manchester. Back on topic; There's only one season link so far but I can guarantee that there will be more on future seasons, for example the 2007-08 season already has an article and I will continue to add new season articles as long as I'm a member of wikipedia. --Krm500 09:45, 15 June 2007 (UTC)

So, is there any verdict from the wiki community? --Krm500 02:48, 27 June 2007 (UTC)