Wikipedia:Long-term abuse/Morning277

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search
Wikilifespan August 2010 [1] to present
Known hostmasks,,, and confirmed with checkuser and blocked; reported
Physical location Pleasanton, California, San Diego, Miami, Bangladesh and others
Severity High
Sockpuppet investigations Morning277
Instructions Suspected socks should be tagged and reported to sockpuppet investigations for confirmation. When reporting, please link to this long-term abuse report. When the active abuse has been taken care of, please update this report with the latest information.
Status Active

Please report all ongoing incidents of abuse to AIV or ANI.

Note: Unfortunately, some of the information below and to the right conflates[2] LegalMorning and Wiki-PR. We now know that they are two separate entities.

Basic information[edit]

Morning277 (talkcontribsblock logautospiconfirmed socks
suspected socks

Comprehensive edits analysis

Who is Morning277?[edit]

This is a writer, or group of hired writers, who collaborate without ever using talk pages to communicate with each other. As of January 2014, 323 accounts have been confirmed, with another 95 suspected.

Wiki-PR editing of Wikipedia#Investigation and company reaction includes a discussion of whether Morning277 is Michael Wood or Wiki-PR.

It could be Michael Wood (Elance / LinkedIn / G+), the owner of professional writing service LegalMorning. Mr. Wood's website advertises Wikipedia article writing, monitoring, and translation services. He advertises that he doesn't use any foreign subcontractors. Mr. Wood adds on his blog that he's also a regular contributor to a bunch of websites: AllBusiness Experts, Yahoo, Business Insider, Business2Community, Social Media Today, and others. He runs a blog with interesting articles such as "Are There Rules Against Paying Someone To Write A Wikipedia Article" and "Understanding What It Takes To Be Notable For Wikipedia".

Or it could be Wiki-PR.

Or perhaps it's both.

Targeted areas, pages, themes[edit]

These writers create or (less often) rewrite articles about the people and companies who commission them. It is believed that there is a company with several regular employees, which also hires freelancers from Odesk and Elance [3] [4].

The client base is almost entirely from the United States. It is heavily laden with Silicon Valley dot-coms and their principals, dubbed "serial entrepreneurs" in several instances. Small financial institutions also make a showing. Articles about authors, medical doctors, a musician, a small oil company, and even a minor political party [5] have been placed.

In the less frequent case when an article about the client already exists, the Morning277 writers make extensive changes, cleansing the article of any disparaging material in the process.

Below is a list of article subjects found in User:Sublimeharmony/sandbox11, linked to the corresponding articles (sometimes the name of the article name differed from the subject). Most of these articles were deleted, but attempts to replace some of them, most often with variations on the name, have been seen. Often the new articles are shorter, but comparison of the new articles to the drafts in User:Sublimeharmony/sandbox11 has shown identical passages. This is not an exhaustive list of Morning277's topics; these drafts appeared between 22 February and 11 July 2013.

Sublimeharmony sandbox topics[edit]

Non-Sublimeharmony topics[edit]

Below is a list of other topics not necessarily present in Sublimeharmony's sandbox but which were worked on by Morning277 writers (to do: remove the Sublimeharmony topics).

Articles posted on simple wiki[edit]

The articles listed below were posted from two accounts. Due to overlap with Morning277 topics found on the regular English Wikipedia, all of these are assumed to be of interest to Morning277. The search links are for searching the regular English Wikipedia.

Habitual behavior[edit]

Morning277 articles usually cite stories from the Web sites below, some of which are blog-like in accepting material from "citizen journalists." Search links are provided for strongly indicative sites:

  • (search)
  • (search)
  • (search) Project Spam page
  • (search) Project Spam page
  • (search) turns up some likely false positives
  • (sometimes misleadingly referred to as simply Yahoo)
  • (sometimes misleadingly referred to as simply CNN)
  • CrunchBase

Variations have been seen, but the most stereotypical editing chronology of these writers is as follows:

  • a series of at least ten edits to existing articles, typically marked (accurately) as minor and without edit summaries, often concentrating on articles related to Bangladesh. This is done in order begin achieving autoconfirmed status.
  • sometimes the creation of a user page and/ or talk page to go along with the account, the user page usually consisting of a one- or two-sentence biography stating the writer's ostensible reason for being on Wikipedia. This is done to prevent the username from showing up as a red link in the history of the user's contributions, which otherwise would be an easy flag.
  • no edits for a few days while awaiting autoconfirmation.
  • once account is autoconfirmed, creation of an article in a sandbox; when created, the article has multiple paragraphs and a list of references, although at this stage the citations are occasionally in a References section rather than in-line (no edit summary is given here, either)
  • references are commonly named with a two- or three-character, capitalized abbreviation and are often used multiple times in the article, sometimes multiple times in the same paragraph, giving the article a visual appearance of overwhelming credibility— for this reason, the writers never bundle their citations as this would detract from the entire purpose of adding citations (i.e., to make the article seem legitimate at first glance or even second)
  • another editor, often using an AT&T DSL IP address beginning in 70, 71, or 99 with "pltn" (believed to be Pleasanton, California) or "sndg" (believed to be San Diego) in the hostname may then remove the sandbox template while the article is still a sandbox
  • after removal of the sandbox template but before the article is moved to main space, there may be a delay of hours or days
  • the article is moved to the main space and may receive small or large changes (including changes before it is moved)
  • account from which article was inserted is usually, but not always, abandoned soon afterward
  • usually the contributed articles are left orphaned, or are linked only to other Morning277 articles; if an unaffiliated editor places an orphan tag on the article, it may be removed by a Morning277 editor without the status as orphan having been altered
  • other affiliated writers, or writers who may be the client or the client's employees, often make small edits to the article; edits from IP addresses are common in this phase
  • photos or logos, if added, are placed through a separate (not necessarily autoconfirmed) account.
  • if the article is tagged for improvement or deletion, Morning277 accounts or IP editors frequently remove the tags or participate in AfD discussions. When tags are removed, the corresponding edit summary deceptively claims that grammar was corrected or promotional material was removed, decrying puffery, or states that the article's subject is well-known in a certain metropolitan area.
  • if an article is deleted, it may be recreated from a different account, typically without the aid of an administrator, often under a different but very similar title

Morning277 articles are written in fluent English, with few spelling, grammatical or punctuation errors. However, they often have a promotional tone, and always contain material that is either neutral or that is flattering of their subjects, never material that is critical or negative, to the extent that they have sometimes been speedily deleted as spam. References sections always have a surfeit of citations, with the clients' press releases and web sites balanced by passing mentions in seemingly independent publications.


Other notes[edit]

Check-user information showed use of belonging to, an ISP which provides service aboard airliners. Used at the Phoenix airport. Edited from Amazon EC2/AWS hosts in the United States (,,, and, all confirmed with check-user information) and Ireland (, not CU confirmed).

Confirmed and suspected accounts[edit]