|The following is a proposed Wikipedia policy, guideline, or process. The proposal may still be in development, under discussion, or in the process of gathering consensus for adoption.|
This style page summarizes Wikipedia "good practice" for Germany pages.
The choice of a style does not mean that other conventions are worse, or wrong. The sole purpose is to enable consistency among a large number of Wikipedia articles. Completed Wikipedia articles should mention the fact that other usages exist and in which contexts they are preferred.
- 1 Disclaimer
- 2 Alphabet
- 3 Naming
- 3.1 Personal names
- 3.2 Titles
- 3.3 Contemporary placenames
- 3.4 General guidelines for placenames
- 3.5 Historic placenames
- 3.6 Universities and colleges
- 3.7 Administrative units
- 3.8 Rail transport terminology
- 4 Disambiguation
- 5 Footnotes and References
This page is still under discussion and is not final.
The Wikipedia convention is to use the 30-letter German alphabet in proper names, in line with the broader Wikipedia convention of using local Latin alphabets. It is helpful to explain near the top of an article how to convert a name to the 26-letter alphabet.
Where an English form of name for a king or prince is in common use, Wikipedia employs that as the headword for an article. Within the article, the German form should be mentioned at least once.
Wikipedia spells out names and does not employ German abbreviation systems whose significance is not understood in English, e.g. "v." for von.
Titles of historic royalty and contemporary family heads and their immediate family are translated into English in Wikipedia. The convention is to include the royal titles in headwords. This is set out at Wikipedia:Naming conventions (names and titles)#Other_royals, e.g. Ernst August V, Prince of Hanover.
Titles of contemporary persons who merely use the title as a consistent and de facto part of their surname are not translated in Wikipedia, e.g. Otto Graf Lambsdorff. This German-language word (not the English form) appears in the headword as if it were a regular surname.
Wikipedia translates and places ecclesiastical titles outside the name of the person, e.g. Cardinal Georg Sterzinsky, not "Georg Kardinal Sterzinsky". This convention is set out at Wikipedia:Naming conventions (clergy). The title is not part of the headword.
Cities and towns
In the absence of a common English name, the current local spelling of a city is used by convention in Wikipedia. Some cities in Germany have English spellings distinct from the German, for example:
- Cologne (universal)
- Hamelin (derived term Pied Piper of Hamelin)
- Hanover (universal)
- Meissen (derived term Meissen porcelain)
- Munich (universal)
- Nuremberg (universal)
- Brunswick/Braunschweig. Wikipedia uses Brunswick in historical contexts and for persons, but Braunschweig as the headword of the article about the contemporary city.
- Düsseldorf. The English variant Dusseldorf, employed where only limited character sets are available, is not used in Wikipedia.
States and administrative regions
Wikipedia uses these English names for the states of:
- Lower Saxony
- North Rhine-Westphalia
For the other states, Wikipedia uses an English name orthographically identical to the German name (including Baden-Württemberg with ü). Mecklenburg-Vorpommern has been adopted as the English form of the name of the state created in 1990, although Pomerania is acceptable for all other uses. Formal names such as "Free State of ..." need to be mentioned early in the article text.
For the seven Bavarian administrative regions derived from the above, Wikipedia uses non-vernacular names:
- Upper Franconia
- Middle Franconia
- Lower Franconia
- Swabia (administrative region)
- Upper Palatinate
- Upper Bavaria
- Lower Bavaria
Wikipedia uses English names for other contemporary geographic features when the English usage is (1) universal or (2) the feature crosses language boundaries or (3) derived terms are in common use:
- Black Forest (universal)
- the Danube (cross-border)
- Franconia (universal)
- Frisia (cross-border; not to be confused with the province of Friesland in the Netherlands and Friesland (district) in Germany)
- Lake Constance (universal)
- Lusatia (cross-border)
- the Moselle (cross-border)
- the Ore Mountains (cross-border; usage not settled)
- Pomerania (cross-border)
- Swabia (universal)
- the Rhine (cross-border)
Wikipedia uses the names from authoritative English language geographical sources such as Dickinson (1964) and Elkins (1972). See Natural regions of Germany and its linked pages. Some examples include:
- Central Uplands (Mittelgebirge)
- Cologne Lowland (Kölner Bucht)
- Lüneburg Heath (Lüneburger Heide)
- Westphalian Basin (Westfälische Bucht)
- Stade Geest (Stader Geest)
- Weser Uplands (Weserbergland)
- Franconian Jura (Fränkische Alb)
- Thuringian Basin (Thüringer Becken)
- Upper Lusatia (Oberlausitz)
- Iller-Lech Plateau ([Donau]-Iller-Lech Platte)
- Palatinate Forest (Pfälzerwald)
- Alpine Foreland (Alpenvorland)
Where no English source can be found, the conventions below, which are derived from authoritative sources, are applied if possible.
General guidelines for placenames
The 2 main rules are: "Use English" and "Use the original if there is no established English usage". However the use of compound nouns in German, where a proper noun and an ordinary noun are combined, complicates the issue. There is no simple answer, but the following guidance is based on the translation practice of place names in authoritative geographical sources, major dictionaries and tourist guides. There are 3 broad categories:
Use the original full German word, unless there is an accepted English equivalent:
- Cities, towns and villages: Wuppertal, Passau; but Munich for München and Nuremberg for Nürnberg. Disambiguation: use German system e.g. Hassel (Bergen), Hassel (Weser).
- Mountains and hills: Zugspitze, Biberkopf, Kahlersberg. Disambiguation: use "(mountain)", "(hill)" or "(mtn range)" as appropriate e.g. Kreuzberg (Rhön).
- Valleys if not named after their river: Höllental, Windautal (the river is the Windauer Ache). Otherwise see Group B below.
- Lakes: Ammersee, Chiemsee; but Lake Constance for Bodensee. It is also acceptable to use "Lake Town" e.g. Lake Brienz for Brienzersee and Lake Starnberg for Starnberger See.
- Rivers: Aabach, Main; but Rhine for Rhein and Moselle for Mosel. Disambiguation: use "(river)" or "(river system)" e.g. Inn (river) or Vils (Danube).
Split the compound word, do not translate the proper noun, unless it has an accepted English equivalent, and translate the ordinary noun e.g. tal as "Valley" or talbrücke as "Viaduct":
- Valleys: Rhine Valley for Rheintal, Moselle Valley for Moseltal. In the text it could also be rendered "valley of the Rhine". Usually capital "V" when it follows the proper noun. Exception: use the original word where it refers to a district or town e.g. Rheintal district (or where the valley is not named after the river).
- Bridges: Theodor Heuss Bridge (Düsseldorf) for Theodor-Heuss-Brücke and Deutz Suspension Bridge for Deutzer Hängebrücke
- Viaducts: Weihe Viaduct for Weihetalbrücke, Landwasser Viaduct for Landwasserviadukt.
- Ranges: Wiehen Hills for Wiehengebirge; Rothaar Mountains for Rothaargebirge, depending on height/usage. NB "-gebirge" is often dropped in German anyway.
- Mountain passes: Oberjoch Pass for Oberjochpass, Feldberg Pass for Feldbergpass and Julier Pass for Julierpass.
- Ravines and gorges: Aare Gorge for Aareschlucht
- Tunnels: Rennsteig Tunnel for Rennsteigtunnel
- Glaciers: Palü Glacier for Palügletscher, Aletsch Glacier for Aletschgletscher
Not compound nouns, but added for completeness. There are two words in German; leave the proper noun in the original, but translate the ordinary noun:
- Dams: Rappbode Dam for Talsperre Rappbode (but see "Reservoirs").
- Reservoirs: Rappbode Reservoir for Talsperre Rappbode (NB Talsperre can refer to the dam or its associated reservoir)
- Bays: Eckernförde Bay for Eckenförder Bucht, Bay of Mecklenburg for Mecklenburgische Bucht (use whichever is the widely accepted English form; if there is no English usage, prefer XX Bay.)
- Castles, palaces, mansions and country houses: Hohenschwangau Castle for Schloß Hohenschwangau, Falkenstein Castle for Burg Falkenstein. But beware; many Schlösser are palaces (Sanssouci Palace, Brunswick Palace) or country/mansion houses (Meisdorf House) and some Burgen are really country houses and should be so-named.
- Waterfalls: Lichtenhain Waterfall for Lichtenhainer Wasserfall
- Adjectives: Convert to a noun, e.g. Lichtenhain Waterfall for Lichtenhainer Wasserfall, unless there is a recognised English adjective, e.g. Bavarian Forest for Bayerischer Wald
- Hyphens: remove (in Groups B and C) unless they would be used in English, e.g. Theodor Heuss Bridge for Theodor-Heuss-Brücke, Main-Neckar Railway for Main-Neckar-Bahn
- Original German name: For Groups B and C, the German name should be a redirect, should be included in the introduction and should be interwiki-linked
- Word order: Prefer the English word order e.g. Falkenstein Castle (Burg Falkenstein) not "Castle Falkenstein"
- Translation of Stadt: In Germany, a settlement is a Stadt if it has been awarded Stadtrechte ("town rights"). In addition, a Großstadt is officially defined as a Stadt with a population of 100,000 or more. For consistency and to avoid confusion over whether to translate Stadt as "town" or "city" in English:
- For settlements with town rights (Stadtrechte) and populations under 100,000: translate as "town"
- For settlements with town rights (Stadtrechte) and populations of 100,000 or more (i.e. a Großstadt): translate as "city"
Universities and colleges
In line with most other national sections of Wikipedia, the headwords and links for German universities are descriptive and short and take the form: University of [[Placename]]. Qualifiers such as "technical", patron names or provincial names should only be prefixed if there are multiple universities in the same town, e.g. Humboldt University of Berlin. The full German name should be reproduced near the top of the relevant article. If the university claims an "official" English name, this should also be mentioned, though this may not be the same as the headword. Schools that do not confer doctorates should be termed colleges or schools in the headwords.
The translation of present-day administrative units (e.g. Länder, Kreise) should generally follow the recommendations of the Directorate-General for Translation of the European Commission, unless the context or other guidelines suggest otherwise. A summary of German terms and their English equivalent from the style guide is given below:
- Amt: authority. An Amt is a group of Gemeinden at a lower level than a Kreis. Do not confuse with historical meanings of Amt. Effectively a sub-district.
- Bezirk: borough (if part of town or city); see also Regierungsbezirk. For Bezirke in the former East Germany leave untranslated. For Austrian Bezirke: district (Bezirke in Austrian administrative structure are only equivalent to Kreise in the German administrative structure. Austrian Bezirke have an average population of 84,613 persons, German Kreise an average population of 190,577).
- Bundesland: federal state (Germany) or province (Austria); see also Land.
- Gemeinde: municipality or parish, centred on a village.
- Gemeindeverband: municipal association.
- Kreis: district.
- Kreisfreie Stadt: urban district. If a distinction needs to be drawn with Stadtkreis, use "town constituting a district in its own right".
- Land: state (Germany) or province (Austria).
- Landkreis: rural district.
- Regierungsbezirk: government region.
- Stadtkreis: urban district.
Rail transport terminology
The following are examples of the main conventions used in rail transport. For further explanation and detail see the link above.
- Railway lines between A and B: Mellrichstadt-Fladungen railway for Bahnstrecke Mellrichstadt-Fladungen
- Named railway lines: Ludwig's Western Railway for Ludwigs Westbahn and Schnaittach Valley Railway for Schnaittachtalbahn.
- Railway stations: Soltau station for Bahnhof Soltau. Central stations, e.g. Bonn Hauptbahnhof, remain untranslated.
Wikipedia does not use the German-language system of hyphenating the subdivisions of municipalities, as this meaning is not intelligible in English, e.g. Spandau, not "Berlin-Spandau". The article explains in the text that this is a place in Berlin. Exception: Bergen-Belsen. However hyphens are retained in town names where the first word is an adjective, e.g. Groß-Gerau, Neu-Ulm, or the town was created by a merger, e.g. Clausthal-Zellerfeld.
German placenames often employ a native disambiguation system where the name of a river or region is added to a town name. These names should be spelled out in full in Wikipedia, because the various German-language abbreviation systems (parentheses, points or forward slashes) are not understood in English, e.g. Linz am Rhein, not "Linz/Rhein" or "Linz (Rhein)", Dillingen an der Donau, not "Dillingen a.d. Donau".
Where disambiguation among like-named places is still needed, specifiers from the native disambiguation system detailed below are used first. If there is no such specifier, the locality names go under [[placename, state]] (the "comma convention", where the name is followed with a comma, a space and the name of the state), as was suggested in the now-inactive project Wikipedia:WikiProject German districts, e.g. Bergen, Lower Saxony to distinguish from Bergen in Norway, Bergen in Hesse and other similarly named places. If there is more than one location within a state, the highest possible administrative division should be used to disambiguate, e.g. Bruckberg, Lower Bavaria and Bruckberg, Middle Franconia.
Where one of the like-named places is a state capital or major urban centre, such as Essen, its name stands alone, while its smaller counterpart is distinguished by a specifier as described above, e.g. Essen, Lower Saxony. Likewise, Wikipedia uses Frankfurt, not Frankfurt am Main, unless discussing German usage (or, perhaps, explicitly disambiguating from Frankfurt an der Oder).
Where disambiguation among entity types is needed, use Wikipedia's parentheses convention, e.g. Braunschweig and Braunschweig (region). For the administrative units Amt, Verbandsgemeinde, Samtgemeinde and Verwaltungsgemeinschaft, use the German term in parentheses if disambiguation is needed, e.g. Hankensbüttel (Samtgemeinde) (vs. Hankensbüttel) and Marne-Land (no disambiguation necessary).
River names are not used in Wikipedia as disambiguating terms in parentheses, since their meaning, especially in the case of minor streams, is not intelligible to English-speaking readers outside Germany.
Disambiguation in German
German place names are disambiguated in three main ways:
- As part of the official name itself often using a river, nearby town, region or state. Examples: Offenbach am Main, Rothenburg ob der Tauber; Neustadt bei Coburg, Bernau bei Berlin; Zell im Fichtelgebirge, Eschenbach in der Oberpfalz; Neustadt in Sachsen.
- In brackets after the name, based on the local district, river[inconsistent], town, region or state. The brackets are often an official part of the name and appear on road signs. Examples: Velden (Pegnitz) (after the River Pegnitz), Kempten (Allgäu) (after the Allgäu region).
- After a forward slash (noting that this is currently deprecated. Brackets may be used instead). Example: Neustadt/Harz (after the Harz mountains).
Footnotes and References
- Dickinson, Robert E. (1964). Germany: A regional and economic geography (2nd ed.). London: Methuen. ASIN B000IOFSEQ.
- Elkins, T.H. (1972). Germany (3rd ed.). London: Chatto & Windus, 1972. ASIN B0011Z9KJA.
- European Commission Directorate-General for Translation (9 April 2014) . Country Compendium: A companion to the English Style Guide (PDF). European Commission. Germany. Retrieved 26 April 2014.
European Commission Directorate-General for Translation (9 April 2014) . English Style Guide: A handbook for authors and translators in the European Commission (PDF) (7th ed.). European Commission. Retrieved 26 April 2014.
- governed by a Bezirksregierung or regional government.