Wikipedia:Wikipedia Takes America/Chicago/User:Taric25-Photos
Original image first on the left, added additional image for Wikipedia:Wikipedia Takes America/Chicago
Not in article space, so I'll ignore. — raekyt 13:06, 12 November 2012 (UTC)
Not in article space, so I'll ignore. — raekyt 13:06, 12 November 2012 (UTC)
Original first image on the left, added additional image
New image isn't used, old image has been properly cropped and skewed to be the right proportions. Both have issues with focus/clarity, old is probably better in color reproduction, so I'd not replace the image. — raekyt 13:06, 12 November 2012 (UTC)
New image isn't used, old image has been properly cropped and skewed to be the right proportions. Both have issues with focus/clarity, old is probably better in color reproduction, so I'd not replace the image. — raekyt 13:06, 12 November 2012 (UTC)
Original first image on the left, added additional images for Ford Center for the Performing Arts Oriental Theatre
Since no replacements was done no real need to review. But I'd not the picture of the facade is good, it adds to the article, but I think the second image showing most of the building doesn't add anything and isn't as good of an angle as the original and should probably be removed. — raekyt 13:06, 12 November 2012 (UTC)
Since no replacements was done no real need to review. But I'd not the picture of the facade is good, it adds to the article, but I think the second image showing most of the building doesn't add anything and isn't as good of an angle as the original and should probably be removed. — raekyt 13:06, 12 November 2012 (UTC)
Original first image on the left, added additional images for Belmont-Sheffield Trust and Savings Bank Building
The original picture is bad, should consider replacing with something else. The image of the plaque is probably a copyright violation, should consider deleting it (images of things with lots of verbiage like plaques is a copyright violation if the text is copyrighted), the source to your twitter feed for the images was removed, inappropriate and not a WP:RS, the image with the sun-flare was removed as being unhelpful to the article. — raekyt 13:06, 12 November 2012 (UTC)
The original picture is bad, should consider replacing with something else. The image of the plaque is probably a copyright violation, should consider deleting it (images of things with lots of verbiage like plaques is a copyright violation if the text is copyrighted), the source to your twitter feed for the images was removed, inappropriate and not a WP:RS, the image with the sun-flare was removed as being unhelpful to the article. — raekyt 13:06, 12 November 2012 (UTC)
I created the brand new article Meekerville Historic District, all by myself, and I added all the photos I took.
Again removed a reference to your twitter feed, is this a regular thing you do if so it needs addressed.... Page has far to many images per our WP:MOS for images consider removing all but 1 or MAYBE 2 images. Two images on a stub is probabably too many. WP:NOTGALLERY — raekyt 13:06, 12 November 2012 (UTC)
Again removed a reference to your twitter feed, is this a regular thing you do if so it needs addressed.... Page has far to many images per our WP:MOS for images consider removing all but 1 or MAYBE 2 images. Two images on a stub is probabably too many. WP:NOTGALLERY — raekyt 13:06, 12 November 2012 (UTC)
I also created the brand new article Lakeview Historic District (Chicago, Illinois), all by myself, and its infobox image is the one I took. Also, at National Register of Historic Places listings in North Side Chicago, replaced left image with right image for Lakeview Historic District.
Removed the twitter link again, also another WP:NOTGALLERY but not as bad, consider removing some images. As for the replacement in the list, I don't know much about the area, so as long as the new image is the correct area, then it's probably an ok replacement, new image at least shows some older buildings which I think is more appropriate for a historical district then what looks like a new shopping center in the old image. — raekyt 13:06, 12 November 2012 (UTC)
Removed the twitter link again, also another WP:NOTGALLERY but not as bad, consider removing some images. As for the replacement in the list, I don't know much about the area, so as long as the new image is the correct area, then it's probably an ok replacement, new image at least shows some older buildings which I think is more appropriate for a historical district then what looks like a new shopping center in the old image. — raekyt 13:06, 12 November 2012 (UTC)
At National Register of Historic Places listings in North Side Chicago, replaced left image with right image for Meekerville Historic District.
Probably a good replacement. — raekyt 13:06, 12 November 2012 (UTC)
Probably a good replacement. — raekyt 13:06, 12 November 2012 (UTC)
_by_Taric_Alani.jpg)
Original image first on the left, added additional image for State/Lake (CTA station)
I don't think the new image adds anything to the article, which is short as it is, and probably doesn't need the second image. — raekyt 13:06, 12 November 2012 (UTC)
I don't think the new image adds anything to the article, which is short as it is, and probably doesn't need the second image. — raekyt 13:06, 12 November 2012 (UTC)
_by_Taric_Alani.jpg)
Superseded image first on the left with additional image for Randolph/Wabash (CTA station). In my humble opinion, the photo I took is of much higher quality than the one another Wikipedian found on Flickr.
The new image is better than old for showing that part of the structure, but still more ideal would be actually being lined up with the structure but that would mean standing in the street and getting run over by the insane taxi drivers, but would be a better picture, lol. Don't know why you kept the old version on the page too, it's too small of an article for three pictures. And again you put your twitter as a reference, why? — raekyt 13:06, 12 November 2012 (UTC)
The new image is better than old for showing that part of the structure, but still more ideal would be actually being lined up with the structure but that would mean standing in the street and getting run over by the insane taxi drivers, but would be a better picture, lol. Don't know why you kept the old version on the page too, it's too small of an article for three pictures. And again you put your twitter as a reference, why? — raekyt 13:06, 12 November 2012 (UTC)
_south_entrance_by_Taric_Alani.jpg)
_north_exit_by_Taric_Alani.jpg)
Original first image on the left, added additional images for Belmont (CTA North Side Main Line station)
Way to over-illustrated, it could probably stand to loose the last 3 images that are stacked up on the right, and even then it would be too much. New images hurts article because of that. So I removed them. Again you put your twitter as a ref in the image captions here? This is probably a huge issue that will need addressed if you've done this in the past, will need to do a check. — raekyt 13:06, 12 November 2012 (UTC)
Way to over-illustrated, it could probably stand to loose the last 3 images that are stacked up on the right, and even then it would be too much. New images hurts article because of that. So I removed them. Again you put your twitter as a ref in the image captions here? This is probably a huge issue that will need addressed if you've done this in the past, will need to do a check. — raekyt 13:06, 12 November 2012 (UTC)
_by_Taric_Alani.jpg)
Original first image on the left, added additional image for Lake/State (CTA station)
Also over illustrated so I removed all the images but the one in the infobox per WP:NOTGALLERY, also noted the twitter source here too. — raekyt 13:06, 12 November 2012 (UTC)
Also over illustrated so I removed all the images but the one in the infobox per WP:NOTGALLERY, also noted the twitter source here too. — raekyt 13:06, 12 November 2012 (UTC)