The Tribe have never qualified for the College World Series but have previously played in three NCAA tournaments in 1983, 2001 and 2013. The Tribe's combined NCAA tournament record is 2–6 (.250). They have won six conference championships with the most recent coming in 2001. The team has an all-time record of 1,359–1,519–12 (.472) over 119 season of play.
The William & Mary Tribe men's baseball team currently plays at off-campus Plumeri Park which opened in 2001 and has a seating capacity of 1,000. The stadium is named after William & Mary alumnus Joseph J. Plumeri II who also played on the baseball team as member of the Class of 1966. Previously, the baseball team played on campus on a field located next to Zable Stadium on land currently occupied by practice fields for the football team as part of the Jimmye Laycock Football Center.