William Bateson

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search
This article is about geneticist. For for his son the anthropologist and cyberneticist, see Gregory Bateson.
William Bateson
William Bateson
Born 8 August 1861
Whitby, Yorkshire[1]
Died 8 February 1926(1926-02-08) (aged 64)
Nationality British
Fields genetics
Alma mater St. John's College, Cambridge
Known for heredity and biological inheritance
Notable awards Royal Medal (1920)

William Bateson (8 August 1861 – 8 February 1926) was an English biologist who was the first person to use the term genetics to describe the study of heredity, and the chief populariser of the ideas of Gregor Mendel following their rediscovery in 1900 by Hugo de Vries and Carl Correns.


Crayon drawing by D.G. Lillie, 1909.

Bateson was born in Whitby on the Yorkshire coast, the son of William Henry Bateson, Master of St John's College, Cambridge. He was educated at Rugby School and at St John's College in Cambridge, where he graduated BA in 1883 with a first in natural sciences.[2]

Taking up embryology, he went to the United States to investigate the development of Balanoglossus. This worm-like enteropneust hemichordate led to his interest in vertebrate origins. In 1883-4 he worked in the laboratory of William Keith Brooks, at the Chesapeake Zoölogical Laboratory in Hampton VA, U.S.A.[3] Turning from morphology to study evolution and its methods, he returned to England and became a Fellow of St John's. Studying variation and heredity, he travelled in western Central Asia.

Work on biological variation (to 1900)[edit]

Bateson's work published before 1900 systematically studied the structural variation displayed by living organisms and the light this might shed on the mechanism of biological evolution,[4] and was strongly influenced by both Charles Darwin's approach to the collection of comprehensive examples, and Francis Galton's quantitative ("biometric") methods. In his first significant contribution,[5] he shows that some biological characteristics (such as the length of forceps in earwigs) are not distributed continuously, with a normal distribution, but discontinuously (or "dimorphically"). He saw the persistence of two forms in one population as a challenge to the then current conceptions of the mechanism of heredity, and says "The question may be asked, does the dimorphism of which cases have now been given represent the beginning of a division into two species?”

In his 1894 book, "Materials for the study of variation",[6] Bateson took this survey of biological variation significantly further. He was concerned to show that biological variation exists both continuously, for some characters, and discontinuously for others, and coined the terms "meristic" and "substantive" for the two types. In common with Darwin, he felt that quantitative characters could not easily be "perfected" by the selective force of evolution, because of the perceived problem of the "swamping effect of intercrossing", but proposed that discontinuously varying characters could. Amongst other interesting observations he noted variations in which an expected body-part has been replaced by another (which he called homeotic). The animal variations he studied included bees with legs instead of antennae; crayfish with extra oviducts; and in humans, polydactyly, extra ribs, and males with extra nipples. Importantly, Bateson wrote, "The only way in which we may hope to get at the truth [concerning the mechanism of biological Heredity] is by the organization of systematic experiments in breeding, a class of research that calls perhaps for more patience and more resources than any other form of biological enquiry. Sooner or later such an investigation will be undertaken and then we shall begin to know."

In 1897 he reported some significant conceptual and methodological advances in his study of variation.[7] “I have argued that variations of a discontinuous nature may play a prepondering part in the constitution of a new species.” He attempts to silence his critics (the "biometricians") who misconstrue his definition of discontinuity of variation by clarification of his terms: "a variation is discontinuous if, when all the individuals of a population are breeding freely together, there is not simple regression to one mean form, but a sensible preponderance of the variety over the intermediates… The essential feature of a discontinuous variation is therefore that, be the cause what it may, there is not complete blending between variety and type. The variety persists and is not “swamped by intercrossing”. But critically, he begins to report a series of breeding experiments, conducted by his pupil, Miss E.R. Saunders, using the alpine brassica Biscutella laevigata in the Cambridge botanic gardens. In the wild, hairy and smooth forms of otherwise identical plants are seen together. They intercrossed the forms experimentally, “When therefore the well-grown mongrel plants are examined, they present just the same appearance of discontinuity which the wild plants at the Tosa Falls do. This discontinuity is, therefore, the outward sign of the fact that in heredity the two characters of smoothness and hairiness do not completely blend, and the offspring do not regress to one mean form, but to two distinct forms.”

At about this time, Hugo de Vries and Carl Erich Correns began similar plant-breeding experiments. But, unlike Bateson, they were familiar with the extensive plant breeding experiments of Gregor Mendel in the 1860s, and they did not cite Bateson's work. Critically, Bateson gave a lecture to the Royal Horticultural Society in July 1899,[8] which was attended by Hugo de Vries, in which he describes his investigations into discontinuous variation, his experimental crosses, and the significance of such studies for the understanding of Heredity. He urges his colleagues to conduct large-scale, well-designed and statistically analysed experiments of the sort that, although he did not know it, Mendel had already conducted, and which would be "rediscovered" by de Vries and Correns just six months later.

Founding the discipline of genetics[edit]

Bateson became famous as the outspoken Mendelian antagonist of Walter Raphael Weldon, his former teacher, and of Karl Pearson who led the biometric school of thinking. The debate centred on saltationism versus gradualism (Darwin had represented gradualism, but Bateson was a saltationist).[9] Later, Ronald Fisher and J.B.S. Haldane showed that discrete mutations were compatible with gradual evolution: see the modern evolutionary synthesis.

Between 1900 and 1910 Bateson directed a rather informal "school" of genetics at Cambridge. His group consisted mostly of women associated with Newnham College, Cambridge, and included both his wife Beatrice, and her sister Florence Durham.[10][11] They provided assistance for his research program at a time when Mendelism was not yet recognized as a legitimate field of study. The women, such as Muriel Wheldale (later Onslow), carried out a series of breeding experiments in various plant and animal species between 1902 and 1910. The results both supported and extended Mendel's laws of heredity. Hilda Blanche Killby, who had finished her studies with the Newnham College Mendelians in 1901, aided Bateson replicate Mendel's crosses in peas. She conducted independent breeding experiments in rabbits and bantam fowl, as well. [12]

Bateson first suggested using the word "genetics" (from the Greek gennō, γεννώ; "to give birth") to describe the study of inheritance and the science of variation in a personal letter to Alan Sedgwick (not the Adam Sedgwick (1785-1873) who had been Darwin's professor), dated 18 April 1905. Bateson first used the term "genetics" publicly at the Third International Conference on Plant Hybridization in London in 1906.[13] Although this was three years before Wilhelm Johannsen used the word "gene" to describe the units of hereditary information, De Vries had introduced the word "pangene" for the same concept already in 1889, and etymologically the word genetics has parallels with Darwin's concept of pangenesis. Bateson and Edith Saunders also coined the word "allelomorph" ("other form"), which was later shortened to allele.[14]

Bateson co-discovered genetic linkage with Reginald Punnett and Edith Saunders, and he and Punnett founded the Journal of Genetics in 1910. Bateson also coined the term "epistasis" to describe the genetic interaction of two independent traits.

Other biographical information[edit]

William Bateson became director of the John Innes Horticultural Institution in 1910 and moved with his family to Merton Park in Surrey. He was director there until his sudden death in February 1926. During his time at the John Innes Horticultural Institution he became interested in the chromosome theory of heredity and promoted the study of cytology by the appointment of WCF(Frank)Newton and in 1923 Cyril Dean Darlington.[15]

In his later years he was a friend and confidant of the German Erwin Baur. Their correspondence includes their discussion of eugenics.

His son was the anthropologist and cyberneticist Gregory Bateson.

In June 1894 he was elected a Fellow of the Royal Society[16] and won their Darwin Medal in 1904 and their Royal Medal in 1920. He also delivered their Croonian lecture in 1920. He was the president of the British Association in 1913–1914.[17] He founded The Genetics Society in 1919, one of the first learned societies dedicated to Genetics.[18] The John Innes Centre holds a Bateson Lecture in his honour at the annual John Innes Symposium.[19]

He was an atheist.[20][21][22]


See also[edit]


  1. ^ "William Bateson". Encyclopædia Britannica Online.
  2. ^ "Bateson, William (BT879)". A Cambridge Alumni Database. University of Cambridge. 
  3. ^ Johns Hopkins University Circular Nov.(1883) vol III. no 27.pg 4.
  4. ^ Scientific papers of William Bateson. RC Punnett (Ed) : Cambridge University Press 1928 Vol 1
  5. ^ Some cases of variation in secondary sexual characters statistically examined, Proc Zool Soc 1892
  6. ^ Materials for the study of variation, treated with especial regard to discontinuity in the origin of species William Bateson 1861-1926. London : Macmillan 1894 xv, 598 p
  7. ^ Progress in the study of variation I. Science Progress I, 1897
  8. ^ Bateson, W. (1900) “Hybridisation and Cross-Breeding as a Method of Scientific Investigation” J. RHS (1900) 24: 59 – 66, a report of a lecture given at the RHS Hybrid Conference in 1899. Full text:
  9. ^ Gillham, Nicholas W. (2001). Evolution by Jumps: Francis Galton and William Bateson and the Mechanism of Evolutionary Change. Genetics 159: 1383-1392.
  10. ^ Richmond, Marsha L. (2006). "The 'Domestication' of Heredity: The Familial Organization of Geneticists at Cambridge University, 1895–1910". Journal of the History of Biology. Springer. 39 (3): 565–605. doi:10.1007/s10739-004-5431-7. JSTOR 4332033. 
  11. ^ "Bateson Family Papers". American Philosophical Society. Retrieved 4 October 2013. 
  12. ^ Richmond ML (March 2001). "Women in the early history of genetics. William Bateson and the Newnham College Mendelians, 1900-1910". Isis. 92 (1): 69. doi:10.1086/385040. PMID 11441497. 
  13. ^ Gordon M. Shepherd (2010). "Mendel’s proposal that heredity is the outcome of 'independent factors' led William Bateson in England in 1906 to suggest the term 'genetics' as a specific biological term for the study of the rules of heredity. Following Bateson, Wilhelm Johannsen in Denmark in 1909 proposed the term 'gene' for the 'independent factors', as well as 'genotype' for the combination of genes in an individual and 'phenotype'" (Creating modern neuroscience, p. 17).
  14. ^ Craft, Jude (2013). "Genes and genetics: the language of scientific discovery". Genes and genetics. Oxford English Dictionary. Retrieved 2016-01-14. 
  15. ^ "A Brief History of the John Innes Centre". jic.ac.uk. Retrieved 21 October 2015. 
  16. ^ "Library and Archive Catalogue". Royal Society. Retrieved 11 December 2010. 
  17. ^ "Report of the British Association for the Advancement of Science". archive.org. Retrieved 21 October 2015. 
  18. ^ "Genetics Society Website > About > About the Society". genetics.org.uk. Retrieved 21 October 2015. 
  19. ^ "The Bateson Lecture". John Innes Centre. Retrieved September 23, 2013. 
  20. ^ "William Bateson was a very militant atheist and a very bitter man, I fancy. Knowing that I was interested in biology, they invited me when I was still a school girl to go down and see the experimental garden. I remarked to him what I thought then, and still think, that doing research must be the most wonderful thing in the world and he snapped at me that it wasn’t wonderful at all, it was tedious, disheartening, annoying and anyhow you didn’t need an experimental garden to do research." Interview with Dr. Cecilia Gaposchkin by Owen Gingerich, March 5, 1968.
  21. ^ https://books.google.com/books?id=-6PhO7Og2fYC&pg=PA13&lpg=PA13&dq=william+bateson+atheist&source=bl&ots=hvcGPHESSZ&sig=92fJ5xhg-e0EcDFq0SFm_JlVIcI&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwiXqPjHm5DOAhWFVyYKHSJQAA4Q6AEIIjAB#v=onepage&q=william%20bateson%20atheist&f=false
  22. ^ https://books.google.com/books?id=FDUi1xg26gsC&pg=PR20&lpg=PR20&dq=william+bateson+atheist&source=bl&ots=gmcz2sWKZo&sig=AsiPuLOZA1VHo9TOCpG5DitjuGw&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwiXqPjHm5DOAhWFVyYKHSJQAA4Q6AEIHjAA#v=onepage&q=william%20bateson%20atheist&f=false


External links[edit]