William Morva

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to navigation Jump to search
William Morva
William Morva (mugshot).jpg
Born William Charles Morva
(1982-02-09)February 9, 1982
Midlothian, Virginia, U.S.
Died July 6, 2017(2017-07-06) (aged 35)
Jarratt, Virginia, U.S.
Criminal penalty Death (June 23, 2008)
Details
Victims Eric Sutphin
Derrick McFarland
Date August 20-21, 2006

William Charles Morva (February 9, 1982 – July 6, 2017) was a Hungarian-American convicted of the two 2006 shooting deaths of Sheriff's Deputy Cpl. Eric Sutphin and hospital security guard Derrick McFarland in the town of Blacksburg, Virginia. The shooting deaths occurred near the university campus of Virginia Tech while he awaited trial for attempted armed robbery. A jury sentenced him to death on June 23, 2008, but some doctors stated that he suffered from a serious mental illness,[1] a delusional disorder that caused him to kill.[2][3] Judge Ray Grubbs initially set the execution date for October 21, 2008. On June 4, 2009, an appeal for William Morva was made to the Virginia Supreme Court. However, the capital murder conviction and death sentence were confirmed on September 18, 2009.[4]

The United States Supreme Court declined to review the case in February 2017.[5] Subsequently, Judge Robert Turk set the execution date for July 6, 2017.[6]

On June 20, 2017, Morva's lawyers, on his behalf, filed a request for clemency with Virginia Governor Terry McAuliffe. They requested that Governor McAuliffe, in light of evidence concerning Morva's true mental state, commute his sentence from death to life in prison without the possibility of parole.[7][8] They also urged the governor to ensure that Morva receive treatment with anti-psychotic drugs. Since Morva's lawyers filed his clemency petition, several local and international groups, as well 28 Virginia lawmakers called on Governor McAuliffe to halt the execution of Morva.[9]

The daughter of sheriff's deputy Sutphin, one of the two men slain by Morva, expressed her support for his clemency petition and asked the governor to spare his life.[10]

Despite the efforts of Morva's lawyers, and many supporters locally and internationally, Governor McAuliffe, a Democrat, declined to grant Morva's clemency.[11][12] Morva was being held at the Greensville Correctional Center, in Jarratt, Virginia.[13]

Morva's lawyers released a statement on the governor's decision. They stated that, although Morva lost his battle for clemency, "they hope by improving access to proper evaluation and treatment for persons living with severe mental illness, we can avoid future tragedies."[14] Morva was executed by the Commonwealth of Virginia and pronounced dead at 9:15 pm on July 6, 2017. He had no last words.[15]

The drug cocktail used for the execution was "a controversial lethal injection formula that may have subjected the last prisoner to be executed by the state to an excruciating death equivalent to drowning."[16] The last prisoner to be executed in Virginia using this drug cocktail was Ricky Gray, who was executed in January 2017.[17]

Early years[edit]

William Morva lived near Midlothian, Virginia until his father, Charles, retired and moved the family to Blacksburg. Charles Morva worked as a substitute teacher at Blacksburg High School and barista at a local coffee shop until moving back to the Richmond area with his wife Elizabeth.[18]

Christina Garnder, who attended high school with Morva, reported that he had a difficult relationship with his father. In 2000, he dropped out of high school and subsequently became a fixture in the Virginia Tech Community.[19]

In April 2004, Charles Morva died of cancer. His son's friends believe he did not know how to deal with the death of his father and observed a spiraling decline in his behavior. Before his initial arrest in 2005, William had earned a reputation as a drifter without a fixed permanent address. A self-professed survivalist, he was almost always without shoes, ate only raw meat, berries and pine cones, and spoke of spending nights in the woods around Blacksburg. Many who knew him began questioning his mental state.[20]

Blacksburg shootings[edit]

On August 18, 2005, William and another young man, both armed and wearing masks, approached the Blacksburg Deli Mart but left because the store was closed and locked. The clerk, still inside, phoned the police. The Blacksburg police later that night arrested William for attempted armed robbery.[21]

While in jail awaiting trial, William was taken to Montgomery Regional Hospital on August 20, 2006 for a sprained ankle and wrist. After using a hospital bathroom, he knocked deputy Russell Quesenberry[22] unconscious using a metal toilet-paper container. He took the deputy's gun and shot Derrick McFarland, a hospital security guard who was running to the deputy's aid. McFarland died from his wounds.[23][24]

Police at Virginia Tech in Blacksburg, Virginia, responding to a report of William Charles Morva being seen in the area.

This initiated a manhunt for Morva, who on the morning of August 21, 2006, shot and killed Montgomery County sheriff's deputy Cpl. Eric Sutphin on the Huckleberry Trail near the Virginia Tech Campus. Sutphin had been an officer for 13 years and had survived a prior shooting in May 2003, which killed officer Scott Hylton, leading Sutphin to quit the police force. Sutphin returned, however, after just six months away despite making much more money as a modular home salesman. He was survived by his wife Tamara and his nine-year-old twin daughters.[25]

Virginia Tech canceled classes and closed campus.[26] At 3:36 p.m. EDT August 21, 2006, Morva was captured and taken into custody. He was found hiding in a briar patch about 150 yards from where Sutphin was fatally shot.[citation needed]

Legal proceedings[edit]

On August 29, 2006, Commonwealth's Attorney Brad Finch announced that William Morva would be charged with capital murder and use of a firearm in the shooting death of McFarland. A second capital murder charge would be sought in the shooting death of Sutphin, to be decided on at the grand jury meeting on October 10, 2006. Finch also stated that he would seek the death penalty for Morva.[27]

Morva’s defense attorney requested a change of the trial location for Morva’s original robbery charges. The trial was to be held at Montgomery County Circuit Court, but Morva's attorneys argued it would be impossible to find an impartial jury in Montgomery County due to the publicity Morva received since his escape and the subsequent murders. Morva's attorney is quoted as saying, “I don’t think there (have) been this many cases that have gotten nearly as much attention.” [28]

Morva's trial hearings began September 17, 2007, in Montgomery County for two counts of capital murder and one count of attempting to commit murder with a firearm. On September 20, Judge Ray Grubbs ruled, following a jury selection process in which 45 prospective jurors were dismissed for cause, that the trial could not be held in Montgomery County.[29]

On March 13, 2008 Morva was sentenced to death in an Abingdon, Virginia court.[30] He made an appeal in June 2009 to the Supreme Court of Virginia.[31] On September 18, 2009, the Supreme Court of Virginia affirmed Morva's convictions and death sentences in a 5-2 decision.[32] The Virginia Supreme Court rejected the defense's claim that he should have been allowed to present an expert's testimony on whether he would endanger guards or fellow inmates if the jury sentenced him to life in prison without parole.[33]

On July 24, he was called to appear in Christiansburg by video conferencing to testify for the defense in a trial for his brother Michael Morva, who is charged with helping him escape from the Montgomery County Jail nearly three years before.[34] This trial was delayed, and William Morva was expected to testify in a later trial. In October 2010, the U.S. Supreme Court denied Morva's appeal.[35]

On April 12, 2013, the Supreme Court of Virginia issued a published order dismissing Morva's petition for habeas corpus that challenged his convictions for capital murder. The court's opinion was handed on April 18, 2013.[36]

On April 15, 2015, U.S. District Judge Michael Urbanski dismissed Morva’s federal appeal.[37]

On May 5, 2016, a federal appeals court rejected another appeal of Morva's.[38]

On February 21, 2017, The United States Supreme Court rejected to hear the appeal.[39]

On May 9, 2017, as per a request by Virginia Attorney General Mark Herring four days prior, Morva's execution date was set for Thursday, July 6, 2017.[citation needed]

On June 20, 2017, Morva's lawyers filed his clemency request with Virginia Governor Terry McAuliffe. They petitioned the governor to commute William's sentence from death to life in prison without the possibility of parole and to start treating him with antipsychotic drugs.[citation needed]

Representatives from both Hungary and the European Union have met with and sent letters urging Governor McAuliffe to stop the execution of William Morva, a severely mentally ill man.[40]

On June 27, 2017, the National Alliance on Mental Illness (NAMI) wrote a letter to Governor McAuliffe asking him to stop the execution of a clearly mentally ill man. NAMI highlighted the fact that William suffered from a long-standing mental illness that was initially misdiagnosed and that the jury did not hear that William's delusions led to his crimes.[41]

On June 28, 2017, Linda A. Klein, the president of the American Bar Association (ABA), wrote to Governor McAuliffe to express concern over the scheduled execution of William Morva, a mentally ill man. She asked the governor to fully review evidence of William's delusions at the time he committed the crimes until the present.[42]

On June 29, 2017, advocacy groups presented petition signatures of over 31,000 persons to Governor McAuliffe's office, urging him to grant clemency to William Morva. The signatures were collected by the ACLU, Amnesty International, NAMI, Mental Health America in Virginia, the Virginia Council of Churches, and Virginians for Alternatives to the Death Penalty. Bill Farrar with the ACLU of Virginia expressed the view that "severe mental illness should not be a death sentence."[43]

On July 3, 2017, Virginia delegate Mark Levine wrote that the execution of William Morva would be a grave injustice. Levine noted that during William's half-day sentencing hearing, unusually short for a capital case, the jury was not informed of William's true mental state or of the fact that he had delusions. In fact, the jury was told that William did not suffer from delusions. Levine stressed that the jury had a right to know the full truth when deciding to give the death penalty.[44]

Delegate Levine, along with 27 other Virginia lawmakers, asked Governor McAuliffe to grant clemency for William Morva. State lawmakers include 17 delegates: Del. Charniele Herring, Del. Jennifer Boysko, Del. Patrick A. Hope, Del. Sam Rasoul, Del. Marcus B. Simon, and Del. Eileen Filler-Corn, Del. Lamont Bagby, Del. Rob Bell, Del. Jeff Bourne, Del. Paul Krizek, Del. Joseph C. Lindsey, Del. Kenneth R. Plum, Del. Mark D. Sickles, Del. Marcus Simon, Del. Rip Sullivan, Del. Jeion Ward, and Del. Vivian E. Watts; five (5) senators: Sen. Adam Ebbin, Sen. Barbara Favola, Sen. Lionell Spruill, Sr., Sen. Mamie E. Locke and Sen. Scott Surovell, Minority Whip Alfonso Lopez, and House Democratic leader David Toscano all joined this call for clemency.[45] Members of Congress also voiced their support for clemency, including representatives Bobby Scott, Gerald "Gerry" Connolly and Don Beyer.[46]

On July 5, 2017, two rights experts from the United Nations urged McAuliffe to halt the execution of a man with a psychosocial disability.[47] The same day, Rachel Sutphin, the daughter of sheriff's deputy Eric Sutphin, one of the two men slain by William Morva, also expressed her support for his clemency petition. She asked Governor Terry McAuliffe to spare his life.[48][49]

Mental illness[edit]

Morva's mental decline initially was attributed to schizotypal personality disorder; he was diagnosed with the disorder following his arrest.[50] As a result of this diagnosis, the jurors who sentenced him to death were told that he merely had odd beliefs and attitudes.[51]

A fuller evaluation conducted later during his appeal determined that the diagnosis of schizotypal personality disorder was incorrect and that Morva suffered from delusional disorder, which left him unable to tell reality from delusion.[52][53]

According to some, Morva's case raises ethical questions about executing those with serious mental illnesses.[54][55]

The ethical questions raised surrounding the execution of mentally ill persons is not a new issue in Virginia. In the past, governors have halted executions for mental health concerns. In 2008, Governor Tim Kaine commuted Percy Levar Walton's death sentence amid concerns about his competency. A decade earlier, Governor Jim Gilmore spared the life of Calvin Eugene Swann, who suffered from schizophrenia.[56]

Related incident[edit]

Morva's brother, Michael Morva, was charged with conspiring to help his brother escape. The alleged conspiracy occurred in January 2006, when both brothers were in jail on charges related to the attempted robbery. Michael denied any connection with Morva's escape on August 2006 from police custody, but was convicted on August 3, 2010, and sentenced to three years in prison.[57]

At Michael Morva's sentencing in 2010, jurors asked the judge to recommend he receive mental health treatment. Both Morva brothers were diagnosed with delusional disorder, which has a genetic component. Michael Morva received treatment for his mental illness in prison and was released on May 27, 2016 after serving his sentence.[58]

See also[edit]

References[edit]

  1. ^ "Serious Mental Illness (SMI) Among U.S. Adults". Nimh.nih.gov. Retrieved July 9, 2017. 
  2. ^ Hausman, Sandy. "State to Execute Morva Despite Serious Mental Illness". WVTF Public Radio. NPR/BBC/Music. Retrieved June 8, 2017. 
  3. ^ Board, Editorial; Board, Editorial (2017-06-29). "Virginia's governor still has time to save a mentally ill man from execution". The Washington Post. ISSN 0190-8286. Retrieved 2017-07-10. 
  4. ^ "Morva v. Commonwealth". FindLaw for Legal Professionals. FindLaw, a Thomson Reuters business. Archived from the original on November 5, 2012. Retrieved August 26, 2017. 
  5. ^ Sturgeon, Jeff (February 21, 2017). "U.S. Supreme Court declines to hear appeal of William Morva, who killed 2 in Blacksburg". The Roanoke Times. The Roanoke Times. Newspaper. Retrieved June 8, 2017. 
  6. ^ Gangloff, Mike (9 May 2017). "Morva execution set for July 6". The Roanoke Times. The Roanoke Times. Regional Newspaper. Retrieved June 8, 2017. 
  7. ^ Durkin Richer, Alanna. "Attorneys: Morva needs mental health treatment, not execution". Richmond Times Dispatcher (June 20, 2017). Associated Press. Retrieved June 22, 2017. 
  8. ^ Hausman, Sandy. "State to Execute Morva Despite Serious Mental Illness". WVTF Public Radio. IQ Radio/NPR/BBC. Retrieved June 8, 2017. 
  9. ^ "Pressure grows for governor to stop execution of William Morva". WTVR.com. July 5, 2017. Retrieved July 9, 2017. 
  10. ^ "Daughter of slain sheriff's deputy asks Va. governor to stop execution of her father's killer". Washington Post. Retrieved July 9, 2017. 
  11. ^ Earley, Pete (July 7, 2017). "Virginia Gov. Okays Tonight's Execution of Prisoner With Severe Mental Illness Despite Pleas: But Claims To Be Mental Health Advocate". Pete Earley. Retrieved July 9, 2017. 
  12. ^ Balko, Radley; Balko, Radley (July 7, 2017). "William Morva killed two men. His execution shows no death penalty case is easy". The Washington Post. ISSN 0190-8286. Retrieved July 9, 2017. 
  13. ^ Dashiell, Joe. "Governor McAuliffe says he will not stop William Morva execution". Retrieved July 7, 2017. 
  14. ^ Spivey, Stacey (July 6, 2017). "Governor McAullife denies clemency for convicted killer". virginiafirst.com. Retrieved July 6, 2017. 
  15. ^ "The Latest: Virginia executes inmate for killing 2 in 2006". Washington Post. Retrieved July 7, 2017. 
  16. ^ Pilkington, Ed (July 5, 2017). "Virginia set to execute man using 'potentially torturous' drug cocktail". The Guardian. ISSN 0261-3077. Retrieved July 9, 2017. 
  17. ^ CNN, Azadeh Ansari and Tony Marco. "Virginia executes convicted family killer Ricky Gray". CNN. Retrieved July 9, 2017. 
  18. ^ Alvis-Banks, Donna (August 21, 2006). "Shooting suspect called 'wanderer'". The Roanoke Times. The Roanoke Times. Newspaper. Retrieved July 9, 2017. 
  19. ^ Shear, Michael D. (August 23, 2006). "Suspect Was Legend In Va. Tech Community". The Washington Post. The Washington Post. Newspaper. Retrieved July 9, 2017. 
  20. ^ Segura2017-06-28T01:08:31+00:00, Liliana SeguraLiliana. "Will Virginia Execute a Man Whose Crimes Were Driven by Delusions?". The Intercept. Retrieved 2017-07-10. 
  21. ^ Eaton, Joe. "2 men arrested in Blacksburg robbery attempt". The Roanoke Times (August 18, 2005). Retrieved July 9, 2017. 
  22. ^ [1]
  23. ^ "Details released on Morva's flight, more news on the aftermath of a deadly escape and manhunt", The Roanoke Times, August 22, 2006; retrieved August 22, 2006.
  24. ^ Thornton, Tim. "'He was the heart of our family'", The Roanoke Times; retrieved August 23, 2006.
  25. ^ "Va. had given slain deputy valor medal in 2003". Archived from the original on February 19, 2014. 
  26. ^ "Virginia Tech News". Web.archive.org. Archived from the original on August 25, 2006. Retrieved July 9, 2017. 
  27. ^ Morission, Shawna. "Death penalty will be sought for Morva, prosecutor says". The Roanoke Times (August 29, 2006). THe Roanoke Times. Newspaper. Retrieved June 9, 2017. 
  28. ^ Reinerurg, Katie (December 6, 2006). "Defense blames publicity in attempt to move Morva trial". Collegiate Times. Collegiate Times. Newspaper. Retrieved June 9, 2017. 
  29. ^ "Morva trial moved out of Montgomery Co". WDBJ. September 20, 2007. Archived from the original on March 19, 2008. Retrieved July 9, 2017. 
  30. ^ Lindsey, Sue (March 13, 2008). "Death Verdict for Escapee Who Killed 2". Associated Press. Archived from the original on March 17, 2008. Retrieved March 14, 2008. 
  31. ^ "Morva appeals death penalty to Virginia courts". Collegiate Times. June 10, 2009. Retrieved July 1, 2009. 
  32. ^ "PRESENT: All the Justices" (PDF). Courts.state.va.us. Retrieved 2017-07-09. 
  33. ^ "Va. high court upholds Morva death sentences". Roanoke Times. Archived from the original on September 13, 2012. Retrieved July 9, 2017. 
  34. ^ "William Morva may testify at brother's trial". The Roanoke Times. June 24, 2009. Archived from the original on September 8, 2012. Retrieved July 9, 2017. 
  35. ^ "Va. death sentence appeal denied". The Washington Post. Retrieved July 9, 2017. 
  36. ^ Powell, Melissa (April 19, 2013). "High court upholds Morva's convictions". The Roanoke Times. Retrieved May 8, 2016. 
  37. ^ Sturgeon, Jeff (May 7, 2015). "Appeal rejected, convicted killer Morva prepares next appeal". The Roanoke Times. Retrieved May 8, 2016. 
  38. ^ "4th Circuit Rejects Virginia Death Row Inmate's Appeal". ABC News. May 5, 2016. Retrieved May 8, 2016. 
  39. ^ "Supreme Court rejects appeal from Virginia death row inmate". Washington's top news. February 21, 2017. Retrieved February 21, 2017. 
  40. ^ Staff, WSLS10. "European Union trying to block William Morva execution". WSLS10 (June 23, 2017). Retrieved June 23, 2017. 
  41. ^ Earley, Pete (2017-06-28). "NAMI Joins Campaign To Stop Virginia Execution: "False stereotypes may have played a critical role in Mr. Morva's death sentence"". Pete Earley. Retrieved 2017-07-04. 
  42. ^ "ABA letter to Virginia Gov. McAuliffe asks for consideration of death row inmate Morva's petition". americanbar.org. Retrieved July 5, 2017. 
  43. ^ Green, Frank. "Advocates deliver 31,000 petition signatures to Gov. McAuliffe urging clemency for death row inmate Morva". Richmond Times Dispatcher. Retrieved July 4, 2017. 
  44. ^ lowkell (July 3, 2017). "Del. Mark Levine: "I do not believe [William Morva] should die because of a lack of due process" - Blue Virginia". Blue Virginia. Retrieved July 9, 2017. 
  45. ^ "Democratic lawmakers ask McAuliffe to commute sentence of convicted killer". Washington Post. Retrieved July 9, 2017. 
  46. ^ lowkell (July 6, 2017). "With Hours to Go, Who Has Called for a Halt to William Morva Execution? - Blue Virginia". Blue Virginia. Retrieved July 9, 2017. 
  47. ^ "UN rights experts urge the Governor of Virginia to halt execution of man with psychosocial disability". www.ohchr.org. Retrieved July 9, 2017. 
  48. ^ Times-Dispatch, Frank Green, Richmond. "Daughter of one of Morva's victims seeks clemency for her father's killer". Richmond Times-Dispatch. Retrieved July 9, 2017. 
  49. ^ "Looming Va. execution divides family of slain deputy". USA TODAY. Retrieved July 9, 2017. 
  50. ^ "Morva sentenced to death". Collegiatetimes.com. Retrieved 2017-07-09. 
  51. ^ Wadell, Bill. "New request to halt execution of Morva". VirginiaFirst.com (June 20, 2017). Retrieved June 22, 2017. 
  52. ^ Gangloff, Mike. "Morva attorneys ask governor to stop execution". The Roanoke Times (June 20, 2017). Retrieved June 22, 2017. 
  53. ^ Cote, Nicholas. "Executing a severely mentally ill man would be an injustice". The Washington Post (June 16, 2017). Retrieved June 22, 2017. 
  54. ^ Sarat, Austin (June 28, 2017). "Stop Executing the mentally ill". USNews. Retrieved July 4, 2017. 
  55. ^ Editors, The. "Virginia's Governor Still Has Time to Save a Mentally Ill Man from execution". WashingtonPost. Retrieved July 4, 2017. 
  56. ^ Times-Dispatch, FRANK GREEN Richmond. "Two previous Virginia death row sentences commuted because of mental illness; Morva scheduled to die Thursday". Richmond Times-Dispatch. Retrieved July 9, 2017. 
  57. ^ Morission, Shawna (August 29, 2006). "Death penalty will be sought for Morva, prosecutor says". The Roanoke Times (August 29, 2006). THe Roanoke Times. Newspaper. Retrieved June 9, 2017. 
  58. ^ Green, Frank. "Brother's mental illness supports claim of condemned killer William Morva's delusional disorder, say lawyers". Richmond Times Dispatch. Retrieved July 4, 2017. 

External links[edit]