William Webb Ellis
William Webb Ellis
The only known contemporary image of Webb Ellis, published in the Illustrated London News, 1854
|Died||24 January 1872 (aged 65)|
The Reverend William Webb Ellis (24 November 1806 – 24 January 1872) was an English Anglican clergyman and the alleged inventor of rugby football while a pupil at Rugby School. According to legend, Webb Ellis picked up the ball and ran with it during a school football match in 1823, thus creating the 'rugby' style of play. Although the story has become firmly entrenched in the sport's folklore, it is not supported by substantive evidence, and is discounted by most rugby historians as an origin myth.
William Webb Ellis was born in Salford, Lancashire, the younger of two surviving sons (the eldest, James, died aged three; the second son, Thomas, of Dunchurch, Warwickshire, was a surgeon) of James Ellis, a cornet in the 7th Dragoon Guards, in 1809 made a Lieutenant of the 3rd Dragoon Guards, joining them in Portugal, and Ann, daughter of William Webb, a surgeon, of Alton, Hampshire, whom James married in Exeter in 1804. His paternal grandfather was from Pontyclun in South Wales, a descendant of the Ellis family of Kiddal Hall, just off the A64 near Potterton, West Riding of Yorkshire.
After his father was killed during the Peninsular War in a cavalry action near Albuera on 1 July 1812, Mrs Ellis, in receipt of an allowance of £30 from His Majesty's Royal Bounty in recognition of her husband's service, decided to move to Rugby, Warwickshire, so that William and his elder brother, Thomas, would receive an education at Rugby School with no cost as a local foundationer (i.e. a pupil living within a radius of 10 miles of the Rugby Clock Tower). He attended the school in Town House from 1816 to 1825 and was recorded as being a good scholar and cricketer, although it was noted that he was "rather inclined to take unfair advantage at cricket". The incident in which William Webb Ellis supposedly caught the ball in his arms during a football match (which was allowed) and ran with it (which was not) is supposed to have happened in the latter half of 1823.
After leaving Rugby in 1826, he went to Brasenose College, Oxford, aged 20. He played cricket for his college, and for Oxford University against Cambridge University in a first-class match in 1827. He graduated with a B.A. in 1829 and received his M.A. in 1831. He entered the Church and became chaplain of St George's Chapel, Albemarle Street, London (closed c.1909), and then rector of St. Clement Danes in the Strand. He became well known as a low church evangelical clergyman. In 1855, he became rector of Magdalen Laver in Essex. A picture of him (the only known portrait) appeared in the Illustrated London News in 1854, after he gave a particularly stirring sermon on the subject of the Crimean War.
He never married and died in the south of France in 1872, leaving an estate of £9,000, mostly to various charities. His grave in "le cimetière du vieux château" at Menton in Alpes Maritimes was rediscovered by Ross McWhirter in 1958, was renovated by the Riviera Hash House Harriers in 2003 and is now maintained by the French Rugby Federation.
Origin of the claim
The sole source of the story of Webb Ellis picking up the ball originates with one Matthew Bloxam, a local antiquarian and former pupil of Rugby. On 10 October 1876, he wrote to The Meteor, the Rugby School magazine, that he had learnt from an unnamed source that the change from a kicking game to a handling game had "...originated with a town boy or foundationer of the name of Ellis, Webb Ellis".
On 22 December 1880, in another letter to the Meteor, Bloxam elaborates on the story:
- "A boy of the name Ellis – William Webb Ellis – a town boy and a foundationer, ... whilst playing Bigside at football in that half-year , caught the ball in his arms. This being so, according to the then rules, he ought to have retired back as far as he pleased, without parting with the ball, for the combatants on the opposite side could only advance to the spot where he had caught the ball, and were unable to rush forward till he had either punted it or had placed it for some one else to kick, for it was by means of these placed kicks that most of the goals were in those days kicked, but the moment the ball touched the ground the opposite side might rush on. Ellis, for the first time, disregarded this rule, and on catching the ball, instead of retiring backwards, rushed forwards with the ball in his hands towards the opposite goal, with what result as to the game I know not, neither do I know how this infringement of a well-known rule was followed up, or when it became, as it is now, a standing rule."
Bloxam's first account differed from his second one four years later. In his first letter, in 1876, Bloxham claimed that Webb Ellis committed the act in 1824, a time by which Webb Ellis had left Rugby. In his second letter, in 1880, Bloxham put the year as 1823.
The claim that Webb Ellis invented the game did not surface until four years after his death, and doubts have been raised about the story since 1895, when the Old Rugbeian Society first investigated it. The sub-committee conducting the investigation was "unable to procure any first hand evidence of the occurrence".
Among those giving evidence, Thomas Harris and his brother John, who had left Rugby in 1828 and 1832 respectively (i.e. after the alleged Webb Ellis incident) recalled that handling of the ball was strictly forbidden. Thomas Harris, who requested that he "not [be] quote[d] as an authority", testified that Webb Ellis had been known as someone to take an "unfair advantage at football". John Harris, who would have been aged 10 years at the time of the alleged incident, did not claim to have been a witness to it. Additionally, he stated that he had not heard the story of Webb Ellis's creation of the game.
Thomas Hughes (author of Tom Brown's Schooldays) was asked to comment on the game as played when he attended the school (1834–1842). He is quoted as saying "In my first year, 1834, running with the ball to get a try by touching down within goal was not absolutely forbidden, but a jury of Rugby boys of that day would almost certainly have found a verdict of 'justifiable homicide' if a boy had been killed in running in."
It has been suggested by Dunning and Sheard (2005) that it was no coincidence that this investigation was conducted in 1895, at a time when divisions within the sport led to the schism: the split into the sports of rugby league and rugby union. Dunning and Sheard suggest that the endorsement of a "reductionist" origin myth by the Rugbeians was an attempt to assert their school's position and authority over a sport that they were losing control of.
An article by Gordon Rayner in The Sunday Telegraph about the origin of Rugby football, says that Thomas Hughes told the 1895 investigation that in 1838–1839 a Rugby School boy called Jem Mackie "was the first great runner-in", and that later (in or before 1842) Jem Mackie was expelled from Rugby School for an unspecified incident; in 1845 boys at the school first wrote down an agreed set of rules for the version of football played at Rugby School, which is now rugby football. Gordon Rayner says that the reason for Jem Mackie's expulsion may have damaged Mackie's reputation so much that Bloxam transferred Mackie's part in inventing Rugby football to Webb Ellis, and that a big donation by Bloxam to Rugby School's library may have influenced school official acceptance of this Webb Ellis version. Another theory is that Mackie's role may have been disregarded because the committee was seeking to prove Rugby School had invented the game, and thus may have preferred the earliest possible date. England Rugby says that William Webb Ellis's action (if it happened) did not lead to any immediate change in the rules but may well have inspired later imitators, though not Mackie, as Thomas Hughes said the Webb Ellis story had not survived into his own time (1834, which was before Mackie popularised running-in in 1838/39).
A plaque, erected in 1895, at Rugby School bears the inscription:
- Abner Doubleday, sometimes apocryphally credited with inventing baseball
- Tom Wills, attended Rugby School and pioneered Australian rules football
- Davies, Sean (10 August 2007). "William Webb Ellis – fact or fiction?". BBC. Retrieved 23 October 2009.
- Eric Dunning, Kenneth Sheard (2005). "Part I: 2. Football in the early-nineteenth-century public schools". Barbarians, gentlemen and players: a sociological study of the development of rugby football (2nd ed.). Oxon: Routledge. pp. 52–53. ISBN 0-7146-5353-5. Retrieved 24 October 2009. (ISBN 9780714653532)
- Notices of the Ellises of England, Scotland and Ireland, from the Conquest to the present time, William Smith Ellis, 1866, pg 175
- Notices of the Ellises of England, Scotland, and Ireland, from the Conquest to the present time, William Smith Ellis, 1866, pg 175
- Journals of the House of Commons, 1813–14, vol. 69, The House of Commons, pg 564
- CricketArchive – William Webb Ellis. Retrieved 10 April 2013.
- "Patience is a virtue". ESPN Cricinfo. Retrieved 28 January 2019.
- St George’s, (1740? -1909?) was a proprietary chapel in Albemarle Street, and located opposite the Royal Institution. It was a fashionable chapel, where the Reverend W. W. Ellis preached sermons. The chapel backed onto St George’s Hotel, which was purchased in 1889 by Brown’s Hotel (founded in 1837 by James Brown, one time valet to Lord Byron). The two hotels were incorporated into the enlarged Brown’s Hotel. St. George's is remembered – by a stained glass window located in the hotel's Donovan Bar, and the historic merger is recorded at the entrance to the hotel.
- "A Field Guide to the English Clergy' Butler-Gallie, F p112: London, Oneworld Publications, 2018 ISBN 9781786074416
- Harvey, Sarah (1 October 2015). "The legend of the man who invented rugby". Riviera Press. Archived from the original on 1 December 2017. Retrieved 22 November 2017.
- (Harvey 2005, p. 246)
- (Harvey 2005, p. 247)
- Rayner, Gordon (5 September 2015). "Rugby World Cup: William Webb Ellis is 'King Arthur' figure whose reputation as game's inventor may be a myth". The Sunday Telegraph. Retrieved 22 November 2017.
- Harris, Tim (2009). Players: 250 Men, Women and Animals Who Created Modern Sport. Random House. ISBN 9781409086918 – via Google Books.
- "Who Was William Webb Ellis?". England Rugby. Retrieved 22 February 2019.
Consequently Ellis’s actions (if they happened) were not responsible for changing the rules, and at best can only be seen as inspiration for subsequent ‘runners’. ... Mackie popularised the action in 1838/9 and the custom was officially legalised at Rugby School in 1842. Hughes also states “the Webb Ellis tradition had not survived” to his day (i.e. 1834, 12 years after the alleged Ellis incident) so it was obviously no influence on Mackie.
- Harvey, Adrian (2005). Football: the first hundred years : the untold story. Oxon: Routledge. ISBN 0-415-35019-0. Retrieved 24 October 2009. (ISBN 9780415350198)
- K. G. Sheard, "Ellis, William Webb (1806–1872)", Oxford Dictionary of National Biography, Oxford University Press, September 2004; online edn, October 2006 accessed 23 October 2007
- Rev. William Webb Ellis, Sermons: Preached in St. George's Chapel, Albemarle Street; to Which Is Added, an Essay On the Prophecies Relative to Christ, published prior to 1923