William White (Mayflower passenger)
William White (c.1580 – February 21, 1621) was a passenger on the Mayflower. Accompanied by his wife Susanna, son Resolved and two servants, he travelled in 1620 on the historic voyage. He was a signatory to the Mayflower Compact and perished early in the history of Plymouth Colony.
William White has been a difficult person to research, largely because of the commonness of his name in England. Per author Edward Banks, his surname was one of the dozen most common names in England and his baptismal name one of the four most frequently bestowed in that period, making genealogical research be difficult. And contrary to internet information about his supposed White family ancestry, per the Mayflower Society Families book, Volume 13, the Society states “Little is known about Pilgrim William White.”
Further, there is confusion about William White in Leiden. Records reveal that there were two men of that name living there, other than Mayflower William White about 1620 and both appear to have been still there after the Mayflower departed. Aside from the William Whites in Leiden confusion, an additional contributing factor was the name of the wife of one of the William Whites – Ann – which erroneously has connected the Whites with the Fuller family.
Other evidence of the William White family coming to the Mayflower from England and not Holland comes from William Bradford’s passenger list which has “Mr. William White” in his section for London merchants along with Mr. Christopher Martin, Mr. William Mullins, Mr. Stephen Hopkins, Mr. Richard Warren, and John Billington. It is believed that if William White had been a member of the Leiden congregation, his name would have appeared in Bradford’s work for that section, but it does not. There is no evidence to associate the William White of the Mayflower with Leiden, Holland.
Follows: Information updated by Dr. Jeremy Bangs, Museum director of the Leiden American Pilgrim Museum as presented by James R. Hancock,3 Mar 2003 Ref:http://www.genealogy.com/forum/general/topics/pilgrims/444/
"MF 13 (1995) on the Family of William White, argues against Susanna being Fuller.
However, based upon more recent research (esp. of the Leiden, Holland records) by Dr. Jeremy Bangs, Museum director of the Leiden American Pilgrim Museum, indications to me are that Susanna was in-fact likely the daughter of Robert Fuller of Redenhall, England.
See the article, January 2000 - [NEHGR 154:109-118] - In this issue, Jeremy Dupertuis Bangs, Director, Leiden American Pilgrim Museum, reintroduces the issue of the identity of Edward Winslows second wife in an article entitled 'Notes From Leiden: Another look at the identity of Edward Winslow's wife, Susanna (?Fuller) White.' In particular he examines the Leiden records, their translation and conclusions drawn by Robert M. Sherman and Ruth Wilder Sherman (MF Vol 1, 1975) of research carried out in their behalf by Dr. B. N. Leverland in 1971 and repeated recently in The Great Migration Begins p.1980 (William White), p.2025 (Edward Winslow).
In brief, Bangs provides additional translation interpretations, discusses the two William Whites residing in Leiden, the age discrepancy between the Ann Fuller and Edward Winslow, as well as other perplexities, and suggests the conclusion that 'there is no conclusive evidence against the Dexters' [Henry M.and M. Dexter, The England and Holland of the Pilgrims] identification of Susanna White Winslow with Anna (Fuller) White.
Several objections have been raised:
1. The Bangs article answers the major questions, including the matter of Samuel Fuller's sister, Anna Fuller, being considered too old in 1621 to have married twenty-five-year-old Edward Winslow. Bangs argues that this concern "may be set aside as a reflection of twentieth-century attitudes, not taking into account the circumstances of the many deaths in Plymouth in the first winter and the apparent custom in the colony of rapid remarriage as a way to ensure continued care for women and children.."
2. The will of Robert Fuller is dated 19 May 1613, proved 31 May 1614. It names, among others, "to daughter Ann Fuller, twenty pounds." In Leiden, William White and Ann Fuller were betrothed on 27 Jan 1612 and married on 11 Feb 1612. Robert Fuller's will named her Ann "Fuller." Perhaps the most logical answer would be that Robert White dictated his will to a cleric and named his son Samuel and daughters Anna and Elizabeth. Several logical answers are possible - The recorder may well have added the family name for clarity - not knowing Anna had married in the Netherlands; It's also possible that the modern habits of name change weren't in such rigid form yet.
The article answers other important questions as well.
The strongest, if not irrefutable, proof that Susanna was in-fact, Anna Fuller, is taken from the Bangs article which says that the Leiden records contain...
1. The betrothal of "Willem With" (i.e. William White), woolcomber, bachelor, from England, with "En Foller" (i.e. Ann Fuller), spinster, from England, on 27 Jan 1612. He was accompanied by "Willem Jopson" (i.e. William Jepson) and "Samuel Folle" (i.e. Samuel Fuller), identitfied as "zijn bekende" (his acquaintances(s)); she was accompanied by "Rosemen Jepson" (i.e. Rosamond Jepson) and "Sara Pryst" (i.e. Sarah Priest), identified as "haer bekende" (her acquaintance(s)).
2. The betrothal on 15 Mar 1613, of Samuel Fuller (spelled correctly this time), identified as "saeywercker van Londen" (serge worker from London) and widower of "Els Glaescoock" (i.e. Alice or Elizabeth Glasscock), with "Agnijes Carpenter" (i.e. Agnes Carpenter), spinster from "Wrenton" (Wrington) in England. Samuel Fuller was accompanied by Alexander Carpenter (spelled correctly), "Willem Hoyt zijn zwager" (i.e. William Hoyt or White, his brother-in-law), "Rogier Wilsum" (i.e. Roger Wilson), and "Eduwaert Saetwoot" (i.e. Edward Southworth); Agnes Carpenter was accompanied by "Agnijs Weyt (i.e. Agnes White) and "Els Carpenter haer zuster (i.e. Alice or Elizabeth Carpenter her sister). That "Willem Hoyt" can be rendered as William White is a recognition of the problem of phoenetic spelling attempts; this rendering was given by H. M. and M. Dexter but not by E. Arber. "Hoyt" sounds very close to "White"; another attempt to spell the same sound is seen in "Weyt" in the same document. This second attempt indicates strongly that the name White is being attempted. Neither of these spellings recurs in the Leiden records in this period for betrothals, baptisms, or burials...
Therefore, Bangs says..."that William White could be described as Samuel Fuller's brother-in-law is possible (as he is in this document, granting that Hoyt is White) is possible only if Ann Fuller, who had married William White, was Samuel Fuller's sister. This is the documentary origin of the opinion that Susanna White was Samuel Fuller's sister, an identification first made by the Dexters [in The England and Holland of the Pilgrims]. As noticed above, at the time of William White's own marriage, Samuel Fuller was not yet his brother-in-law, being identified merely as his acquaintance. (The clerk was evidently quite precise in registering such identifications of relationships; this cannot be explained away as a clerical oversight)" [end].
The article by Dr. Bangs has therefore established from the Leiden records that:
1. Anna can also be Susanna. 2. An Ann Fuller m. a William White (with a Samuel Fuller was an acquaintance). 3. Samuel Fuller had a sister who was m. to a William White, by the time Samuel married. 4. Various other interactions among those people in Holland.
With this context, what are the chances that The Mayflower passenger list would then include a Samuel Fuller (3rd wife Bridget Lee came later on the Anne), and that William and Susanna (and Resolved) White, would NOT BE THE SAME PEOPLE?
And further from Dr. Bangs, "...and just how many William Whites are we supposed to believe belonged to the Pilgrim congregation? The evidence is not just that there were at least two in Leiden, but that they were also both in the congregation. Now if one of them (the one who does not appear in Leiden after 1620) was not the Mayflower passenger, we would have to suppose that a third William White joined the group from England and became a member of the Plymouth congregation later. And again how many different Fuller families are there [in Leiden] ?..."
In conclusion, while more research of the Fuller family might assist in confirmation, it is my opinion that until any new unanswerable questions against arise, the burden should be to disprove this Fuller/White connection.
James R. Hancock"
The Mayflower Voyage
William White came on board the Mayflower with his pregnant wife Susanna, son Resolved, then about five years in age and two servants. Susanna gave birth to their son Peregrine on board the Mayflower several weeks after White signed the Mayflower Compact.
The White family, as recalled by William Bradford in 1651, per their Mayflower voyage, and the birth of Peregrine: “Mr. William White, and Susana, his wife, and one sone, called Resolved, and one borne a ship-bord, called Peregriene; and *2* servants, named William Holbeck and Edward Thomson.”
The Mayflower departed Plymouth, England, September 6/16, 1620. The small, 100-foot ship had 102 passengers and a crew of about 30-40 in extremely cramped conditions. By the second month out, the ship was being buffeted by strong westerly gales, causing the ship‘s timbers to be badly shaken with caulking failing to keep out sea water, and with passengers, even in their berths, lying wet and ill. This, combined with a lack of proper rations and unsanitary conditions for several months, attributed to what would be fatal for many, especially the majority of women and children. On the way there were two deaths, a crew member and a passenger, but the worst was yet to come after arriving at their destination when, in the space of several months, almost half the passengers perished in cold, harsh, unfamiliar New England winter.
On November 9/19, 1620, after about 3 months at sea, including a month of delays in England, they spotted land, which was the Cape Cod Hook, now called Provincetown Harbor. After several days of trying to get south to their planned destination of the Colony of Virginia, strong winter seas forced them to return to the harbor at Cape Cod hook, where they anchored on November 11/21. The Mayflower Compact was signed that day.
In Plymouth Colony
William White died late in the first winter on February 21, 1621. With the death of her husband, Susanna White, with newborn Peregrine and five-year-old Resolved, became the only surviving widow out of the many families who perished that winter. By the Spring of 1621, 52 of the 102 persons who originally had arrived on the Mayflower at Cape Cod would be dead.
In May 1621, Susanna White became the first Plymouth colony bride, marrying Edward Winslow, a fellow Mayflower passenger whose wife had perished on March 24, 1621. At least five children were born to Edward Winslow and his wife Susanna.
And though deceased, in the 1623 Division of Land, White received five acres (akers) “lyeth behind the forte to the little ponde.” (lying behind the fort to the little pond). Edward Winslow, his wife Susanna’s husband since May 12, 1621, received four acres in the same section. White’s sons Resolved and Peregrine were both listed with their step-father Edward Winslow and mother Susanna in the 1627 Division of Cattle, and moved with their parents to Marshfield in 1632.
About 1638, the Winslows moved with Susanna’s sons Resolved and Peregrine White, to Green Harbor, now called Marshfield Massachusetts. Edward Winslow later became Governor of Plymouth County, and was also the colony agent in England. In England, his diplomatic skills soon came to the attention of Oliver Cromwell, the new Puritan leader of the country. Cromwell required Winslow head a joint award reparations commission to assess damage caused by Danish ships.
Edward Winslow lived in England the last six years of his life, serving the government there. When his will was written in 1654 as resident of London, the document stated that he left his New England property to his son Josiah “hee (sic) allowing to my wife a full third parte thereof for her life also” so it is probable that his wife did not follow him to London. Edward Winslow died of fever May 7/8, 1655 while on a British military expedition in the Caribbean
There is no trace of Susanna’s death beyond a sales record in 1647, and no further record of Susanna has been found. Though she was the wife of one colony governor and the mother of another, the first bride in the colony and the mother of the famed Peregrine White, she seems forgotten in the records.
The Mayflower Society has refuted the reported maiden surname of 'Fuller' for Susanna White and has determined that the maiden name of Susanna White is unknown. Further, Susanna ____ (White) Winslow, was not the sister of Dr. Samuel Fuller as is often stated. The Samuel and Edward Fuller who traveled on the Mayflower were sons of Robert Fuller of Redenhall, England. Robert had a daughter Anna, born about 1578, far too old a bride for Winslow who was not born until 1595. The 1615 will of Robert Fuller mentions no daughter named Susanna, nor a daughter married to William White. It does mention Alice Bradford, a sister-in-law. In a letter that Edward Winslow wrote in 1623 to “Uncle Robert Jackson”, he provided news of Susanna, her late husband William White, and her children. He also sends his regards to his father-in-law in England, obviously not Robert Fuller who had been dead for nine years.
Another misrepresentation is that William White once lived in Holland. For many years genealogists assumed that William White spent his early married years in Holland, marrying and burying children but no proof that they apply to the Pilgrim William White but rather they probably apply to the William White who was still living there in 1621.
Family of William White and Susanna
William White married Susanna ca 1612 (a marriage to Anna Fuller was disproven years ago)  and had two sons. White died on February 21, 1621. Susanna remarried on May 12, 1621 to Edward Winslow and had five children with him. The death date of Susanna is uncertain – sometime between 1654 and 1675. She was buried in Winslow Cemetery in Marshfield where her sons Resolved and Peregrine White and their wives were buried. Edward Winslow died on a British military expedition in the Caribbean in 1655 and was buried at sea.
Children of William White and his wife Susanna:
- Resolved White was born in England, about 1615. He died sometime after September 19, 1687. He and his first wife Judith were buried in Winslow Cemetery, Marshfield.
- He married:
- 1. Judith Vassall, daughter of William Vassall, on November 5, 1640 in Scituate. She was born in England ca. 1619, and was buried in the Winslow Cemetery in Marshfield on April 3, 1670. They had eight children born in Scituate between 1642 and 1656.
- 2. Abigail (____) Lord, widow of William Lord, on October 5, 1674 in Salem. She was born in England ca. 1606 and died in Salem between June 15 and 27, 1682.
- Peregrine White was born aboard the ship Mayflower late in November 1620 and died in Marshfield on July 20, 1704. He married Sarah Bassett, daughter of William Bassett, by March 6, 1648/9 and had seven children. She died in Marshfield on January 22, 1711.
The fate of the White family as recalled by William Bradford in 1651: “Mr. White dyed soon after ther landing. His wife married with Mr. Winslow (as is before noted). His *2* sons are married, and Resolved had *5* children, Peregrine tow (sic), all living. So their increase are now *7*.”
Death of William White
William White died on February 21, 1621. He was buried in Coles Hill Burial Ground in Plymouth, likely in an unmarked grave as with most from the Mayflower who died that first winter. His name appears on the Pilgrim Memorial Tomb (sarcophagus) on Coles Hill. The date of death of his wife Susanna, who became the second wife of Edward Winslow, is uncertain. She was buried in the Winslow Cemetery, Marshfield, as were her sons Resolved and Peregrine and their families. Edward Winslow died on a British military expedition in the Caribbean in 1655 and was buried at sea.
Servants traveling with White family
William Holbeck. He boarded the Mayflower as an indentured servant. He did not sign the Mayflower Compact so it may be presumed he was under the age of 21, possibly in his teens. His surname was a not especially a common one. It may be assumed that he came from the same region of England as the White family, but the origins of this family have not been located.
Edward Thomson (or Thompson). He boarded the Mayflower as a servant to William White. He did not sign the Mayflower Compact which indicates he was not yet 21 years of age, and was probably in his teens. His English origins are unknown and due to his very common name, difficult to research. He may have come from the same area of England as the White family, whose origins are also unknown. Edward Thompson was the first Mayflower passenger to die, as reported by William Bradford, after the ship’s arrival at Cape Cod, probably on December 4, 1620. This was several weeks before the Pilgrims located and decided to settle at Plymouth. Several memorials to him and others from the Mayflower who were the earliest to die exist today at Provincetown on Cape Cod.
- Caleb H. Johnson, The Mayflower and Her Passengers (Indiana: Xlibris Corp., copyright 2006 Caleb Johnson), pp. 246-247
- Eugene Aubrey Stratton, Plymouth Colony: Its History and People, 1620-1691, (Salt Lake City: Ancestry Publishing, 1986), pp. 25, 405, 412
- Nathaniel Philbrick, Mayflower: A story of Courage, Community and War (New York: Viking, 2006), p. 104
- A genealogical profile of William White
- Charles Edward Banks, The English Ancestry and Homes of the Pilgrim Fathers (Boston: Genealogical Publishing Co., 2006), p. 94
- Caleb H. Johnson, The Mayflower and Her Passengers (Indiana: Xlibris Corp., copyright 2006 Caleb Johnson), p. 247
- Nathaniel Philbrick, Mayflower: A story of Courage, Community and War (New York: Viking, 2006), p. 69
- Eugene Aubrey Stratton, Plymouth Colony: Its History and People, 1620-1691, (Salt Lake City: Ancestry Publishing, 1986), p. 406
- Eugene Aubrey Stratton, Plymouth Colony: Its History and People, 1620-1691, (Salt Lake City: Ancestry Publishing, 1986), p. 413
- George Ernest Bowman, The Mayflower Compact and its signers, (Boston: Massachusetts Society of Mayflower Descendants, 1920), Photocopies of the 1622, 1646 and 1669 versions of the document, pp. 7-19
- Nathaniel Philbrick, Mayflower: A story of Courage, Community and War (New York: Viking, 2006), pp. 89-90
- Eugene Aubrey Stratton, Plymouth Colony: Its History and People, 1620-1691, (Salt Lake City: Ancestry Publishing, 1986), p. 25
- Pilgrim Village Family Sketch: Edward Winslow
- William Bradford, History of Plymouth Plantation by William Bradford, the second Governor of Plymouth, (Boston: 1856), p. 101
- Eugene Aubrey Stratton, Plymouth Colony: Its History and People, 1620-1691, (Salt Lake City: Ancestry Publishing, 1986), p. 416
- Nathaniel Philbrick, Mayflower: A story of Courage, Community and War, (New York: Viking 2006), p. 184
- David Lindsay, PhD., Mayflower Bastard: A Stranger amongst the Pilgrims, (New York: St. Martins Press, 2002), p. 137
- Nathaniel Philbrick, Mayflower: A Story of Courage, Community and War (New York: Viking 2006), p. 184.
- Ruth Wilder Sherman, CG, FASG and Robert Moody Sherman, CG, FASG. Re-edited by Robert S. Wakefield, FASG, Mayflower Families through Five Generations: Descendants of the Pilgrims who landed at Plymouth, Mass. December 1620. Vol. 13: Family of William White (Pub. General Society of Mayflower Descendants 2006 3rd Ed.), p. 2.
- David Lindsay, PhD., Mayflower Bastard: A Stranger amongst the Pilgrims (New York: St. Martins Press, 2002), p. 137
- Ruth Wilder Sherman, CG, FASG and Robert Moody Sherman, CG, FASG. Re-edited by Robert S. Wakefield, FASG, Mayflower Families through Five Generations: Descendants of the Pilgrims who landed at Plymouth, Mass. December 1620. Vol. 13: Family of William White (Pub. General Society of Mayflower Descendants 2006 3rd Ed.) p. 2.
- Ruth Wilder Sherman, CG, FASG and Robert Moody Sherman, CG, FASG. Re-edited by Robert S. Wakefield, FASG, Mayflower Families through Five Generations: Descendants of the Pilgrims who landed at Plymouth, Mass. December 1620. Vol. 13: Family of William White (Pub. General Society of Mayflower Descendants 2006 3rd Ed.) pp. 2-4.
- Ruth Wilder Sherman, CG, FASG and Robert Moody Sherman, CG, FASG. Re-edited by Robert S. Wakefield, FASG, Mayflower Families through Five Generations: Descendants of the Pilgrims who landed at Plymouth, Mass. December 1620. Vol. 13: Family of William White (Pub. General Society of Mayflower Descendants 2006 3rd Ed.), p. 3.
- Leiden Pilgrim Archives
- Memorial for Resolved White
- Memorial for Peregrine White
- Eugene Aubrey Stratton, Plymouth Colony: Its History and People, 1620-1691, (Salt Lake City: Ancestry Publishing, 1986), p. 408
- Memorial for William White
- Caleb H. Johnson, The Mayflower and Her Passengers (Indiana: Xlibris Corp., copyright 2006 Caleb Johnson), p. 158
- Charles Edward Banks, The English Ancestry and Homes of the Pilgrim Fathers (Boston: Genealogical Publishing Co., 2006), p. 59
- Caleb H. Johnson, The Mayflower and Her Passengers (Indiana: Xlibris Corp., copyright 2006 Caleb Johnson), p. 233
- Charles Edward Banks, The English Ancestry and Homes of the Pilgrim Fathers (Boston: Genealogical Publishing Co., 2006), p. 85
- Nick Bunker, Making Haste from Babylon: The Mayflower Pilgrims and their New World, (NY. Alfred A. Knopf 2010) p. 277