Writing therapy is a form of expressive therapy that uses the act of writing and processing the written word as therapy. Writing therapy posits that writing one's feelings gradually eases feelings of emotional trauma. Writing therapeutically can take place individually or in a group and it can be administered in person with a therapist or remotely through mailing or the Internet.
The field of writing therapy includes many practitioners in a variety of settings. The therapy is usually administered by a therapist or counselor. Several interventions exist online. Writing group leaders also work in hospitals with patients dealing with mental and physical illnesses. In university departments they aid student self-awareness and self-development. When administered at a distance, it is useful for those who prefer to remain personally anonymous and are not ready to disclose their most private thoughts and anxieties in a face-to-face situation.
As with most forms of therapy, writing therapy is adapted and used to work with a wide range of psychoneurotic illnesses, including bereavement, desertion and abuse. Many of these interventions take the form of classes where clients write on specific themes chosen by their therapist or counsellor. Assignments may include writing unsent letters to selected individuals, alive or dead, followed by imagined replies from the recipient or parts of the patient's body, or a dialogue with the recovering alcoholic's bottle of alcohol.
Research into the therapeutic action of writing
The expressive writing paradigm
Expressive writing is a form of writing therapy developed primarily by James W. Pennebaker in the late 1980s. The seminal expressive writing study instructed participants in the experimental group to write about a 'past trauma', expressing their very deepest thoughts and feelings surrounding it. In contrast, control participants were asked to write as objectively and factually as possible about neutral topics (e.g. a particular room or their plans for the day), without revealing their emotions or opinions. For both groups, the timescale was 15 minutes of continuous writing repeated over four consecutive days. It was also instructed that should a participant run out of things to write, they should go back to the beginning and repeat themselves, perhaps writing a little differently.
Typical writing instructions include:
For the next 4 days, I would like you to write your very deepest thoughts and feelings about the most traumatic experience of your entire life or an extremely important emotional issue that has affected you and your life. In your writing, I'd like you to really let go and explore your deepest emotions and thoughts. You might tie your topic to your relationships with others, including parents, lovers, friends or relatives; to your past, your present or your future; or to who you have been, who you would like to be or who you are now. You may write about the same general issues or experiences on all days of writing or about different topics each day. All of your writing will be completely confidential.
Don't worry about spelling, grammar or sentence structure. The only rule is that once you begin writing, you continue until the time is up.
Several measurements were made before and after, but the most striking finding was that relative to the control group, the experimental group made significantly fewer visits to a physician in the following months. Although many report being upset by the writing experience, they also find it valuable and meaningful.:167
These results have hatched further studies, numbering over 200. One of these went on to strongly suggest that expressive writing has the potential to actually provide a 'boost' to the immune system, perhaps explaining the reduction in physician visits. This was shown by measuring lymphocyte response to the foreign mitogens phytohaemagglutinin (PHA) and concanavalin A (ConA) just prior to and 6 weeks after writing. The significantly increased lymphocyte response led to speculation that expressive writing enhances immunocompetence. The results of a preliminary study of 40 people diagnosed with Major Depressive Disorder suggests that routinely engaging in expressive writing may be effective in reducing symptoms of depression.
Reception and criticism of Pennebaker's theories
Pennebaker's experiments, begun over twenty years ago, have been widely replicated and validated. Following on from Pennebaker's original work, there has been a renewed interest in the therapeutic value of abreaction. This was first discussed by Josef Breuer and Freud in Studies on Hysteria but not much explored since. At the heart of Pennebaker's theory is the idea that actively inhibiting thoughts and feelings about traumatic events requires effort, serves as a cumulative stressor on the body, and is associated with increased physiological activity, obsessive thinking or ruminating about the event, and longer-term disease. However, as Baikie and Wilhelm note, the theory has intuitive appeal but mixed empirical support:
Studies have shown that expressive writing results in significant improvements in various biochemical markers of physical and immune functioning (Pennebaker et al, 1988; Esterling et al, 1994; Petrie et al, 1995; Booth et al, 1997). This suggests that written disclosure may reduce the physiological stress on the body caused by inhibition, although it does not necessarily mean that disinhibition is the causal mechanism underlying these biological effects. On the other hand, participants writing about previously undisclosed traumas showed no differences in health outcomes from those writing about previously disclosed traumas (Greenberg & Stone, 1992) and participants writing about imaginary traumas that they had not actually experienced, and therefore could not have inhibited, also demonstrated significant improvements in physical health (Greenberg et al, 1996). Therefore, although inhibition may play a part, the observed benefits of writing are not entirely due to reductions in inhibition.
An additional line of enquiry, which has particular bearing on the difference between talking and writing, derives from Robert Ornstein's studies into the bicameral structure of the brain. While noting that what follows should be considered "wildly hypothetical", L'Abate, quoting Ornstein, postulates that:
One could argue ... that talk and writing differ in relative cerebral dominance. ... if language is more related to the right hemisphere, then writing may be more related to the left hemisphere. If this is the case, then writing might use or even stimulate parts of the brain that are not stimulated by talking.
Julie Gray, founder of Stories Without Borders notes that "People who have experienced trauma in their lives, whether or not they consider themselves writers, can benefit from creating narratives out of their stories. It is helpful to write it down, in other words, in safety and in non-judgment. Trauma can be quite isolating. Those who have suffered need to understand how they feel and also to try to communicate that to others."
The role of the distance therapies
With the accessibility provided by the Internet, the reach of the writing therapies has increased considerably, as clients and therapists can work together from anywhere in the world, provided they can write the same language. They simply "enter" into a private "chat room" and engage in an ongoing text dialogue in "real time". Participants can also receive therapy sessions via e-text and/or voice with video, and complete online questionnaires, handouts, workout sheets and similar exercises.
This requires the services of a counsellor or therapist, albeit sitting at a computer. Given the huge disjunction between the amount of mental illness compared with the paucity of skilled resources, new ways have been sought to provide therapy other than drugs. In the more advanced societies pressure for cost-effective treatments, supported by evidence-based results, has come from both insurance companies and government agencies. Hence the decline in long term intensive psychoanalysis and the rise of much briefer forms, such as cognitive therapy.
Via the Internet
Currently, the most widely used mode of Internet writing therapy is via e-mail (see analytic psychotherapist Nathan Field's paper "The Therapeutic Action of Writing in Self-Disclosure and Self-Expression"). It is asynchronous; i.e. messages are passed between therapist and client within an agreed time frame (for instance, one week), but at any time within that week. Where both parties remain anonymous the client benefits from the online disinhibition effect; that is to say, feels freer to disclose memories, thoughts and feelings that they might withhold in a face-to-face situation. Both client and therapist have time for reflecting on the past and recapturing forgotten memories, time for privately processing their reactions and giving thought to their own responses. With e-therapy, space is eliminated and time expanded. Overall it considerably reduces the amount of therapeutic input, as well as the speed and pressure that therapists habitually have to work under.
The anonymity and invisibility provides a therapeutic environment that comes much closer than classical analysis to Freud's ideal of the "analytic blank screen". Sitting behind the patient on the couch still leaves room for a multitude of clues to the analyst's individuality; e-therapy provides almost none. Whether distance and reciprocal anonymity reduces or increases the level of transference has yet to be investigated.
In a 2016 randomised controlled trial, expressive writing was tested against direction to an online support group for individuals with anxiety and depression. No difference between the groups was found. Both groups showed a moderate improvement over time, but of a magnitude comparable to what one would expect to see over the time period concerned without intervention.
The oldest and most widely practiced form of self-help through writing is that of keeping a personal journal or diary—as distinct from a diary or calendar of daily appointments—in which the writer records their most meaningful thoughts and feelings. One individual benefit is that the act of writing puts a powerful brake on the torment of endlessly repeating troubled thoughts to which everyone is prone. Moreover, as Kathleen Adams notes, through the act of journal writing, the writer is also able to "literally [read] his or her own mind" and thus "to perceive experiences more clearly and thus feels a relief of tension".
Pulitzer Prize for Poetry finalist Bruce Weigl, a veteran of the Vietnam War, has discussed the therapeutic benefits of writing, especially when combined with other forms of therapy, for people coming to terms with traumatic experiences such as war. According to Weigl, "What it helps you do is externalize things, give a shape to it. And that's what Denise Levertov kept telling me is that, Look, you control it now. It doesn't control you anymore. You own it now."
- Woolston, Chris (2000-03-16). "Writing for therapy helps erase effects of trauma". CNN. Archived from the original on November 20, 2004.
- Pennebaker JW, Beall SK (Aug 1986). "Confronting a traumatic event: toward an understanding of inhibition and disease". Journal of Abnormal Psychology. 95 (3): 274–81. doi:10.1037/0021-843x.95.3.274. PMID 3745650.
- Pennebaker, James W. (May 1997). "Writing about Emotional Experiences as a Therapeutic Process" (PDF). Psychological Science. 8 (3): 162–166. doi:10.1111/j.1467-9280.1997.tb00403.x. JSTOR 40063169. Archived from the original (PDF) on October 20, 2003.
- Pennebaker, JW (2010). "Expressive writing in a clinical setting". The Independent Practitioner. 30: 23–25.
- Pennebaker JW, Kiecolt-Glaser JK, Glaser R (Apr 1988). "Disclosure of traumas and immune function: health implications for psychotherapy". Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology. 56 (2): 239–45. doi:10.1037/0022-006x.56.2.239. PMID 3372832.
- Krpan, Katherine, et. al. (2013). "An everyday activity as a treatment for depression:The benefits of expressive writing for people diagnosed with major depressive disorcer". Journal of Affective Disroders. 150. doi:https://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jad.2013.05.065
- Ornstein, Robert (1998). The Right Mind: Making Sense of the Hemispheres. Mariner Books.
- L'Abate, Luciano (2001). Distance Writing and Computer-Assisted Interventions in Psychiatry and Mental Health. Westport: Ablex Publishing. pp. 9–10.
- Gary, Julie. "Transformative Writing". Stories without Borders. Retrieved 1 August 2014.
- Harwood, T. Mark and L'Abate, Luciano. "Distance Writing: Helping without Seeing Participants." Self-Help in Mental Health: A Critical Review. London: Springer, 2010. 47.
- Bailey Belmont (December 6, 2016). "Healing Through Words: The Benefits Of Writing Therapy".
- Dean, J; Potts, HWW; Barker, C (2016). "Direction to an Internet Support Group Compared With Online Expressive Writing for People With Depression And Anxiety: A Randomized Trial". JMIR Mental Health. JMIR Publications. 3 (2): e12. doi:10.2196/mental.5133.
- Adams, Kathleen. "A Brief History of Journal Writing". The Center for Journal Therapy. Retrieved 28 December 2011.
- Blast Furnace (February 14, 2012). "An Interview with Bruce Weigl". Blast Furnace.
- Baikie, Karen A. & Wilhelm, Kay (2005). "Emotional and physical health benefits of expressive writing". Advances in Psychiatric Treatment. 11 (5): 338–346. doi:10.1192/apt.11.5.338.
- Graybeal, A.; Sexton, J.D. & Pennebaker, J.W. (2002). "The Role of Story-Making in Disclosure Writing: The Psychometrics of Narrative" (PDF). Psychology & Health. 17 (5): 571–581. doi:10.1080/08870440290025786.
- Morisano, D.; Hirsh, J.B.; Peterson, J.B.; Pihl, R.O. & Shore, B.M. (2010). "Setting, elaborating, and reflecting on personal goals improves academic performance" (PDF). Journal of Applied Psychology. 95 (2): 255–264. doi:10.1037/a0018478. PMID 20230067. Archived from the original (PDF) on June 2, 2016.