Harry Farr

Harry Farr
Born	1891 London, England
Died	18 October 1916 (aged 25) Carnoy, France
Allegiance	United Kingdom
Service/branch	British Army
Battles/wars	First World War

Private Harry Farr (1891– 18 October 1916) was a British soldier who was executed during World War I for cowardice at the age of 25. He came from Kensington in London and was serving in the 1st Battalion, the West Yorkshire Regiment. He was formally pardoned by the British Government in 2006.

Background

Harry Farr was born in 1891. He joined the British Army as a professional soldier on 8 May 1908, enlisting at Hursely Park.

On the outbreak of World War 1 in August 1914 he was mobilized with the 2nd Battalion of his regiment as part of the British Expeditionary Force, and fought on the Western Front. His position was repeatedly shelled, and in May 1915 he collapsed with strong convulsions. His wife Gertrude recalled that while he was in hospital,

He shook all the time. He couldn't stand the noise of the guns. We got a letter from him, but it was in a stranger's handwriting. He could write perfectly well, but couldn't hold the pen because his hand was shaking.

Battle of the Somme

Despite this, Farr was discharged from hospital and sent back to the front with the 1st Battalion of the West Yorkshire Regiment, a part of the 6th Infantry Division, with which he fought in the Battle of the Somme. Farr reported himself to the medical station several times over the following months. In April 1916, he was kept at the medical station for a fortnight due to his state. On 22 July 1916 he spent the night at a medical station and was discharged for duty the following morning.

Desertion

On 17 September 2016, Farr's battalion was due to move to the frontline of the Battle of Flers–Courcelette as part of an assault on the German 'Quadrilateral' at the front line of the Somme. To reach this position, the battalion travelled through the so-called 'Chimpanzee Valley' near an ongoing British artillery bombardment. On the morning of the 17th, Farr informed the regimental sergeant major–Major Hanking–that he was unwell and unable to fight. Farr was instructed to seek the help of a medical orderly, but Farr did not appear to be physically wounded and the medical officer did not record anything wrong with him. Farr was ordered to reported for duty with a ration party transporting goods to the frontline at around 8 P.M., but went missing shortly afterwards. That evening, Farr was still not at the frontline. Major Hanking discovered Farr at 11 P.M. that evening at the transport lines, alone with a brazier. He was ordered to join his battalion but said he "could not stand it". Major Hanking is recorded to have said in response "You are a fucking coward and you will go to the trenches. I give fuck all for my life and I give fuck all for yours and I'll get you fucking well shot". Hanking also threatened to shoot Farr if he did not follow orders, saying "I will blow your fucking brains out if you don't go". Hanking arranged an escort and a corporal to try and force Farr to return to the front. A physical confrontation between the men ensued and Farr escaped.

Court martial

He was subsequently arrested for disobeying orders, and on 1 October 1916 tried by court martial at Ville-sur-Ancre. He had to defend himself against the formal accusation of 'misbehaving before the enemy in such a manner as to show cowardice'. The Divisional court martial, presided over by Lieutenant-Colonel Frederick Spring, the Commanding Officer of the 11th (Service) Battalion of the Essex Regiment, lasted 20 minutes, and questions have subsequently been raised about its competence. The hearing found Farr guilty and sentenced him to death. General Sir Douglas Haig, as the Commander-in-Chief of the British Expeditionary Force subsequently confirmed the execution order, and Farr was shot by a firing squad made up from men of his own regiment at 6.00 A.M. on 18 October 1916, near Carnoy on the Somme. His family have always argued that he was suffering from shell shock at the time.

Pardon

Harry Farr's wife, Gertrude, then living in Central London, was first told her husband had been killed in action, but later when her pension was stopped, she was informed he had been shot for cowardice and she was not entitled to receive a war widow's pension. In 1992, Gertrude and her family discovered that some documents were being released by the government and that Andrew MacKinlay MP was involved in a campaign for justice for those in similar positions to Farr. When they got hold of the court martial papers, they were horrified to discover that Farr had been sent back to the front, when he in fact needed urgent medical treatment.

Despite a sustained campaign, Prime Minister John Major refused a pardon. Gertrude Farr died in 1994.

On 15 August 2006, Harry Farr's family announced that Farr was to be granted a pardon. The announcement came as Des Browne, the Defence Secretary, said that he would seek a statutory group pardon; i.e. one achieved through an Act of Parliament for all those executed regardless of the individual merits of the case. Des Browne told BBC Radio 4's Today programme that, after 90 years, "the evidence just doesn't exist inside the cases individually". It has been suggested that the move would avoid numerous court cases. A group pardon would also exonerate those who had been properly found guilty of cowardice. A historian said that of cases in the Norfolk Regiment he had examined there was at least one who had a history of desertion. Historians have criticised such a move in the past as trying to apply modern standards retroactively.

The mass pardon of 306 British Empire soldiers executed for certain offences during the Great War was enacted in section 359 of the Armed Forces Act 2006, which came into effect on royal assent on 8 November 2006. This number included three from New Zealand, twenty three from Canada, two from the West Indies, two from Ghana and one each from Sierra Leone, Egypt and Nigeria.

Tom Watson, then Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State at the Ministry of Defence, was instrumental in including this in the Act. He was said to have acted having met the relatives of Private Farr.

However section 359(4) states that the pardon "does not affect any conviction or sentence." Since the nature of a pardon is normally to commute a sentence, Gerald Howarth MP asked during parliamentary debate: "we are entitled to ask what it does do." It would appear to be a symbolic pardon only, and some members of Parliament had called for the convictions to be quashed, although the pardon has still been welcomed by relatives of executed soldiers.

Popular culture

The UK rock group, Stray included the song, "Harry Farr" on their 2009 album, Valhalla. Singer and songwriter Reg Meuross wrote about the execution of Harry Farr in his song, "And Jesus Wept".

The book Shell Shock by Steve Stahl features a character Private Simon Jennings, based on Harry Farr.

See also

• Shot at Dawn Memorial
• Lucien Bersot a French soldier executed by the French Army

References

Works cited

• Babington, Anthony (1997). Shell-shock : A History of the Changing Attitudes to War Neurosis. England: Leo Cooper. ISBN 0-85052-562-4.
• Moore, Darren (2009). The Soldier : a History of Courage, Sacrifice and Brotherhood. London: Icon Books. ISBN 978-184831-079-7.
• Shephard, Ben (2002) [First published by Jonathan Cape in 2000]. A War of Nerves : Soldiers and Psychiatrists 1914-1994. London: Pimlico. ISBN 0-7126-6783-0.
• Tomasini, Floris (2017). Remembering and Disremembering the Dead. United Kingdom: Palgrave MacMillan. ISBN 978-1-137-53828-4.
• Walker, Stephen (2007). Forgotten Soldiers : the Irishmen Shot at Dawn. Great Britain: Gill & Macmillan. ISBN 978-07171-4182-1.
• Wessely, Simon (September 2006). "The Life and Death of Private Harry Farr". Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine. 99 (9): 440–443. doi:10.1258/jrsm.99.9.440. PMC 1557889. PMID 16946385.{{cite journal}}: CS1 maint: PMC format (link)

Further reading

• BBC News
• Articles in the Eastern Daily Press (17 August 2006)
• Hansard

External links

• Soldat fusillé pour l'exemple (in French)