Jump to content

Battle of Carham

Coordinates: 55°38′13″N 2°19′15″W / 55.63694°N 2.32083°W / 55.63694; -2.32083
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This is an old revision of this page, as edited by Dudley Miles (talk | contribs) at 08:24, 17 October 2022 (Deleted irrelevant quotes from ASC in 1016 and clarified view of Woolf). The present address (URL) is a permanent link to this revision, which may differ significantly from the current revision.

Battle of Carham
Date1018
Location
River Tweed
Result Scottish victory
Belligerents
Earldom of Northumbria Kingdom of Scotland
Kingdom of Strathclyde
Commanders and leaders
Uhtred the Bold King Malcolm II
Owen the Bald

The Battle of Carham (c. 1018) was fought between the Kingdom of Scotland and the Northumbrians at Carham on Tweed. Uhtred, son of Waltheof of Bamburgh (or his brother Eadwulf), fought the combined forces of Malcolm II of Scotland and Owen the Bald (King of Strathclyde). Their combined forces defeated Earl Uhtred's forces, determining the eastern border of Scotland at the River Tweed.[1]

Written records of the battle

Sources for the battle are scarce. Those that do mention the battle often include it in a survey of other events. The Anglo-Saxon Chronicle does not mention it.[2]

King Malcolm and Owen grouped together "near Caddonlea (Selkirkshire) […] where the Wedale road from Alba met the Tweeddale road from Strathclyde, lay at the northern edge of Ettrick Forest (roughly corresponding to Selkirkshire in extent) which formed a march between Cumbria and Northumbria."[3] Uhtred's forces intercepted them before they crossed Cheviot. This interception meant that he did not have enough time to gather enough troops.[4] Another source, De obsessione Dunelmi ("On the Siege of Durham"), places the battle under the 1018 annal listing Uhtred as the Northumbrian army.[5]

Dating controversy

Symeon of Durham (12th Century), using dependable Northumbrian materials, located the year of the battle in 1018 ("without mention of Uhtred") in the Historia Dunelmensis Ecclesie.[6] His record of a comet's visibility 30 days before the battle correlates with astronomical evidence from August 1018.[7] Stenton mentions the comet but dismisses it on the grounds that the Anglo-Saxon Chronicle dates the death of Earl Uhtred to 1016.[8]

Stenton and C. Plummer argue that the earlier date of the battle used the 1016 annal's inclusion of Uhtred's death.[9] Duncan argues and Woolf supports that the mention is an aside from the scribe recording in 1018 or 1019.[10] De Obsessione Dunelmi (c. 1165) supports Duncan's theory that the Anglo-Saxon Chronicle scribe is discussing the more recent death of Uhtred as it places his death following the events outlined in the English source under the 1018 annal.[11] Woolf argues that 1018 is more likely and that the Northumbrian leader was most likely Uhtred but just possible his brother Eadwulf.[12]

Significance

The battle's significance is a matter of controversy, especially in regard to the region of Lothian. Scottish historians claim Lothian was won for Scotland at Carham and that Scotland's borders were expanded as a result; Marjorie O. Anderson argues that the English king Edgar the Peaceful granted Lothian to Kenneth II of Scotland, King of Scots, in 973.[13] In English sources, the Battle of Carham is not given any special significance.[14] Still others, such as G.W.S. Barrow hold, that "What English annalists recorded as the 'cession' of Lothian was... the recognition by a powerful but extremely remote south-country king of a long-standing fait accompli."[14]

The Scots' possession of what now constitutes the south-east of Scotland seems to have been recognized by kings of England, even when kings such as Cnut and William the Conqueror invaded, as they did not seek permanent control of the area.

Aftermath

After the battle of Carham, much of present-day Scotland was under the control of the King of Scots, although Norsemen still held sway in Ross, Caithness, Sutherland, and The Isles. The Lords of Galloway remained semi-independent. Scotland or Scotia referred to what constitutes present-day Scotland north of the Forth and Clyde; it was not until the time of King David I of Scotland, citizens in the south-east of the kingdom began to think of themselves as Scots. In his own charters (e.g. to St Cuthbert's in Edinburgh), he continued to refer to the men of Lothian as English. Woolf asserts that "the likelihood is that these are under representative glimpses of a much longer conflict which escaped the detailed gaze of our chroniclers because far more interesting things were happening in Southumbria and Ireland at the time."[15]

Carham 1018 Society

The society's mission statement is "to investigate, raise awareness, and commemorate the Battle of Carham."[16] The society's website provides dates for "public meetings, commemorative events, and future plans" as well as excerpts from articles and archaeological findings pertaining to the battle.[16]

References

  1. ^ Mack, p. 6
  2. ^ Whitelock, pp. 248-251
  3. ^ Woolf, A., The New Edinburgh History of Scotland Vol. 2: From Pictland To Alba 789-1070, Edinburgh UP, 2007, p. 238
  4. ^ Woolf, p. 238
  5. ^ The full title is De obsessione Dunelmi et de probitate Uhtredi comitis, et de comitibus qui ei successerunt ("On the siege of Durham, and the character of Earl Uhtred, and the earls who succeeded him"); Translated by Christopher J. Morris, Marriage and Murder.
  6. ^ Duncan, A.A.M., "The Battle of Carham, 1018" The Scottish Historical Review, Vol. 55, No. 159, 1976, p. 21
  7. ^ Woolf, p. 27
  8. ^ Stenton, Frank (1971). Anglo-Saxon England 3rd Edition. Oxford UP. p. 418.
  9. ^ Stenton, p. 418; Plummer, C. Two of the Saxon Chronicles Parallel, Oxford, 1892, 154-5.
  10. ^ Duncan, p. 25; Woolf, p. 27
  11. ^ Morris, p. 3.
  12. ^ Woolf, pp. 236-237
  13. ^ Anderson, M.O. (1980). Kings and Kingship in Early Scotland. Scottish Academic Press.
  14. ^ a b G.W.S. Barrow
  15. ^ Woolf, 239
  16. ^ a b "Welcome | Carham 1018 Society". www.carham1018.org.uk. Retrieved 4 September 2020.

References

  • Anderson, M.O. (1980). Kings and Kingship in Early Scotland. Scottish Academic Press.
  • Carham Society of 1018 (2015)
  • De obsessione Dunelmi et de probitate Uhtredi comitis, et de comitibus qui ei successerunt ("On the siege of Durham, and the character of Earl Uhtred, and the earls who succeeded him"), C. J. Morris. (1992) in Marriage and Murder in 11th Century Northumbria: A Study of De Obsessione Dunelmi. University of York.
  • Duncan, A.A.M., "The Battle of Carham, 1018" The Scottish Historical Review, Vol. 55, No. 159, 1976
  • Mack, Logan, (1924) "The Border Line - Solway Firth to the North Sea", Oliver & Boyd.
  • Plummer, C. Two of the Saxon Chronicles Parallel, Oxford, 1892.
  • Stenton, Frank (1971). Anglo-Saxon England, 3rd ed. Oxford UP.
  • Whitelock, Dorothy, ed. (1979) [1st edition 1955]. English Historical Documents, Volume 1, c. 500–1042 (2nd ed.). London, UK: Routledge. ISBN 978-0-415-14366-0.
  • Woolf, A. (2007) The New Edinburgh History of Scotland Vol. 2: From Pictland To Alba 789-1070, Edinburgh UP.

Further reading

  • Daly, Rannoch (2018). Birth of the Border: The Battle of Carham 1018 AD. Alnwick: Wanney Books. ISBN 978-1-9997905-5-4
  • McGuigan, Neil; Woolf, Alex, eds. (2018). The Battle of Carham: A Thousand Years On. Edinburgh: John Donald. ISBN 978-1910900246.

55°38′13″N 2°19′15″W / 55.63694°N 2.32083°W / 55.63694; -2.32083

Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Battle_of_Carham&oldid=1116579437"