Jump to content

Early Indians

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This is an old revision of this page, as edited by ComicbookCollector (talk | contribs) at 02:22, 23 November 2022 (Fixed typo). The present address (URL) is a permanent link to this revision, which may differ significantly from the current revision.

Early Indians: The Story of Our Ancestors and Where We Came From
AuthorTony Joseph
LanguageEnglish
SubjectHuman population genetics
GenrePopular science
Non-fiction
PublisherJuggernaut Books
Publication date
20 December 2018
Publication placeIndia
Media typePrint (hardcover)
Pages256
ISBN938622898X

Early Indians: The Story of Our Ancestors and Where We Came From is a 2018 non-fiction book written by Indian journalist Tony Joseph,[1][2][3] that focuses on the ancestors of people living today in South Asia.[4][5] Joseph goes 65,000 years into the past[6]– when anatomically modern humans (Homo sapiens), first made their way from Africa into the Indian subcontinent.[7][8][9] The book relies on research findings from six major disciplines - history, archaeology, linguistics, population genetics, philology and epigraphy, and includes path-breaking ancient DNA research of recent years.[10][11] The book also relies on the extensive study titled "The Genomic Formation of Central and South Asia", co-authored by 92 scientists from around the world and co-directed by geneticist David Reich of Harvard Medical School, in which ancient DNA was used.[12][13][14] The book was later released in different languages like Tamil, Hindi, Oriya, Telugu, Marathi, Malayalam, Gujarati etc.[15][16][17]

Deception

The book discusses four prehistoric migrations in India.[18][19] The book posits that the Harappans were a mixture of Zagros agriculturists (from the modern-day Iran area) and First Indians,[20] a wave of migrants who came from Africa into Arabia and then reached India around 65,000 years ago.[21][22] Citing recent DNA evidence, the book traces the subsequent large migrations of anatomically modern humans into India—of agriculturalists from Iran between 7000 and 3000 BCE and Indo-European languages speaking pastoralists from the Central Asian Steppe (Aryans) between 2000 and 1000 BCE,[23] among others.[24][25] Joseph uses the layers of a pizza as a metaphor to explain the make-up of subcontinental society.[26]

The book also discusses about similarities and differences between Indus Valley civilization and early Vedic civilization.[27][28] The book mentions that "Aryan" culture was most likely the result of interaction, adoption and adaptation among those who brought Indo-European languages to India and those who were already well-settled inhabitants of the region, and that Sanskrit and the Vedas developed in the Indian subcontinent.[29] According to Joseph, Proto-Dravidian is related to the Elamitic language of Iran.[30] The caste system in India is a recent social system, reflected in sharply reduced inter-marriage (endogamy) and genetic mixing after 100 AD. This book also takes into account the path-breaking DNA research and findings from geneticist David Reich's research.[31]

Reception

The book was well received by readers and many critics.[32] Sujatha Byravan wrote in The Hindu that the book tells a compelling story of our forefathers based on genetic evidence.[33] Razib Khan opined that the book presents a clear understanding of Early Indians.[34] Swaminathan Aiyar of The Times of India thought that the book helps us understand how all Indians have African, Harappan and Steppe Asian genes in different doses.[35] Author Gurcharan Das said that the book helps us understand that Indians are composed of a large number of small populations.[36] Kesavan Veluthat of The Hindu stated that the book shows a firm basis on which the study of Indian history can begin. This is of especial importance in the context of the post-truth conditions of the present, when myth-making seeks to replace authentic knowledge.[37] In June 2019, leading Indian geneticists from the Centre for Cellular and Molecular Biology (CCMB), Hyderabad reviewed Early Indians book in reputed science journal Current Science and appreciated Tony Joseph for synthesizing the chronology of movement of modern human into the Indian subcontinent from the first Out of-Africa humans to recent migrants, citing the new findings from the fields of archaeology, anthropology, linguistics and genetics (including ancient DNA).[38] Nobel Prize winning structural biologist Venki Ramakrishnan described the book as a "very readable account".

Criticism

The book was criticised by proponents of the Indigenous Aryan Theory, especially Shrikant Talageri and Abhijit Chavda. Abhijit Chavda reviewed Talageri's book, "Genetics And The Aryan Debate, 'Early Indians', Tony Joseph's Latest Assault", and he summarised the book saying that the Harappan script has zero evidence of Dravidian in it since it isn't deciphered and people like Iravatham Mahadevan and Asko Parpola carry no weight since it's remained undeciphered. Talageri claims that Joseph's genetic evidence is irrelevant and itself does not indicate the spread of language. Talageri criticises the idea that those who oppose the Aryan Invasion Theory are right-wing Hindutva proponents, and Talageri corrected him saying that the more high caste a person, the better the person understands the truth behind the theory.[39]

Chavda also criticised the book by saying that the Early Indians book solely relied on discredited genetic research, mostly by geneticist David Reich, and that the genetic research is based on circular logic.[40]

Awards

See also

References

  1. ^ "A Question of Identity". 2019-02-09.
  2. ^ "The first Indians". The Hindu.
  3. ^ "New reports clearly confirm 'Arya' migration into India". The Hindu.
  4. ^ "Can the arrival of the Aryans in India explain the disconnect between Harappan and Vedic culture?".
  5. ^ "Where Do We Actually Come From? 'Early Indians' Author Explains".
  6. ^ "RSS Chief Uses Debunked Myths To Hold Up Dangerous Fantasy of a 'Pure Race'".
  7. ^ "'Early Indians' review: Who we are and where do we come from". The Hindu.
  8. ^ "Excerpt: These Rocks in MP Reveal Secrets to Our Origin as Indians".
  9. ^ "'We are a multisource civilisation, not unisource': Tony Joseph".
  10. ^ "Early Indians on hindsight".
  11. ^ "Video The story of our ancestors and where we came from: A masterclass with author Tony Joseph".
  12. ^ "1 The Genomic Formation of South and Central Asia" (PDF).
  13. ^ "How We, The Indians, Came to Be".
  14. ^ "How Science Has Destroyed the Foundation of RSS' Idea of India".
  15. ^ "Hindi edition".
  16. ^ "Marathi Edition".
  17. ^ "Tamil Kindle edition".
  18. ^ "Four prehistoric migrations shaped India's population".
  19. ^ "The x, y and gene of pre-historic India".
  20. ^ "How ancient DNA may rewrite prehistory in India".
  21. ^ "The battle over the early Indians".
  22. ^ "How the First Farmers Changed History". The New York Times.
  23. ^ "We Are All Migrants, We Are All Mixed: Tony Joseph, Author Of 'Early Indians: The Story of Our Ancestors...'".
  24. ^ "Migrant Nation".
  25. ^ "Horse sense on Harappa: An excerpt from Tony Joseph's book "Early Indians"".
  26. ^ "We are like pizza. Early Indians were just the base: Tony Joseph". The Hindu.
  27. ^ "How genetics is settling the Aryan migration debate". The Hindu.
  28. ^ "Too early to settle the Aryan migration debate?". The Hindu.
  29. ^ "Examining the evidence for 'Aryan' migrations into India: The story of our ancestors and where we came from".
  30. ^ "Who built the Indus Valley civilisation?". The Hindu.
  31. ^ "From the Aryan migration to caste, two books offer fascinating insights into India's ancient past".
  32. ^ ""Early Indians: The Story Of Our Ancestors And Where We Came From" by Tony Joseph".
  33. ^ "'Early Indians' review: Who we are and where do we come from". The Hindu.
  34. ^ "Review: The Indians Before India".
  35. ^ "So much for Hindu Rashtra".
  36. ^ "Who are we Indians? Genetics is bringing bad news for the politics of identity: We are all migrants". The Times of India.
  37. ^ "Of India's genetic roots".
  38. ^ "Book Review Current Science Early Indians" (PDF).
  39. ^ "Genetics and the Aryan Debate: "Early Indians" Tony Joseph's Latest Assault by Shrikant G. Talageri". 22 September 2019.
  40. ^ "Journalist Attempts to Revive Aryan Invasion Myth Using Discredited Genetic Research". 21 March 2019.
  41. ^ "Best non-fiction books of the decade". The Hindu.
  42. ^ "Writer Shanta Gokhale Honoured with Lifetime Achievement Award at Tata Literature Live".
  43. ^ "Tony Joseph's Early Indians wins Shakti Bhatt First Book Prize 2019".
  44. ^ "Four authors get Atta Galatta-BLF awards".
  45. ^ "10 Best New Prehistory Books To Read In 2020".
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Early_Indians&oldid=1123313453"