This is a table of the overall win-loss-tie records for the Wranglers against certain opponents. Teams in italics are no longer members of the ECHL. Some franchises have moved over the years, and records against franchises which have since moved are combined. Records in the playoffs are also included in the overall win-loss-tie records presented. The Wranglers have the most success against the Phoenix Roadrunners and the least success against the Reading Royals. Of the other 18 teams in the current 19-team ECHL, the Wranglers have never played against teams in Charlotte, Charleston (SC), Duluth (GA), or Elmira (NY). The Wranglers have only played against Cincinnati during the 2008 Kelly Cup Finals.
Note that any overtime losses in the regular season are declared as if they were tie games, since they are worth one (1) point in team standings.
1. Previously known as the Texas Wildcatters (4 games, 3-1-0)
2. Previously known as the Atlantic City Boardwalk Bullies (3 games, 1-1-1).
3. Previously known as the Toledo Storm before the team suspended operations in 2007 in order to construct new arena. All eight games were played before the name change.
4. Team changed its nickname to Devils in 2007 to reflect new ownership.