Lord Howe's action, or the Glorious First of June

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search
Lord Howe's action, or the Glorious First of June
Loutherbourg, The Glorious First of June.jpg
Artist Philippe-Jacques de Loutherbourg
Year 1795
Type Oil on canvas
Dimensions 266.5 cm × 373.5 cm (104.9 in × 147.0 in)
Location Queen's House (NMM), London

Lord Howe's action, or the Glorious First of June is a 1795 painting by Philippe-Jacques de Loutherbourg of the victory of British naval forces under Lord Howe over a French force led by Louis Thomas Villaret de Joyeuse on the Glorious First of June 1794. After time in the Royal Collection of George IV, it is currently in the collection of the National Maritime Museum and on display in the ground floor of its Queen's House, in place of Turner's The Battle of Trafalgar (whilst the latter is on long-term foreign loan).

History[edit]

The painting was commissioned by V. and R. Green and Christian von Mechel, engravers and publishers, for £500. They had in 1793 commissioned the equally large "The Siege of Valenciennes" from him, and this painting of the naval battle was intended to accompany it. Both paintings were intended for engraving (prints of them were produced by James Fittler, with 'Glorious First' coming out in January 1799[1] and 'Valenciennes' in 1801) and public exhibition (from 2 March 1795 at the Historic Gallery, Pall Mall, thus garnering interest for the images' publication, and on tour after their sale to Mr T. Vernon of Liverpool in 1799). James Gillray, as with Louthebourg's 'Valenciennes', gave Louthebourg help with painting the figures (Gillray had accompanied the army carrying out the siege).

Shown at Edinburgh in 1800, Vernon later sold them separately, with the 'Valenciennes' eventually finishing up in Lord Hesketh's collection at Easton Neston. The 'Glorious First' was purchased early in the 19th century for the Royal Collection by the Prince of Wales, who displayed it at St James's Palace and - after his accession to the throne in 1820 - commissioned JMW Turner's The Battle of Trafalgar as a pendant for it. However, Turner's piece was criticised for perceived factual inaccuracies, and so George gave both the 'Trafalgar' and 'Glorious First' to the Naval Gallery at Greenwich Hospital in 1829 as one of his last gifts to them.

Description[edit]

A ship model of the Montagne
The signal flag "S"
The French Revolutionary ensign until May 1794

In the centre are the two flagships are depicted fighting each other; HMS Queen Charlotte is to the left and Montagne to the right, with bodies falling from the gunports of the latter. The pair did engage during the battle, but never in the broadside position shown in the painting, and Queen Charlotte only lost her fore-topmast whilst already well astern of the Montagne, rather than during a broadside engagement shown here. This wrongly makes it appear that Queen Charlotte dropped behind Montagne due to the loss of this mast and thus failed to capture her, and led to criticism of the painting by Lord Howe and by James Bowen (Howe's Master of the Fleet, and a hero of the battle) - Bowen commented that Queen Charlotte would have captured Montagne if such a broadside engagement as shown had occurred in reality and that the painting was thus a slur on the Queen Charlotte's honour.

In the extreme right is the port bow of an English ship (probably HMS Brunswick), behind which is another French ship (flying, like the Montagne, the signal flag S from one of her masts), whilst in the left foreground is shown the port side of the 74 gun Vengeur du Peuple, sinking after a long and fatal duel with the Brunswick, and beyond Vengeur are other ships' topsails, just showing above the smoke of battle.

The French ships are shown flying the early Revolutionary naval ensign (with the French tricolour added to the upper quadrant of the Bourbon white naval ensign), the only major action the French fleet fought under it. It had officially been replaced by the new (and current) tricolour in May 1794, but the new pattern had not arrived when Villaret-Joyeuse's ships sailed.

Analysis[edit]

Though the accuracy as regards the French ensign and Loutherbourg's detailed preparatory sketches[2] show the artist's great care over the detail, the matter of the central duel and its departure from literal historical truth shows how the painting is more a Romantic treatment of the battle than a literally documentary one, though such departures did not attract such widespread criticism as Turner's did in Trafalgar. Attempts are being made by four English boats to rescue the Vengeur's crew, who are shown clinging to their ship's spars and to other wreckage blasted off other ships right across the foreground. Both sides are shown heroically fighting the sea itself as well as each other, intensifying both and giving the event drama as well as human scale, as well as showing the British sailor as compassionate to his defeated enemy. Compared to Turner's later pendant, the painting is an unequivocally heroic image and its overall style is conventionally patriotic.

References[edit]

  1. ^ A copy of the print of 'Glorious First' at the British Museum
  2. ^ Detailed studies of the 'Queen Charlotte' (here, here, here, here, and here), along with an overall compositional sketch, are now in the British Museum.

External links[edit]