Jump to content

On Bullshit

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This is an old revision of this page, as edited by Damenleeturks (talk | contribs) at 17:36, 22 July 2022 (→See also: adding link to Twain essay). The present address (URL) is a permanent link to this revision, which may differ significantly from the current revision.

On Bullshit
AuthorHarry G. Frankfurt
LanguageEnglish
GenrePhilosophy
PublisherPrinceton University Press
Publication date
2005
Media typePrint
ISBN978-0691122946

On Bullshit is a 2005 book (originally a 1986 essay) by American philosopher Harry G. Frankfurt which presents a theory of bullshit that defines the concept and analyzes the applications of bullshit in the context of communication. Frankfurt determines that bullshit is speech intended to persuade without regard for truth. The liar cares about the truth and attempts to hide it; the bullshitter doesn't care if what they say is true or false, but cares only whether the listener is persuaded.[1] Frankfurt's philosophical analysis of bullshit has been analyzed, criticized and adopted by academics since its publication.[2]

Harry G. Frankfurt

History

Frankfurt originally published the essay "On Bullshit" in the Raritan Quarterly Review journal in 1986. Nineteen years later, the essay was published as the book On Bullshit (2005), which proved popular among lay readers; the book appeared for 27 weeks on The New York Times Best Seller list,[3] and was discussed on the television show The Daily Show With Jon Stewart,[4][5] as well as in an interview with a representative of the publisher, Princeton University Press.[6][7] On Bullshit served as the basis for Frankfurt's follow-up book On Truth (2006).

Summary

Frankfurt is a professional philosopher, trained in analytical philosophy. When asked why he decided to focus on bullshit, he explained:

Respect for the truth and a concern for the truth are among the foundations for civilization. I was for a long time disturbed by the lack of respect for the truth that I observed... bullshit is one of the deformities of these values.[8]

His book On Bullshit addresses his concern and makes a distinction between "bullshitters" and liars. He concludes that bullshitters are more insidious: they are more of a threat against the truth than are liars.[8]

Humbug and bullshit

Frankfurt begins his work on bullshit by presenting an explanation and examination of Max Black's concept of humbug.[9] Black's essay on humbug and Frankfurt's book on bullshit are similar. Both focus on understanding, defining and explaining their respective concepts whilst using examples. Frankfurt focuses on humbug as he believes it is similar to bullshit but is the more respectful term. Frankfurt uses Black's work on humbug to break down the description of humbug into defining factors: "deceptive misrepresentation",[10] "short of lying”[11] and "misrepresentation... of somebody's own thoughts, feelings, or attitudes."[12] Frankfurt's analysis enables him to distinguish the difference between humbug and lying. The main distinction is the intent that motivates them. The intent behind humbug is misrepresentation whilst the intent behind lying is more extreme, intending to cover the truth. The comparison of humbug to lying acts as an initial introduction to bullshit. Humbug is closely related to bullshit, but Frankfurt believes it is inadequate to explain bullshit and its characteristics.[13]

Lying and bullshit

Frankfurt's book focuses heavily on defining and discussing the difference between lying and bullshit. The main difference between the two is intent and deception. Both people who are lying and people who are telling the truth are focused on the truth. The liar wants to steer people away from discovering the truth and the person telling the truth wants to present the truth. The bullshitter differs from both liars and people presenting the truth with their disregard of the truth. Frankfurt explains how bullshitters or people who are bullshitting are distinct as they are not focused on the truth. In his book, Frankfurt[13] defines: shit, bull session and bull. This is done in a lexicographical manner which breaks down the word bullshit and examines each component. The components of the word bullshit highlights the corresponding terms that encompass the overall meaning of the word bullshit: useless, insignificance and nonsense.[13]

Next, Frankfurt focuses on the complete word, and its implications and acceptance. He presents an example of advice provided to a child from his father which encourages choosing bullshit over lying when possible.[14] Frankfurt gives two reasons for the different levels of consequences between bullshit and lying. First, the liar is viewed as being purposefully deceitful or harmful because of the accompanying intent behind the act. Second, the person who bullshits lacks the kind of intention characteristic of the liar. Producing bullshit requires no knowledge of the truth. The liar is intentionally avoiding the truth and the bullshitter may potentially be telling the truth or providing elements of the truth without the intention of doing so.[15] Frankfurt believes bullshitters and the growing acceptance of bullshit is more harmful to society than liars and lying. This is because liars actively consider the truth when they conceal it whilst bullshitters completely disregard the truth. "Bullshit is a greater enemy of the truth than lies are."[1] Frankfurt believes that while bullshit may be tolerated more, it is much more harmful.

Rise of bullshit

Frankfurt concludes his book by discussing the rise of bullshit.[13] He does not argue that there is more bullshit in society now than there was in the past. He explains that all forms of communications have increased leading to more bullshit being seen, read and heard. He states that the social expectation for individuals to have and express their opinions on all matters requires more bullshit.[16] Despite a lack of knowledge on a subject matter, for example politics, religion or art, there is an expectation to participate in the conversation and provide an opinion. This opinion is likely to be bullshit at times as it is not based on fact and research. The opinion is motivated by a disregard of the truth with a desire to appear knowledgeable or adequately opinionated. Frankfurt acknowledges that bullshitting may not always be intentional but believes that ultimately it is performed with a disregard and carelessness of the truth.[17] Frankfurt argues that this rise in bullshit is dangerous as it accepts and enables a growing disregard of the truth.

Reception and criticisms

The responses to Frankfurt's work have varied greatly. Since the publication it has been discussed, adapted, praised and criticized.[18] It has received a positive reception by many academics,[19] is considered remarkable by some,[20] and its popularity amongst the public is evident with its status as a best seller for many weeks.[21] His work has also received criticisms. One of the main criticisms has been that the work is overly simplistic[19] and too narrow:[22] that the book does not acknowledge the many dynamic factors involved in communication, or the dynamic nature of truth.[19] This criticism also explains that the work is limited in its analysis of other motives and forms of bullshit aside from one stemming from a lack of concern for the truth.[22] One critic notes that the book does not mention, or dismisses, the audience's ability to detect bullshit:[18] that Frankfurt's explanation of bullshit presents a narrative where bullshit goes unnoticed or is easily excusable by its audience.[23] Another critic points to the book's failure to rewrite the original essay to include an acknowledgement or discussion of criticism and accounting for any of the new developments and ideas within psychology and philosophy for the publication of his book.[24]

Despite all these criticisms, as previously mentioned, the work is popular and has received a positive reception. Anthropologist and anarchist David Graeber refers to Frankfurt's text in his 2018 book Bullshit Jobs.

See also

Bibliography

References

  1. ^ a b On Bullshit (2005), by Harry Frankfurt. p. 61.
  2. ^ Fredal, James (2011). "Rhetoric and Bullshit". College English. 73 (3): 243–259. JSTOR 25790474. Retrieved 8 October 2020.
  3. ^ Wallace, Niamh (2005-10-11), On College, Bullshit, and Love, UWM Post, archived from the original on 2016-03-06, retrieved 2008-08-11
  4. ^ Frankfurt, Harry G. (2005-03-14), The Daily Show
  5. ^ Blessing, Kimberly; Marren, Joseph (2013), "More Bullshit: Political Spin and the PR-ization of Media", in Holt, Jason (ed.), The Ultimate Daily Show and Philosophy: More Moments of Zen, More Indecision Theory, Malden, MA: Wiley-Blackwell, pp. 139–1154, ISBN 978-1118397688
  6. ^ Frankfurt, Harry G. (January 2005), "On Bullshit (Part 1; 6m12s): A Conversation with Harry G. Frankfurt", youtube.com, Princeton University Press, retrieved July 16, 2017. Interview conducted by Ben Tate, Director of Subsidiary Rights, Princeton University Press
  7. ^ Frankfurt, Harry G. (January 2005), "On Bullshit (Part 2; 5m20s): A Conversation with Harry G. Frankfurt", youtube.com, Princeton University Press, archived from the original on 2021-12-21, retrieved July 16, 2017. Interview conducted by Ben Tate, Director of Subsidiary Rights, Princeton University Press
  8. ^ a b "On Bullshit Part 1 - YouTube". www.youtube.com. Retrieved 2020-11-19.
  9. ^ Black, Max (1983). The Prevalence of Humbug and Other Essays. New York: Cornell University Press. ISBN 978-0801415142.
  10. ^ Frankfurt, Harry (2005). On Bullshit. New Jersey: Princeton University Press. p. 6. ISBN 978-0691122946.
  11. ^ Frankfurt, Harry (2005). On Bullshit. New Jersey: Princeton University Press. p. 9. ISBN 978-0691122946.
  12. ^ Frankfurt, Harry (2005). On Bullshit. New Jersey: Princeton University Press. p. 12. ISBN 978-0691122946.
  13. ^ a b c d Frankfurt, Harry (2005). On Bullshit. New Jersey: Princeton University Press. ISBN 978-0691122946.
  14. ^ Frankfurt, Harry (2005). On Bullshit. New Jersey: Princeton University Press. p. 48. ISBN 978-0691122946.
  15. ^ "Harry Frankfurt on Bullshit And Lying". ieet.org. Retrieved 2020-11-02.
  16. ^ Frankfurt, Harry (2005). On Bullshit. New Jersey: Princeton University Press. p. 63. ISBN 978-0691122946.
  17. ^ Frankfurt, Harry (2005). On Bullshit. New Jersey: Princeton University Press. p. 65. ISBN 978-0691122946.
  18. ^ a b Fredal, James (2011). "Rhetoric and Bullshit". College English. 73 (3): 243–259. ISSN 0010-0994. JSTOR 25790474.
  19. ^ a b c Perla, Rocco J.; Carifio, James (2007-06-01). "Psychological, Philosophical, and Educational Criticisms of Harry Frankfurt's Concept of and Views about "Bullshit" in Human Discourse, Discussions, and Exchanges". Interchange. 38 (2): 119–136. doi:10.1007/s10780-007-9019-y. ISSN 1573-1790. S2CID 59444691.
  20. ^ Holt, Jim (15 August 2005). "Say Anything". The New Yorker. Retrieved 2020-11-02.
  21. ^ Frankfurt, Harry G. (2005). On Bullshit. ISBN 978-0691122946.
  22. ^ a b Johnson, Andrew (2010-07-01). "A New Take on Deceptive Advertising: Beyond Frankfurt's Analysis of 'BS'". Business and Professional Ethics Journal. 29 (1/4): 5–32. doi:10.5840/bpej2010291/43. Retrieved 2020-11-02.
  23. ^ Fredal, James (2011). "Rhetoric and Bullshit". College English. 73 (3): 250. JSTOR 25790474 – via JSTOR.
  24. ^ Perla, Rocco; Carifio, James (2007). "Psychological, Philosophical, and Educational Criticisms of Harry Frankfurt's Concept of and Views about "Bullshit" in Human Discourse, Discussions, and Exchanges". Interchange. 38 (2): 132. doi:10.1007/s10780-007-9019-y. S2CID 59444691 – via Springer Link.

Further reading

  • Blessing, Kimberly A.; Marren, Joseph J. (2007). "Bullshit and Political Spin: Is the Medium the Massage?". In Holt, Jason (ed.). The Daily Show and Philosophy: Moments of Zen in the Art of Fake News. Malden, MA: Blackwell. pp. 133–145. ISBN 978-1405163149.
  • Penny, Laura (2005). Your Call Is Important to US: The Truth About Bullshit. Toronto: McClelland & Stewart. ISBN 978-0771070426.
  • Pfeifer, Karl (Summer 2006). "On Bullshit". Book Reviews. Dialogue. 45 (3): 617–620. doi:10.1017/S0012217300001189. S2CID 170243037.Verbatim preprint archived here: [1]
  • Sneddon, Andrew (2007). "Bullshitting Bullshitters and the Bullshit They Say". In Holt, Jason (ed.). The Daily Show and Philosophy: Moments of Zen in the Art of Fake News. Malden, MA: Blackwell. pp. 146–157. ISBN 978-1405163149.
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=On_Bullshit&oldid=1099803958"