Oxhide ingot
Oxhide ingots are heavy (20-30 kg) metal slabs, usually of copper but sometimes of tin, produced and widely distributed during the Mediterranean Late Bronze Age (LBA). Their shape resembles the hide of an ox with a protruding handle in each of the ingot’s four corners. Early thought was that each ingot was equivalent to the value of one ox.[1]: 138 However, the similarity in shape is simply a coincidence. The ingots' producers probably designed these protrusions to make the ingots easily transportable overland on the backs of pack animals.[1]: 140 Complete or partial oxhide ingots have been discovered in Sardinia, Crete, Peloponnese, Cyprus, Cannatello in Sicily, Boğazköy in Turkey (ancient Hattusa, the Hittite capital), Qantir in Egypt (ancient Pi-Ramesses), and Sozopol in Bulgaria.[2][3] Archaeologists have recovered many oxhide ingots from two shipwrecks off the coast of Turkey (one off Uluburun and one in Cape Gelidonya).
Context
The appearance of oxhide ingots in the archaeological record corresponds with the beginning of the bulk copper trade in the Mediterranean—approximately 1600 BC.[4]: 281 The earliest oxhide ingots found come from Crete and date to the Late Minoan IB, approximately 1500 BC to 1450 BC.[5]: 322 The latest oxhide ingots date to approximately 1000 BC, and were found on Sardinia.[4]: 283 The copper trade was largely maritime: the principal sites where oxhide ingots are found are at sea, on the coast, and on islands.[1]: 138
Purposes
It is uncertain whether the oxhide ingots served as a form of currency. Ingots found in excavations at Mycenae are now part of the exhibits of the Numismatic Museum of Athens. Cemal Pulak argues that the weights of the Uluburun ingots are similar enough to have allowed "a rough but quick reckoning of a given quantity of raw metal prior to weighing".[1]: 138 But George Bass proposes, via the Gelidonya ingots, whose weights are approximately the same if somewhat lower than the Uluburun ingot weights, that the weights were not standard and thus the ingots were not a currency.[6]: 70 Another theory is that the oxhide shape, as well as the bun shape that some ingots took, was a visual statement that the ingot at hand is part of a legitimate trade.[1]: 138 In Sardinia, oxhide ingot fragments have been found in hoards with bun ingots and scrap metal and, in some cases, in a metallurgical workshop.[7] Citing this evidence, Vasiliki Kassianidou argues that the oxhide ingots "were meant to be used rather than to be kept as prestige goods".[7]
Major finds
Uluburun shipwreck
In 1982, a diver discovered a shipwreck off the shore of Uluburun, Turkey.[8] The ship contained 317 copper ingots in the normal oxhide shape, 36 with only two corner protrusions, 121 shaped like buns, and five shaped like pillows.[9]: 276 [1]: 141 [10]: 2 The oxhide ingots (ingots with two or four protrusions) range in weight from 20.1 to 29.5 kilograms (44 to 65 lb) after being cleaned of their corrosion.[1]: 141 These ingots were found stacked in four rows following a herringbone pattern.[1]: 140 The smooth sides of the ingots faced downwards, and the lowest layer rested on brushwood.[1]: 140–141 There are three whole tin oxhide ingots, and there are many tin ingots cut into quarters or halves, with their corner protrusion(s) still intact.[1]: 150–151 Besides metal ingots, the cargo included ivory, metal jewelry, and Mycenaean, Cypriot, and Canaanite pottery.[9]: 274 Tree-ring dating of firewood from the ship gives an approximate date of 1300 BC.[1]: 137 More than 160 copper oxhide ingots, 62 bun ingots, and some of the tin oxhide ingots have incised marks typically on their rough sides.[1]: 146 Some of these marks—resembling fish, oars, and boats—relate to the sea, and they were probably incised after casting, when the ingot was received or exported.[1]: 146
Recently Yuval Goren proposed that the ten tons of copper ingots, one ton of tin ingots, and the resin stored in the Canaanite jars aboard the ship were one complete package. The recipients of the copper, tin, and resin would have used these materials for bronze casting through the lost-wax technique.[11]
Cape Gelidonya shipwreck
In the early 1950s, divers found the remains of a shipwreck in Cape Gelidonya, off the coast of Turkey.[6]: 14 The remains included a substantial amount of copper oxhide ingot material: 34 in full, five in half, 12 corners, and 75 kilograms (165 lb) of random fragments.[6]: 52 Twenty-four full copper oxhide ingots have stamps on their centers—usually of a circle containing intersecting lines.[6]: 52 These stamps were likely made when the metal was soft.[6]: 52 In addition, the ship contained numerous complete and incomplete copper bun-shaped ingots, rectangular tin bars, and Cypriot agricultural tools made of scrap bronze.[12][6]: 78 Radiocarbon dating of brushwood from the ship gives an approximate date of 1200 BC.[6]: 168
Composition and microstructure
Typically the copper oxhide ingots are highly pure (approximately 99 weight percent copper) with trace element content of less than one weight percent.[10]: 13 The few tin oxhide ingots that have been available to study are also exceptionally pure.[10]: 16 Microscopic analysis of the Uluburun copper oxhide ingots reveals that they are highly porous.[10]: 4 This feature results from the effervescence of gases as the molten metal cooled.[10]: 4 Slag inclusions are also present.[10]: 6–7 Their existence implies that slag was not fully removed from the smelted metal and thus that the ingots were made from remelted copper.[10]: 12
Macroscopic observation of the Uluburun copper ingots indicates that they were cast through multiple pours; there are distinct layers of metal in each ingot.[1]: 141 Furthermore, the relatively high weight and high purity of the ingots would be difficult to achieve even today in only one pour.[13][4]: 287–288
The porosity of the copper ingots and the natural brittleness of tin suggest that both metal ingots were easy to break.[10]: 19 As Bass et al. proposes, a metalsmith could simply break off a piece of the ingot whenever he liked for a new casting.[6]: 71
Provenance
Controversy has swirled around the provenance of the copper oxhide ingots. Lead isotope analysis (LIA) suggests that the late LBA ingots (that is, after 1250 BC) are composed of Cypriot copper, specifically copper from the Apilki mine and its surrounding area.[14] The Gelidonya ingots' ratios are consistent with Cypriot ores while the Uluburun ingots fall on the periphery of the Cypriot isotopic field.[15] On the other hand, Late Minoan I ingots found on Crete have Paleozoic lead isotope ratios and are more consistent with ore sources in Afghanistan, Iran, or Central Asia.[14] The controversy settles on the validity of LIA. Paul Budd argues that LBA copper is the product of such extensive mixing and recycling that LIA, which works best for metals from a single ore deposit, is unfeasible.[16]
Some scholars worry that the 1250 BC date is too limiting. They note that Cyprus was smelting copper on a large scale in the early LBA and had the potential to export the metal to Crete and other places at this time.[7]: 334 [4]: 292 Furthermore, copper ore is more plentiful on Cyprus than on Sardinia and far more plentiful than on Crete.[5]: 320–321 Archaeologists have discovered numerous Cypriot exports to Sardinia including metalworking tools and prestige metal objects.[17]
Due to the heavy corrosion of tin oxhide ingots and the limited data for lead isotopic studies of tin, the provenance of the tin ingots has been uncertain.[18] The fact that scholars have been unable to pinpoint Bronze Age tin ore deposits compounds this problem.[19]
Molds
A mold for casting an oxhide ingot was discovered in the LBA north palace at Ras Ibn Hani in Syria.[20]: 4 It is made of fine-grained "ramleh", a "shelly" limestone.[20]: 4 Archaeologists found burnt copper droplets around the mold.[20]: 4 In spite of the questionable durability of limestone, Paul Craddock et al. concluded that limestone can be used for casting “large simple shapes” such as oxhide ingots.[20]: 7 Evolution of carbon dioxide from the limestone would damage the metal surface that touched the mold.[20]: 6 Thus, metal objects requiring surface detail could not be produced successfully.[20]: 6
This is not to say that oxhide ingots were normally cast in limestone molds. Using an experimental clay mold, Bass et al. argue that the ingot's smooth side was in contact with the mold while its rough side was exposed to the atmosphere.[6]: 70 The roughness results from the interaction of the atmosphere and the cooling metal.[6]: 70
Bronze stands with oxhide ingot depictions
In the Late Bronze Age, Cyprus produced numerous bronze stands that depicted a man carrying an oxhide ingot. The stands were designed to hold vases, and they were cast through the lost-wax process.[21]: 341, 344 The ingots show the familiar shape of four protruding handles, and the men carry them over their shoulders. These Cypriot stands were exported to Crete and Sardinia, and both islands created similar stands in local bronze workshops.[21]: 351
Egyptian connections
While only one oxhide ingot fragment has been recovered from Egypt (in the context of a LBA smelting workshop), there is a wide array of painted scenes in Egypt that show oxhide ingots. The earliest scene dates to the 15th century BC and the latest scene to the 12th century BC.[6]: 62, 67 The ingots display their typical four protrusions, and red paint (which suggests they are copper) is preserved on them.[6]: 62–67 The captions accompanying the scenes explain that the men who bring the ingots come from the north, specifically Retnu (Syria) and Keftiu (unidentified).[6]: 62–67 They are shown being carried on the shoulders of men, sitting with other goods in storage, or as part of scenes in smelting workshops.[6]: 62–67 In a relief from Karnak, the pharaoh Amenhotep II is seen riding a chariot and spearing an oxhide ingot with five arrows. A laudatory caption emphasizing the pharaoh’s strength accompanies the scene.[6]: 65
Several of the “Amarna letters” dating to the mid-14th century BC refer to hundreds of copper talents—in addition to goods such as elephant tusks and glass ingots—sent from the kingdom of Alashiya to Egypt.[4]: 293 [1]: 140 Some scholars identify Cyprus with Alashiya.[4]: 293 In particular, the Uluburun cargo is similar to the goods that, according to the letters, Alashiya sent to Egypt.[1]: 140
References
- ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p Pulak, Cemal (2000), "The Copper and Tin Ingots from the Late Bronze Age Shipwreck at Uluburun", in Yalçin, Ünsal (ed.), Anatolian Metal I, Bochum: Deutsches Bergbau-Museum, p. 138, ISBN 9783921533796
- ^ Muhly, J.D. (1986). "The Role of Cyprus in the Economy of the Eastern Mediterranean". In Karageorghis, V. (ed.). Acts of the International Archaeological Symposium "Cyprus between the Orient and the Occident" Nicosia, 8-14 Sept. 1985. Nicosia: Department of Antiquities, Cyprus. p. 55–6. ISBN 9789963364077.
- ^ Lo Schiavo, Fulvia (2005). "Oxhide Ingots in the Mediterranean and Central Europe". In Lo Schiavo, Fulvia; et al. (eds.). Archaeometallurgy in Sardinia. Montagnac: Éditions Monique Mergoil. p. 307. ISBN 9782907303958.
- ^ a b c d e f Muhly, J.D.; et al. (1988). "Cyprus, Crete, and Sardinia: Copper Oxhide Ingots and the Bronze Age Metals Trade". Report of the Department of Antiquities, Cyprus, Part 1 (Nicosia) (Report).
- ^ a b Stos-Gale, Zofia A.; Gale, Noël H. (1992). "New Light on the Provenience of the Copper Oxhide Ingots Found on Sardinia". In Tykot, Robert H.; Andrews, Tamsey K. (eds.). Sardinia in the Mediterranean: A Footprint in the Sea. Sheffield: Sheffield Academic Press. ISBN 9781850753865.
- ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o Bass, George F.; Throckmorton, Peter; Taylor, Joan Du Plat; Hennessy, J. B.; Shulman, Alan R.; Buchholz, Hans-Günter (1967). "Cape Gelidonya: A Bronze Age Shipwreck". Transactions of the American Philosophical Society. 57 (8): 1–177. JSTOR 1005978.
- ^ a b c Kassianidou, Vasiliki (2005). "Cypriot Copper in Sardinia: Yet Another Case of Bringing Coals to Newcastle?". In Lo Schiavo, Fulvia; et al. (eds.). Archaeometallurgy in Sardinia. Montagnac: Éditions Monique Mergoil. p. 336. ISBN 9782907303958.
- ^ Cemal Pulak, "The Uluburun Shipwreck," The Ship of Uluburun, trans. Ünsal Yalçin, (Bochum: Deutsches Bergbau-Museum, 2006), 6.
- ^ a b Bass, George F. (1986). "A Bronze Age Shipwreck at Ulu Burun (Kaş): 1984 Campaign". American Journal of Archaeology. 90 (3): 269–296. doi:10.2307/505687. JSTOR 505687. S2CID 192966981.
- ^ a b c d e f g h Hauptmann, Andreas; Maddin, Robert; Prange, Michael (2002). "On the Structure and Composition of Copper and Tin Ingots Excavated from the Shipwreck of Uluburun". Bulletin of the American Schools of Oriental Research. 328 (328): 1–30. doi:10.2307/1357777. JSTOR 1357777. S2CID 163526572.
- ^ Yuval Goren, "International Exchange in the Eastern Mediterranean: Food and Ships, Sealing-Wax and Kings as Seen Under the Petrographic Microscope," Institute of Archaeology Kenyon Lecture, London, 13 Nov. 2008.
- ^ George F. Bass, "Bronze Age Shipwrecks on the Eastern Mediterranean," The Ship of Uluburun, trans. Ünsal Yalçin, (Bochum: Deutsches Bergbau-Museum, 2006), 3.
- ^ Merkel, John (1986). "Ancient Smelting and Casting of Copper for 'Oxhide' Ingots". In Balmuth, Miriam S. (ed.). Studies in Sardinian Archaeology. Vol. II. Ann Arbor: The University of Michigan Press. p. 260. ISBN 9780472100811.
- ^ a b Stos-Gale, Z. A.; Maliotis, G.; Gale, N. H.; Annetts, N. (1997). "Lead Isotope Characteristics of the Cyprus Copper Ore Deposits Applied to Provenance Studies of Copper Oxhide Ingots". Archaeometry. 39: 107, 109. doi:10.1111/j.1475-4754.1997.tb00792.x.
- ^ Pulak 2006: 9.
- ^ James D. Muhly, "Copper and Bronze in the Late Bronze Aegean," The Ship of Uluburun, trans. Ünsal Yalçin, (Bochum: Deutsches Bergbau-Museum, 2006), 72.
- ^ Fulvia Lo Schiavo, "Cyprus and Sardinia," Archaeometallurgy in Sardinia, eds. Fulvia Lo Schiavo et al., (Montagnac: Éditions Monique Mergoil, 2005), 313.
- ^ Pulak 2006: 12.
- ^ Pulak 2006: 11–12.
- ^ a b c d e f Craddock, Paul T.; et al. (1997). "Casting Metals in Limestone Moulds". Historical Metallurgy Journal. 31. S2CID 138087661.
- ^ a b Karageorghis, Vassos; Papasavvas, George (2001). "A Bronze Ingot-bearer from Cyprus" (PDF). Oxford Journal of Archaeology. 20 (4): 339–354. doi:10.1111/1468-0092.00141.