Prooftext

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search

Prooftexting (sometimes "proof-texting" or "proof texting") is the practice of using isolated quotations from a document to establish a proposition. Using discrete quotations is generally seen as decontextualised. Critics note that such quotes may not accurately reflect the original intent of the author,[1] and that a document quoted in such a manner may not in fact support the proposition for which it was cited when read as a whole.[2][3][4][5]

This is to be distinguished from quotations from a source deemed a hostile witness, who inadvertently substantiates a point beneficial to his opponents in the course of his own narrative. Even when lifted out of context, those facts still stand.

Many ministers and teachers have used some version of the following humorous anecdote to demonstrate the dangers of prooftexting: "A man dissatisfied with his life decided to consult the Bible for guidance. Closing his eyes, he flipped the book open and pointed to a spot on the page. Opening his eyes, he read the verse under his finger. It read, "Then Judas went away and hanged himself" (Matthew 27:5b). Finding these words unhelpful, the man randomly selected another verse. This one read, "Jesus told him, 'Go and do likewise.'" (Luke 10:37b). In desperation he tried one more time. The text he found was: "What you are about to do, do quickly." (John 13:27)[6]

See also[edit]

References[edit]

  1. ^ "The Use of a Doctrinal Catechism in Sunday-School Instruction: A Symposium", Jesse L. Hurlbut et al; The Biblical World, Vol. 16, No. 3 (Sept 1900); retrieved via JSTOR
  2. ^ March 24, 2010 (2010-03-24). "Problem with Proof-Texting". Covenant of Love. Retrieved 2013-11-14. 
  3. ^ "problems with proof-texting (1)". Peripatetic Learning. Carlsweatman.wordpress.com. 2010-08-04. Retrieved 2013-11-14. 
  4. ^ "Is Bible Verse Proof-Texting Problematic?". Mainsailministries.org. Retrieved 2013-11-14. 
  5. ^ McDonough, Kathy (2012-07-19). "The Subtle Power of Spiritual Abuse, Chapter 7: Abuse and Scripture". Recovering Grace. Retrieved 2013-11-14. 
  6. ^ A version of this story can be found in Elizabeth Tokar, "Humorous Anecdotes Collected from a Methodist Minister" Western Folklore, Vol. 26, No. 2 (April, 1967), 92; retrieved via JSTOR