User:Carcharoth/Esperanza MfD review: Difference between revisions
Carcharoth (talk | contribs) re-add correct list |
Carcharoth (talk | contribs) remove admin stats - on second thoughts, this is not helpful until properly explained |
||
Line 8: | Line 8: | ||
Deletion and restoration actions after 02/01/2007 have not been added to this record yet. |
Deletion and restoration actions after 02/01/2007 have not been added to this record yet. |
||
Deleting/restoring admins in alphabetical order (deleting unless otherwise specified): Alphachimp (66); Cohesion (1); Cyde (64); Henrygb (1); Mailerdiablo (25); Martinp23 (1 restoration, 85 deletions); Meegs (1); Merope (1); Misza13 (1 deletion, 15 restorations); NawlinWiki (1); Radiant! (37); Royalguard11 (3); Srikeit (1); Steve block (8); Tangotango (2); Wiki Alf (1); Xaosflux (1). '''NB. Some of these are speedy deletion of user pages on request.''' |
|||
Full details will come later. For now, a list of the pages (some are user pages, some are templates, most are Wikipedia:Esperanza pages or talk pages): |
Full details will come later. For now, a list of the pages (some are user pages, some are templates, most are Wikipedia:Esperanza pages or talk pages): |
Revision as of 17:45, 13 January 2007
Following the Esperanza MfD, numerous Esperanza pages and subpages, as well as images and templates, were deleted, inactivated, redirected, deleted and recreated as a redirect, deleted and recreated as a salted page, and maybe other possibilities not covered here. Some were later restored, some were later deleted. Due to there being literally hundreds of pages, several admins help to carry out the necessary deletions and redirections. Some concern was raised at the time, and in a later deletion review, that some mistakes were made, and this page is a review intended to help demonstrate what happened, and point the way towards a proper tidying up, archving and shelving of Esperanza that will satisfy everyone. It is currently in my userspace, but when it is ready, I propose to move it to an appropriate subpage of the second MfD (the first MfD is already archived as a subpage of that MfD).
I raised these issues with the admin who closed the MfD (Mailerdiablo), and he responded: " I think trawling through the deletion log is the only viable method at the moment I can think of, but I don't expect the deletion period to stretch to over two to three days. (~ 5000-10000 records) - Mailer Diablo 22:39, 10 January 2007 (UTC)" [1]
The following lists and details were obtained from a survey of Wikipedia's deletion log over 9825 entries from 01:43 on 31/12/2006 to 23:02 on 02/01/2007. In addition, the contents of Category:Esperanza and the existing subpages of Esperanza at midnight on 02/01/2007 were also listed, as these may have later been deleted (the deletion log for the intervening hour was also checked and no further deletions or restorations were found there).
The results can be sorted by type (deletion or restoration), page name, time and date of action, and admin involved.
Deletion and restoration actions after 02/01/2007 have not been added to this record yet.
Full details will come later. For now, a list of the pages (some are user pages, some are templates, most are Wikipedia:Esperanza pages or talk pages):
- Wikipedia talk:Esperanza/2005 Advisory Committee Elections
- Wikipedia talk:Esperanza/Advisory Committee Meeting April 2006
- Wikipedia talk:Esperanza/Advisory Committee Meeting April 2006/log
- Wikipedia talk:Esperanza/Advisory Committee Meeting March 2006
- Wikipedia talk:Esperanza/Advisory Council
- Wikipedia talk:Esperanza/Charter Reform Convention
- Wikipedia talk:Esperanza/Collaboration of the Month
- Wikipedia talk:Esperanza/Frequently Asked Questions
- Wikipedia talk:Esperanza/Front page redesign
- Wikipedia talk:Esperanza/Images
- Wikipedia talk:Esperanza/New charter
- Wikipedia talk:Esperanza/New Charter
- Wikipedia talk:Esperanza/Overhaul
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/2005 Advisory Committee Elections
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Advisory Committee Meeting April 2006
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Advisory Committee Meeting April 2006/log
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Advisory Committee Meeting August 2006
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Advisory Committee Meeting August 2006/log
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Advisory Committee Meeting December 2005/log
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Advisory Committee Meeting February 2006
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Advisory Committee Meeting February 2006/log
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Advisory Committee Meeting January 2005
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Advisory Committee Meeting January 2006
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Advisory Committee Meeting January 2006
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Advisory Committee Meeting January 2006/log
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Advisory Committee Meeting March 2006
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Advisory Committee Meeting March 2006/log
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Advisory Committee Meeting May 2006
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Advisory Committee Meeting May 2006/log
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Advisory Committee Meeting October 2006
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Advisory Committee Meeting October 2006/log
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Advisory Committee Meeting September 2006
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Advisory Committee Meeting September 2006/log
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Advisory Council Elections April 2006/Actown
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Advisory Council Elections April 2006/Banes
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Advisory Council Elections April 2006/Davidpk212
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Advisory Council Elections April 2006/Deryck Chan
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Advisory Council Elections April 2006/Discounted votes
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Advisory Council Elections April 2006/Drini
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Advisory Council Elections April 2006/Exir Kamalabadi
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Advisory Council Elections April 2006/HighwayCello
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Advisory Council Elections April 2006/IAMTHEEGGMAN
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Advisory Council Elections April 2006/Ian13
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Advisory Council Elections April 2006/ILovePlankton
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Advisory Council Elections April 2006/Ilyanep
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Advisory Council Elections April 2006/Jfingers88
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Advisory Council Elections April 2006/Karmafist
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Advisory Council
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Charter Reform Convention
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Charter/Constitutional Convention
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Collaboration of the Month
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Collaboration of the Month/American Revolution
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Editors' Forum
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Frequently Asked Questions
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Front page redesign
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Front page redisign/Archive1
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Header
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Images
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Jimbo Birthday Challenge
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/New Charter
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/New charter
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Newsletter
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Newsletter/Slimline
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/NPA Reform/NPA Punishment Idea
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Other Programs
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Overhaul
- User:London UK/Esperanza
- Template:User Esperanza
- Wikipedia talk:Esperanza/Appreciation Week
- Wikipedia talk:Esperanza/Governance
- Wikipedia talk:Esperanza/Members
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/box-footer
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/box-header
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/box-header-simple
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Calendar/December/22
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Calendar/February/1
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Calendar/February/12
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Calendar/February/22
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Calendar/February/25
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Calendar/February/28
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Calendar/February/4
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Calendar/February/7
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Calendar/September/19
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Calendar/September/21
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Calendar/September/24
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Calendar/September/27
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Calendar/September/3
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Calendar/September/5
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Calendar/September/8
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Contact
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/December 2005 elections/Celestianpower
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/December 2005 elections/FireFox
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/December 2005 elections/Gryffindor
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/December 2005 elections/Karmafist
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/December 2005 elections/Sango123
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/December 2005 elections/Titoxd
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/December 2005 elections/YOUR USER NAME
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/December 2006 elections
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/EALinks
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Esperanza services
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/February 2006 elections/Aaron
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/February 2006 elections/Aaron's Reply
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/February 2006 elections/Bratsche
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/February 2006 elections/Drini
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/February 2006 elections/Flcelloguy
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/February 2006 elections/Ilyanep's Reply
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/February 2006 elections/Karmafist
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/February 2006 elections/Karmafist's Request
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/February 2006 elections/KnowledgeOfSelf
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/February 2006 elections/Revolución
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/February 2006 elections/Revolución's Reply
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/February 2006 elections/Tally
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/February 2006 elections/Vote/Discounted votes
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/February 2006 elections/Wikizach question replies
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/February 2006 elections/Wikizach
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/February 2006 elections/Wikizach's Reply
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Front page redesign/Archive1
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Front page redesign/Archive2
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Governance
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Happy Birthday/Members
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/intro
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/IRC channel log
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/June 2006 elections/Banes
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/June 2006 elections/Dure
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/June 2006 elections/GangstaEB
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/June 2006 elections/Kingfisherswift
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/June 2006 elections/Petros471
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/June 2006 elections/Tally
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/June 2006 elections/The Gerg
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Members
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/What Esperanza is not
- User:Sd31415/Esperanza
- Wikipedia talk:Esperanza/Advisory Council Elections April 2006
- Wikipedia talk:Esperanza/Advisory Council Elections April 2006/vote
- Wikipedia talk:Esperanza/December 2005 elections
- Wikipedia talk:Esperanza/December 2005 elections/Vote
- Wikipedia talk:Esperanza/February 2006 elections
- Wikipedia talk:Esperanza/February 2006 elections/Vote
- Wikipedia talk:Esperanza/Governance
- Wikipedia talk:Esperanza/Members
- Wikipedia talk:Esperanza/October 2005 elections/Vote
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Advisory Council Elections April 2006
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Advisory Council Elections April 2006/vote
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Alerts/Indicators
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/December 2005 elections
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/December 2005 elections/Vote
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Design Assignments
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Do-It-Yourself
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Election
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/February 2006 elections
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/February 2006 elections/Vote
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Governance
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Members
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Members/Election
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Newsletter/Opt Out List
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/October 2005 elections
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/October 2005 elections/Vote
- User:Seivad/Elections/Esperanza/Jun06
- User:Seivad/Elections/Esperanza/Jun06
- Wikipedia talk:Esperanza/Charter Amendments
- Wikipedia talk:Esperanza/Charter Convention
- Wikipedia talk:Esperanza/February 2006 elections/Karmafist
- Wikipedia talk:Esperanza/February 2006 elections/Tally
- Wikipedia talk:Esperanza/IRC channel log
- Wikipedia talk:Esperanza/June 2006 elections
- Wikipedia talk:Esperanza/June 2006 elections/Shreshth91
- Wikipedia talk:Esperanza/June 2006 elections/Vote
- Wikipedia talk:Esperanza/September 2006 elections
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Advisory Committee Meeting December 2005
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Charter Amendments
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Charter Convention
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/December 2005 elections/Celestianpower
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/December 2005 elections/Discounted votes
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/December 2005 elections/FireFox
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/December 2005 elections/Gryffindor
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/December 2005 elections/Jdhowens90
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/December 2005 elections/Karmafist
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/December 2005 elections/Sango123
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/December 2005 elections/Tally
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/December 2005 elections/the wub
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/December 2005 elections/Titoxd
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/December 2005 elections/YOUR USER NAME
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/December 2006 elections
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/February 2006 elections/Aaron
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/February 2006 elections/Aaron's Reply
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/February 2006 elections/Bratsche
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/February 2006 elections/Drini
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/February 2006 elections/Flcelloguy
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/February 2006 elections/Ilyanep's Reply
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/February 2006 elections/Karmafist
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/February 2006 elections/Karmafist's Request
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/February 2006 elections/KnowledgeOfSelf
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/February 2006 elections/Revolución
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/February 2006 elections/Revolución's Reply
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/February 2006 elections/Tally
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/February 2006 elections/Vote/Discounted votes
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/February 2006 elections/Wikizach question replies
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/February 2006 elections/Wikizach
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/February 2006 elections/Wikizach's Reply
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/IRC channel log
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/June 2006 elections
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/June 2006 elections
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/June 2006 elections
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/June 2006 elections/Abcdefghijklm
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/June 2006 elections/Ajwebb
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/June 2006 elections/Banes
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/June 2006 elections/CorbinSimpson
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/June 2006 elections/D-Day
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/June 2006 elections/Dure
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/June 2006 elections/EWS23
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/June 2006 elections/FireFox
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/June 2006 elections/GangstaEB
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/June 2006 elections/Geo.plrd
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/June 2006 elections/Ian13
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/June 2006 elections/Kingfisherswift
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/June 2006 elections/Kirill Lokshin
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/June 2006 elections/Natalya
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/June 2006 elections/Petros471
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/June 2006 elections/Report
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/June 2006 elections/Shreshth91
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/June 2006 elections/Tally
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/June 2006 elections/Tdxiang
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/June 2006 elections/Terence Ong
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/June 2006 elections/The Gerg
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/June 2006 elections/The Giant Puffin
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/June 2006 elections/The Halo
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/June 2006 elections/Vote
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/June 2006 elections/Vote/Discounted votes
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/June 2006 elections/Wisden17
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/September 2006 elections
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/September 2006 elections/Actown
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/September 2006 elections/Aeon1006
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/September 2006 elections/Celestianpower
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/September 2006 elections/Daniel.Bryant
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/September 2006 elections/HighwayCello
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/September 2006 elections/Hoopydink
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/September 2006 elections/Report
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/September 2006 elections/Shreshth91
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/September 2006 elections/Srikeit
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/September 2006 elections/Tally
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/September 2006 elections/The Halo
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/September 2006 elections/Vote
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/September 2006 elections/Vote/Discounted votes
- User:Whispering/Esperanza
- User:Merope/Esperanza
- Image:Esperanza.svg
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Calendar/December/22
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Calendar/February/1
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Calendar/February/12
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Calendar/February/22
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Calendar/February/25
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Calendar/February/28
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Calendar/February/4
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Calendar/February/7
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Calendar/September/19
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Calendar/September/21
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Calendar/September/24
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Calendar/September/27
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Calendar/September/3
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Calendar/September/5
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Calendar/September/8
- User:Teh tennisman/Esperanza
- Category:Esperanza tutorials
- Category:Stressed Wikipedians
- Template talk:Esperanza Election
- Template:Cafe Esperanza
- Template:EA-welcome
- Template:Esperanza Coffee
- Template:Esperanza Election
- Template:Esperanza Fhloston small
- Template:Esperanza Fhloston
- Template:Esperanza First Edit
- Template:Esperanza Party
- Template:Esperanza star
- Template:Esperanza Voyage
- Template:Esp-guideline
- Template:User ESP-AC
- Template:User ESP-AG
- Template:User ESP-member
- Template:User wikipedia/Esperanza
- User:HighwayCello/BB
- User:HighwayCello/BB2
- User:Husond/Userboxes/BarnstarBrigade
- User:Kyo cat/userboxes/BB
- User:Saoshyant/Userboxes/User ESP-member
- Wikipedia talk:Esperanza/Advisory Council Elections April 2006/freakofnurture
- Wikipedia talk:Esperanza/Advisory Council Elections April 2006/Moe Epsilon
- Wikipedia talk:Esperanza/Advisory Council Elections April 2006/Tally
- Wikipedia talk:Esperanza/Charter Proposal Voting
- Wikipedia talk:Esperanza/Charter
- Wikipedia talk:Esperanza/Code of Conduct
- Wikipedia talk:Esperanza/Happy Birthday
- Wikipedia talk:Esperanza/Incivility
- Wikipedia talk:Esperanza/Members/Archive 1
- Wikipedia talk:Esperanza/Missing Wikipedians/Archive1
- Wikipedia talk:Esperanza/Tutorial Drive
- Wikipedia talk:Esperanza/WikiCharter
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Proceedings in Removal
- Wikipedia:Esperenza/Februrary 2006 elections/IAMTHEEGGMAN
- User:E@L/Esperanza
- User:Joshua Chiew/Esperanza
- User:SonicChao/Esperanza
- User:Srikeit/Esperanza
- Template:ECOTM Banner
- Wikipedia:C/Calendar/December/10
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Collaboration of the Month/American Revolution/Draft
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Collaboration of the Month/Approved
- Wikipedia:Esperanza/Collaboration of the Month/Rejected
- WP:EA/COTM
- WP:ECOTM
- WP:ESP/COTM
- User:Tangotango/Esperanza
- User:Tangotango/New members of Esperanza
- User:Wiki alf/Esperanza
- User:JB82/Esperanza