Jump to content

Pallab Ghosh: Difference between revisions

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Content deleted Content added
A major contributor to this article appears to have a close connection with its subject. It may require cleanup to comply with Wikipedia's content policies, particularly neutral point of view. Please discuss further on the talk page.
restore those sections that were reliably sourced out of the material deleted on 4 September 2009 by 132.185.240.122 (registered to the BBC) See Talk
Line 9: Line 9:


As science correspondent, Ghosh has broken several important stories, notably the cloned [[Dolly the sheep]] having [[arthritis]], and the abandonment of the construction of a primate research centre by [[Cambridge University]] because of fears of attacks from [[animal rights]] activists.
As science correspondent, Ghosh has broken several important stories, notably the cloned [[Dolly the sheep]] having [[arthritis]], and the abandonment of the construction of a primate research centre by [[Cambridge University]] because of fears of attacks from [[animal rights]] activists.

==Reporting==
Ghosh's reporting of GM crops has caused controversy. In 2003 he reported that farmers in India were cross-breeding [[Monsanto Company]]'s GM [[cotton]] with their own local varieties. The Monsanto variety was unsuited to the local weather conditions and had performed badly in the previous harvest. The Indian Government had already set up an expert panel that concluded that Monsanto's GM cotton was "unfit for cultivation and should be banned". It was claimed by local manufacturers that the home-produced variety was more robust, and local farmers were hopeful that they would be able to improve crop yieds without paying Monsanto's higher prices. Ghosh reported, however that the home grown product if anything seemed to perform even less well.<ref>{{cite news |url=http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/sci/tech/2998150.stm |title=India's GM seed piracy |author=Ghosh, Pallab |date=17 June, 2003 |work=BBC News |accessdate=2008-03-27}}</ref>


===GM and the BMA===
===GM and the BMA===
In 2003 Ghosh reported that the Science Board of the [[British Medical Association]] (BMA) was reviewing the organisation's precautionary approach to GM crops and food.<ref>{{cite news |url=http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/scotland/2494267.stm |title=Doctors want GM crop ban |author=Ghosh, Pallab |date=20 November 2002 |work=BBC News |accessdate=2008-03-27}}</ref> There was particular concern that the [[Zambia]]n Government had cited the BMA's advice, that health risks could not be ruled out, as part of the reason it had turned away much needed grain shipments during a food shortage.<ref>{{cite news |url=http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/sci/tech/2711801.stm |title=Doctors review GM crop evidence |date=31 January 2003 |work=BBC News |accessdate=2008-03-27}}</ref> The BMA issued a press release the same day quoting its spokesperson Vivienne Nathanson, which stated that the BBC report was "wrong" and "totally incorrect."{{Citation needed|date=March 2008}} The following year The BMA admitted it had indeed reviewed its stance on GM crops, and decided that new research suggested that GM crops posed no health risk.<ref>{{cite news |url=http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/sci/tech/3545717.stm |title=UK doctors alter tack to back GMs |author=Kirby, Alex |date=9 March 2004 |work=BBC News |accessdate=2008-03-27}}</ref>
In 2003 Ghosh reported that the Science Board of the [[British Medical Association]] (BMA) was reviewing the organisation's precautionary approach to GM crops and food.<ref>{{cite news |url=http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/scotland/2494267.stm |title=Doctors want GM crop ban |author=Ghosh, Pallab |date=20 November 2002 |work=BBC News |accessdate=2008-03-27}}</ref> There was particular concern that the [[Zambia]]n Government had cited the BMA's advice, that health risks could not be ruled out, as part of the reason it had turned away much needed grain shipments during a food shortage.<ref>{{cite news |url=http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/sci/tech/2711801.stm |title=Doctors review GM crop evidence |date=31 January 2003 |work=BBC News |accessdate=2008-03-27}}</ref> The BMA issued a press release the same day quoting its spokesperson Vivienne Nathanson, which stated that the BBC report was "wrong" and "totally incorrect."{{Citation needed|date=March 2008}} The following year The BMA admitted it had indeed reviewed its stance on GM crops, and decided that new research suggested that GM crops posed no health risk.<ref>{{cite news |url=http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/sci/tech/3545717.stm |title=UK doctors alter tack to back GMs |author=Kirby, Alex |date=9 March 2004 |work=BBC News |accessdate=2008-03-27}}</ref>


===Árpád Pusztai===
==Leadership==
In 1999 Ghosh also reported critically on Dr [[Árpád Pusztai]]'s work on the possible health effects of GM potatoes. This is what Dr Pusztai had to say about Ghosh's coverage: "[he] came up to Aberdeen after the [[Royal Society]] and the Science and Technology Committee's sitting [in 1999], and he was all smiles and extremely accommodating, but when the interview went out on the BBC he twisted everything out of context. So much so that I decided not to have anything more to do with the BBC."{{Fact|date=March 2008}} Dr Pusztai's work was also dismissed as "flawed" by an independent scientific review panel.<ref>{{cite news |url=http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/europe/346826.stm |title=GM Food report condemned as flawed |date=May 18, 1999 |work=BBC News |accessdate=2008-03-27}}</ref>

==Professional Leadership==


Ghosh is President of the World Federation of Science Journalists, and is a past chairman of the Association of British Science Writers. In these roles he has attempted to promote a more direct approach to science journalism, with the introduction of national and international prizes for [[investigative journalism]].
Ghosh is President of the World Federation of Science Journalists, and is a past chairman of the Association of British Science Writers. In these roles he has attempted to promote a more direct approach to science journalism, with the introduction of national and international prizes for [[investigative journalism]].

Revision as of 20:34, 11 March 2011

Pallab Ghosh (born 1962) is a science correspondent for BBC News. Born in India, he came to the United Kingdom in 1963, and has been a science journalist since 1984. He won the Media Natura Environment Award, and BT's Technology Journalist of the Year.[citation needed]

He has interviewed notable figures including the first man on the moon, Neil Armstrong; the creator of the World Wide Web, Tim Berners Lee; and cosmologist Stephen Hawking. Ghosh has covered subjects including the human genome project, cloning, stem cell research and genetically modified (GM) crops.

Career

He began his career in the British Electronics and Computer Press before joining New Scientist as the magazine's Science News Editor. Ghosh joined BBC News in 1989. He worked as a general news producer on BBC Radio 4's The World at One and then went on to become a senior producer on the Today Programme.

As science correspondent, Ghosh has broken several important stories, notably the cloned Dolly the sheep having arthritis, and the abandonment of the construction of a primate research centre by Cambridge University because of fears of attacks from animal rights activists.

Reporting

Ghosh's reporting of GM crops has caused controversy. In 2003 he reported that farmers in India were cross-breeding Monsanto Company's GM cotton with their own local varieties. The Monsanto variety was unsuited to the local weather conditions and had performed badly in the previous harvest. The Indian Government had already set up an expert panel that concluded that Monsanto's GM cotton was "unfit for cultivation and should be banned". It was claimed by local manufacturers that the home-produced variety was more robust, and local farmers were hopeful that they would be able to improve crop yieds without paying Monsanto's higher prices. Ghosh reported, however that the home grown product if anything seemed to perform even less well.[1]

GM and the BMA

In 2003 Ghosh reported that the Science Board of the British Medical Association (BMA) was reviewing the organisation's precautionary approach to GM crops and food.[2] There was particular concern that the Zambian Government had cited the BMA's advice, that health risks could not be ruled out, as part of the reason it had turned away much needed grain shipments during a food shortage.[3] The BMA issued a press release the same day quoting its spokesperson Vivienne Nathanson, which stated that the BBC report was "wrong" and "totally incorrect."[citation needed] The following year The BMA admitted it had indeed reviewed its stance on GM crops, and decided that new research suggested that GM crops posed no health risk.[4]

Árpád Pusztai

In 1999 Ghosh also reported critically on Dr Árpád Pusztai's work on the possible health effects of GM potatoes. This is what Dr Pusztai had to say about Ghosh's coverage: "[he] came up to Aberdeen after the Royal Society and the Science and Technology Committee's sitting [in 1999], and he was all smiles and extremely accommodating, but when the interview went out on the BBC he twisted everything out of context. So much so that I decided not to have anything more to do with the BBC."[citation needed] Dr Pusztai's work was also dismissed as "flawed" by an independent scientific review panel.[5]

Professional Leadership

Ghosh is President of the World Federation of Science Journalists, and is a past chairman of the Association of British Science Writers. In these roles he has attempted to promote a more direct approach to science journalism, with the introduction of national and international prizes for investigative journalism.

Ghosh has also introduced schemes to get people from more diverse backgrounds into the higher levels of science journalism. He believes that those reporting on scientific issues that increasingly have a social dimension should be more representative of their community.

References

  1. ^ Ghosh, Pallab (17 June, 2003). "India's GM seed piracy". BBC News. Retrieved 2008-03-27. {{cite news}}: Check date values in: |date= (help)
  2. ^ Ghosh, Pallab (20 November 2002). "Doctors want GM crop ban". BBC News. Retrieved 27 March 2008.
  3. ^ "Doctors review GM crop evidence". BBC News. 31 January 2003. Retrieved 27 March 2008.
  4. ^ Kirby, Alex (9 March 2004). "UK doctors alter tack to back GMs". BBC News. Retrieved 27 March 2008.
  5. ^ "GM Food report condemned as flawed". BBC News. 18 May 1999. Retrieved 27 March 2008.

Template:Persondata