Uncommon Dissent: Difference between revisions
restored direct quote from Darwinism while requesting sources for claim that by "Darwinism" they mean the theory of evolution, and for the *fourth time*, for claim that the book rejects evolution |
rv per talk and opinions of all editors except Timm |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
'''''Uncommon Dissent: Intellectuals Who Find Darwinism Unconvincing''''' is a [[2004]] anthology edited by [[intelligent design]] activist [[William Dembski]] in which fifteen intellectuals criticise |
'''''Uncommon Dissent: Intellectuals Who Find Darwinism Unconvincing''''' is a [[2004]] anthology edited by [[intelligent design]] activist [[William Dembski]] in which fifteen intellectuals criticise "[[Darwinism]]", which they use to refer to the theory of [[evolution]]. The book's introduction characterizes Darwinism by the central claim that "an unguided physical process can account for the emergence of all biological complexity and diversity".<ref>Dembski, ''Uncommon Dissent'', p. xx.''</ref> |
||
It is published by the publishing wing of the [[paleoconservative]] [[Intercollegiate Studies Institute]]. The foreword is by John Wilson, editor of the [[evangelical Christian]] magazine ''[[Christianity Today]]''. Described by the Discovery Institute as "a summary of the widespread attack upon Darwinism by ... leading intellectuals,"<ref>[http://www.discovery.org/scripts/viewDB/index.php?command=view&program=Book%20-%20CSC&id=3605 Uncommon Dissent, Intellectuals who find Darwinism Unconvincing] Center for Science and Culture, June 1 2004.</ref> the book rejects |
It is published by the publishing wing of the [[paleoconservative]] [[Intercollegiate Studies Institute]]. The foreword is by John Wilson, editor of the [[evangelical Christian]] magazine ''[[Christianity Today]]''. Described by the Discovery Institute as "a summary of the widespread attack upon Darwinism by ... leading intellectuals,"<ref>[http://www.discovery.org/scripts/viewDB/index.php?command=view&program=Book%20-%20CSC&id=3605 Uncommon Dissent, Intellectuals who find Darwinism Unconvincing] Center for Science and Culture, June 1 2004.</ref> the book rejects the broad acceptance of [[evolution]] within the [[scientific community]].<ref>National Association of Biology Teachers [http://www.nabt.org/sub/position_statements/evolution.asp Statement on Teaching Evolution]</ref><ref>[http://www.interacademies.net/Object.File/Master/6/150/Evolution%20statement.pdf IAP Statement on the Teaching of Evolution] Joint statement issued by the national science academies of 67 countries, including the [[United Kingdom|United Kingdom's]] [[Royal Society]] (PDF file)</ref><ref>From the [[American Association for the Advancement of Science]], the world's largest general scientific society: [http://www.aaas.org/news/releases/2006/pdf/0219boardstatement.pdf 2006 Statement on the Teaching of Evolution] (PDF file), [http://www.aaas.org/news/releases/2006/0219boardstatement.shtml AAAS Denounces Anti-Evolution Laws]</ref> In her expert witness report for the [[Kitzmiller v. Dover Area School District]] trial [[Barbara Forrest]] cited [[Discovery Institute]] fellow [[Nancy R. Pearcey]]'s writings in Uncommon Dissent as evidence of the religious foundations of the institute's [[Wedge strategy]] and of intelligent design.<ref> [http://www2.ncseweb.org/kvd/experts/Forrest_supplemental_report.pdf Expert Witness Report] [[Barbara Forrest]], April 1, 2005, page 29.</ref> |
||
The title is a pun on the principle of biology known as [[common descent]]. |
The title is a pun on the principle of biology known as [[common descent]]. |
||
Revision as of 22:36, 28 November 2006
Uncommon Dissent: Intellectuals Who Find Darwinism Unconvincing is a 2004 anthology edited by intelligent design activist William Dembski in which fifteen intellectuals criticise "Darwinism", which they use to refer to the theory of evolution. The book's introduction characterizes Darwinism by the central claim that "an unguided physical process can account for the emergence of all biological complexity and diversity".[1]
It is published by the publishing wing of the paleoconservative Intercollegiate Studies Institute. The foreword is by John Wilson, editor of the evangelical Christian magazine Christianity Today. Described by the Discovery Institute as "a summary of the widespread attack upon Darwinism by ... leading intellectuals,"[2] the book rejects the broad acceptance of evolution within the scientific community.[3][4][5] In her expert witness report for the Kitzmiller v. Dover Area School District trial Barbara Forrest cited Discovery Institute fellow Nancy R. Pearcey's writings in Uncommon Dissent as evidence of the religious foundations of the institute's Wedge strategy and of intelligent design.[6]
The title is a pun on the principle of biology known as common descent.
Topics Addressed
The book contains four sections: Part I: A Crisis of Confidence; Part II: Darwinism's Cultural Inroads; Part III: Leaving the Darwinian Fold; and Part IV: Auditing the Books. Part I, consisting of three essays, offers opinions on why Darwinism is questioned by the public at large. Part II, consisting of four essays, discusses the authors' opinions on the effects Darwinism has had on society and culture. Part III, consisting of three essays, deals with the personal intellectual journeys of contributors Behe, Denton, and Barham, whose attitudes toward Darwinism have changed through their lives. Part IV, consisting of four essays, presents the authors' opinions on the consistency and scope of Darwinism.
ISBN 1932236317
The Dissenters
The fifteen "dissenting intellectuals" are:
- William A. Dembski, intelligent design activist
- Robert Koons, philosopher, theologian, Christian apologist
- Phillip E. Johnson, lawyer, Christian apologist
- Marcel-Paul Schützenberger, mathematician
- Nancy R. Pearcey, Christian apologist
- Edward Sisson, attorney
- J. Budziszewski, philosopher
- Frank J. Tipler, mathematical physicist
- Michael J. Behe, biochemist
- Michael John Denton, biochemist
- James Barham, classical historian
- Cornelius G. Hunter, biophysicist
- Roland F. Hirsch, US Dept of Energy
- Christopher Michael Langan
- David Berlinski, popular mathematics author
Although at least three of the contributors work in biology-related fields, none is a professional biologist.
References
- ^ Dembski, Uncommon Dissent, p. xx.
- ^ Uncommon Dissent, Intellectuals who find Darwinism Unconvincing Center for Science and Culture, June 1 2004.
- ^ National Association of Biology Teachers Statement on Teaching Evolution
- ^ IAP Statement on the Teaching of Evolution Joint statement issued by the national science academies of 67 countries, including the United Kingdom's Royal Society (PDF file)
- ^ From the American Association for the Advancement of Science, the world's largest general scientific society: 2006 Statement on the Teaching of Evolution (PDF file), AAAS Denounces Anti-Evolution Laws
- ^ Expert Witness Report Barbara Forrest, April 1, 2005, page 29.
External links
- "The Myths of Darwinism" - the book's introduction, by William Dembski
- "Refereed Journals: Do They Insure Quality or Enforce Orthodoxy?" - Frank Tipler's chapter