Wikipedia:Deletion review/Log/2007 September 25: Difference between revisions
→John McGrady: moving closing admin commentary to talk page to reduce impact on ongoing discussion - I should have done that at the outset, sorry |
Ariverawpb (talk | contribs) |
||
| Line 26: | Line 26: | ||
Thank you for your review [[User:Ariverawpb|Ariverawpb]] 04:31, 25 September 2007 (UTC) |
Thank you for your review [[User:Ariverawpb|Ariverawpb]] 04:31, 25 September 2007 (UTC) |
||
*'''Endorse deletion'''. All of the versions of this article (which has been deleted by more than one administrator), meet one or more of the [[WP:CSD|criteria for speedy deletion]]. In particular G11 (as blatant advertising) and/or A7 (company with no assertion of notability). To be acceptable a new version should be based on [[WP:RS|reliable sources]] independent of the company itself and not a restatement of its press materials or a [[WP:STUB|sub-stub]] that is no more informative than an entry in a [[WP:NOT#DIR|telephone directory]]. [[User:Eluchil404|Eluchil404]] 05:33, 25 September 2007 (UTC) |
*'''Endorse deletion'''. All of the versions of this article (which has been deleted by more than one administrator), meet one or more of the [[WP:CSD|criteria for speedy deletion]]. In particular G11 (as blatant advertising) and/or A7 (company with no assertion of notability). To be acceptable a new version should be based on [[WP:RS|reliable sources]] independent of the company itself and not a restatement of its press materials or a [[WP:STUB|sub-stub]] that is no more informative than an entry in a [[WP:NOT#DIR|telephone directory]]. [[User:Eluchil404|Eluchil404]] 05:33, 25 September 2007 (UTC) |
||
I disagree. If this is the case, than the entire "list of franchised companies should be deleted off of your site. Realtor.com, RISMedia, and Isucceed.com all show USA BEST REALTY as being a notable franchise. Even though there are reliable sources showing that it is, the fact is that the one-line informational sentence regarding a "true" real estate franchise shows absolutely no form of advertising - just factual truth. WILL SOMEBODY FAIR PLEASE STEP IN? |
|||
Revision as of 14:43, 25 September 2007
- John McGrady (edit | talk | history | protect | delete | links | watch | logs | views) (restore|cache|AfD)
Closing administrator did not interpret the debate, he made his own decision about the article and used a rationale for keeping not presented by anyone in the debate. The opinion of those commenting in the debate were clearly in favour of deletion. One Night In Hackney303 11:49, 25 September 2007 (UTC)
- Comment I am the closing admin. I have moved commentary made here to the talk page to reduce impact on the ongoing discussion. --User:Ceyockey (talk to me) 12:38, 25 September 2007 (UTC)
- USA BEST REALTY (edit | talk | history | protect | delete | links | watch | logs | views) (restore|cache|AfD)
factual Ariverawpb 04:31, 25 September 2007 (UTC) Please review the deletion of this article. I feel that the moderator was unfair in his/her actions since many other of the companies under the Wiki heading "List of Franchises" have an informational link. No advertisement is implied here, it is just a one sentence bit of information on a viable franchise.
Thank you for your review Ariverawpb 04:31, 25 September 2007 (UTC)
- Endorse deletion. All of the versions of this article (which has been deleted by more than one administrator), meet one or more of the criteria for speedy deletion. In particular G11 (as blatant advertising) and/or A7 (company with no assertion of notability). To be acceptable a new version should be based on reliable sources independent of the company itself and not a restatement of its press materials or a sub-stub that is no more informative than an entry in a telephone directory. Eluchil404 05:33, 25 September 2007 (UTC)
I disagree. If this is the case, than the entire "list of franchised companies should be deleted off of your site. Realtor.com, RISMedia, and Isucceed.com all show USA BEST REALTY as being a notable franchise. Even though there are reliable sources showing that it is, the fact is that the one-line informational sentence regarding a "true" real estate franchise shows absolutely no form of advertising - just factual truth. WILL SOMEBODY FAIR PLEASE STEP IN?