Talk:Dermot Farrell: Difference between revisions
Flowerpotman (talk | contribs) m →NPOV, BLP and sources: tyop #2 |
No edit summary |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
== NPOV, BLP and sources == |
== NPOV, BLP and sources == |
||
The subject probably does meet [[WP:N|notabilty criteria]] for inclusion as a Wikipedia article, but this article has become a [[WP:NPOV|point of view]] and [[WP:BLP|biography of living persons]] nightmare. A Wikipedia article is '''not''' the place for speculation on motives or actions; if any assertion is made, especially when a controversial assertion is introduced, it '''must''' be accompanied with reference to a [[WP:RS|reliable source]]. This article, as it stands, has '''no sources''', and from even a cursory examination of the edit history, has been a battleground of speculation and opinion, with no attempts to provide sources. <font face="monospace" color="#004080">[[User:Flowerpotman|<span style="color:#004080; font-variant:small-caps">FlowerpotmaN</span>]]·([[User talk:Flowerpotman|t]])</font> 00:53, 8 October 2007 (UTC) |
The subject probably does meet [[WP:N|notabilty criteria]] for inclusion as a Wikipedia article, but this article has become a [[WP:NPOV|point of view]] and [[WP:BLP|biography of living persons]] nightmare. A Wikipedia article is '''not''' the place for speculation on motives or actions; if any assertion is made, especially when a controversial assertion is introduced, it '''must''' be accompanied with reference to a [[WP:RS|reliable source]]. This article, as it stands, has '''no sources''', and from even a cursory examination of the edit history, has been a battleground of speculation and opinion, with no attempts to provide sources. <font face="monospace" color="#004080">[[User:Flowerpotman|<span style="color:#004080; font-variant:small-caps">FlowerpotmaN</span>]]·([[User talk:Flowerpotman|t]])</font> 00:53, 8 October 2007 (UTC) |
||
==Notability== |
|||
Notability has not been established and the article will be referred for deletion unless Msgr. Farrell's inclusion in Wikipedia is justified by something distinguishing him from other clerics in Ireland. [[User:Mythicproportions|Mythicproportions]] 16:30, 8 October 2007 (UTC) |
|||
Revision as of 16:30, 8 October 2007
NPOV, BLP and sources
The subject probably does meet notabilty criteria for inclusion as a Wikipedia article, but this article has become a point of view and biography of living persons nightmare. A Wikipedia article is not the place for speculation on motives or actions; if any assertion is made, especially when a controversial assertion is introduced, it must be accompanied with reference to a reliable source. This article, as it stands, has no sources, and from even a cursory examination of the edit history, has been a battleground of speculation and opinion, with no attempts to provide sources. FlowerpotmaN·(t) 00:53, 8 October 2007 (UTC)
Notability
Notability has not been established and the article will be referred for deletion unless Msgr. Farrell's inclusion in Wikipedia is justified by something distinguishing him from other clerics in Ireland. Mythicproportions 16:30, 8 October 2007 (UTC)