Talk:Genseiryū: Difference between revisions

Content deleted Content added

Inline

Revision as of 17:31, 5 July 2005

This article is being considered for deletion in accordance with Wikipedia's deletion policy .
Please vote on and discuss the matter. See this article's entry on the Votes for Deletion page.

You are welcome to edit this article, but please do not blank, merge, or move this article, or remove this notice, while the discussion is in progress. For more information, read the Guide to Votes for Deletion.

@@ Line 1: / Line 1: @@
+{{disputed}}
-== Sensei Shukumine's involvement in Genseiryu after 1962 ==
+<!-- Please do not remove nor change this VfD message until the issue is settled -->
-In 1962 Shukumine sensei introduced a further development of Genseiryu which he named Taido. Taido is not to be regarded as Karate, but as a new martial art. This new Budo has a lot of acrobatic movements such as sommersaults and flips. Since leaving Genseiryu in 1962, Shukumine sensei only held a friendly relation with his former students/masters of Genseiryu, but he never took actual part in neither teaching nor examinations.
+<div class="boilerplate metadata" id="vfd" style="margin: 0 5%; padding: 0 7px 7px 7px; background: #EDF1F1; border: 1px solid #999999; text-align: left; font-size:95%;">
+'''This article is being considered for deletion in accordance with Wikipedia's [[Wikipedia:Deletion policy|deletion policy]][[Template:Vfd|.]]'''<br />
-This is also stated by a Taido-ka, I have contacted. "''Officially, Taido was started in 1965 and that is also when he '''definately left''' Genseiryu.''" This is a part of what he wrote te me.
+Please vote on and discuss the matter. See '''[[Wikipedia:Votes for deletion/{{PAGENAME}}|this article's entry]]''' on the Votes for Deletion page.<br />
+You are welcome to edit this article, but please do not blank, merge, or move this article, or remove this notice, while the discussion is in progress. For more information, read the [[Wikipedia:Guide to Votes for deletion|Guide to ''Votes for Deletion'']].</div>[[Category:Pages on votes for deletion]]
-Between the period 1962 and 1965 he completed the five basic principels of Taido, especially the TEN en NEN movements."'' In the World Taido Championships in Okinawa in 2001, Saiko Shihan asked to the highest Genseiryu senseis (Tosa and others) to convert to Taido.''" This is also what the Taido-ka wrote to me! So please, for those who are writing untrue stories, back those stories up with true arguments. -- [[User_Talk:Zzaroc|Zzaroc]] 17:58, 5 Jun 2005 (UTC)
+<!-- End of VfD message, feel free to edit beyond this point -->
-:I am sorry to say Mr.Tosa was not invited to that championship. So what you are telling is not true. Sensei Shukumine never had any contact with Tosa after Tosa turned his back on him and started his own commercial Karate organization. Please see also Sensei Shukumine's personal message at a training seminar in The Netherlands with Sensei Kanai and Sensei Konno. Please see the pictures on the [http://www.xs4all.nl/~mroering/gensei-ryu/galleries/gallery05.html Genseiryu website]: Taido and Genseiryu people united to celebrate 55 years Genseiryu - 40 years Taido and to commemorate Sensei Shukumine. Besides that there are pictures of Sensei Shukumine teaching several Genseiryu Teachers like Genseiryu Head Instructor Sensei Kanai in Genseiryu Head dojo situated in Ito Japan in 1996. [[User_Talk:212.127.137.2|212.127.137.2]] 19:37, 5 Jun 2005 (UTC)
-::Were you at the championship or something?
-::So, if Mr. Tosa never had any contact with Mr. Shukumine after 1962, then please explain these picturse of Mr. Tosa and Mr. Shukumine together on the Brazilian Genseiryu website [http://geocities.yahoo.com.br/genseiryu_br/SHUKUMINE.HTM]. -- [[User_Talk:Zzaroc|Zzaroc]] 22:01, 5 Jun 2005 (UTC)
-:I am sorry I didn't say Sensei Shukumine had any contact after 1962. I said he didn't had any contact after Sensei Tosa turned his back to Sensei Shukumine. This was after Sensei Shukumine wrote the preface for sensei Tosa's book about Genseiryu Butokukai. And yes I was present at the championship in Okinawa amongst other Genseiryu practitioners from Spain, Denmark, Holland, and Japan. I will try to give also a link with pictures of that event. I need a little time for that I am not an Internet black belt sorry for that. [[User_Talk:212.127.137.2|212.127.137.2]] 22:53, 5 Jun 2005 (UTC)
-::You don't have to be a black belt, when your good, by the way. But take your time, I am patient.
-::But I was wondering. Mr. Tosa published his book in 1984, but there still a picture of him together with Mr. Shukumine in 1985 (I mean those pictures on the Brazilian site). Then there are still a few questionmarks.
-::But by the way, did you know that Mr. Tosa received several letters all over the world, just after Mr. Shukumine died? Those letters were asked for permission if some dojo's could join the organization of Mr. Tosa. Mr. Tosa denied these people to join his organization.
-::There was one person who send such a letter to Mr. Tosa from Holland, and you may guess who.
-::And I have got also another question. Mr. Seiken Shukumine past away to an hart attack. But when did he started to get ill? -- [[User_Talk:Zzaroc|Zzaroc]] 23:59, 5 Jun 2005 (UTC)
-:No a black belt is not needed to have a certain skill. But in most occasion it shows an amount of training effort,time. And as you probably know training effort makes you become more skillfull.
-:I don't know when Mr. Tosa turned his back to sensei Shukumine so maybe my remark that they didn't had any contact shouldn't be done by me because I am not aware of that specific date. So I apologize for that. But I heard this occured in the mid till end '80s.
-:No, I didn't know that Mr. Tosa received several letters from all over the world. I know he claimed to get a letter from Holland. I know he received one which was delivered by someone from Denmark. But I know that the letter was completely different from what is claimed by Mr. Tosa. That is also easy to believe if you are member of a Genseiryu organization in Ito which was directly connected to sensei Shukumine where Sensei Shukumine still gave, in very few occasions, lectures about Genseiryu (pictures are on the way (few days necessary)). So you can imagine you don't beg for acknowledgement by Mr. Tosa who only wants you to train his way, which is very near to Shotokan with the basic kata of Shotokan. This dojo in Holland is not interested in any connection with Mr. Tosa. For what reason, if you want to train Genseiryu the same way as sensei Shukumine taught his students? The Head Instructor of this organization is now Sensei Kanai one of the first students of Sensei Shukumine. In Sensei Shukumine's book ''"Shin Karatedo Kyohan"'' there are several pictures of teachers who are still in this group. I met them during the celebrating anniversary of Taido and Genseiryu beginning of this year (Jan. 2005). Many nice teachers who still respect Sensei Shukumine, as should be in the relationship with teacher and student.
-:I was never involved with the sickness of Sensei Shukumine and I don't like to talk about his sickness. I met Mr. Shukumine one time and talked a little bit with him. In Okinawa I only met him from a distance. So I am sorry I can't anwer this question for I didn't have such a close relationship with Sensei Shukumine. -- [[User_Talk:212.127.137.2|212.127.137.2]] 06:48, 6 Jun 2005 (UTC)
-I'm not intending to edit this, knowing nothing about the subject, but the article should be moved to [[Genseiryu]] to keep the case consistent. [[User:DJ Clayworth|DJ Clayworth]] 01:11, 7 Jun 2005 (UTC)
-I did this. Maybe the preferred spelling is [[Gensei-Ryu]], [[Gensei Ryu]] or [[Gensei-ryu]], but [[GENSEIRYU]] is not. [[User:DJ Clayworth|DJ Clayworth]] 01:47, 7 Jun 2005 (UTC)
-''<<Whole discussion here moved to [[User_Talk:Peter_Lee|Peter Lee's Talk page]] since most of it was copied there already anyway and the discussion has gone way beyond the subject Genseiryu! >>''