Talk:Wadsworth's cipher: Difference between revisions
m assess |
Noting two serious problems |
||
Line 36: | Line 36: | ||
|US= yes |
|US= yes |
||
}} |
}} |
||
== Serious problems == |
|||
I would like to mention two issues with this article. |
|||
Firstly, regarding its first reference (cited as [http://all.net/edu/curr/ip/Chap2-1.html|"A Short History of Cryptography"], Fred Cohen, 1995; but that is actually only one chapter of an entire on-line book.) The entire second paragraph of this article is copied almost verbatim from Dr. Cohen's copyrighted article. Only a few words are modifed here and there, such as replacing "several" with "a few". |
|||
Second, the actual description of the cipher seems to copy an error in Dr. Cohen's article. Specifically, |
|||
:''To encipher a message, the inner disk was turned until the desired letter was at the top position, with the '''''number of turns required''''' for the result transmitted as ciphertext.'' (Emphasis added.) |
|||
This description frankly makes little sense. Not only is it cumbersome, but it does not allow a unique decipherment. It also leaves the second disk unused! Further, it is completely unlike the operation of the Wheatstone cryptograph, even though all sources agree that the two instruments are almost identical (differing only in the size of the larger disk.) In Wheatstone's machine, once the inner disk has been turned, the ciphertext is simply read off from the index on the outer disk, precisely as you might expect. (See, for example, [http://books.google.com.au/books?id=m65tKWiI-MkC&pg=PA170&lpg=PA170&dq=%22Wheatstone+cryptograph%22&source=bl&ots=-QN8d9_4lK&sig=4vbj-2GY1TpfU3HpvhB0r7WbwCs&hl=en&sa=X&ei=j3EsUdejEISUiAff6YD4Bg&redir_esc=y#v=onepage&q=%22Wheatstone%20cryptograph%22&f=false].) |
|||
Unfortunately, the only source I can find which purports to accurately examine and describe a Wadsworth cipher machine, is behind a very expensive paywall. |
|||
-- [[Special:Contributions/202.63.39.58|202.63.39.58]] ([[User talk:202.63.39.58|talk]]) 11:28, 26 February 2013 (UTC) |
Revision as of 11:28, 26 February 2013
{{WikiProject banner shell}}
to this page and add the quality rating to that template instead of this project banner. See WP:PIQA for details.![]() | Military history: Intelligence / Technology / North America / United States Stub‑class | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Serious problems
I would like to mention two issues with this article.
Firstly, regarding its first reference (cited as "A Short History of Cryptography", Fred Cohen, 1995; but that is actually only one chapter of an entire on-line book.) The entire second paragraph of this article is copied almost verbatim from Dr. Cohen's copyrighted article. Only a few words are modifed here and there, such as replacing "several" with "a few".
Second, the actual description of the cipher seems to copy an error in Dr. Cohen's article. Specifically,
- To encipher a message, the inner disk was turned until the desired letter was at the top position, with the number of turns required for the result transmitted as ciphertext. (Emphasis added.)
This description frankly makes little sense. Not only is it cumbersome, but it does not allow a unique decipherment. It also leaves the second disk unused! Further, it is completely unlike the operation of the Wheatstone cryptograph, even though all sources agree that the two instruments are almost identical (differing only in the size of the larger disk.) In Wheatstone's machine, once the inner disk has been turned, the ciphertext is simply read off from the index on the outer disk, precisely as you might expect. (See, for example, [1].)
Unfortunately, the only source I can find which purports to accurately examine and describe a Wadsworth cipher machine, is behind a very expensive paywall. -- 202.63.39.58 (talk) 11:28, 26 February 2013 (UTC)
- Stub-Class military history articles
- Stub-Class intelligence articles
- Intelligence task force articles
- Stub-Class military science, technology, and theory articles
- Military science, technology, and theory task force articles
- Stub-Class North American military history articles
- North American military history task force articles
- Stub-Class United States military history articles
- United States military history task force articles