Talk:Marketplace of ideas: Difference between revisions
Srich32977 (talk | contribs) add project, |
→Mill and the marketplace of ideas? Doubtful: new section |
||
Line 14: | Line 14: | ||
Just wanting to point out that the claim for first (verbatim) usage is incorrect: Edwin Emery uses the term in the foreword to the second edition of "The Press and America", published in 1962. So the 1967 date has to be wrong. I haven't edited because I can't prove that this is the first use. Does anyone have an earlier date? ([[Special:Contributions/121.210.0.192|121.210.0.192]] ([[User talk:121.210.0.192|talk]]) 21:27, 4 May 2008 (UTC)) |
Just wanting to point out that the claim for first (verbatim) usage is incorrect: Edwin Emery uses the term in the foreword to the second edition of "The Press and America", published in 1962. So the 1967 date has to be wrong. I haven't edited because I can't prove that this is the first use. Does anyone have an earlier date? ([[Special:Contributions/121.210.0.192|121.210.0.192]] ([[User talk:121.210.0.192|talk]]) 21:27, 4 May 2008 (UTC)) |
||
== Mill and the marketplace of ideas? Doubtful == |
|||
This article claims that the marketplace of ideas metaphor can be found in Mill's On Liberty, though it notes that the phrase appears nowhere in Mill. However, I think that's doubtful and presented as original research. Mill doesn't say anything about market efficiency and free speech. Quite to the contrary, he's very concerned with a tyrrany of the majority, which is what we would expect if we relied on the market mechanisms to weed out bad ideas. Anyway, the notion that the marketplace of ideas is in Mill is nowhere cited (though I'm sure that you could find scholars who make this claim). Here's someone who makes the contrary claim: Jill Gordon, "John Stuart Mill and the 'Marketplace of Ideas,' " Social Theory and Practice 23 (1997). So the idea that this is in Mill is at least controversial. It should be removed from the article. Were this an article about Mill, it may be worth mentioning the controversy. But it isn't, so we shouldn't.[[Special:Contributions/68.63.148.22|68.63.148.22]] ([[User talk:68.63.148.22|talk]]) 13:00, 26 September 2014 (UTC) |
Revision as of 13:00, 26 September 2014
![]() | Libertarianism Start‑class Mid‑importance | |||||||||
|
2007 comment
While Holmes may have been the first person to use the terminology of the market to describe this concept, the notion of a free marketplace of ideas was expressed and developed in John Stuart Mill's "On Liberty" in 1869, particularly in "Chapter II: Of the Liberty of Thought and Discussion." It is available here: http://www.bartleby.com/130/2.html Schol4r 16:16, 23 March 2007 (UTC)
Market place of Ideas
First, that someone would credit such an important idea to "Big Bird" is in and of itself absurd. First of all, "Big Bird" is a fictional character played by a person. So even if he did state the quote attributed to him by the Wikipedia contributor, someone else wrote it. Moreover, I wonder if the 4-9 year olds who watch Big Bird would have had any idea what he was talking about?!
As my scholarly predecessor has noted the idea has both recent and ancient roots. Richard Hofstadter (1955) rightly points out that the idea can be traced to Socrates and Aristotle. The Socratic Method is the pedagogical embodiment of the "Marketplace of Ideas." In the modern era,in addition to Mills, Thomas Jefferson, in reference to the University of Virginia stated,"This institution will be based upon the illimitable freedom of the human mind. For here we are not afraid to follow truth wherever it may lead, nor to tolerate any error so long as reason is left free to combat it."
Interestingly, Justice Holmes (1919), who is usually given credit for the concept, never used the term. Granted, he implied the idea in his dissenting opinion in Abrams v. U S , 250 U.S. 616 (1919). Nonetheless, you will not find the term "Marketplace of ideas" in his decision. The term came into use when it was tied to the concept of academic freedom in the years following Holme's opinion.
Just wanting to point out that the claim for first (verbatim) usage is incorrect: Edwin Emery uses the term in the foreword to the second edition of "The Press and America", published in 1962. So the 1967 date has to be wrong. I haven't edited because I can't prove that this is the first use. Does anyone have an earlier date? (121.210.0.192 (talk) 21:27, 4 May 2008 (UTC))
Mill and the marketplace of ideas? Doubtful
This article claims that the marketplace of ideas metaphor can be found in Mill's On Liberty, though it notes that the phrase appears nowhere in Mill. However, I think that's doubtful and presented as original research. Mill doesn't say anything about market efficiency and free speech. Quite to the contrary, he's very concerned with a tyrrany of the majority, which is what we would expect if we relied on the market mechanisms to weed out bad ideas. Anyway, the notion that the marketplace of ideas is in Mill is nowhere cited (though I'm sure that you could find scholars who make this claim). Here's someone who makes the contrary claim: Jill Gordon, "John Stuart Mill and the 'Marketplace of Ideas,' " Social Theory and Practice 23 (1997). So the idea that this is in Mill is at least controversial. It should be removed from the article. Were this an article about Mill, it may be worth mentioning the controversy. But it isn't, so we shouldn't.68.63.148.22 (talk) 13:00, 26 September 2014 (UTC)