Talk:Gamergate (harassment campaign)/FAQ: Difference between revisions

Content deleted Content added

Inline

Revision as of 04:25, 5 February 2015

Below are answers to frequently asked questions about the corresponding page Gamergate (harassment campaign). They address concerns, questions, and misconceptions which have repeatedly arisen on the talk page. Please feel free to change this material in light of new discussion.

To view an answer, click the [show] link to the right of the question.

Q1: I found a YouTube video, a post on 4chan/Reddit/9GAG/8chan, or a blog that relates to GamerGate. Can I use it as a source in the article?

A1: All sources used in the article must comply with Wikipedia's standards for reliable sources. Self-published sources cannot be used for biographical content on a living person. If such sources were used, then gossip, slander and libelous material may find its way into the article, which would a) tarnish the quality of Wikipedia's information and b) potentially open up Wikipedia to legal action. For further information, please read the guidelines for sources in biographies of living people.

Q2: Why is Wikipedia preventing me from editing the article or talk page? Why is this article biased towards one party or the other?

A2: Content on Wikipedia is required to maintain a neutral point of view as much as possible, and is based on information from reliable sources (Vox, Wall Street Journal, etc). The article and its talk page are under protection due to constant edit warring and attraction of people with negative comments prohibited by our policy on biographical content concerning living people (see WP:BLP).

Q3: Can I use a particular article as a source?

A3: What sources can be used in Wikipedia is governed by our reliable sources policy, which requires "published sources with a reputation for fact-checking and accuracy." If you have a question about whether or not a particular source meets this policy, a good place to ask is the Reliable sources noticeboard.

Q4: The "reliable sources" don't tell the full story. Why can't we use other sources?

A4: Verifiability in reliable sources governs what we write. Wikipedia documents what the reliable sources say. If the reliable sources are incorrect or inadequate, it is up to other reliable sources to correct this. Wikipedia's role is not to correct the mistakes of the world; it is to write an encyclopedia based on reliable, verifiable sources.

@@ Line 5: / Line 5: @@
 {{FAQ row
 |q=Q1: I found a YouTube video, a post on 4chan/Reddit/9GAG/8chan, or a blog that relates to GamerGate.  Can I use it as a source in the article?
-|a=A1: All sources used in the article must comply with Wikipedia's standards for [[WP:RS|reliable sources]].  [[WP:SPS|Self-published sources]] cannot be used for [[WP:BLP|biographical content on a living person]]. If such sources were used, then gossip, slander and libelous material may find its way in the article, which would a) tarnish the quality of Wikipedia's information and b) potentially open up Wikipedia to legal action. For further information, please read [[Wikipedia:Identifying reliable sources#Reliable Sources|the guidelines for sources in biographies of living people.]]
+|a=A1: All sources used in the article must comply with Wikipedia's standards for [[WP:RS|reliable sources]]. [[WP:SPS|Self-published sources]] cannot be used for [[WP:BLP|biographical content on a living person]]. If such sources were used, then gossip, slander and libelous material may find its way into the article, which would a) tarnish the quality of Wikipedia's information and b) potentially open up Wikipedia to legal action. For further information, please read [[Wikipedia:Identifying reliable sources#Reliable Sources|the guidelines for sources in biographies of living people.]]
 }}
 {{FAQ row
-|q=Q2: Why is Wikipedia preventing me from editing? Why is this article biased towards one party or the other?
+|q=Q2: Why is Wikipedia preventing me from editing the article or talk page? Why is this article biased towards one party or the other?
-|a=A2: Content on Wikipedia is required to maintain a [[WP:NPOV|neutral point of view]] as much as possible, and is based on information from reliable sources (ex, [[Vox]], [[Wall Street Journal]], etc). The article and its talk page is under protection due to constant edit warring and attraction of people with negative comments prohibited by our policy on biographical content concerning living people (see [[WP:BLP]]).
+|a=A2: Content on Wikipedia is required to maintain a [[WP:NPOV|neutral point of view]] as much as possible, and is based on information from reliable sources ([[Vox]], [[Wall Street Journal]], etc). The article and its talk page are under protection due to constant edit warring and attraction of people with negative comments prohibited by our policy on biographical content concerning living people (see [[WP:BLP]]).
 }}
 {{FAQ row
 |q=Q3: Can I use a particular article as a source?
-|a=A3: What sources can be used in Wikipedia is governed by our [[WP:RS|reliable sources policy]], which requires "published sources with a reputation for fact-checking and accuracy".  If you have a question about whether or not a particular source meets this policy, a good place to ask is the [[WP:RSN|Reliable sources noticeboard]].
+|a=A3: What sources can be used in Wikipedia is governed by our [[WP:RS|reliable sources policy]], which requires "published sources with a reputation for fact-checking and accuracy."  If you have a question about whether or not a particular source meets this policy, a good place to ask is the [[WP:RSN|Reliable sources noticeboard]].
 }}
 {{FAQ row
 |q=Q4: The "reliable sources" don't tell the full story.  Why can't we use other sources?
-|a=A4: [[Wikipedia:Verifiability|Verifiability]] in reliable sources governs what we write.  Wikipedia documents what the reliable sources say.  If the reliable sources are incorrect or inadequate, it is up to other reliable sources to correct this.  Wikipedia's role is not to [[WP:RIGHTGREATWRONGS|correct the mistakes of the world]], it is to write an encyclopedia based on reliable, verifiable sources.
+|a=A4: [[Wikipedia:Verifiability|Verifiability]] in reliable sources governs what we write. Wikipedia documents what the reliable sources say. If the reliable sources are incorrect or inadequate, it is up to other reliable sources to correct this. Wikipedia's role is not to [[WP:RIGHTGREATWRONGS|correct the mistakes of the world]]; it is to write an encyclopedia based on reliable, verifiable sources.
-}}
-{{FAQ row
-|q=Q5: Why can I not contribute to this talk page?
-|a=A5: You may not be [[Help:Logging in|logged in]].
-<br>(Thanks to whoever put this answer up, but I am definitely logged in, and there are no edit buttons next to each talk topic) -- [[User:PersnicketyGareth|PersnicketyGareth]] ([[User talk:PersnicketyGareth|talk]]) 11:54, 4 February 2015 (UTC)
 }}