Architecture in Texas, 1895–1945
Architecture in Texas, 1895–1945 is a 1993 book written by Jay C. Henry and published by the University of Texas Press. Kenneth Breisch of the Journal of the Society of Architectural Historians described the book as "a thorough analysis of building styles in the state from 1895 to 1945."[1] It was the first comprehensive study of Texas architecture of that period.[2] The author's thesis, stated on page one of the book, was that this period of architecture represented "a large cross section of America in microcosm".[3] According to Joseph L. Aranha of Texas Tech University the book also serves as an "encyclopedia of the works of Texas architects" and a "catalog of significant buildings and architectural styles in Texas".[4]
Contents
The book contains information on various types of buildings. The selection is mostly populated with structures in large cities, and the book does not describe agricultural and ranch buildings.[4] The author categorizes each building by style and compares them to other structures in the United States East Coast, Chicago, and Europe.[5] Most buildings in the book were, at the time of publication, still standing, but the author included any demolished ones which had "essential tendencies better than any surviving example".[6] Some buildings featured were not designed by architects.[4]
There is a chapter on public housing and a two-page discussion of Highland Park Shopping Village in the Dallas-Fort Worth area; the other building descriptions do not contain analyses of any urban development, technological, historical, nor social aspects.[7] The book, according to Breisch, does not have a lot of detail on the architect and client interaction processes nor on the design processes of the buildings.[5]
Much of the material used in the book had not been previously published.[3]
Drexel Turner of The Menil Collection described the contents as "a parade of often repetitive buildings that are explained chiefly in terms of stylistic derivation."[8] Breisch argued that the author had taken "strains to pigeonhole Texas buildings into preconceived stylistic slots".[5] Aranha argued that the organizational style used stymies the reader's understanding of the chronology of the buildings and that it was possible that some buildings were not included because the author could not fit them into his categorization system. Aranha added that because some buildings were not designed by architects it was surprising that he did not include rural structures.[4]
Graphics
There are 397 images,[9] including 380 photographs.[10] Most of the photographs in the book are views of the buildings's exteriors;[6] they are generally of the whole building and are 4.5 inches (110 mm) by 3.5 inches (89 mm).[9] They are in black-and-white and the author took most of the pictures.[3] Five photographs depict building details and four depict interiors.[9] Most building featured in the book have one photograph apiece.[6]
There are 17 line drawings,[10] including detail and plan drawings which depict some campuses,[6] housing projects, individual houses, and the Texas Centennial Exposition. There are six site detail graphics in total for campuses, the exposition, and housing projects; and nine detail graphics for individual houses.[9]
Turner stated that the lack of photographs hampers the depiction of the Isabella Court in Midtown Houston and some other architectural works.[6] Christopher Long of Austin, Texas wrote in the Southwestern Historical Quarterly that there should have been archival plan drawings as that would show the evolution in architecture.[3] Aranha stated that if additional floor plan drawings were included they could communicate information about alterations or demolitions.[10]
Reception
Aranha concluded that even though there were some "shortcomings", "Henry is to be given due credit for producing a scholarly survey of a variety of significant buildings".[4]
Long stated that "Hopefully the book will inspire others to take a closer look at this lively and interesting period."[3] Long argued that the book did not show "a social history of Texas architecture" even though the book jacket stated that it was in the book, and that his thesis "does little to illuminate the forces and ideas that combined to create the diverse architectural landscape."[3]
Turner argued that the book should have put more focus on fewer works of architecture.[6]
References
- Aranha, Joseph L. (Texas Tech University) (1995-10-01). "Architecture in Texas 1895-1945 (Book Review)". 7 (1). Traditional Dwellings and Settlements Review: 51–52. JSTOR 41757722.
{{cite journal}}: Cite journal requires|journal=(help) - Breisch, Kenneth A. (Southern California Institute of Architecture) (March 1995). "The See-Through Years: Creation and Destruction in Texas Architecture and Real Estate 1981-1991 Joel Warren Barna Abner Cook: Master Builder on the Texas Frontier Kenneth Hafertepe Architecture in Texas: 1895-1945 Jay C. Henry Dugout to Deco: Building in West Texas, 1880-1930 Elizabeth Skidmore Sasser". Journal of the Society of Architectural Historians. 54 (1): 81–85. doi:10.2307/991029. JSTOR 991029.
- Long, Christopher (Austin, Texas) (July 1994). "Architecture in Texas: 1895-1945". Southwestern Historical Quarterly. 98 (1): 151(2). JSTOR 30238975.
{{cite journal}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link) - Turner, Drexel (The Menil Collection) (May 1995). "Architecture in Texas: 1895-1945". Journal of Southern History. 61 (2): 406(2). doi:10.2307/2211621. JSTOR 2211621.
Notes
- ^ Breisch, p. 82.
- ^ Long, p. 151.
- ^ a b c d e f Long, p. 152.
- ^ a b c d e Aranha, p. 51.
- ^ a b c Breisch, p. 83.
- ^ a b c d e f Turner, p. 407. "Although Henry's research,[...]it is unfortunate that the opportunity was not taken here to focus on fewer examples in greater depth."
- ^ Breisch, p. 82-83.
- ^ Turner, p. 406.
- ^ a b c d Breisch, p. 84.
- ^ a b c Aranha, p. 52.