Battle of Morbihan
| Battle of Quiberon Bay | |||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Part of the Gallic Wars | |||||||
 | |||||||
| |||||||
| Belligerents | |||||||
 Roman Republic | Veneti | ||||||
| Commanders and leaders | |||||||
|
Julius Caesar Decimus Junius Brutus Albinus | |||||||
| Strength | |||||||
| c. 110 ships | 220 ships | ||||||
| Casualties and losses | |||||||
| Light | Almost all ships destroyed or captured | ||||||
The Battle of Quiberon Bay, was a naval battle fought in the summer of 56 BC between the Gallic tribe of the Veneti and a Roman fleet sent by Julius Caesar. The battle was fought off the coast of Brittany in modern-day France, likely near Quiberon Bay. The battle was a part of the Gallic Wars. The battle ended in a decisive Roman victory.
Background
During the winter of 57-56 BC, Publius Crassus was stationed among the Andecavi. Since the Romans were undersupplied, Crassus sent officers to neighboring tribes to procure food and provisions. Quintus Velanius and Titus Silius were sent to the Veneti, where they were detained. The Veneti offered to return Velanius and Silius, if the Romans returned the hostages they had previously given to Crassus. Caesar interpreted these detentions as an act of war. After receiving word in Illyricum from Crassus, Caesar ordered a fleet to be built on the river Loire and rowers and seamen to be recruited.[1] When the Veneti learned that Caesar was headed towards them, they prepared for war by gathering their navy and allying with the nearby Osismii, Lexovii, Namnetes, Ambiliati, Morini, Diablintes, and Menapii. Caesar appointed Decimus Brutus to command the Roman fleet.[2]
The Veneti held the upper hand for much of the campaign. Their ships were well-suited to the region, and when their hill forts were under siege, they could simply evacuate them by sea. Despite having the superior army and great siege equipment, the Romans were making little progress. Caesar realized that the campaign could not be won on land and halted the campaign until the Roman fleet was complete. The fleet was complete near the end of that summer.[2]
Battle
The Roman fleet met the Veneti fleet around Quiberon Bay. The Veneti fleet had around 220 ships while the Romans are estimated to be outnumbered around two to one, giving a fleet of 110.[3] Caesar and the Roman army overlooked the battle from cliffs nearby, possibly in modern-day Saint-Gildas-de-Rhuys.[3] The battle occurred close to shore so Caesar and his soldiers could watch and encourage the Roman fleet. The Venetic ships were designed for the open ocean of the Atlantic and so were much larger than the Roman ships adapted to the Mediterranean Sea. Merely the stern of the Venetic ship surpassed the height of the Roman ships, even when equipped with turrets. The Venetic ships were made out of sturdy oak and used sails made of leather to survive ocean-storm weather. Venetic ships were powered entirely by sails as opposed to Roman ships primarily powered by rowers. The Venetic ships were too large and sturdy to ram and so the Romans devised a different plan.[2]
The Romans attached hooks to the end of wooden poles on their ships. The Roman ships would sail against the Venetic ships so that the hooks would catch the halyards holding the yard to the mast. Once the hook caught, the ship was rowed fast ahead so the halyard was cut causing the yard and sail to drop. Once the sails were taken down, the Venetic ships became inoperable and were then surrounded by two or three Roman ships and boarded. Once boarded, the Romans overpowered the Veneti.[1][4]
The uncaptured ships saw the Roman tactics and began to flea. Soon after the retreat began, the wind stopped and the remaining Venetic ships were stuck in place without rowers. The attempted flight caused the Venetic ships to become dispersed and unable to help one another. The Romans continued to board the Venetic ships as they had before the flight. The battle lasted from around 10 o-clock in the morning until sunset. Only a few remaining Venetic ships escaped under cover of night.[2][3]
Aftermath
The surviving Veneti surrendered to Julius Caesar following the Battle of Morbihan. Julius Caesar had all members of the Veneti's ruling senate put to death and sold the rest of the population into slavery.[2] The severity of the punishment was most likely intended to make an example of the Veneti and deter any further uprisings in Gaul.[1][4]
Caesar later used the fleet built for the Battle of Quiberon Bay in his invasions of Britain.[2]
Historiography
Similar to many events within the Gallic Wars, Commentarii de Bello Gallico by Julius Caesar is the only primary source documenting the events of the Battle of Quiberon Bay. Unexplained within Caesar's account is the delay in constructing the fleet. The fleet took around nine months to prepare, longer than the standard time for fleet construction at the time.[3]
Later historians have criticized the cruelty Caesar treated the Veneti to following the battle. Napoleon, in his commentaries on the wars of Julius Caesar, says "this conduct was not just; still less was it politic. Such means never achieve their aim; they anger and disgust the nations. The punishment of a few chief people is all that justice and policy permit; it is an important rule to treat prisoners well."[5] Several historians argue that this punishment among other actions against the Gauls satisfy the modern definition of genocide.[6][7]
References
- ^ a b c Freeman, Philip (2008). Julius Caesar. Simon and Schuster. pp. 164–169. ISBN 9781416565888.
- ^ a b c d e f Hammond, Carolyn, ed. (1996). Caesar: The Gallic War. Oxford University Press. ISBN 978-0-19-283120-0.
- ^ a b c d Dodge, Theodore (1892). Caesar: A History of the Art of War Among the Romans Down to the End of the Roman Empire, With A Detailed Account of the Campaigns of Caius Julius Caesar. Houghton Mifflin Company. pp. 131–140.
- ^ a b Meier, Christian (1995). Caesar: A Biography. Translated by McLintock, David. Basic Books. pp. 273–275. ISBN 9780465008940.
- ^ Bonaparte, Napoleon (5 April 2018). Napoleon's Commentaries on the Wars of Julius Caesar: A New English Translation. Translated by Macguire, R. A. Pen and Sword Military. p. 16.
One can only despise Caesar's treatment of the Senate of Vannes. This people had not revolted; they had provided hostages and promised to live quietly, but they were in possession of all their rights and liberties. They had indeed given Caesar grounds to make war against them, but not to violate the law of nations in their case and to misuse his victory in so atrocious a way. This conduct was not just; still less was it politic. Such means never achieve their aim; they anger and disgust the nations. The punishment of a few chief people is all that justice and policy permit; it is an important rule to treat prisoners well.
- ^ Kiernan, Ben; Lemos, T. M.; Taylor, Tristan (2023). The Cambridge World History of Genocide: Volume 1, Genocide in the Ancient, Medieval and Premodern Worlds. Cambridge University Press. pp. 309–329.
- ^ Raaflaub, Kurt (14 May 2021). "Caesar and Genocide: Confronting the Dark Side of Caesar's Gallic Wars". New England Classical Journal. 48 (1). doi:10.52284/NECJ/48.1/article/raaflaub. Retrieved 1 May 2024.