Talk:American Gothic
I think some explanation of why it's called "American Gothic" is due. Perhaps people did not like the wording of my explanation. Okay, that is one thing. But the ideas should remain, I feel.
The text I wrote, which was removed, said: "Why is it called "Gothic?" Look at the windows in the background; They have the distinct look of gothic architecture. There are also hints in the clothing and perhaps facial expressions as well."
Isn't this something called "Carpenter Gothic?"
- The house is most definitely carpenter gothic and I think the title is explained sufficiently by the statement "house of Carpenter Gothic style". I also think the old line felt out of place with its abrupt change in tone to a question-answer dialogue. The focus on the windows overlooks the other equally important gothic features like board and bat siding, and I think seeing a gothic theme in the clothes and expressions is an opinion that may not be widely held. —TeknicT-M-C July 7, 2005 00:34 (UTC)